1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:12,040
If I could hope for but one thing for you, so you'd be curious in all that you do.

2
00:00:13,460 --> 00:00:19,120
Cause love like a flower just wants to grow.

3
00:00:19,660 --> 00:00:26,520
Oh, and knowledge like your heart just wants to be known.

4
00:00:26,520 --> 00:00:33,000
If you like, please subscribe. This is Bitcoin Study Sessions.

5
00:00:38,000 --> 00:00:45,780
Today, Lucas and I are continuing our studies of broken money, why our financial system is failing us, and how we can make it better.

6
00:00:46,020 --> 00:00:51,160
We're on the chapters 12 and 13, which kind of broadly speaking, as we're going to discuss,

7
00:00:51,160 --> 00:00:55,680
are about the geopolitical effects of the U.S. operating as the world reserve currency,

8
00:00:56,120 --> 00:01:02,780
how it's negative for both the U.S. and the world, and kind of we get some premonition at the end

9
00:01:02,780 --> 00:01:10,780
that Bitcoin might be the solution to this global reserve asset problem. So I'll do what I do

10
00:01:10,780 --> 00:01:15,680
usually and kind of give a summary of the book up until this point and a little bit more in-depth

11
00:01:15,680 --> 00:01:21,060
summary of what we're going to discuss today, and then Lucas and I will hash it out. So we're on

12
00:01:21,060 --> 00:01:28,660
part three but we began this book part one alden asked the question what is money uh sometimes it

13
00:01:28,660 --> 00:01:33,540
has been a commodity historically like gold based on the characteristics scarcity portability divisibility

14
00:01:33,540 --> 00:01:38,700
sometimes it's just been credit doing something for someone for a favor a deferral of payment

15
00:01:38,700 --> 00:01:46,020
underlying both those theories alden concluded is that money is a ledger both commodity and credit

16
00:01:46,020 --> 00:01:51,160
It depends on an underlying idea of an abstract ledger, a way to maintain a record of ownership

17
00:01:51,160 --> 00:01:51,880
and transactions.

18
00:01:52,280 --> 00:01:55,620
That brought us to part two of the book, The Birth of Banks.

19
00:01:56,160 --> 00:02:01,320
And so kind of roughly in that section, banks developed because gold, which was used as a

20
00:02:01,320 --> 00:02:05,200
commodity money, was insufficient to fuel the economy.

21
00:02:05,200 --> 00:02:09,260
It moved too slow, especially in the age of telecommunications.

22
00:02:09,680 --> 00:02:15,840
So banks, as a technology, were able to create paper claims for gold, which circulate much

23
00:02:15,840 --> 00:02:20,720
quicker than actually shipping the gold around to settle transactions. This had a lot of secondary

24
00:02:20,720 --> 00:02:25,140
effects like the expansion of credit through fractional reserve banking, where banks maintain

25
00:02:25,140 --> 00:02:31,020
only a small amount of the reserves they have and the rest they lend out as paper claims on the

26
00:02:31,020 --> 00:02:36,840
deposits, which leads to centralization and banks being backstopped by a central bank.

27
00:02:37,420 --> 00:02:42,700
Then we moved on to part three where we're at where we are at today. The first part of part

28
00:02:42,700 --> 00:02:47,660
three we discussed last time. Part three is the rise and fall of global monetary orders. So we're

29
00:02:47,660 --> 00:02:54,420
getting into a geopolitical framework here. Last time we got kind of the three frameworks that

30
00:02:54,420 --> 00:03:00,560
bring us to today, where there was the pre-1944 global monetary framework, which was kind of gold

31
00:03:00,560 --> 00:03:07,880
standard, broadly speaking. Then there was 1944 to 1971. That's the Bretton Woods system, which is

32
00:03:07,880 --> 00:03:14,240
the dollar pegged to gold, and then the dollar being the reserve asset. And then in 1971,

33
00:03:14,880 --> 00:03:22,320
there's the Nixon shock, where Nixon ended redeemability of the dollar for gold. And

34
00:03:22,320 --> 00:03:27,500
shortly thereafter that, we arrive at the petrodollar system, which is roughly speaking,

35
00:03:27,500 --> 00:03:34,380
the system we have today, where Saudi Arabia requires paying for their oil in dollars.

36
00:03:34,380 --> 00:03:42,560
All countries need oil, so they stack dollars in the form usually of U.S. treasuries, and then the dollar is kind of loosely backed by oil.

37
00:03:43,020 --> 00:03:49,720
So that gets us to today, the latter part of part three, the rise and fall of global monetary orders.

38
00:03:52,060 --> 00:04:01,860
And we're really kind of coming to head on the geopolitical and political aspect of a global monetary order, the reserve asset.

39
00:04:01,860 --> 00:04:19,200
So chapter 12 is called Pushing Chaos to the Peripheries. The peripheries is the developing world, and the chaos that is being pushed there is kind of the worst consequences of our fiat-based monetary system where the dollar is not pegged to anything, and it's the reserve asset under the petrodollar system.

40
00:04:19,200 --> 00:04:43,260
So like the using fiat as a reserve asset has a lot of volatility. The developed world mitigates that by shifting a lot of the worst consequences onto the developing world. It's, as Alden describes it, kind of a neocolonialism, a new form of colonialism that's an extension of the way that the developed world was predatory on the developing world in the past.

41
00:04:43,260 --> 00:05:01,300
So there's really three ways that this happens, that chaos is pushed to the peripheries. First, the Federal Reserve System. The U.S. has the World Reserve Currency, and the Fed mandate is really about maintaining the stability of the U.S. financial system.

42
00:05:01,300 --> 00:05:08,100
focus on U.S., it has no mandate to cater to the world at large, except to the extent that that

43
00:05:08,100 --> 00:05:14,380
affects the U.S. financial system. So U.S. dollar is the world reserve currency, but the Fed that

44
00:05:14,380 --> 00:05:20,360
managed that is only focusing on the effects that that has on the U.S. So this leads us to export

45
00:05:20,360 --> 00:05:25,940
inflation and volatility as much as we can, the negative consequences out to the periphery to

46
00:05:25,940 --> 00:05:32,200
other countries. If the Fed strengthens the dollar, this affects developing countries that

47
00:05:32,200 --> 00:05:37,620
are in debt because their debt is denominated in dollars. So a stronger dollar means the debt is

48
00:05:37,620 --> 00:05:42,040
now more difficult to pay back. If the Fed weakens the dollar, nations with dollar-based

49
00:05:42,040 --> 00:05:49,560
savings in the form of treasuries, their savings are devalued. Also, of course, individuals

50
00:05:49,560 --> 00:05:56,400
that have accrued dollars to save because their own currency is deficient have had their own

51
00:05:56,400 --> 00:06:02,020
savings devalued. So that's the first way that chaos is pushed through the periphery,

52
00:06:02,060 --> 00:06:06,100
through the Federal Reserve System that focuses on the US. The second way is through the IMF and

53
00:06:06,100 --> 00:06:11,240
the World Bank, which are two institutions that were created in 1944 as part of the Bretton Woods

54
00:06:11,240 --> 00:06:18,680
system, nominally to help developing countries, help all countries, but really the emphasis was

55
00:06:18,680 --> 00:06:23,320
to help those that needed help with balance of payment issues, which is what the IMF did,

56
00:06:23,600 --> 00:06:27,940
and the World Bank did helping fund the infrastructure, the development of infrastructure

57
00:06:27,940 --> 00:06:33,640
projects. However, these two institutions are controlled by the developed countries.

58
00:06:33,980 --> 00:06:39,340
They're headquartered in Washington, D.C., of course, close to the locus of U.S. power.

59
00:06:39,940 --> 00:06:45,440
The U.S. has veto power. They're often headed by these institutions by European or French

60
00:06:45,440 --> 00:06:51,440
officials. So what ends up happening is that the IMF and the World Bank, well-intentioned,

61
00:06:51,500 --> 00:06:57,340
end up essentially engaging in predatory lending on an international scale. The loans really

62
00:06:57,340 --> 00:07:04,580
meddle, the way the loans are given to developing countries kind of meddle with the sovereignty of

63
00:07:04,580 --> 00:07:10,560
these countries and are designed really to change their economies, to redesign them so that they

64
00:07:10,560 --> 00:07:17,980
and export to rich countries. So IMF loans and World Bank loans, et cetera, usually entail what's

65
00:07:17,980 --> 00:07:23,220
called a structural adjustment, conditions such as increased taxes, higher interest rates, wage

66
00:07:23,220 --> 00:07:28,800
ceilings, ending consumer subsidies on food and energy, restrictions on government spending,

67
00:07:28,940 --> 00:07:33,680
especially to health care and education, and then favorable legal conditions for

68
00:07:33,680 --> 00:07:41,360
multinationals that come in. So this kind of set of conditions, these impositions, these strings

69
00:07:41,360 --> 00:07:48,240
attached to IMF lending serve to suppress domestic wages and make them more competitive

70
00:07:48,240 --> 00:07:53,880
to export globally. But the effects on these developing countries can be extremely bad.

71
00:07:54,740 --> 00:08:01,320
Some of these effects are multinational takeover. They've kind of restricted local access to credit

72
00:08:01,320 --> 00:08:06,840
through these conditions in the loans, even as multinationals are given kind of beneficial

73
00:08:06,840 --> 00:08:12,680
conditions to come into the country and take over. It also initiates a cycle of debt. This really is

74
00:08:12,680 --> 00:08:17,720
a predatory lending cycle where old loans are repaid by taking out new loans, and they're kind

75
00:08:17,720 --> 00:08:24,040
of never paid back, just rolled over. And this is, I think, a really overlooked point, and it's so

76
00:08:24,040 --> 00:08:31,800
simple. Loans also end up going back to developed countries. We think, oh, this is great aid going

77
00:08:31,800 --> 00:08:37,040
to developing countries. But no, like what happens is, for example, a loan is given for an

78
00:08:37,040 --> 00:08:43,060
infrastructure project in a developing country, but then they have to contract with multinational

79
00:08:43,060 --> 00:08:48,000
or, you know, companies in the United States or Europe, somewhere that has a technical capacity

80
00:08:48,000 --> 00:08:53,320
to actually carry out and do the infrastructure project. So we give them, loan them money that

81
00:08:53,320 --> 00:08:55,200
that didn't pay back to our companies.

82
00:08:56,380 --> 00:08:59,240
These loans under the IMF and World Bank

83
00:08:59,240 --> 00:09:01,500
are also pillaged by authoritarian leaders.

84
00:09:01,840 --> 00:09:03,980
The money is often siphoned off

85
00:09:03,980 --> 00:09:07,640
by corrupt officials in a government

86
00:09:07,640 --> 00:09:08,820
given to their cronies.

87
00:09:09,280 --> 00:09:11,360
Even when these people are later deposed

88
00:09:11,360 --> 00:09:12,300
or taken out of power,

89
00:09:12,560 --> 00:09:14,800
the people of the country are still liable

90
00:09:14,800 --> 00:09:17,680
for the debt that has been actually siphoned off

91
00:09:17,680 --> 00:09:23,300
to buy large black SUVs for leaders of countries.

92
00:09:23,320 --> 00:09:31,060
even the designated effect is actually perverse of these loans and IMF and World Bank meddling.

93
00:09:31,060 --> 00:09:36,740
They reshape economies to be export-driven, which is away from a natural diversified economy.

94
00:09:37,740 --> 00:09:43,080
An example that Alden gives is, for example, Bangladesh is encouraged to do shrimp farming.

95
00:09:43,840 --> 00:09:48,540
Bangladeshis can't even afford the shrimp. It's a luxury item that they're now farming.

96
00:09:48,540 --> 00:10:08,320
They shift production away from local agriculture, local products they need. They begin to import basic items and export something for luxury consumption. Then if the shrimp market globally takes a downturn, the Bangladeshis, in order to pay for basic foodstuffs and other items coming in, have to get a new loan from the IMF.

97
00:10:08,320 --> 00:10:16,160
a really good um alvin cites alex gladstein's book hidden repression how the imf and world bank

98
00:10:16,160 --> 00:10:20,980
sell exploitation as development and that's kind of the canonical read on this subject definitely

99
00:10:20,980 --> 00:10:26,340
worth a look the third way so we have the federal reserve system focusing on the u.s

100
00:10:26,340 --> 00:10:32,380
the imf and world bank doing predatory lending the third way that chaos is pushed to the peripheries

101
00:10:32,380 --> 00:10:38,240
that colonialism continues as neocolonialism is, well, the third one is literally just like

102
00:10:38,240 --> 00:10:45,920
actual colonialism is still going on. Two examples that are given are in the French context. One is

103
00:10:45,920 --> 00:10:53,180
Madagascar, which was invaded by the French in 1895. But apparently, and after that invasion,

104
00:10:53,300 --> 00:10:57,940
the French then begin to tax the Malagasy people to pay for their own invasion to recoup their costs

105
00:10:57,940 --> 00:11:01,800
and also to pay for infrastructure that they told the Malagasy people they needed.

106
00:11:02,280 --> 00:11:06,780
Evidently, the French are still receiving payments from their colonial endeavor,

107
00:11:07,060 --> 00:11:11,640
the payments in the form that they call a loan, but which is actually their past colonialism.

108
00:11:12,820 --> 00:11:18,460
Another example is the CFA, the CFA franc countries in Western and Central Africa.

109
00:11:18,460 --> 00:11:24,060
The CFA franc is also an old colonial project of the French.

110
00:11:24,060 --> 00:11:30,260
It was a money that was managed by the French that was initially pegged to the franc and now to the euro.

111
00:11:31,340 --> 00:11:49,260
France still essentially kind of engages in overseas, manipulates, manages the monetary policies of these nominally sovereign nations, collects fees for that, stores their foreign reserves.

112
00:11:49,260 --> 00:11:57,880
and leaders in these countries that are anti-CIFA in the past have been kind of met with violent ends.

113
00:11:58,780 --> 00:11:59,260
Alden notes.

114
00:11:59,260 --> 00:12:02,100
So the summary of this chapter, to quote Alden,

115
00:12:02,620 --> 00:12:09,260
it, the current global financial system, helps keep people in developing countries in a state of constant development,

116
00:12:09,420 --> 00:12:15,460
dependency and ever-rising debt while structuring their economies around serving the wealthy and developed countries

117
00:12:15,460 --> 00:12:19,240
rather than optimizing for self-sufficiency and well-roundedness.

118
00:12:19,260 --> 00:12:26,020
So that's how the U.S. dollar as a World Reserve asset tends to push chaos to the peripheries through these institutions.

119
00:12:27,240 --> 00:12:30,800
Chapter 13 is heavy is the head that wears the crown.

120
00:12:31,400 --> 00:12:38,760
And so that's a reference to the burden that the U.S. has as the issuer of the World Reserve currency, the dollar.

