1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:23,740
All right. Chapter five, Bitcoin and credit of the Satoshi Papers. Hey, welcome back. We had a little break there. We got busy with life as we do. But today we're going to move on to the next essay here. As I mentioned, chapter five, Bitcoin and credit by Jack Watt in the Satoshi Papers, Reflections on Political Economy After Bitcoin, edited by Natalie Smolenski.

2
00:00:23,740 --> 00:00:28,280
Chapter five, we've already read four essays. Lucas and I are in agreement. This is a phenomenal

3
00:00:28,280 --> 00:00:36,260
collection. As with the prior essays, this essay is academic in caliber in the best sense. The

4
00:00:36,260 --> 00:00:41,380
author, Jack Watt, I had not heard of him before, but he is an entrepreneur and writer whose focus

5
00:00:41,380 --> 00:00:47,500
is Austrian economics and monetary theory. His writing is featured on mysees.org. He co-founded

6
00:00:47,500 --> 00:00:53,680
the Bitcoin-focused company, SOV, BTC, and is a professional pilot. And it says his writer's

7
00:00:53,680 --> 00:00:59,140
focused on Austrian economics. This essay, Bitcoin and Credit, if you are interested in Austrian

8
00:00:59,140 --> 00:01:06,220
economics, the taxonomies it creates, the way that it talks about money and economics, this essay is

9
00:01:06,220 --> 00:01:10,040
excellent for that. I'm going to give a little summary here like we usually do, and then Lucas

10
00:01:10,040 --> 00:01:16,200
and I are going to dissect it a bit. And I'm super excited to hear Lucas's take on this. I haven't

11
00:01:16,200 --> 00:01:21,600
got it yet. And this is more in Lucas's real house than mine, Bitcoin and Credit. Credit's

12
00:01:21,600 --> 00:01:26,520
such an abstract thing and I'm more of kind of a humanities guy. But that's what we do. When you

13
00:01:26,520 --> 00:01:32,640
consider Bitcoin, you have to think about credit. So this essay, like I said, called Bitcoin and

14
00:01:32,640 --> 00:01:36,720
Credit. And I'm just going to read the last paragraph so you can see where we're going to go.

15
00:01:36,720 --> 00:01:43,760
So the last paragraph, the Bitcoin community now faces the challenge of designing and implementing

16
00:01:43,760 --> 00:01:51,240
Bitcoin-based credit instruments. How these are adopted and used around the world is arguably one

17
00:01:51,240 --> 00:01:56,680
of the most significant economic questions of our time. So Bitcoin-based credit instruments,

18
00:01:56,960 --> 00:02:01,180
one of the most significant questions of our time. That's what this essay is going to maintain.

19
00:02:01,440 --> 00:02:05,440
This essay is very rich, as I mentioned, especially for those interested in Austrian

20
00:02:05,440 --> 00:02:10,040
economics, that school of theory, and its application to Bitcoin. There's an entire

21
00:02:10,040 --> 00:02:15,340
section we might not get to on Mice's taxonomy of money, and maybe we'll hash it out a bit more

22
00:02:15,340 --> 00:02:20,900
in conversation. But without going into too far in the weeds, kind of in that aspect, in the summary,

23
00:02:21,240 --> 00:02:22,740
Here are the main points of the essay.

24
00:02:23,100 --> 00:02:28,860
Bitcoiners sometimes have a problem with the whole even idea of credit, but the problem

25
00:02:28,860 --> 00:02:31,360
is not with credit issuance as such.

26
00:02:31,620 --> 00:02:38,360
As Jack Watt notes, markets everywhere exhibit perennial demand to channel savings from savers

27
00:02:38,360 --> 00:02:43,540
to producers who in turn invest that capital into productive activity that drives economic

28
00:02:43,540 --> 00:02:43,940
growth.

29
00:02:43,940 --> 00:02:48,780
So just like on a base level, credit does seem to be very integrated into the way our

30
00:02:48,780 --> 00:02:51,020
economy has functioned.

31
00:02:51,020 --> 00:02:55,880
And so Bitcoin does seem to need to be able to incorporate some notion of credit.

32
00:02:56,480 --> 00:03:03,340
The problem is also not kind of necessarily with fractional reserve banking as such.

33
00:03:03,340 --> 00:03:11,020
Fractional reserve banking, which again is a method for loaning where only a fraction of the savings deposit is retained, the rest is loaned out.

34
00:03:11,540 --> 00:03:17,420
The problem of credit or what makes credit problematic is rehypothecation.

35
00:03:17,420 --> 00:03:22,420
So that's a great vocab word, but that's one of the takeaways from this essay.