121
00:12:38,760 --> 00:12:52,720
So it's going to – having a world reserve currency – having a currency serve as like the world reserve asset both hurts those countries on the peripheries, developing countries, and also hurts the US.

122
00:12:53,460 --> 00:12:58,060
So this refers to the negative aspects being the issue of the world reserve currency.

123
00:12:58,060 --> 00:13:11,180
We even saw it when the dollar was pegged to gold under the Bretton Woods system, 1944-1971, gold fled the country due to the U.S. redeeming our issuance of dollars for gold.

124
00:13:11,640 --> 00:13:19,180
Now, even in the unpegged petrodollar system, we have pure fiat as a world-deserved currency supported by the Saudis accepting dollars for gold.

125
00:13:19,180 --> 00:13:23,840
so Alden here gives

126
00:13:23,840 --> 00:13:25,840
I just want to take a step back and say in this chapter

127
00:13:25,840 --> 00:13:28,720
to describe the negative effects

128
00:13:28,720 --> 00:13:31,760
of the US issuing the world reserve currency

129
00:13:31,760 --> 00:13:34,580
Alden gives a lot of definition of economic terms

130
00:13:34,580 --> 00:13:35,860
that I'm not going to go into

131
00:13:35,860 --> 00:13:38,980
I'm going to try to give a really simplified broad description

132
00:13:38,980 --> 00:13:41,880
basically the world is hungry for dollars

133
00:13:41,880 --> 00:13:43,400
when it's the world reserve asset

134
00:13:43,400 --> 00:13:46,760
so this introduces a monetary premium on the dollar

135
00:13:46,760 --> 00:13:48,360
dollars are desired

136
00:13:48,360 --> 00:14:05,820
Other countries need them for commerce, to buy oil, for example. So the dollar is now strong enough that the U.S., we can just print money to buy all that we need and import things that we need, send out U.S. dollars, get back goods, rather than have to create them here domestically.

137
00:14:05,820 --> 00:14:14,180
um this having a monetary premium premium on the u.s dollar in this way also just simply makes u.s

138
00:14:14,180 --> 00:14:23,060
exports less competitive because u.s wages are um people in the u.s uh are gaining more in wages

139
00:14:23,060 --> 00:14:29,000
and so it's less um it's less competitive for them to produce these products especially because we

140
00:14:29,000 --> 00:14:34,140
can import them so chiefly because other countries need dollars for oil and for the liquidity of

141
00:14:34,140 --> 00:14:40,720
global commerce. This leads to, over the long run, a structural trade deficit. We print dollars to

142
00:14:40,720 --> 00:14:46,100
buy Chinese goods, which depreciate in value. For the countries that are receiving dollars,

143
00:14:46,280 --> 00:14:52,320
usually in the form of treasuries, they can also diversify into U.S. real estate, U.S. equities.

144
00:14:52,320 --> 00:15:02,060
And so foreign holders of U.S. assets increases, which means that the future U.S. income streams

145
00:15:02,060 --> 00:15:08,180
from those assets decrease for domestic persons. So the result of this kind of is that U.S. has

146
00:15:08,180 --> 00:15:13,760
geopolitical strength. We issue this reserve asset. We can maintain military bases abroad.

147
00:15:14,060 --> 00:15:20,380
But given that we have this structural trade deficit, we end up deindustrializing,

148
00:15:20,560 --> 00:15:24,880
hollowing out our industrial base, and then that industrial base being reconstructed in other

149
00:15:24,880 --> 00:15:31,640
countries because it's cheaper to import than to create. This leads also to anger in the working

150
00:15:31,640 --> 00:15:39,840
class, a rise of populism. We can ask qui bono, who benefits? Other industries grow domestically

151
00:15:39,840 --> 00:15:44,260
that are not industrial, so to speak, those that have high margin in the domestic monopoly,

152
00:15:44,800 --> 00:15:49,160
and so don't need to worry about cheap imports. That tends to be, Alden mentions, finance,

153
00:15:49,540 --> 00:15:55,100
government, defense, technology, healthcare, whereas blue collar jobs then end up being

154
00:15:55,100 --> 00:16:02,480
kind of sent overseas abroad. So to summarize, to quote Alden, the past 50 years can be described

155
00:16:02,480 --> 00:16:08,680
as a period of dominion for United States elites, which came at the expansion of liberty and domestic

156
00:16:08,680 --> 00:16:16,320
economic vibrancy for the majority. United States, the empire, quote unquote, grew while United States,

157
00:16:16,440 --> 00:16:22,700
the country stagnated. And this was largely a bipartisan phenomenon. As a result, we have

158
00:16:22,700 --> 00:16:27,500
hundreds of foreign military bases while our domestic infrastructure is aging. We can win

159
00:16:27,500 --> 00:16:33,120
practically any naval battle while we fall behind the rest of the developed world in terms of

160
00:16:33,120 --> 00:16:38,780
education. We actively engage with China in a great power competition while relying heavily

161
00:16:38,780 --> 00:16:44,480
on importing Chinese-made goods to finance our consumption. So to focus on what she said there,

162
00:16:44,680 --> 00:16:49,840
United States, the empire versus United States, the country. United States, the empire is that

163
00:16:49,840 --> 00:16:56,820
which engaged in the war on terror, in which we invade Iraq, which has no connection to 9-11,

164
00:16:58,340 --> 00:17:03,380
in which we do that with lots of popular support because the United States, as the issuer of the

165
00:17:03,380 --> 00:17:08,940
world reserve currency, can simply print money rather than directly tax its citizens.

166
00:17:09,580 --> 00:17:14,380
Alden quotes somebody who gave congressional testimony who called these credit card wars

167
00:17:14,380 --> 00:17:18,940
that are financed through a congressional mechanism that does not require offsets in the budget.

168
00:17:18,940 --> 00:17:25,520
So United States, the empire can print money to fund questionable endeavors like the war on terror as it occurred in Iraq.

169
00:17:26,140 --> 00:17:29,780
We then also kind of see this empire decaying nowadays.

170
00:17:30,120 --> 00:17:35,900
Maybe we feel it, but the way that Alden describes it more objectively is how China is subverting it.

171
00:17:36,400 --> 00:17:42,240
China declares in 2013 that it's not in their interest to stack dollars to hold U.S. treasuries.

172
00:17:42,840 --> 00:17:52,980
Instead, they launched something called the Belt and Road Initiative, which is kind of their attempt to engage in neocolonialism and mimic the IMF and World Bank.

173
00:17:53,600 --> 00:18:07,140
China is now going to do a type of predatory lending, one might say, financing projects in developing countries with lots of strings attached about future usage of the projects, usually infrastructure that they're sponsoring, that they're funding.

174
00:18:07,140 --> 00:18:16,800
um also china benefits by industrializing even as u.s industry is hollowed out so the summary is

175
00:18:16,800 --> 00:18:22,700
that u.s kind of overall u.s is now defending its trade defending all these trade routes around the

176
00:18:22,700 --> 00:18:27,340
world with its powerful navy while china conducts the most trade through these routes

177
00:18:27,340 --> 00:18:35,700
so alden does give some prescription as to what should happen when she says um we should pull back

178
00:18:35,700 --> 00:18:41,760
from United States the empire and emphasize United States the country.

179
00:18:42,700 --> 00:18:48,360
And she even goes as far as to say that we should get rid of the dollar reserve,

180
00:18:49,060 --> 00:18:51,860
the dollar as having this reserve currency status.

181
00:18:52,240 --> 00:18:57,660
To quote Alden, losing dollar hegemony at this point would harm special interests

182
00:18:57,660 --> 00:19:00,600
in the United States, would reduce the country's imperial reach,

183
00:19:00,940 --> 00:19:05,320
and would require a shift of priorities, but ultimately it would lead toward

184
00:19:05,320 --> 00:19:12,140
a more natural and balanced global economy and provide the opportunity for U.S. domestic revitalization.

185
00:19:14,340 --> 00:19:18,940
Can another country even issue the reserve currency? What happens if the U.S. steps back?

186
00:19:19,220 --> 00:19:24,980
Europe seems insufficient to the task. All the notes, they have insufficient kind of energy

187
00:19:24,980 --> 00:19:31,220
independence. China also doesn't seem up to the task. They have a weak rule of law,

188
00:19:31,220 --> 00:19:35,480
kind of people don't trust the ccp to manage the global reserve currency

189
00:19:35,480 --> 00:19:42,160
does the world though need a reserve currency what it needs alvin says as she ends this chapter

190
00:19:42,160 --> 00:19:47,040
is a neutral reserve asset that has natural scarcity and that is not issued by a government

191
00:19:47,040 --> 00:19:53,660
and that we might take to be a nod to bitcoin so to toss it over to you lucas the question i was

192
00:19:53,660 --> 00:20:00,560
left with like exiting this chapter like alvin it really gestures towards the multipolar world

193
00:20:00,560 --> 00:20:06,340
that uses that word multipolar. I mean, do you think that the US, there's a lot of people who

194
00:20:06,340 --> 00:20:12,240
like the idea of US as an empire, like dollar dominance. I think even Trump seems mixed. He

195
00:20:12,240 --> 00:20:16,840
wants a strong dollar, even as he does endorse more populist sentiments of wanting to revitalize

196
00:20:16,840 --> 00:20:22,320
domestically. So what do you think about that idea of refocusing on United States, the country

197
00:20:22,320 --> 00:20:29,800
versus United States, the empire, maybe even to the extent of sacrificing US dollar hegemony?

198
00:20:30,560 --> 00:20:41,100
having the world reserve currency is a good job if you could get it because

199
00:20:41,100 --> 00:20:49,660
breaking it down into a very simple way of conceptualizing it if i'm the united states

200
00:20:49,660 --> 00:20:56,560
and you are every other country in the world who uses the dollar and we're sitting across

201
00:20:56,560 --> 00:21:06,880
the table from each other and you are knitting socks or you are writing books or you are baking

202
00:21:06,880 --> 00:21:18,360
pies or you are making shoes. You make a shoe. I instantly write something on a piece of paper.

203
00:21:18,560 --> 00:21:24,860
I hand that to you and now I take the shoe and you just accept it. And then you make another shoe

204
00:21:24,860 --> 00:21:29,640
and it takes you three hours to make this shoe and it takes me three seconds to write this thing

205
00:21:29,640 --> 00:21:34,300
on a piece of paper and I hand it to you and you give me the shoe and when it goes the other way

206
00:21:34,300 --> 00:21:42,040
I have a piece of paper and I'm like I'm going to write on this piece of paper for your benefit

207
00:21:42,040 --> 00:21:47,080
I'm going to create a contract and it's going to take me

208
00:21:47,080 --> 00:21:56,540
30 minutes and you're going to have to work 15 hours in order to, you're going to have to make

209
00:21:56,540 --> 00:22:01,780
10 pairs of shoes or something like that in order for me to exchange that for you. So it creates

210
00:22:01,780 --> 00:22:10,460
this obviously beneficial for the, for the kingdom, for the empire that has it. It creates this ability

211
00:22:10,460 --> 00:22:18,520
to not have to spend time in the same manner that other participants have to spend time

212
00:22:18,520 --> 00:22:22,080
in order to acquire goods and acquire services.

213
00:22:22,960 --> 00:22:25,020
So it's a great job if you can get it.

214
00:22:25,160 --> 00:22:30,960
I think the story that Alden gives, the heavy is the head that wears the crown, which is

215
00:22:30,960 --> 00:22:37,440
the story of the king who has this person that says, oh, your life must be so great

216
00:22:37,440 --> 00:22:38,300
because you're king.

217
00:22:38,400 --> 00:22:40,160
And the king says, all right, cool, step into it.

218
00:22:40,160 --> 00:22:40,940
Let's see what happens.

219
00:22:41,020 --> 00:22:45,580
And he says, all right, wear the crown, sit on the throne, have the servants, have the power.

220
00:22:46,100 --> 00:22:54,060
And the guy's sitting there and he's having a great time until he looks up and he realizes that there's a sword dangling on a string above his head.

221
00:22:54,560 --> 00:22:57,780
And if that string is severed, then he's dead.

222
00:22:57,780 --> 00:23:04,120
And what it makes you think of is that there.

223
00:23:05,120 --> 00:23:14,280
So you said something about the Navy of the United States, basically, is like we have this Navy that can win any battle.

224
00:23:14,900 --> 00:23:21,520
And it's protecting the seas effectively for China's trade resources, because we're not trading.

225
00:23:21,720 --> 00:23:23,620
We're not sending things overseas.

226
00:23:23,620 --> 00:23:27,660
You know, we the things that we send overseas go in emails.

227
00:23:27,780 --> 00:23:29,620
and they go in telephone calls.

228
00:23:30,020 --> 00:23:31,760
We're not sending products overseas.

229
00:23:32,000 --> 00:23:34,200
A little bit, but nowhere near compared.

230
00:23:35,460 --> 00:23:38,220
But what I heard when you said that in my mind,

231
00:23:38,640 --> 00:23:42,580
it was that the United States can win any naval battle for now.

232
00:23:43,100 --> 00:23:44,240
Like, for now.

233
00:23:44,440 --> 00:23:46,300
Until they don't, you know.

234
00:23:46,860 --> 00:23:52,220
And the thing about the string hanging over the head of the king

235
00:23:52,220 --> 00:23:54,560
is that the string eventually breaks.

236
00:23:54,560 --> 00:24:12,740
I mean, even if it isn't cut, it just severs. It falls under the weakness of the might of the oppressive force that is trying to escape from its containment.

237
00:24:12,740 --> 00:24:16,520
You know, the sword is the oppressive force trying to escape from its containment.

238
00:24:17,380 --> 00:24:21,040
When it's dangled by a string, developed nations are the oppressive.

239
00:24:21,240 --> 00:24:23,360
They're not they're oppressive to the United States.

240
00:24:23,500 --> 00:24:27,760
At least they they are in what they need to do in order to survive.

241
00:24:27,880 --> 00:24:31,460
They're not, I don't think, naturally opposed in any way.

242
00:24:31,560 --> 00:24:35,660
I don't I don't see that they are wanting to actually be enemies.

243
00:24:35,660 --> 00:24:41,800
But you see that they they want to escape from this system.

244
00:24:42,160 --> 00:24:45,100
And there have been attempts and there have been tries.

245
00:24:45,100 --> 00:25:06,880
And those attempts and those tries have been thwarted most often in the way of financial repression, but also very overtly in terms of covert action, you know, CIA meddling or the uprising of a different candidate.

246
00:25:06,880 --> 00:25:32,020
You know, it's it is strange how the United States, which wants to spread freedom, seems to be really good at putting dictators into power and removing democratically elected candidates, which would seem counterintuitive to the narrative that is that is being spread.

247
00:25:32,020 --> 00:25:39,360
And that takes me back to my very first thought about this chapter was the narrative versus the actuality.

248
00:25:39,620 --> 00:25:44,920
Before we got on camera, we were talking about first principles and trying to think from first principles.

249
00:25:45,200 --> 00:26:03,809
You don accept what somebody tells you about something and you also don accept the relationship to something that is familiar to that You don accept the reason by analogy You break it down into the grounded theory that Jason Lowry uses in his thesis And

250
00:26:03,809 --> 00:26:14,269
so the monetary neocolonialism that is popularized by the United States as the

251
00:26:14,269 --> 00:26:21,269
issuer of the world currency, the narrative is something almost like domestication.

252
00:26:21,269 --> 00:26:35,329
It's sort of like this, you know, you've got this benevolent superpower and it's like they're adopting this this lost, you know, developing country and and offering guidance and cooperation.

253
00:26:38,289 --> 00:26:43,829
It's it's almost like like they're a cow and we are going to care for the cow.

254
00:26:43,949 --> 00:26:46,769
We're going to feed the cow. We're going to make sure that coyotes don't kill the cow.

255
00:26:48,269 --> 00:26:50,949
And then what we're going to take in exchange is the milk.

256
00:26:51,269 --> 00:27:11,889
That's kind of the narrative. But then there's the other way of viewing it, which is to look at what the outcomes are and to look at the outcomes in these countries and the examples that Alden gives, especially with the shrimp field, which it makes you it makes me think of the Bible.

257
00:27:11,889 --> 00:27:24,589
There's a story in Judges about how a conqueror then goes out and salts the fields of the conquered in order to make them infertile so that they can't grow their own food.

258
00:27:25,089 --> 00:27:27,129
And they are therefore dependent upon him.

259
00:27:27,129 --> 00:27:33,809
And that's what happened with these shrimp farms was that they leveled all of these trees.

260
00:27:33,809 --> 00:27:50,248
They tore out all of this ground that, or not tore out, they flooded all of this ground that had previously been farm ground that these people were using to feed themselves, to create their own food, to be self-sufficient.

261
00:27:51,209 --> 00:27:56,589
And now, not only is that land taken out of production, but they flooded it with salt water.

262
00:27:56,589 --> 00:28:16,468
And so even if you do remove that, then that salt remains. I used to actually work in this industry. I used to work in the soil amendment industry where we would take gypsum and use it to naturally remove salt from soil because it will bind with it.

263
00:28:16,468 --> 00:28:22,748
the calcium sulfate will break down with the addition of water and bind with the sodium

264
00:28:22,748 --> 00:28:32,708
and draw it out of there. And you would see insane differences in a very short time,

265
00:28:32,708 --> 00:28:40,889
but it does take a while. It still takes a while. And by the way, this is just the small amount of

266
00:28:40,889 --> 00:28:45,789
salt that you get from pumping a little, um, a little salt water out of the ground. It's not,

267
00:28:45,789 --> 00:28:50,889
this is not ocean water. This is not ocean water. That's been flooded on top of this for years,

268
00:28:50,968 --> 00:28:56,629
you know? So this, the, the second and third order effects of these decisions are not,

269
00:28:56,949 --> 00:29:02,289
these are not easily reversible decisions, but so anyway, so you, you, it's affected. It's like

270
00:29:02,289 --> 00:29:08,829
this biblical punishment of the conquered of salting the fields of the conquered to make them

271
00:29:08,829 --> 00:29:19,748
depended upon you and it instead of milking the cow it's almost like going out to sedate the cow

272
00:29:19,748 --> 00:29:29,089
slowly cut off a steak and then bandage it up and let it hobble off and then the next day do it again

273
00:29:29,089 --> 00:29:38,589
and the next day and it becomes this horrific it becomes this horror movie of slowly cutting off

274
00:29:38,589 --> 00:29:47,669
the pieces until there is nothing left and, and then taking that as your, as the spoils of your,

275
00:29:47,769 --> 00:29:56,049
of your victory. So, um, the, the question about, um, the United States having the world reserve

276
00:29:56,049 --> 00:30:01,708
currency and, and kind of what do we, what, where do we go from here? Um, you know, is it something

277
00:30:01,708 --> 00:30:11,109
that we want to maintain. I would say that it's a whole lot like a movie star who

278
00:30:11,109 --> 00:30:17,988
gets really used to doing the press and stops doing the work on their, you know, they're like,

279
00:30:18,049 --> 00:30:22,629
they're an action star. And the thing that got them the role was the body that they had, right?

280
00:30:22,708 --> 00:30:28,549
They like, Oh, this guy looks incredible. And then he gets the roles. And now he gets all the money

281
00:30:28,549 --> 00:30:33,189
and he gets to stand in front of a crowd and just make money for standing there.

282
00:30:34,029 --> 00:30:38,589
But when he abandons going to the gym, when he stops doing the work,

283
00:30:38,669 --> 00:30:40,208
when he stops maintaining the body,

284
00:30:40,429 --> 00:30:48,389
then you only have the last vestiges of the people that don't feel like they have any other choice

285
00:30:48,389 --> 00:30:50,029
because they're invested in you.

286
00:30:50,208 --> 00:30:54,748
It's like, oh, this is the seventh movie in this series.

287
00:30:54,889 --> 00:30:57,349
I'm going to go watch it just because I watched the other six.

288
00:30:57,349 --> 00:31:03,189
But by now, the superstar is bald and fat and old and wrinkled.

289
00:31:03,349 --> 00:31:07,309
And it's not believable, the things that they're doing in the movie.

290
00:31:07,549 --> 00:31:13,129
But you're just hanging on to it because you're suspending disbelief in order to be a participant in something.

291
00:31:14,508 --> 00:31:21,189
I think if I can kind of view it that way, that's sort of how the United States looks right now.

292
00:31:21,189 --> 00:31:24,309
And by the way, our movies reflect this.

293
00:31:24,488 --> 00:31:25,728
Our media reflects this.

294
00:31:25,728 --> 00:31:31,089
If you watch any, you watch anything that comes out of Hollywood, it's almost always old.

295
00:31:31,449 --> 00:31:36,289
You know, it's people that were action stars in the 80s that are still action stars now.

296
00:31:37,369 --> 00:31:42,129
And we're revisiting all of these old movies and we're continuing to push this stuff out.

297
00:31:42,409 --> 00:31:48,029
Meantime, if you look at what Chinese movies and Chinese media look like, it looks like the stuff we put out in the 80s.

298
00:31:48,089 --> 00:31:48,689
It's badass.

299
00:31:48,689 --> 00:31:54,889
It's like Red Dawn on steroids with AI and it's killer and it's really good stuff.

300
00:31:54,889 --> 00:32:00,849
and it's actionable and it's young and it's vital and it's virile and it's strong.

301
00:32:01,069 --> 00:32:10,029
So I would say that the way that you look at that dollar dominance

302
00:32:10,029 --> 00:32:16,728
and whether or not you want to maintain it is it depends on your time horizon.

303
00:32:17,228 --> 00:32:21,289
If you can have that for a while, it's great, but it's never going to last

304
00:32:21,289 --> 00:32:28,508
because what we know about money is that the natural money that is hardest will always rise to the top.

305
00:32:28,508 --> 00:32:33,629
It doesn't matter what a global hierarchy says. It doesn't matter what they impose.

306
00:32:34,449 --> 00:32:43,049
There will be created a natural order whereby that reserve currency, if it's not the strongest,

307
00:32:43,449 --> 00:32:47,689
will be repatriated to the country that created it out of nothing.

308
00:32:47,689 --> 00:32:51,529
and their shores will be flooded with inflation, much like we see now.

309
00:32:51,669 --> 00:32:56,369
So you see other countries that they would much rather invest in United States real estate,

310
00:32:56,508 --> 00:33:00,889
United States equities, United States hard assets.

311
00:33:01,488 --> 00:33:05,649
And what that effectively is, is that we've got a fence

312
00:33:05,649 --> 00:33:11,708
and you've got these guys on the outside of the fence just throwing dollars back over into the pool

313
00:33:11,708 --> 00:33:15,429
and flooding it in order to get them out of their system

314
00:33:15,429 --> 00:33:20,029
and take the means of our production and put that in their portfolio.

315
00:33:20,269 --> 00:33:23,909
So it works against you in two ways.

316
00:33:23,909 --> 00:33:30,309
It increases your inflation and it loses your ability to be strong by, you know,

317
00:33:30,369 --> 00:33:35,049
hollowing out that industrial base, but also literally selling the means of production

318
00:33:35,049 --> 00:33:38,149
in exchange for the dollars that you created out of nothing.

319
00:33:38,609 --> 00:33:42,649
And by the way, by the time they get back to the United States,

320
00:33:42,649 --> 00:33:49,409
you're at the very, very tail end and the worst benefit of the Cantillon effect.

321
00:33:50,069 --> 00:33:53,988
It's, you know, it's great when you're selling it to the foreign country as a treasury.

322
00:33:54,228 --> 00:33:54,708
That's cool.

323
00:33:55,008 --> 00:33:59,508
And then it gets moved around and that, and then it finally gets, you know, it's like,

324
00:33:59,508 --> 00:34:00,869
this is the last thing.

325
00:34:01,329 --> 00:34:06,569
By now, these dollars are worth so much more less or worth so much less.

326
00:34:06,988 --> 00:34:11,448
And you know that they're worth so much less because you see the price of real estate,

327
00:34:11,448 --> 00:34:16,349
especially like farm real estate, you see that skyrocketing.

328
00:34:17,189 --> 00:34:21,289
You know, in the 80s, even into the 90s,

329
00:34:21,289 --> 00:34:25,249
you could see guys that were buying farm real estate in the United States

330
00:34:25,249 --> 00:34:28,648
for hundreds of dollars an acre, 400, 500, 600.

331
00:34:30,289 --> 00:34:34,488
You know, there's a lot of land out where my folks are that sold for 200, 400,

332
00:34:35,289 --> 00:34:39,329
something like that, dollars an acre in the 70s and 80s.

333
00:34:39,329 --> 00:34:44,209
And now it's three thousand, four thousand. And it's it's worse in other places.

334
00:34:44,209 --> 00:34:53,309
You go up into Iowa and they're selling farm ground for over twenty thousand dollars an acre that used to be sold for, you know, a thousand dollars an acre.

335
00:34:53,829 --> 00:35:01,689
And so you've had this problem for a long time and and and it's existed and it's getting it's getting worse.

336
00:35:01,689 --> 00:35:11,589
It's, you know, working in that industry, I saw a lot of foreign, mainly Chinese, a lot of foreign purchasing.

337
00:35:12,109 --> 00:35:18,909
So, yeah, it's I don't think I know that's a very long winded answer to your question because I wanted to kind of cover a couple of things.

338
00:35:19,069 --> 00:35:27,109
But when I think about whether or not it's valuable for the United States to hang on to the dollar as a world reserve currency, I don't know that it's really valuable now.

339
00:35:27,109 --> 00:35:41,369
I think we've passed the point of it being valuable because if you frame it in terms of not just can we create money out of thin air and use it to pay people for stuff.

340
00:35:42,389 --> 00:35:56,189
If you think about the second and third order effects of what happens with that when it comes back into this country, when we lose our industrial base, when we lose our means of production, then no, I would say that it's certainly not in the best interest of the United States.

341
00:35:56,189 --> 00:36:01,549
in probably any country to have the world reserve currency now because you have so many options.

342
00:36:02,729 --> 00:36:08,988
Yeah. So that is then – you're a patriotic American. That is – is that a vote for the end

343
00:36:08,988 --> 00:36:16,529
of American empire? And do you think that that's a problem? I mean Alden phrases it as we need to

344
00:36:16,529 --> 00:36:22,569
return to United States, the country, revitalize domestically and end this notion of United States,

345
00:36:22,569 --> 00:36:29,209
the empire. And she quotes or refers to Natalie Smolenski, who is a Bitcoin commentator,

346
00:36:29,709 --> 00:36:36,769
an anthropologist, and who kind of says that if you're going to back away from this, from some

347
00:36:36,769 --> 00:36:43,529
idea of America, the empire, you need to have a story to tell to Americans. People need something

348
00:36:43,529 --> 00:36:48,089
to be proud of. And you're not going to be proud of, we are a nation in decline, an empire in

349
00:36:48,089 --> 00:36:53,488
decline. And so, you know, if you want to step back from the United States, the empire, you need

350
00:36:53,488 --> 00:36:59,369
to tell a new story about United States, something else to stand in, give people a positive vision

351
00:36:59,369 --> 00:37:04,729
for what the future is going to look like. So I want to, I guess, just press you on that point,

352
00:37:04,729 --> 00:37:09,769
because I think it gets to the heart of maybe the dilemma that a lot of Americans might feel

353
00:37:09,769 --> 00:37:15,309
at hearing this is US dollar hegemony has negative and positive effects. You've went through them,

354
00:37:15,309 --> 00:37:22,988
we've talked about them. But US geopolitical hegemony has led to this idea of empire military

355
00:37:22,988 --> 00:37:27,988
bases in other countries, dramatic influence around the world. Is that something that a

356
00:37:27,988 --> 00:37:33,508
patriotic American should be willing to give up? And if so, what is the vision of the future that

357
00:37:33,508 --> 00:37:38,948
they're giving it up for? And just to complexify it a bit too, I think Trump has been a little bit

358
00:37:38,948 --> 00:37:44,429
schizophrenic on this, maybe seeing the, you know, that he's walking a tightrope, because on one hand,

359
00:37:44,429 --> 00:37:50,049
He's talking about like acquiring Greenland and the Panama Canal, these kind of seemingly imperial endeavors.

360
00:37:50,609 --> 00:37:55,089
He also talks about he chastises bricks for wanting to introduce a new currency.

361
00:37:55,569 --> 00:38:02,249
So he can seem a bit imperialist, even as he was definitely the less imperialist candidate in the elections.

362
00:38:02,809 --> 00:38:07,329
So what do you think about what is the new story for America if we step back from America the empire?

363
00:38:07,648 --> 00:38:09,669
And can a patriotic American do that?

364
00:38:09,669 --> 00:38:16,829
yeah i'm a patriotic american but i'm probably not the definition of what most people would

365
00:38:16,829 --> 00:38:23,809
think a patriotic american is i think that that term patriotism has really been bastardized to

366
00:38:23,809 --> 00:38:31,889
mean that you will support and enable um propaganda and that you will support and enable

367
00:38:31,889 --> 00:38:36,849
almost like addictive type behavior from your country.

368
00:38:36,849 --> 00:38:41,128
So if I think about like, am I, am I a loving son?

369
00:38:41,448 --> 00:38:45,909
And I think about my father, like I am a loving son to my father because I,

370
00:38:46,269 --> 00:38:49,648
I want him to be, I want him to be strong.

371
00:38:49,749 --> 00:38:50,729
I want him to be healthy.