36
00:03:22,600 --> 00:03:31,920
If you take away nothing else from this convo, rehypothecation and another phrase, fiduciary media, which is another term we're going to get to.

37
00:03:32,320 --> 00:03:33,440
What is rehypothecation?

38
00:03:33,840 --> 00:03:39,500
Basically money or something that claims to be money being in two places at the same time.

39
00:03:39,560 --> 00:03:41,080
That's kind of the simplest explanation.

40
00:03:41,500 --> 00:03:55,640
Example, a dollar on a bank's ledger can be simultaneously recorded as one part of a customer's account and then lent out by the bank to another customer and used by that other customer as collateral for a loan they receive from yet another party.

41
00:03:55,780 --> 00:04:02,840
So that's an example from the essay of money or something claiming to be money being in multiple places at the same time.

42
00:04:02,920 --> 00:04:04,240
That's rehypothecation.

43
00:04:04,240 --> 00:04:16,180
So in rehypothecation, rehypothecated money becomes something that Austrian economics, or at least Mises, according to this essay, refers to as fiduciary media.

44
00:04:16,860 --> 00:04:21,860
That's the second vocab word that I think is great and kind of helps understand this essay a lot.

45
00:04:22,280 --> 00:04:24,720
Fiduciary media is money.

46
00:04:24,880 --> 00:04:26,700
You could define it as a money substitute.

47
00:04:27,160 --> 00:04:31,740
It's a type of, you're calling it kind of derogatorily media instead of money, fiduciary media.

48
00:04:31,740 --> 00:04:44,740
This is a money substitute which is used in excess of the actual money supply, a substitute which is going to enable some more liquidity, some more usage of money-like things.

49
00:04:45,580 --> 00:04:46,920
That's fiduciary media.

50
00:04:46,920 --> 00:05:02,480
The increase in the money supply with the addition of money substitutes, fiduciary media, leads to boom-bust business cycles, the kind of cycles that we have that seem to be inherent and integral to our economic system.

51
00:05:02,700 --> 00:05:15,340
The issuance of fiduciary media drives credit expansion, this is a quote, during the boom phase of business cycles, which eventually go bust and result in credit contraction back to levels more in line with real savings.

52
00:05:15,340 --> 00:05:20,280
So we begin issuing a bunch of fiduciary media, a bunch of money substitutes.

53
00:05:20,400 --> 00:05:22,100
That leads to the boom phase.

54
00:05:22,320 --> 00:05:25,500
And then we have the bust phase and people realize this is not actually money.

55
00:05:25,600 --> 00:05:26,180
It's a substitute.

56
00:05:26,840 --> 00:05:31,740
During the boom phase, we have, as we all know, the illusion of prosperity, rising wages,

57
00:05:31,940 --> 00:05:35,300
production increases that tend to cater to future demand.

58
00:05:35,520 --> 00:05:37,280
So we begin like investing in things.

59
00:05:37,360 --> 00:05:39,200
We think people are going to buy a bunch of stuff.

60
00:05:39,360 --> 00:05:40,220
Things are going well.

61
00:05:40,220 --> 00:05:45,940
In the bus phase, we realize, oh, the means of production are scarce, but money is not.

62
00:05:46,240 --> 00:05:56,040
We discover that savings are insufficient and people try to redeem this money substitutes they have, the fiduciary media, for real money, for real things.

63
00:05:56,040 --> 00:06:02,020
And we see that capital was wasted on a half-finished projects and unprofitable ventures.

64
00:06:02,020 --> 00:06:07,000
So then you have that boom and bust, and then the central banks intervene to prop up demand.

65
00:06:07,000 --> 00:06:11,620
And we end with a general rise in prices and a devaluation of savings.

66
00:06:11,840 --> 00:06:13,360
And this devaluation is not equal.

67
00:06:13,560 --> 00:06:21,140
This is, of course, key lore for Bitcoin or something I learned as I got more into Bitcoin, one of the key concepts.

68
00:06:21,400 --> 00:06:27,460
Politically connected are the best able to protect themselves in any bust phase of a cycle, any boom phase as well.

69
00:06:27,800 --> 00:06:31,760
I situate and monopolize on it through what is called the Cantillon effect.

70
00:06:32,180 --> 00:06:36,000
This is a really good summary of the Cantillon effect from this essay.

71
00:06:36,000 --> 00:06:36,640
I'm going to quote here.

72
00:06:36,640 --> 00:06:46,920
So here's our vocabulary words, I think, which kind of give us a good understanding of where we're going with this essay so far, which is money substitutes instead of real money.

73
00:06:47,140 --> 00:06:55,300
And then we get boom-bust cycles, and the Cantillon effects jumps in to reward political entrepreneurs who are closest to the money printer.