372
00:38:50,968 --> 00:38:56,429
And therefore I, I will, I will, you know,

373
00:38:56,429 --> 00:39:00,109
encourage him to do those things that make him healthy as opposed to,

374
00:39:00,109 --> 00:39:19,589
You know, like, basically, it's, it's like, do I want to listen to the stories of the strength of your youth? Or do I want to see you be strong now? I don't want to I don't want to enable the reminiscing and the rumination of America as the empire.

375
00:39:19,589 --> 00:39:31,029
at the cost of the planning and the sacrifice that needs to be made for America, the country,

376
00:39:31,029 --> 00:39:41,389
to be strong. So I agree entirely and I disagree with Trump's stance on some of that. I just think

377
00:39:41,389 --> 00:39:48,209
he's ill-informed. I think that, and it's fun to say this because you can say this now,

378
00:39:48,968 --> 00:39:50,889
And it can probably be true.

379
00:39:51,029 --> 00:40:02,909
I think there's a whole lot of people that understand how the monetary system works and what you can and can't do with it much better than Trump and some of the people that are around him to advise.

380
00:40:02,909 --> 00:40:21,889
I do think that he has some really good people, but you can't on one hand promote a strategic Bitcoin reserve and on the other hand say that the United States dollar is going to maintain strength as the world reserve currency.

381
00:40:21,889 --> 00:40:37,769
Because if you promote the United States as the world currency, then you're trying to fight against the inevitability of a superior technology that is taking over, regardless of what you think about it.

382
00:40:37,769 --> 00:40:46,128
Like, you know, war is not, you know, what is the quote is that you may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.

383
00:40:46,669 --> 00:40:53,389
And Bitcoin is war. If you look at it from Lowry's perspective, you don't you don't have to be interested in it.

384
00:40:53,889 --> 00:40:57,929
You don't have to show it strength. You don't have to support it.

385
00:40:57,929 --> 00:41:05,589
it's just taking over. It's just eating things. It's just removing the competition and like the

386
00:41:05,589 --> 00:41:14,809
Strangler Vine coming up upon all of the competitors and running over them in the manner

387
00:41:14,809 --> 00:41:22,468
that a bulldozer runs over an ant. It is inconsequential. Tick tock next block. This

388
00:41:22,468 --> 00:41:28,789
train never stops it. And those are these fun little sayings that we have, but, but it is true.

389
00:41:28,789 --> 00:41:36,709
Like nothing is stopping this. And so, um, this is posturing. Um, it's ill-informed posturing.

390
00:41:36,709 --> 00:41:42,769
It is, I think probably specifically as posturing, uh, saying that the United States is going to

391
00:41:42,769 --> 00:41:47,128
maintain the strength of the dollar that, you know, you can't, you know, bricks is not going

392
00:41:47,128 --> 00:41:52,549
to happen that you're not going to like bricks is going to happen um or something like bricks is

393
00:41:52,549 --> 00:41:58,789
going to happen um or the whole system just evolves and and countries no longer feel like

394
00:41:58,789 --> 00:42:08,829
they need to have all of these uh political allies and political ties because you don't need that to

395
00:42:08,829 --> 00:42:15,589
maintain a currency anymore you have something that maintains itself um it it doesn't care it's

396
00:42:15,589 --> 00:42:23,069
superordinate to all of your laws. It's superordinate to all of your ideals. It stands

397
00:42:23,069 --> 00:42:32,689
on top and it cannot be stopped by your technological attempts. And so, yeah, I just don't

398
00:42:32,689 --> 00:42:39,148
think that there is a whole lot of congruence between the things that Trump and that administration

399
00:42:39,148 --> 00:42:47,369
is saying with regard to attempting to maintain the dollar's position at the top of the pile.

400
00:42:48,109 --> 00:42:52,648
I just and I also just don't think it's useful. I really don't think it's useful to the United

401
00:42:52,648 --> 00:43:00,608
States. You can make the argument that there's a political advantage to be gained by doing that

402
00:43:00,608 --> 00:43:05,789
because you can probably fool the world and you can probably maintain you might be able to even

403
00:43:05,789 --> 00:43:12,369
push out some strength for the next two years and make sure that you're in a good position to win

404
00:43:12,369 --> 00:43:18,409
the midterm elections. But I was thinking of it in my mind last night. I was thinking about

405
00:43:18,409 --> 00:43:28,968
Germany in the 1930s and the thousand-year Reich, right? This vision of a thousand years for this

406
00:43:28,968 --> 00:43:35,108
country. Obviously, there were some things that went wrong, but if you're thinking long-term,

407
00:43:35,108 --> 00:43:37,669
then you're going to do things long term for your country.

408
00:43:38,209 --> 00:43:42,549
But if you're thinking short term, if you're thinking two years to the next election,

409
00:43:43,049 --> 00:43:46,468
then I think you're going to make some really stupid mistakes.

410
00:43:46,909 --> 00:43:53,769
I don't think that there's any validity in trying to maintain the dollar as the world's reserve currency.

411
00:43:54,309 --> 00:44:00,669
I actually believe that the faster the shock happens, the better it will be.

412
00:44:00,669 --> 00:44:25,148
Um, but that's just my, I guess that's just my experience from my own life experience, which is that whenever there has been a shock in my life, whenever there's been a crisis, um, it helps to realign priorities in a way that is much more clear than if something is slowly going wrong and slowly falling by the wayside.

413
00:44:25,148 --> 00:44:32,389
So I don't know. I kind of want to know, yeah, what do you think about that in terms of speed?

414
00:44:33,128 --> 00:44:33,449
Yeah.

415
00:44:33,749 --> 00:44:41,669
And I'll set it up by saying one of the things that I'm really interested in is studying, I think it's called the Hankey Krauss hyperinflation table.

416
00:44:42,488 --> 00:44:51,508
I've seen Bology, sort of awesome post it, and I've seen a couple other places, which shows the amount of time that it takes for a currency to hyperinflate.

417
00:44:51,508 --> 00:44:56,249
And I believe they define hyperinflation by prices doubling.

418
00:44:57,029 --> 00:45:09,869
So there's a whole page full of these examples of major and minor and developing currencies that have hyperinflated during the – by the way, they're all during the fiat currency era.

419
00:45:10,229 --> 00:45:11,809
Like this doesn't happen in silver.

420
00:45:11,988 --> 00:45:13,269
This doesn't happen in cattle.

421
00:45:13,369 --> 00:45:14,369
This doesn't happen in salt.

422
00:45:14,369 --> 00:45:20,508
It only happens in fiat currency because eventually the music stops and there's the,

423
00:45:20,988 --> 00:45:22,628
everybody goes for a chair and there's no chairs.

424
00:45:23,929 --> 00:45:30,389
But anyways, the thing that I remember looking at it was I think the fastest occurrence for

425
00:45:30,389 --> 00:45:34,749
prices to double was like a day, something like that.

426
00:45:34,968 --> 00:45:41,508
And then there's a whole bunch of them where it's like, you know, 30 days, 25 days, 45 days,

427
00:45:41,508 --> 00:45:48,589
67 days. But during every single one of those examples, there was not an off ramp. And today

428
00:45:48,589 --> 00:45:54,968
there exists an off ramp. Like if Germany would have had an off ramp for their Deutschmark in the

429
00:45:54,968 --> 00:46:01,529
20s when they hyperinflated, during a time where people were, the stories are you would go into a

430
00:46:01,529 --> 00:46:05,289
bar and you would pay for all your drinks at the beginning of the night because by the end of the

431
00:46:05,289 --> 00:46:10,309
night, the prices would have gone up. That's how fast their inflation was happening. And they didn't

432
00:46:10,309 --> 00:46:17,968
have an off ramp. They didn't have a way for people to maintain the little bit of strength

433
00:46:17,968 --> 00:46:24,589
left in their currency by moving it to something that was going to retain value. Instead, they

434
00:46:24,589 --> 00:46:31,269
hyperinflated it by putting that currency back. You want to spend that money as fast as possible.

435
00:46:31,449 --> 00:46:38,589
It becomes that debt spiral, or not debt spiral, but it becomes a spiral where the money, once it

436
00:46:38,589 --> 00:46:44,589
starts becoming worth less, you start spinning it faster and faster and faster and faster because

437
00:46:44,589 --> 00:46:51,369
you get less and less and less. And eventually it hyperinflates and explodes. So I kind of want to,

438
00:46:52,108 --> 00:46:57,949
this is not really a theoretical question, but you're more than welcome to opine upon the speed

439
00:46:57,949 --> 00:47:06,008
at which you think this can take. To put it into reference, I think it took about 30 years or so

440
00:47:06,008 --> 00:47:11,128
for the world to really go to gold after they left to buy metallic standard.

441
00:47:11,128 --> 00:47:16,949
And anybody left holding silver in their bags was caught out in the cold.

442
00:47:17,468 --> 00:47:24,929
And we've read about this example earlier in this book where China tried to maintain a silver standard

443
00:47:24,929 --> 00:47:31,669
and they fell behind by about 400 years in a manner of about 30 years.

444
00:47:32,189 --> 00:47:33,988
They really lost their position in the world.

445
00:47:33,988 --> 00:47:42,729
So if if we do see something like this, I mean, it's not if we will.

446
00:47:43,309 --> 00:47:46,008
But where do you think it goes in terms of speed?

447
00:47:46,169 --> 00:47:50,909
And what do you think that it's beneficial for it to happen faster than slower?

448
00:47:50,909 --> 00:48:08,988
Is there actually some benefit to Trump trying to walk a tightrope and use Bitcoin to shore up the dollar while also trying to push out the dollar as the world's reserve currency and maintain that status?

449
00:48:08,988 --> 00:48:22,289
Like, is that something that should be approached? I'm kind of throwing your question back at you. But with the addition of commenting on the speed aspect of it, is it better if it happens quickly or over 30 years?

450
00:48:22,289 --> 00:48:30,569
so on the speed question um generally as you know it tends to happen very quickly metcalf's law

451
00:48:30,569 --> 00:48:34,849
is that a network's value increases as the participants in the network increase

452
00:48:34,849 --> 00:48:39,988
in a sort of exponential way because each of the nodes on the network is connecting with more and

453
00:48:39,988 --> 00:48:46,269
more nodes as each new node is added alden in a past chapter said there's reverse metcalf's law

454
00:48:46,269 --> 00:48:51,749
when the network collapses and they tend to collapse very very quickly with regard to trump

455
00:48:51,749 --> 00:48:55,029
as you were talking, I think I might have been conflating two things as well.

456
00:48:55,209 --> 00:48:59,488
There is the notion of maintaining a strong dollar and also the notion of

457
00:48:59,488 --> 00:49:03,488
maintaining the dollar as the U.S. reserve currency, like the unit of account.

458
00:49:03,488 --> 00:49:05,289
I think those are at odds with each other.

459
00:49:06,869 --> 00:49:14,269
So maybe, yeah, to a certain extent, I mean, U.S. has to keep on,

460
00:49:14,369 --> 00:49:17,648
to maintain global liquidity, has to keep on providing dollars.

461
00:49:18,329 --> 00:49:21,349
But the dollar is strong right now, and it does have strength with respect

462
00:49:21,349 --> 00:49:25,889
to other currencies. So the question is, can we maintain, can we keep the dollar from collapsing

463
00:49:25,889 --> 00:49:34,289
while extricating it as the global reserve asset? And I think that's behind good faith criticism

464
00:49:34,289 --> 00:49:39,949
of the Bitcoin strategic reserve. And Nick Carter specifically is somebody who's pro-Bitcoin.

465
00:49:41,628 --> 00:49:45,889
He's a venture capitalist in Florida. I think it's Castle Island or something like that is his

466
00:49:45,889 --> 00:49:49,648
company, but he's a prolific commentator on Twitter as well and in the media.

467
00:49:50,648 --> 00:49:55,749
And he has come out against the strategic Bitcoin reserve, at least as far as having

468
00:49:55,749 --> 00:49:58,468
an acquisition element to it of getting new Bitcoin.

469
00:49:59,229 --> 00:50:07,988
For that reason, I think that he thinks it would quickly, it would signal a lack of confidence

470
00:50:07,988 --> 00:50:10,309
in the dollar and so weaken the dollar.

471
00:50:11,389 --> 00:50:15,749
And I think that, I mean, I don't agree or disagree with that.

472
00:50:15,749 --> 00:50:30,709
I think I kind of actually disagree with that. But I think that in any case, there are people who want to think, and I think we all do, about how to navigate the extrication of the U.S. as a world reserve asset while maintaining the strength of the dollar.

473
00:50:30,709 --> 00:50:44,309
And I think that it's going to happen quickly in terms of like a five to 10 year period, which I think is actually be slow in monetary terms and network terms.

474
00:50:44,309 --> 00:50:53,809
But I think that it can be managed with things like Tether being tied to both treasuries and Bitcoin.

475
00:50:53,809 --> 00:51:02,589
so things that tie the dollar to bitcoin i think are going to help us transition to more bitcoin

476
00:51:02,589 --> 00:51:07,589
usage while maintaining the strength of the dollar something like that um i don't know if that answers

477
00:51:07,589 --> 00:51:11,949
your question but i think that the goal is to maintain the strength of the dollar to a certain

478
00:51:11,949 --> 00:51:17,148
extent while extricating it as a global reserve currency i think that that's a good idea because

479
00:51:17,148 --> 00:51:23,108
i do think that america the empire is a notion that um should end not in a negative sense of

480
00:51:23,108 --> 00:51:29,648
the collapse of the empire, but in a revitalized domestic United States. So a new narrative,

481
00:51:29,648 --> 00:51:34,089
a new story, a new positive story arising that is not about empire, that is about

482
00:51:34,089 --> 00:51:39,089
make America great again, you know, telling a new story about domestic revitalization that gives

483
00:51:39,089 --> 00:51:46,889
people hope, even as America's imperial aspirations are retracted. So I guess I see that as the twin

484
00:51:46,889 --> 00:51:59,317
goal is extricating the US currency from reserve status and also pulling back from imperial aspiration both of those connected And I think both of those pointing towards a positive future and things that can be managed

485
00:51:59,417 --> 00:51:59,797
I guess.

486
00:52:01,397 --> 00:52:05,697
I wouldn't, I don't know, I'm not pushing back, but I am going to challenge.

487
00:52:06,097 --> 00:52:07,637
I don't think that the dollar is strong.

488
00:52:07,757 --> 00:52:14,577
I think the dollar is the weakest it's probably ever been in history and continuing to get

489
00:52:14,577 --> 00:52:14,877
weaker.

490
00:52:14,877 --> 00:52:20,077
It just appears to be strong because it's being compared to a basket of other currencies.

491
00:52:20,237 --> 00:52:36,197
But if we compare it to things that are less changing, like a house or the cost of farm real estate or the cost of Bitcoin, it would appear that the dollar is actually at or near the weakest it's ever been.

492
00:52:36,197 --> 00:52:55,497
And it just, to me, I'll go back to something that I think was really, when I heard Michael Saylor challenge somebody on diversification, who said, I think you should have 2% of your assets in Bitcoin.

493
00:52:55,817 --> 00:53:00,277
And he said, okay, it's cool that you want to do that.

494
00:53:00,417 --> 00:53:03,837
However, show me 49 better ideas and I'll do it.

495
00:53:03,837 --> 00:53:10,617
and that's kind of what I think about like he was the first person to frame it in that way for me and

496
00:53:10,617 --> 00:53:18,957
now I kind of see that in every other avenue where Tom Brady was like I'm gonna throw footballs

497
00:53:18,957 --> 00:53:25,037
and nobody else like said maybe you should diversify into bowling and trimming hedges

498
00:53:25,037 --> 00:53:31,237
you know because you're you're really good but um you know diversification is really how you how

499
00:53:31,237 --> 00:53:38,437
you make it. It's like, no, I think I'll just throw footballs. And in Coca-Cola, you know,

500
00:53:38,497 --> 00:53:45,437
they make, make soda and maybe you should make tractors and maybe you should make lawn ornaments.

501
00:53:45,437 --> 00:53:50,377
They're like, no, actually we're just really good at mixing sugar up with water. And so we're going

502
00:53:50,377 --> 00:53:57,017
to do that. And that's how you become dominant. You don't become dominant by being indecisive.

503
00:53:57,017 --> 00:54:12,237
You don't when you find the person that you want to be with, you don't also navigate 10 other relationships at one time in order to say, well, I'm going to put two percent of my love here.

504
00:54:12,237 --> 00:54:17,637
You know, and by the way, that's what you see, like the happiest people have the tightest knit families.

505
00:54:17,877 --> 00:54:28,777
They're close and they're they're really they really have a social community that they've invested a great deal of their time in a small amount of people.

506
00:54:29,377 --> 00:54:34,097
So you've invested a great deal of your resources in a small amount of opportunities.

507
00:54:34,097 --> 00:54:45,057
And so, yeah, I just I would challenge anybody that thinks that they can save the fiat system in any fashion.

508
00:54:46,517 --> 00:54:53,117
You know, why would you ever choose to be involved?

509
00:54:53,277 --> 00:54:54,457
Like you have a choice.

510
00:54:54,457 --> 00:55:06,837
So why would you choose to be involved with a system that systematically robs you when you can buy the thing with the money that they're using to rob you?

511
00:55:07,217 --> 00:55:14,817
You can buy the thing that they are talking about using to make their robbery proliferate for longer.

512
00:55:14,817 --> 00:55:22,237
um you know like we we're gonna we're gonna we're gonna buy this thing that that makes it easier

513
00:55:22,237 --> 00:55:28,357
for us to do this for longer to you and you're like well actually I can just buy that thing too

514
00:55:28,357 --> 00:55:33,937
you know I don't I don't I no longer have to buy your dollars I no longer have to be subject to

515
00:55:33,937 --> 00:55:40,497
your seizures I no longer have to be subject to your freezes and to your your sanctions I can just

516
00:55:40,497 --> 00:55:46,537
by. I mean, to me, I don't, I don't think there is, I think that anyone that thinks that there

517
00:55:46,537 --> 00:55:53,997
is an option here is woefully uninformed on what it looks like when a superior technology comes

518
00:55:53,997 --> 00:55:59,697
around. The car showed up and nobody rides horses anymore. The plane showed up and nobody walks

519
00:55:59,697 --> 00:56:04,217
places anymore. The refrigerator showed up and there's nobody delivering milk anymore.

520
00:56:04,217 --> 00:56:13,737
like these these superior technologies they don't move in and take a little bit of the market share

521
00:56:13,737 --> 00:56:20,097
they take over everything um and so that's kind of how i view it i just i just don't think that

522
00:56:20,097 --> 00:56:24,657
there is there is that interim period where things get messy and that's why i hope that it goes very

523
00:56:24,657 --> 00:56:29,277
fast because i don't want that mess to last for long no that's i mean my response was about speed

524
00:56:29,277 --> 00:56:33,197
and the strength of the US dollar in reference to other currencies

525
00:56:33,197 --> 00:56:37,537
and not in reference to the dollar over time.

526
00:56:39,397 --> 00:56:43,637
So I just don't think that speed and decline,

527
00:56:44,097 --> 00:56:47,197
it is like pulling the Band-Aid off quickly,

528
00:56:47,557 --> 00:56:52,717
but the financial system is designed around the US dollar

529
00:56:52,717 --> 00:56:55,617
and it's going to take some time, not centuries,

530
00:56:55,617 --> 00:57:02,757
but not days either to redesign it, reincorporate it, build faith in the new system.

531
00:57:02,917 --> 00:57:06,617
And so I agree that superior technology over time wins.

532
00:57:07,757 --> 00:57:10,797
But I think that it's the U.S. should.

533
00:57:12,177 --> 00:57:16,997
Alden gives this metaphor or just says pivot from a place of strength rather than weakness.

534
00:57:16,997 --> 00:57:22,817
And I think that that means that she gives this other metaphor of the U.S. right now through the structural deficit.

535
00:57:22,817 --> 00:57:27,597
it. It's like a boxer taking punches. The damage is accruing. And not feeling it.

536
00:57:27,837 --> 00:57:32,757
Yeah. And you're not feeling it until such a point as you just kind of collapse. And so I don't think

537
00:57:32,757 --> 00:57:37,957
that that collapse is what should happen. I think the speed, we should decelerate the decline in

538
00:57:37,957 --> 00:57:44,737
order to ramp up the future, which I do think is a Bitcoin standard. But I think that that comes

539
00:57:44,737 --> 00:57:50,537
with the US can manage its transition to it in a way that maintains the strength of the dollar

540
00:57:50,537 --> 00:57:57,517
in the sense of not completely devastating people who have invested their lives in some

541
00:57:57,517 --> 00:58:02,537
savings tech related to the dollar. You know, not everybody's full in on Bitcoin,

542
00:58:02,857 --> 00:58:07,077
and there needs to be an, there doesn't need to be, but it would be good if the US in some way,

543
00:58:07,077 --> 00:58:13,777
I think, could help manage a transition that was not sudden and overnight, that didn't go from

544
00:58:13,777 --> 00:58:18,657
hyperinflating the US dollar to grasping onto Bitcoin, that there was pivoting from strength

545
00:58:18,657 --> 00:58:27,577
to manage imperial retraction and the dollar's relative strength while we adopt new tech.

546
00:58:28,077 --> 00:58:31,977
So I guess I don't think that speed is necessarily what we want to endorse,

547
00:58:32,557 --> 00:58:37,837
except that on a modest timeframe, we want to pivot to something new,

548
00:58:37,937 --> 00:58:41,617
if that makes sense, kind of a mishmash, mealy-mouthed, moderate position.

549
00:58:41,617 --> 00:58:49,477
Yeah, I think, I don't know, I just think that's like a, I think that's a nice political answer.

550
00:58:49,477 --> 00:59:06,137
But in terms of when I think when I think about what the United States is is maybe proposing to try to do with this, it seems as though you're trying to slowly manipulate the market.

551
00:59:06,137 --> 00:59:11,817
And when you manipulate the market, what you do is you send the wrong signals to producers and consumers.

552
00:59:11,997 --> 00:59:15,637
Producers produce things that shouldn't be produced and they don't produce things that should be.

553
00:59:15,637 --> 00:59:22,117
and consumers obviously are in able to buy the things they need and they are able to buy things

554
00:59:22,117 --> 00:59:31,357
they don't need. And the consequences of poor signals to the market, uh, last for generations.

555
00:59:31,737 --> 00:59:38,677
And so that's where, I guess that's where I just maybe to stand on a bit of like a moral high horse

556
00:59:38,677 --> 00:59:44,477
is to be able to say, I want it to happen immediately and fast, not, not for my own

557
00:59:44,477 --> 00:59:50,597
personal benefit. But because by doing so, you will actually have a clear signal from the market

558
00:59:50,597 --> 00:59:56,297
and that market will tell you where is the opportunity. And this leads to a question that

559
00:59:56,297 --> 01:00:03,417
I wanted to ask you, which was when we have the system that we do, which is the dollar system that

560
01:00:03,417 --> 01:00:08,797
is exporting our industrial base to other countries, and it creates the United States

561
01:00:08,797 --> 01:00:16,477
as the service and technology sector, where we have all these very high margin industries,

562
01:00:16,777 --> 01:00:21,177
finance, accounting, healthcare, things like that.

563
01:00:23,077 --> 01:00:29,237
One of the problems with that, so there's one view that I have towards this,

564
01:00:29,277 --> 01:00:33,457
and there's one quote that I think is really prescient in terms of taking a look at it.

565
01:00:33,457 --> 01:00:38,077
The quote is Jeff Bezos, who says that your margin is my opportunity.

566
01:00:38,797 --> 01:00:53,617
And the mindset that I have now is when I look at industries that have a high margin, I look for them to be most rapidly disrupted.

567
01:00:54,017 --> 01:00:58,297
And the reason being is that the higher the margin, the greater the opportunity.

568
01:00:58,297 --> 01:01:16,377
So if you're a safe cracker and you know that this safe on the left has a trillion dollars in it and this safe on the right has $500 in it, you're going to spend your time trying to crack the trillion dollar safe because there's a higher benefit ratio there.

569
01:01:16,877 --> 01:01:23,357
Your cost to benefit ratio, because it's going to take you the same time pretty much to knock those things out.

570
01:01:23,357 --> 01:01:34,477
So I also, by the way, I think that any this is this is my own this is my own little pet, my own little pet, little pet philosophy.

571
01:01:34,477 --> 01:01:53,397
But I think that any industry where you see giant billboards of fat guys and bleach blonde girls who are promoting that specific sector, that one's going to get disrupted.

572
01:01:53,817 --> 01:01:58,017
And across the nation, having traveled, that's real estate right now.

573
01:01:58,097 --> 01:01:59,837
And real estate's getting crushed.

574
01:02:00,397 --> 01:02:06,657
You had the ruling that takes away the, I believe it's like the buyer's premium because they're like, well, this is ridiculous.

575
01:02:07,177 --> 01:02:11,657
You know, like you don't need to get paid 3% for doing literally nothing all the time.

576
01:02:13,137 --> 01:02:15,237
And you just see everybody.

577
01:02:15,377 --> 01:02:18,077
It's like it turns out everybody's a real estate agent now.

578
01:02:18,357 --> 01:02:20,257
Like everybody's a real estate agent now.

579
01:02:20,357 --> 01:02:22,317
Everybody, oh, I'm going to go get my real estate license.

580
01:02:22,477 --> 01:02:22,697
Why?

581
01:02:22,697 --> 01:02:26,877
Well, it's because it's a really high margin opportunity that you don't really have to do a whole lot for.

582
01:02:26,977 --> 01:02:28,297
You don't have to know a whole lot about.

583
01:02:28,957 --> 01:02:32,157
You can just kind of get in there and know some people and then make a lot of money.

584
01:02:32,157 --> 01:02:57,497
So anyways, to round it back is that there's, I think, ample means, ample reason to believe that the high margin industries of the United States are going to be the next casualty of our dollar reserve system.

585
01:02:57,497 --> 01:03:04,997
where first we lost the industrial base and that industrial base created this high margin,

586
01:03:05,837 --> 01:03:09,897
this high margin service and information technology sector.

587
01:03:10,477 --> 01:03:19,017
And I think we're going to be challenged in that very rapidly because in order to compete with that,

588
01:03:19,017 --> 01:03:23,557
you don't have to build a factory. You don't have to have natural resources. You don't have to have the labor.

589
01:03:23,557 --> 01:03:29,797
you just simply have to do something a little faster, a little cheaper, a little better in terms

590
01:03:29,797 --> 01:03:35,157
of the computer work. And now you have the industry. These are, these are winner take all

591
01:03:35,157 --> 01:03:41,237
industries as noted by the fact that there are usually between four and eight players at the top

592
01:03:41,237 --> 01:03:48,737
of all of these. So I guess I want to frame that in terms of, I still want to keep it on, on, on

593
01:03:48,737 --> 01:03:55,457
kind of the issue of the dollar as the world reserve currency. But do you feel that there is,

594
01:03:57,197 --> 01:04:03,317
do you feel that that's worth trying to save more than saving the dollar as the reserve currency?

595
01:04:04,157 --> 01:04:08,377
Or do you feel that it can be saved? What can be saved?

596
01:04:08,377 --> 01:04:16,137
That high margin service and technology sector of the United States, the finance sector,

597
01:04:16,137 --> 01:04:32,837
the, you know, the entrepreneurial sector, you're seeing a lot of people that are moving to Dubai and Portugal and taking their technological prowess with them to lower tax jurisdictions and places like that.

598
01:04:33,177 --> 01:04:41,597
So I don't know, just kind of what are your thoughts about that as sort of a second and third order effect of the decay of the system?

599
01:04:41,597 --> 01:05:00,717
I guess I don't see those high margin sectors being a result of deindustrialization. Maybe they were accelerated a bit by it. I think they can go hand in hand with reindustrializing.

600
01:05:00,717 --> 01:05:26,617
And in fact, to the extent that those high margin sectors depend on U.S. power projection, maybe that's needed because once the U.S. hollows out its industrialized sectors sufficiently, then we're a paper tiger in relation to other countries that actually have an industrial sector and can make new arms even as we print pieces of paper to try to buy those arms from them.

601
01:05:26,617 --> 01:05:43,897
So I guess I don't see the necessary relation between domestic revitalization by encouraging reindustrialization and also the preservation of those high margin information related sectors.

602
01:05:43,897 --> 01:06:00,857
I guess I think that they can go hand in hand. And in fact, at a certain point, it would be necessary that we have a more diversified portfolio of industry in the United States in order for each of those particular industries to flourish.

603
01:06:00,857 --> 01:06:08,117
it may be that it does put us in a good position to re-industrialize because we have a lot of

604
01:06:08,117 --> 01:06:16,157
technological prowess that can be applied to industry you know industrial processes yeah

605
01:06:16,157 --> 01:06:23,257
exactly yeah yeah yeah that's a good argument i think and i think that's why germany you know

606
01:06:23,257 --> 01:06:29,977
has its its strength for a while was exactly that and even though they paid high wages in their

607
01:06:29,977 --> 01:06:34,837
industrial sector that they were very efficient and apply technology well so they could still

608
01:06:34,837 --> 01:06:43,317
compete on a global um global stage but yeah what do you think about then do you think this is

609
01:06:43,317 --> 01:06:49,517
taking a turn a bit but do you think that tariffs are a potential solution um

610
01:06:49,517 --> 01:06:57,977
in in the short term in that they will encourage us to re-industrialize make

611
01:06:57,977 --> 01:07:04,397
Americans have to turn domestically to buy goods rather than importing them cheaply.