74
00:06:55,540 --> 00:06:59,360
The key point, here's a good quote that helps us kind of understand this all in one sentence.

75
00:06:59,360 --> 00:07:05,740
money cannot be a superposition of present and future goods and be used by several parties at

76
00:07:05,740 --> 00:07:11,580
once without creating a business cycle rehypothecation is exactly what does that though so

77
00:07:11,580 --> 00:07:18,460
rehypothecation leads to fiduciary media or money substitutes but what is real money then real money

78
00:07:18,460 --> 00:07:26,400
is defined in this essay as quote scarce money that functions as a rival good so rival goods

79
00:07:26,400 --> 00:07:27,940
It's kind of a technical concept in there.

80
00:07:28,360 --> 00:07:32,980
And it's just like, really, rival good is just the opposite of fiduciary media, or of

81
00:07:32,980 --> 00:07:34,200
rehypothecation.

82
00:07:34,360 --> 00:07:40,760
Being a rival good means that unlike a rehypothecation, or maybe unlike something abstract like an

83
00:07:40,760 --> 00:07:43,660
idea, it can only be in one place at one time.

84
00:07:43,800 --> 00:07:46,700
A rival good is in one place at one time.

85
00:07:46,700 --> 00:07:48,940
It's not rehypothecated in multiple places.

86
00:07:49,180 --> 00:07:50,380
Money must be a rival good.

87
00:07:50,500 --> 00:07:56,020
Real money, that is, must be a rival good, or else it leads to limitless credit expansion.

88
00:07:56,020 --> 00:07:58,800
And who loves limitless credit expansion?

89
00:07:59,300 --> 00:08:02,360
Debtors do because it devalues the debts that they have.

90
00:08:02,520 --> 00:08:04,000
And who is the biggest debtor?

91
00:08:04,160 --> 00:08:04,980
The state.

92
00:08:05,340 --> 00:08:12,720
So historically, commodity monies like gold, which are real money, it's scarce and it's a rival good.

93
00:08:12,900 --> 00:08:18,680
Gold can only be physically in one place at one time, are replaced by imposed fiat currencies.

94
00:08:19,020 --> 00:08:24,240
Fiat currencies themselves are actually also in their kind of most benign state rival.

95
00:08:24,240 --> 00:08:27,560
They're not scarce, but they're at least rival goods because of fiat dollar.

96
00:08:27,760 --> 00:08:29,940
I mean, the physical thing can only be in one place.

97
00:08:30,000 --> 00:08:31,880
You only can print infinity dollars.

98
00:08:32,400 --> 00:08:36,920
So but in any case, so commodity monies like gold historically replaced by fiat currencies

99
00:08:36,920 --> 00:08:40,580
because commodity monies place limits on government spending.

100
00:08:40,580 --> 00:08:45,500
They have a hard physical cap on paying a rival good and they place limits on government

101
00:08:45,500 --> 00:08:47,380
spending and growth of industry and trade.

102
00:08:47,700 --> 00:08:50,240
Bitcoin is I misspoke there.

103
00:08:50,240 --> 00:08:55,160
So commodity monies don't necessarily place limits on growth of industry and trade themselves.

104
00:08:55,260 --> 00:08:57,980
We're going to go a bit more into how credit aids in that.

105
00:08:58,320 --> 00:09:10,060
But in any case, Bitcoin is a technological solution, according to this essay, to the problems of rehypothecation and fiduciary media in a way that gold is not.

106
00:09:10,260 --> 00:09:12,180
So I'm glossing over quite a bit.

107
00:09:12,180 --> 00:09:27,620
I want to say to fiduciary media, I've kind of like money substitutes, I've kind of framed it as necessarily a bad thing, but it can also be not necessarily evil, just a way to increase liquidity by using a substitute for money, introducing that also in the monetary system.

108
00:09:27,920 --> 00:09:40,240
But in any case, Bitcoin has certain technological aspects that make it different than gold in a way that can't be co-opted and then rehypothecated or turned into a fiduciary media so easily.

109
00:09:40,840 --> 00:09:45,640
So Bitcoin is a currency that is an absolutely scarce rival good.

110
00:09:45,860 --> 00:09:52,280
It can scale its transaction throughput and it has its own transaction rails included.

111
00:09:52,500 --> 00:09:53,680
And that's kind of a key point.

112
00:09:53,680 --> 00:09:57,040
The problem with gold is it's hard to move around.

113
00:09:57,480 --> 00:10:06,520
But imagine if gold, of course, had its own manner of transaction included in the substance of gold, which is what Bitcoin ontologically does.

114
00:10:06,620 --> 00:10:09,640
It is its own ledger and protocol.

115
00:10:09,960 --> 00:10:15,520
Bitcoin's properties then allow for at least three important things in the context of this essay.