612
01:07:05,177 --> 01:07:12,177
Trump, when he proposed tariffs, got a lot of grief from economists whose models they said showed

613
01:07:12,177 --> 01:07:17,237
that this would be bad for the economy. But I think that we may be in sort of an unprecedented

614
01:07:17,237 --> 01:07:24,077
position at this moment in history, given us holding the global reserve currency and being

615
01:07:24,077 --> 01:07:30,257
at this advanced stage of it. And so I wonder, maybe tariffs aren't as nonsensical as certain

616
01:07:30,257 --> 01:07:36,757
economists make them seem once you really kind of see that this historical moment is different and

617
01:07:36,757 --> 01:07:41,577
that what Trump is trying to do as far as encouraging local industry is a valid thing to do

618
01:07:41,577 --> 01:07:46,017
to mitigate one of the harms of the US being a global reserve currency. Do you think tariffs are

619
01:07:46,017 --> 01:07:52,637
a good idea? Overall, I don't believe that tariffs are a good idea. And I can just come at that by

620
01:07:52,637 --> 01:07:57,797
saying they do send an inaccurate signal to producers and consumers and they do cloud the

621
01:07:57,797 --> 01:08:06,037
market and they do in some fashion misallocate resources. I understand the argument that if a

622
01:08:06,037 --> 01:08:13,137
pair of jeans in the United States costs $100 to make and in China they cost $30, that putting a

623
01:08:13,137 --> 01:08:21,197
$70 tariff on Chinese jeans allows for American producers to be competitive. However,

624
01:08:21,197 --> 01:08:27,257
that is not thinking about the desired outcome.

625
01:08:27,537 --> 01:08:31,737
And the desired outcome is to make things better for the United States people,

626
01:08:32,057 --> 01:08:37,877
not for the United States industrial sector or the United States gene manufacturing sector.

627
01:08:38,497 --> 01:08:45,397
I think there's a whole lot of danger in turning tariffs into the sort of like modern day,

628
01:08:45,397 --> 01:08:49,757
like instead of putting pork barrel projects into bills,

629
01:08:49,757 --> 01:09:00,437
I think there's a lot of danger that tariffs just pop up in every industry that has a strong lobby and not in the industries that don't have strong lobbies.

630
01:09:00,437 --> 01:09:10,377
And to put it in the in the words of or the observation of my host in Colombia, lobbying is legalized bribery.

631
01:09:10,877 --> 01:09:18,977
And what we have developed in the United States with the beltway system, you've got in D.C. the inner beltway and the outer beltway.

632
01:09:19,757 --> 01:09:26,797
The Outer Beltway is the highest per capita income jurisdiction in the United States.

633
01:09:27,237 --> 01:09:31,477
Lobbyists are the highest per capita income jurisdiction in the United States.

634
01:09:32,217 --> 01:09:37,637
And it's because they engage in a practice of legalized bribery.

635
01:09:37,637 --> 01:09:45,517
and it's not always what you and I think about in terms of bribery where it's like I'm going to hand

636
01:09:45,517 --> 01:09:49,937
a bag of cash to a boxer before the match and then he's going to take a fall in round three

637
01:09:49,937 --> 01:09:55,537
it's you're going to vote on this bill in order to get this factory built in this jurisdiction

638
01:09:55,537 --> 01:10:01,357
and then when you leave office you're going to be on our board earning a million dollars a year

639
01:10:01,357 --> 01:10:04,637
in showing up for three meetings via Zoom.

640
01:10:06,597 --> 01:10:08,277
And that's far more insidious

641
01:10:08,277 --> 01:10:11,837
because the effects of it last so much longer.

642
01:10:12,057 --> 01:10:15,997
So I do, I think, have a genuine fear

643
01:10:15,997 --> 01:10:20,157
that tariffs will proliferate the bribery system

644
01:10:20,157 --> 01:10:23,877
in the United States and make it even more outrageous.

645
01:10:24,917 --> 01:10:29,597
I don't agree with tariffs from an economic perspective

646
01:10:29,597 --> 01:10:34,877
because they send an inaccurate signal for resource allocation to the market.

647
01:10:35,237 --> 01:10:41,077
I do agree, and you did say this in your question, short-term.

648
01:10:41,777 --> 01:10:47,397
Short-term, if we can dispense with the idea that they send a bad signal to the market,

649
01:10:47,517 --> 01:10:53,097
if we can dispense with the idea that it encourages immoral behavior, what about short-term?

650
01:10:53,097 --> 01:11:08,657
So short term, what it would do is it would inspire a number of participants in gene manufacturing in the United States that aren't currently enlisted in that operation to join up.

651
01:11:08,657 --> 01:11:16,177
And most of them shouldn't be there. However, there will be people just because there are people that are more competent than others.

652
01:11:16,177 --> 01:11:33,657
There will be people that turn out to be really good at it and they will be able to stand on their own after those tariffs are removed or they will be able to slowly wean themselves off of it.

653
01:11:33,657 --> 01:11:41,677
However, I do think that tariffs are something that once put in place are really hard to take out of place.

654
01:11:42,437 --> 01:11:56,837
And so you just effectively are going to put a semi-permanent price floor on a certain good by putting a tariff there.

655
01:11:56,837 --> 01:12:03,757
And the end result is that consumers in the United States are not getting a better deal.

656
01:12:04,117 --> 01:12:05,257
They're not benefiting.

657
01:12:06,977 --> 01:12:12,157
You know, there is the argument to be made that, you know, there's going to be a couple more jobs to be had.

658
01:12:12,277 --> 01:12:17,277
But those jobs are very tenuous because they're wholly dependent upon that tariff.

659
01:12:17,277 --> 01:12:28,417
So, no, I just I think any game you have to play where you have to any game you play where you have to rig the rules in your favor to be competitive is a game that you should look at and go.

660
01:12:28,657 --> 01:12:35,337
I should go play some other game because eventually something bad is going to happen.

661
01:12:35,337 --> 01:12:45,757
Like you're going to be exploited. And especially if you are rigging the rules in your favor, like there's incentive for the oppressed in that system to exploit you.

662
01:12:45,757 --> 01:12:51,877
Go play a fair game. Go play a fair game where the incentive is for everybody to just do well for themselves.

663
01:12:52,537 --> 01:12:55,277
And you're not the heavy head wearing the crown.

664
01:12:55,877 --> 01:12:58,017
So I guess that's kind of how I think about that.

665
01:12:58,777 --> 01:12:59,997
No, I don't disagree.

666
01:13:01,537 --> 01:13:03,977
I would note two things. Maybe the steel man, the tariff argument.

667
01:13:04,257 --> 01:13:10,897
One is you gave Gene Manufacturer, but we could replace that with high-tech components or something.

668
01:13:11,137 --> 01:13:12,217
So there are –

669
01:13:12,217 --> 01:13:13,937
There's national security concerns.

670
01:13:13,937 --> 01:13:20,577
Yeah, there's industries that are vital to national security and our advancement into the future, et cetera.

671
01:13:20,737 --> 01:13:23,757
Also, that tariffs send inaccurate signals.

672
01:13:24,017 --> 01:13:29,957
I think people would respond – they would respond that we are already in a managed system that is sending very inaccurate signals.

673
01:13:30,197 --> 01:13:33,017
And so we're sending a strong signal to try to reorient it.

674
01:13:33,097 --> 01:13:38,497
There's already people who exploit the arbitrage that US as a reserve currency.

675
01:13:39,197 --> 01:13:43,277
People domestically, they import a bunch of cheap products and sell them.

676
01:13:43,277 --> 01:13:50,097
And so they're really – they're exploiting the false signal that is sent by the US having this global reserve status.

677
01:13:50,437 --> 01:13:53,197
And so tariffs, again, a shock in the opposite direction.

678
01:13:53,697 --> 01:13:54,937
And not to endorse that.

679
01:13:55,237 --> 01:13:58,197
That's the – we don't live in a free, free market.

680
01:13:58,517 --> 01:14:05,657
We live in a free market system with a bunch of already inaccurate signals being sent due to – for political reasons.

681
01:14:05,917 --> 01:14:11,117
And so it's a valid thing I think for people to lobby for their own signal to be sent in a certain sense.

682
01:14:11,117 --> 01:14:18,617
that to me is an argument for two wrongs making a right and it really makes me think of it well

683
01:14:18,617 --> 01:14:22,477
it's just an it's an argument did not utterly capitulate in the face of other people doing

684
01:14:22,477 --> 01:14:31,437
something too well what what it makes i mean i don't know yet what it makes me think of is that

685
01:14:31,437 --> 01:14:39,297
um saying it's okay to do something that is um bad but just a different sort of bad it's to me

686
01:14:39,297 --> 01:14:47,457
To me, what that really rings, and by the way, this is really popular with the woke side, is that they really like tariffs.

687
01:14:48,317 --> 01:14:49,397
They enjoy them.

688
01:14:50,237 --> 01:14:57,537
And it's because they can manipulate markets with them.

689
01:14:58,117 --> 01:15:00,757
And it makes me think it really does.

690
01:15:00,757 --> 01:15:05,917
the first thought that came to mind when you said that, because I instantly, in my mind,

691
01:15:05,957 --> 01:15:13,097
I recognize it as doing something wrong in order to combat doing something else wrong,

692
01:15:13,277 --> 01:15:19,857
which is when I look at the woke ideology is I saw that they were fighting racism with racism,

693
01:15:20,037 --> 01:15:24,697
that they were fighting sexism with sexism. They were fighting homophobia with heterophobia.

694
01:15:24,697 --> 01:15:31,417
that the argument was like, oh, the pendulum swung too far in this direction.

695
01:15:32,017 --> 01:15:38,317
So it's OK that there are certain groups that are disenfranchised now because they historically

696
01:15:38,317 --> 01:15:39,017
haven't been.

697
01:15:39,577 --> 01:15:45,557
And it's time for them to get their ass kicking, as opposed to maybe we could look at this

698
01:15:45,557 --> 01:15:47,737
in terms of how can we just all be better?

699
01:15:47,737 --> 01:15:56,917
and how can we, instead of promoting racism and promoting sexism and promoting all these,

700
01:15:56,917 --> 01:16:01,717
how can we simply look at people on the merits?

701
01:16:01,937 --> 01:16:03,637
And so I look at that.

702
01:16:03,777 --> 01:16:07,917
I look at markets on the – I want to look at the market on the merit.

703
01:16:07,917 --> 01:16:18,237
I completely agree that there are some national security interests that need to be prioritized.

704
01:16:18,957 --> 01:16:31,817
What I would say is that if you want to really look at the outcomes and how they tend to proliferate,

705
01:16:31,817 --> 01:16:35,977
then really what you should do is you should say, well, the national security interests,

706
01:16:36,177 --> 01:16:42,777
those are the ones where the government should absolutely 100 percent not be involved in any sort of fashion

707
01:16:42,777 --> 01:16:44,997
because everything that government touches, they ruin.

708
01:16:45,437 --> 01:16:47,737
And it's not because they're government.

709
01:16:48,217 --> 01:16:54,817
It's because they the nature of it is that it creates a middleman who has a handout,

710
01:16:54,817 --> 01:16:59,837
who needs to be fed and they take resources away from resolving the problem.

711
01:16:59,837 --> 01:17:18,877
Um, the industries that have proliferated in the United States did so without government support, like no government support. Um, they did so because they were able to explode, like less regulation, less involvement, less participation by the government.

712
01:17:18,877 --> 01:17:25,877
So, I mean, I would say that if you want to encourage an industry, the best thing for the government to do would be completely leave.

713
01:17:25,977 --> 01:17:35,577
Like, I'm perfectly fine if the industry wants to put – if they want to put tariffs on cereal and, I don't know, cereal and swatch watches.

714
01:17:35,957 --> 01:17:36,157
Cool.

715
01:17:36,537 --> 01:17:37,257
But that's fine.

716
01:17:37,697 --> 01:17:40,197
But leave my computer chips alone.

717
01:17:40,477 --> 01:17:45,657
Well, I think you've selected a nice moral high ground to die on.

718
01:17:45,657 --> 01:17:57,526
But as a realist I mean people have to operate within the system as it is until the system is different And you know it a small sucker to a person who has lost their blue collar job to say no no no

719
01:17:57,526 --> 01:18:00,786
The world depends upon unreasonable men.

720
01:18:02,026 --> 01:18:02,466
Yeah.

721
01:18:03,106 --> 01:18:06,426
You have to be unreasonable to break out of the unreasonable system.

722
01:18:07,026 --> 01:18:10,106
In the long term, you know, those people are going to change history.

723
01:18:10,106 --> 01:18:15,286
But in the short term, as we transition to a new system, it's like lobbying you posit as an evil.

724
01:18:15,286 --> 01:18:23,086
But lobbying for crypto, Bitcoin and stuff has led to positive changes and has elected a president who is pro-Bitcoin.

725
01:18:23,286 --> 01:18:30,666
So in the short term, I think people have to be pragmatic and work with the tools that are endemic to the system in order to change the system.

726
01:18:31,186 --> 01:18:37,826
I think that unreasonable people in the long term can bring new ideas, but it takes utterly reasonable men to actually move things and get things done.

727
01:18:40,546 --> 01:18:42,726
OK, I can buy some of that.

728
01:18:42,726 --> 01:18:44,266
I do think there's some good.

729
01:18:45,286 --> 01:18:47,666
I just want to kill your idealism, choke it to death and bury it.

730
01:18:47,666 --> 01:18:50,566
Yeah, it's adorable.

731
01:18:51,146 --> 01:18:51,686
It's adorable.

732
01:18:52,886 --> 01:19:02,666
But I would, the problem, I don't know, the problem I have with this is that, so we're creating a crypto industry.

733
01:19:02,666 --> 01:19:12,726
We're creating a crypto regulation industry that is not going to exist in some other country that is just going to say it's a sandbox.

734
01:19:13,126 --> 01:19:13,786
Do what you will.

735
01:19:14,566 --> 01:19:18,866
We recognize that there are benefits to this that we don't need to have a hand in.

736
01:19:18,866 --> 01:19:21,246
But our regulatory framework could be sandbox.

737
01:19:21,526 --> 01:19:22,266
That's a valid one.

738
01:19:22,326 --> 01:19:25,646
We could choose and we could have a lobbyist that advance that position.

739
01:19:25,746 --> 01:19:26,406
That would be a good thing.

740
01:19:26,746 --> 01:19:31,286
Well, just look at in terms of where it's gone already.

741
01:19:31,286 --> 01:19:53,726
So you originally there was no regulation around crypto. And then there stepped in some fairly strict stuff, you know, capital gains, pretty ridiculous to pay capital gains on Bitcoin. Bitcoin is functionally sending someone Bitcoin is no different than sending someone an email.

742
01:19:53,726 --> 01:19:55,966
and I don't get taxed on an email.

743
01:19:56,306 --> 01:20:00,006
Literally what I'm doing is I am sending a transaction

744
01:20:00,006 --> 01:20:04,726
in a digital system that is not necessarily

745
01:20:04,726 --> 01:20:06,846
and cannot really be proven

746
01:20:06,846 --> 01:20:10,026
to be in the domain of the taxing jurisdiction.

747
01:20:10,906 --> 01:20:13,066
So somebody is going to realize that

748
01:20:13,066 --> 01:20:14,526
and somebody is going to say,

749
01:20:14,746 --> 01:20:17,466
it's utterly ridiculous that we have capital gains tax

750
01:20:17,466 --> 01:20:18,306
on this thing.

751
01:20:18,426 --> 01:20:19,986
Like we don't tax texts.

752
01:20:20,106 --> 01:20:21,126
We don't tax emails.

753
01:20:21,626 --> 01:20:22,546
Why would we text?

754
01:20:22,546 --> 01:20:43,266
Why would you go around and cares about your texts or emails? No one's going to buy those from you for everybody cares about everybody cares about them because reading those things, putting clauses into your terms of service that say that you can read those things and take the information out and use that to market to people that created the most powerful companies that have ever existed in the entire world.

755
01:20:43,266 --> 01:20:48,626
there is more there is that's where all the value is there all of the value in the world

756
01:20:48,626 --> 01:20:56,046
is in information it's not in it's not in cows and it's not in socks it's in that information

757
01:20:56,046 --> 01:21:01,206
so i see what you're saying and it's just information like the the value transfer of

758
01:21:01,206 --> 01:21:08,386
bitcoin is merely letters and numbers just like the text that i send in the email that i send is

759
01:21:08,386 --> 01:21:12,246
letters but so is the transmission of equities nowadays through a stock market i mean that all

760
01:21:12,246 --> 01:21:17,026
happens electronically, all of its movement on the ledger of all monetary or value-based things

761
01:21:17,026 --> 01:21:18,406
anymore when we're moving towards reduction termination.

762
01:21:18,406 --> 01:21:20,726
Yeah, but the stock market is housed in the United States.

763
01:21:21,986 --> 01:21:24,426
That is a physical jurisdiction.

764
01:21:25,066 --> 01:21:26,926
Some of the people who transact in Bitcoin are.

765
01:21:27,446 --> 01:21:31,306
It has a physical jurisdiction that people literally buy.

766
01:21:32,786 --> 01:21:34,306
You've heard these stories, I'm sure.

767
01:21:35,226 --> 01:21:40,746
Buying the closest real estate that you can to the stock market so that you can be one

768
01:21:40,746 --> 01:21:46,826
nanosecond faster on, on, you know, there is a geographical tie to that. There's no geographical

769
01:21:46,826 --> 01:21:52,206
tie to Bitcoin. There is people who own Bitcoin have it. It's everywhere. It's every node. It's

770
01:21:52,206 --> 01:21:57,166
every node in the entire world, but the holders of it are in a specific geographic location. And so

771
01:21:57,166 --> 01:22:03,006
it's, I mean, law is an arbitrary convention and the people who define the, the standing under it

772
01:22:03,006 --> 01:22:07,466
of a certain thing can define it in a certain way. I think, yeah, that gets us kind of far

773
01:22:07,466 --> 01:22:14,146
field, but I think it's taxable. All tax is an arbitrary legalistic convention. If they want to

774
01:22:14,146 --> 01:22:18,806
define it a certain way, they're casting magic spells in a different way, but that's the case.

775
01:22:19,726 --> 01:22:24,766
I think you're going to find in very short order that Bitcoin is not taxable. And I think you're

776
01:22:24,766 --> 01:22:30,046
going to find that it's not taxable, not because there's not a will to tax it, but because there's

777
01:22:30,046 --> 01:22:35,626
so much will for it to not be taxed. Because people, for the first time, have the opportunity

778
01:22:35,626 --> 01:22:42,586
to hold on to it and not have it taken away and be able to say, no, just just flat out. No,

779
01:22:42,766 --> 01:22:48,766
you can't take this away from me. You can't take it by force. The returns to violence and the

780
01:22:48,766 --> 01:22:55,206
returns to lawfare in terms of the economic return that you get to putting somebody in a chair,

781
01:22:55,366 --> 01:23:00,586
tying them down and beating them until you get their Bitcoin password out of them or taking them

782
01:23:00,586 --> 01:23:07,346
to court and suing them over and over in a country that has the strongest property rights in the world.

783
01:23:08,246 --> 01:23:15,626
The returns to those sorts of violence and oppression have dramatically fallen to the

784
01:23:15,626 --> 01:23:21,846
point that it is no longer economically feasible to take that approach. So I think, and by the way,

785
01:23:22,106 --> 01:23:25,926
it doesn't have to happen here. It doesn't have to happen here. It happened, you know,

786
01:23:25,926 --> 01:23:31,906
in in dubai there's zero tax on cryptocurrency yeah and and what happens is that people vote

787
01:23:31,906 --> 01:23:36,546
with their feet and they flood and they leave maybe people will move to dubai but i don't think

788
01:23:36,546 --> 01:23:41,186
that matt that the fact that people can engage in mass tax evasion with bitcoin is an argument for

789
01:23:41,186 --> 01:23:45,906
making it untaxable i don't i mean i think the government can still make it taxable to the extent

790
01:23:45,906 --> 01:23:49,026
that it goes through corporate channels they have to report all that stuff and to the extent that

791
01:23:49,026 --> 01:23:53,486
you think that bitcoin we're going to hyper bitcoin eyes it's always going to hit some taxable

792
01:23:53,486 --> 01:23:59,786
transparent entity, a corporation or something like that. Unless you're going to borrow against

793
01:23:59,786 --> 01:24:03,746
it and never sell your Bitcoin and use fiat, in which case you're endorsing that world of fiat

794
01:24:03,746 --> 01:24:08,866
currency in addition to Bitcoin. But there's always going to be individuals who are incorporated

795
01:24:08,866 --> 01:24:12,386
in the United States, entities that are incorporated in the United States and have to report things to

796
01:24:12,386 --> 01:24:16,986
the government. And they're not going to engage in tax evasion just because it's easier with Bitcoin.

797
01:24:16,986 --> 01:24:27,426
i think it's short-sighted to believe that the system that we are currently in is not going to

798
01:24:27,426 --> 01:24:33,546
be radically altered by surely is yeah by you know by because we're in we're in a system that

799
01:24:33,546 --> 01:24:38,126
is created to encourage debt and it's created like you know that's why the rules are written

800
01:24:38,126 --> 01:24:42,966
the way they are so that if you have an asset and you take a loan against it there is no tax on it

801
01:24:42,966 --> 01:24:48,466
And it's encouraging that because that's what benefits the system.

802
01:24:48,786 --> 01:24:51,806
But you don't have to play those rules anymore.

803
01:24:51,806 --> 01:24:57,866
And it doesn't have to be that the change happens here first because it will happen somewhere else.

804
01:24:58,026 --> 01:25:08,086
And the benefit will be so great that the system, the new system will be adapted by players who want to continue to be competitive in a global market.

805
01:25:08,226 --> 01:25:11,586
I cannot see it going in a different direction.

806
01:25:11,586 --> 01:25:21,926
I can certainly see the current system fighting tooth and nail to maintain the rent-seeking status that it has because that is to their benefit.

807
01:25:22,546 --> 01:25:35,866
But when I think about the way that the Bitcoin network grows is simply by adding more people that exchange more value, and they don't need anything in between them.

808
01:25:36,066 --> 01:25:37,526
They don't need a government between them.

809
01:25:37,586 --> 01:25:38,806
They don't need a bank between them.

810
01:25:38,806 --> 01:25:41,066
And they're not going to opt in for it.

811
01:25:41,586 --> 01:25:47,306
You know, it's now an opt in system instead of a claw your way out of its system.

812
01:25:48,046 --> 01:25:51,266
And why would you ever do that?

813
01:25:51,526 --> 01:25:55,746
I'm never going to move to Dubai, no matter how favorable a tax jurisdiction it is.

814
01:25:55,886 --> 01:25:57,226
I'm not going to leave the United States.

815
01:25:57,926 --> 01:25:59,786
You know, I may be some part of Latin America.

816
01:25:59,786 --> 01:26:01,066
I could conceivably.

817
01:26:01,246 --> 01:26:11,246
But I think the vast majority of the United States, people in the United States are not going to go to Panama to Dubai just because it's even if there was a tax on Bitcoin in the United States.

818
01:26:11,246 --> 01:26:13,026
and not in one of those other jurisdictions.

819
01:26:13,846 --> 01:26:15,306
Breather the man with heart so dead

820
01:26:15,306 --> 01:26:16,906
who never to himself hath said,

821
01:26:17,006 --> 01:26:18,346
this is my own, my native land.

822
01:26:18,506 --> 01:26:20,206
We all have the sentiment that we love,

823
01:26:20,326 --> 01:26:22,226
not we all, but many people have the sentiment

824
01:26:22,226 --> 01:26:24,726
that they love the place in which they were born,

825
01:26:24,866 --> 01:26:27,346
even if it does impose some taxation on them.

826
01:26:27,366 --> 01:26:29,026
That's like the whole idea of Europe now.

827
01:26:29,466 --> 01:26:31,086
People are okay living there

828
01:26:31,086 --> 01:26:33,826
despite its ossification economically

829
01:26:33,826 --> 01:26:35,586
because they like the quaintness of it.

830
01:26:35,666 --> 01:26:36,926
They like it because it's their homeland.

831
01:26:37,486 --> 01:26:40,406
And people do not move just for favorable tax reasons,

832
01:26:40,406 --> 01:26:43,406
except for maybe marginally some billionaires here and there.

833
01:26:44,446 --> 01:26:50,306
I think that there are a couple hundred million people that came to the United States that would disagree with that.

834
01:26:50,586 --> 01:26:54,746
And they were Europeans first.

835
01:26:55,506 --> 01:26:58,166
Yeah, I was just speaking for myself, I guess I would never have to do that.

836
01:26:58,166 --> 01:27:04,186
Right, right. But again, I think that we can have those feelings.

837
01:27:05,466 --> 01:27:09,886
And I certainly have those feelings. I don't want to leave the United States. I wouldn't prefer it.

838
01:27:09,886 --> 01:27:24,446
But it turns out that throughout history, there have been numerous examples of times when the economic situation has gotten so bad in a country that used to be strong that people who would have never left leave.

839
01:27:25,226 --> 01:27:27,906
And that's that's not an outlier.

840
01:27:28,046 --> 01:27:29,186
That's the common theme.

841
01:27:29,806 --> 01:27:36,906
And you see the exportation of of talent to the places that treat it best.

842
01:27:36,906 --> 01:27:39,366
and so I

843
01:27:39,366 --> 01:27:41,326
it's great

844
01:27:41,326 --> 01:27:43,186
I love the United States

845
01:27:43,186 --> 01:27:44,286
it's awesome but

846
01:27:44,286 --> 01:27:46,306
in terms of

847
01:27:46,306 --> 01:27:47,846
can it

848
01:27:47,846 --> 01:27:50,766
keep you? Probably

849
01:27:50,766 --> 01:27:52,586
can it keep

850
01:27:52,586 --> 01:27:54,906
the vast majority of its talent?

851
01:27:55,106 --> 01:27:57,346
I don't think so because the talent that came here

852
01:27:57,346 --> 01:27:58,886
was free agents to begin with

853
01:27:58,886 --> 01:28:00,546
it came here from other countries

854
01:28:00,546 --> 01:28:02,586
there is a native

855
01:28:02,586 --> 01:28:04,406
there is a spirit

856
01:28:04,406 --> 01:28:06,606
of the United States

857
01:28:06,606 --> 01:28:10,106
and the people within it that is prone to adventure.

858
01:28:10,486 --> 01:28:12,946
It does have that reckless feel.

859
01:28:13,266 --> 01:28:16,866
It does have that idea that we're going to set out in a wagon

860
01:28:16,866 --> 01:28:19,506
and we're going to go across a country that we've never seen

861
01:28:19,506 --> 01:28:23,306
in order to get away from an oppressive tax structure,

862
01:28:23,566 --> 01:28:26,786
in order to get away from a system that does not benefit us,

863
01:28:27,106 --> 01:28:31,806
and to have opportunity to be able to grow our own whatever,

864
01:28:32,066 --> 01:28:35,286
our own food, our own resources, our own families,

865
01:28:35,286 --> 01:28:39,226
without the inhibition of an overarching power source.

866
01:28:40,306 --> 01:28:40,386
Yeah.

867
01:28:40,566 --> 01:28:42,046
I just think that that's,

868
01:28:42,306 --> 01:28:46,286
I think it's such a constant theme throughout the globe

869
01:28:46,286 --> 01:28:49,286
and throughout history that I see no reason

870
01:28:49,906 --> 01:28:52,066
why you can't see a hundred million,

871
01:28:52,186 --> 01:28:54,486
like I see no reason why you can't see

872
01:28:54,486 --> 01:28:57,166
50 million people leave the United States.

873
01:28:57,786 --> 01:29:01,426
Not immediately, but why,

874
01:29:01,426 --> 01:29:11,566
if you're if if you're a if you're someone that has the means to do it um why would you like why

875
01:29:11,566 --> 01:29:19,186
why would you other than sentiment and the thing about sentiment is that you rapidly learn going

876
01:29:19,186 --> 01:29:25,746
through sentimental things that it's never the actual thing that holds the value of the memory

877
01:29:25,746 --> 01:29:31,326
it is just the memory like going through stuff with my parents uh when they when they're like

878
01:29:31,326 --> 01:29:37,506
cleaning up and finding old pictures and old college yearbooks and baby pictures and stuff,

879
01:29:37,586 --> 01:29:42,306
right? It's not the picture itself that's valuable. It's the memory because they put,

880
01:29:42,606 --> 01:29:48,586
you enjoy it and then you put it away. So you can take a picture of the farm to South America and

881
01:29:48,586 --> 01:29:55,286
you can take a picture of your local coffee shop to Dubai and you can still retain that same

882
01:29:55,286 --> 01:30:01,866
sentiment. But then you can also live in a place where you aren't constantly under the thumb of

883
01:30:01,866 --> 01:30:11,426
what has become up until November, a more and more oppressive regime that remains to be seen,

884
01:30:11,486 --> 01:30:13,586
whether or not it's going to be less oppressive in the future.

885
01:30:14,466 --> 01:30:18,886
Yeah. I mean, so I don't know. We're not, you know, I don't know the relative debates,

886
01:30:19,006 --> 01:30:23,446
of course, of Dubai. There's lots of talk about their human rights regime not being the best.

887
01:30:23,446 --> 01:30:51,566
And of course, you know, there may be many reasons why it's not the perfect sandbox of freedom. But even that aside, there is, I think, bracketing other than sentiment as a reason, you know, like that's the only reason people might want to stay. That's all there is to life is sentiment. There's much more. I mean, there's much more in life than what money can buy than what Bitcoin can buy. And at the end of the day, that's family. That's being close to people you love. And there's people who are not going to leave.

888
01:30:51,566 --> 01:30:54,746
So I think this ties to the question I wanted to end with.

889
01:30:55,226 --> 01:31:02,746
Alden says we need to step back from, quote, America, the empire and get back to, quote, America, the country.

890
01:31:03,406 --> 01:31:09,206
And again, Smolenski's point is there needs to be a positive narrative tied to what that is.

891
01:31:09,946 --> 01:31:11,866
What is America, the country?

892
01:31:11,986 --> 01:31:13,286
How do you define that?

893
01:31:13,286 --> 01:31:21,126
What's the story you give it so that people endorse that vision and want to make that great again and actually step back from empire?

894
01:31:21,566 --> 01:31:32,166
And so maybe even to put a finer point on that, I mentioned to you before we were talking, Sam Hyde, the comedian, has this video that he taped to Elon Musk.

895
01:31:32,526 --> 01:31:49,666
It's relating to the H-1B debate, but it goes much broader, I think, in that there is the idea America the country, even if we endorse that, there's one subset, Vivek, Elon, others like that who say America is an idea.

896
01:31:49,666 --> 01:32:01,146
And there's another set, Sam Hyde, other people on the other side of the H1B debate to say America is a nation. America is a collection of people with a shared history and a shared culture.

897
01:32:01,146 --> 01:32:09,206
So one camp says America is an idea, an abstract narrative about competitiveness, about entrepreneurial spirit.

898
01:32:09,846 --> 01:32:14,506
The other ones who say America is not inherently about competitiveness.

899
01:32:14,806 --> 01:32:16,466
People are more than economic units.

900
01:32:16,606 --> 01:32:21,546
People are inherently based and grounded in their culture.

901
01:32:21,806 --> 01:32:26,646
They're inherently tied through filial bonds to their family.

902
01:32:27,066 --> 01:32:30,066
And, you know, you can't have unchosen obligations in life.

903
01:32:30,066 --> 01:32:40,926
If you can be born into a family where your brother or sister is disabled and maybe you have a bond or obligation to them that is unfair that you can't just jettison, that you have to support them.

904
01:32:40,926 --> 01:32:44,246
So what is America? Is America the country?

905
01:32:44,366 --> 01:32:58,646
Even if we move away from America the empire and endorse America the country to revitalize domestically, do we say America is an idea or do we say America is a nation, a culture tied to a specific piece of land?

906
01:32:58,646 --> 01:33:04,346
where people have an identity they did not choose and which is not reducible to them as an economic

907
01:33:04,346 --> 01:33:10,626
unit, um, cashes out in terms of competitiveness and entrepreneurial spirit. I want to give you

908
01:33:10,626 --> 01:33:18,226
credit for probably the best question that you've posed during our discussions here. And I think,

909
01:33:18,286 --> 01:33:22,486
I think it's the best question because it immediately popped into my mind what I think

910
01:33:22,486 --> 01:33:28,326
is a beautiful story, uh, in terms of being able to answer it. So, so maybe it's, it's just that it,

911
01:33:28,646 --> 01:33:34,886
It inspires this. But I want to I want to yeah, I want to weave my way through this a little bit.

912
01:33:34,986 --> 01:33:39,786
And I'll up front state my answer and say that it's both. But one is a consequence of the other.

913
01:33:40,346 --> 01:33:45,566
So you've got the idea and you've got the nation. But I'm just going to say the culture or the community.

914
01:33:45,666 --> 01:33:48,886
Let's say the community. What is a nation? It's just a big community. Right.

915
01:33:49,206 --> 01:33:58,146
You've heard people I've heard the quote was like a nation is a group of people that agree to like selectively forget the same things, the same history or something like that.

916
01:33:58,646 --> 01:34:18,966
But but it's culture. Like, I understand the argument. Like, are we a nation of free market, open competitiveness? Or are we a nation of free speech and this and that and, you know, and guns and football and apple pie and and, you know, all these things.

917
01:34:18,966 --> 01:34:36,506
So it's an idea that creates a culture. One leads to another. And the way that I think I know that is I'm going to this is for the benefit of everybody that might be listening, but but for you and me.

918
01:34:36,506 --> 01:35:00,946
So the most vibrant culture that I've ever experienced was when I moved up to Wenatchee, Washington, and I stayed with Grant in his little apartment there. And we went out and we went out and we started doing a lot of things with people in the community that were simply a consequence of things that we wanted to do in order to better ourselves.

919
01:35:01,626 --> 01:35:05,346
We wanted to go do some cold punches.

920
01:35:05,546 --> 01:35:09,586
And so we started going down to the Columbia River every morning and getting in the water.

921
01:35:09,586 --> 01:35:12,346
And then we mentioned it to some other people.

922
01:35:12,506 --> 01:35:21,286
And we grew a group that started coming with us every day and wanted to challenge ourselves to go do some yoga.

923
01:35:21,806 --> 01:35:31,026
So we found a vibrant community of people in that yoga studio that turns out were interested in a lot of the things that we were interested in as well.

924
01:35:31,726 --> 01:35:33,366
We wanted to go do some hiking.

925
01:35:33,566 --> 01:35:38,006
And so we found some people along the way who wanted to come along and hike with us.

926
01:35:38,646 --> 01:35:42,646
And that all culminated when we decided to host a party.

927
01:35:42,646 --> 01:35:49,386
And we had this party in this tiny little, what, 600 square foot apartment, maybe.

928
01:35:49,386 --> 01:35:56,546
and we had like 40 people in there and every single one of them was a friend. None of them

929
01:35:56,546 --> 01:36:02,046
were hangers on. None of them were somebody that you didn't want to talk to. And we knew that they

930
01:36:02,046 --> 01:36:06,146
were all people that we wanted to talk to and wanted to enjoy because we got called in for a

931
01:36:06,146 --> 01:36:13,126
noise complaint because we were having so much fun. It was the idea that was first proffered by

932
01:36:13,126 --> 01:36:21,406
by Grant when he read my blog when I was living in Columbia and said, hey, you know, this is such

933
01:36:21,406 --> 01:36:29,046
a cool place up in Wenatchee. He was really, really just selling the idea of these things.

934
01:36:29,146 --> 01:36:33,586
He wasn't even offering for me to come. And I kind of invited myself and I said, OK, well,

935
01:36:33,586 --> 01:36:38,546
we're both interested in these same sort of things, in bettering ourselves and being competitive with

936
01:36:38,546 --> 01:36:43,786
ourselves, um, in improving ourselves in, in these other manners. And so let's go do these

937
01:36:43,786 --> 01:36:49,026
activities. Let's do the cold punch. Let's do the exercising. Let's go to the open mic night. Um,

938
01:36:49,686 --> 01:36:55,446
and, uh, and let's engage in, in all of these different communities. And as a result of the

939
01:36:55,446 --> 01:37:02,906
idea, we created a, a miniature nation of friends. We created a community, we created a culture,

940
01:37:02,906 --> 01:37:06,446
that became much more valuable than the idea.

941
01:37:07,046 --> 01:37:09,506
And so I love the question.

942
01:37:10,046 --> 01:37:12,586
And I think the answer is that it is both.

943
01:37:12,666 --> 01:37:16,446
I think it's the idea that leads to the culture.

944
01:37:16,446 --> 01:37:25,926
I think that the idea of wanting to escape the oppressiveness of the regimes

945
01:37:25,926 --> 01:37:30,106
and the kingdoms and the monarchies in Europe

946
01:37:30,106 --> 01:37:33,926
is what led people to come to the shores of the United States.

947
01:37:33,926 --> 01:37:38,986
And they didn't bring with them the rules.

948
01:37:39,526 --> 01:37:53,006
Those rules were made after the Constitution was created after that idea had planted enough seeds

949
01:37:53,006 --> 01:38:00,426
and started to grow such that there was commonalities that were able to be encoded in law

950
01:38:00,426 --> 01:38:07,926
and encoded in rights and natural liberties. So yeah, I think that the answer to your question

951
01:38:07,926 --> 01:38:16,306
is that it is a beautiful transformation of the idea expressing itself through the culture.

952
01:38:16,306 --> 01:38:23,166
yeah no i i agree with that i think that ideas definitely come from the culture and you have to

953
01:38:23,166 --> 01:38:27,906
be in a certain culture for certain ideas to be able to flourish if you're in communist china

954
01:38:27,906 --> 01:38:33,406
you know you're not going to be able to um do certain things that you can do here for cultural

955
01:38:33,406 --> 01:38:38,726
due to cultural constraints that place constraints on the ideas that one can have but i think that

956
01:38:38,726 --> 01:38:44,906
you know that's to in the context of the h1b debate it was the idea people who look at as

957
01:38:44,906 --> 01:38:51,666
America as purely an abstract idea about being free market competitive, they would say,

958
01:38:51,666 --> 01:38:56,266
you can take somebody from some other nation, drop them in the United States, and they're an

959
01:38:56,266 --> 01:39:00,666
American. And people on the culture side say, no, there's actually an acculturation,

960
01:39:00,786 --> 01:39:06,326
enculturation, assimilation aspect, where you learn many things about how to be an American,

961
01:39:06,486 --> 01:39:12,406
how to respect free speech, how to even maybe just things like how you operate your body in space,

962
01:39:12,406 --> 01:39:18,566
your body bubble, the hygiene that you have, how you treat the public spaces that you're in.

963
01:39:18,746 --> 01:39:24,506
These are all learned things that are cultural that then allow certain ideas to flourish within

964
01:39:24,506 --> 01:39:30,206
them like entrepreneurship, human dignity, things like that. So I agree with you. I do think ideas

965
01:39:30,206 --> 01:39:35,806
are related to culture, but culture is primary. And I think, I mean, take that back to the original

966
01:39:35,806 --> 01:39:41,046
question then. If one has to define what United States, the country, what's the positive vision

967
01:39:41,046 --> 01:39:47,326
going forward, I think one has to, you know, if you really want people to believe in it,

968
01:39:47,386 --> 01:39:53,906
you can't just say America, the country is about free market competition and entrepreneurship,

969
01:39:53,906 --> 01:40:00,326
because that's, I think, a cold and empty vision for most people, not completely empty. And those

970
01:40:00,326 --> 01:40:06,146
are those are good things, but they only have value to the extent that they enrich our communities

971
01:40:06,146 --> 01:40:08,666
and are, you know, that are products of our culture.

972
01:40:08,786 --> 01:40:13,286
And so it can seem blood and soil nationalist to say something like that.

973
01:40:13,346 --> 01:40:17,986
But I think it's just realistic that what makes a human a human is the cultural apparatus

974
01:40:17,986 --> 01:40:22,346
that generated the consciousness that person has in the way that that then caches out

975
01:40:22,346 --> 01:40:26,666
in the ideas that they, you know, put into the world and operate within.

976
01:40:26,866 --> 01:40:29,866
So I would agree with you.

977
01:40:29,946 --> 01:40:34,026
Ideas are important, but they stem from culture and that any definition positive,

978
01:40:34,026 --> 01:40:43,946
any positive definition of America, the country going forward, if it's a tool for domestic revitalization and a step away from hegemony and empire,

979
01:40:44,306 --> 01:40:52,966
is going to have to respect that we do have a culture and that it's not just some abstract ideal free floating without a culture.

980
01:40:52,966 --> 01:41:01,006
so so maybe maybe you can maybe you can find a compromise between what both of us are saying

981
01:41:01,006 --> 01:41:08,466
if you can view ideas as a personal culture as an individual and an idea is a culture that an

982
01:41:08,466 --> 01:41:15,266
individual has that would combined with other people who have similar ideas arises from from

983
01:41:15,266 --> 01:41:26,146
which we see a nation and a community. And yeah, I, yeah, I don't know. It's a, it's a beautiful

984
01:41:26,146 --> 01:41:34,246
thing to consider that, that I, by the way, I do completely agree that you can't take someone from

985
01:41:34,246 --> 01:41:38,506
outside the United States and drop them in the United States and have them be an American. I

986
01:41:38,506 --> 01:41:43,386
think we see examples of that. And the reason, by the way, is that you can't take an American

987
01:41:43,386 --> 01:41:45,406
and drop them in China and have them be Chinese.

988
01:41:45,906 --> 01:41:47,346
Like that can't happen.

989
01:41:47,606 --> 01:41:48,886
Like it just can't happen.

990
01:41:50,226 --> 01:41:57,386
But you can eventually – like the difference is that I can never be Chinese ever.

991
01:41:58,086 --> 01:42:00,186
Like it just – it cannot happen.

992
01:42:00,406 --> 01:42:03,366
But a Chinese person can be an American.

993
01:42:03,366 --> 01:42:11,726
And so there is beauty in that flexibility and the adaptability of being able to adopt those ideas and beliefs.

994
01:42:12,006 --> 01:42:12,406
So yeah.

995
01:42:12,406 --> 01:42:37,906
Yeah, no, I think that that's a good ending point. I mean, this part three was the rise and fall of global monetary orders. We've been talking about the rise of the next order. And these kinds of broad questions about one's vision of the United States or whatever country you're in, I mean, we're going to create or in some sense orchestrate or be dragged into the next global monetary order.

996
01:42:37,906 --> 01:42:48,126
And so I think it does benefit us to have these large conceptual discussions about what a nation is and what's important. So I think that's a really great place, a point to have coalesced on here at the end.

997
01:42:48,126 --> 01:43:15,786
Yeah, I think the we are going to see that the next world order is created more so from the bottom up than from the top down. And that's something that sounds good to me, because it just means that there's going to be more people involved in in solving the problem. And the more people that you have to solve the problem, the more chances that you'll run into a really good idea on how to solve it. So, yeah, I love it. Fantastic.

998
01:43:15,786 --> 01:43:21,906
and as always a wonderful discussion here on broken money and we'll guess we'll see you guys

999
01:43:21,906 --> 01:43:28,386
next time i'm lucas and that's grant he's at the whole frame on twitter and i am at lucas maddy

1000
01:43:28,386 --> 01:43:35,606
see you guys see you later thank you for listening if you like please subscribe every little bit gets

1001
01:43:35,606 --> 01:43:40,766
me one tiny step closer to my ultimate goal of living in a cave you never have to buy windows

1002
01:43:40,766 --> 01:43:45,326
or shingles and there's no lawn to mow. Look it up. Dream big kids.