116
00:10:15,520 --> 00:10:28,280
So the first thing, again, as I started off at the beginning, this author thinks that figuring out the problem of credit is one of the key things that Bitcoin needs to do and is going to do.

117
00:10:28,680 --> 00:10:38,220
And so one of the three important things in the context of this essay that Bitcoin does is it still allows for the issuance of short-term credit instruments.

118
00:10:38,220 --> 00:10:47,060
This essay is not anti-credit. It's kind of anti-fiduciary media, which is endlessly rehypothecated credit in the form of money substitutes.

119
00:10:47,380 --> 00:10:57,100
Credit instruments on top of Bitcoin is something that can actually help and address like scaling problems with limited block size on the Bitcoin network.

120
00:10:57,100 --> 00:11:09,220
It also addresses the need for credit in an economic system, which is, as I noted at the beginning, allowing real savings to be transferred in money terms to the highest bidding entrepreneur capitalists.

121
00:11:09,580 --> 00:11:16,540
This essay does go into depth technically into how to do a Bitcoin bill of exchange.

122
00:11:16,740 --> 00:11:18,760
That's a little bit too much for this summary.

123
00:11:18,860 --> 00:11:20,820
Maybe we'll talk about it in the discussion.

124
00:11:21,580 --> 00:11:28,020
I'll kind of quote a bit on that just so you get a gist of what that idea of a Bitcoin bill exchange means, though.

125
00:11:28,020 --> 00:11:33,900
Because Bitcoin bill creation simply reflects a transfer of Bitcoin, its contribution to credit expansion is nil.

126
00:11:34,180 --> 00:11:38,880
Such bills are real credit. They grant the holder a future good, a claim to Bitcoin on the maturity date.

127
00:11:39,280 --> 00:11:45,520
In this way, the pool of saved Bitcoin, real savings, is distributing to the highest bidding entrepreneur for product.

128
00:11:45,520 --> 00:11:51,000
That's a capsule summary of what a Bitcoin bill of exchange can do.

129
00:11:51,460 --> 00:11:56,740
And again, this essay does go into the technical aspects of how those would be crafted a bit more.

130
00:11:56,920 --> 00:11:59,420
Bitcoin allows for three important things in the context of this essay.

131
00:11:59,480 --> 00:12:02,140
The first thing, it still allows for the issuance of short-term credit.

132
00:12:02,140 --> 00:12:07,500
The second thing, Bitcoin is resistant to the issuance of fiduciary media.

133
00:12:07,500 --> 00:12:21,700
Again, fiduciary media are bad because it's rehypothecated money substitute, not backed one-to-one, not scarce, not a rival good, which leads to credit expansion and then a boom-bust business cycle.

134
00:12:21,940 --> 00:12:33,640
Bitcoin, though, can allow for issuance of credit but also resist the rehypothecation being in more than one place at the same time that leads to fiduciary media.

135
00:12:33,640 --> 00:12:48,360
How? Just the inherent technical aspects of Bitcoin. Bitcoin transactions preclude the opaque chains of rehypothecation to which most near monies today are subject and which create hidden leverage throughout the global financial system.

136
00:12:48,880 --> 00:12:50,940
Bitcoin is just transparent.

137
00:12:51,860 --> 00:12:54,900
You can trace what's happening with each Satoshi.

138
00:12:55,140 --> 00:12:58,640
And so it resists being in more than one place at one time.

139
00:12:58,640 --> 00:13:03,800
You can go back and see the place the thing actually is, the unique location of each unit.

140
00:13:04,220 --> 00:13:13,100
So three important things that Bitcoin does in the context of this essay still allows for short-term credit, is resistant to the issuance of fiduciary media.

141
00:13:13,100 --> 00:13:23,240
And then third, Bitcoin has capture-resistant properties that help it avoid the fate of physical commodity monies and transforming into fiat and being endlessly rehypothecated.

142
00:13:23,580 --> 00:13:29,580
So fiat money occurs when institutions suspend redemption of commodity money.

143
00:13:29,580 --> 00:13:34,140
But Bitcoin, so Bitcoin comes with its own transaction rails included.

144
00:13:34,140 --> 00:13:48,980
So unlike gold, which, you know, once you centralize the control of that, everybody puts it in a bank that's held by certain third parties, the government can then step in and say, we're not going to let you take any of the gold out.

145
00:13:49,340 --> 00:13:54,860
Bitcoin is a little bit different because it has its own transaction rails included.

146
00:13:54,860 --> 00:13:59,740
quote, unlike all physical commodity monies, Bitcoin comes integrated with the means for

147
00:13:59,740 --> 00:14:05,620
transferring balances, a digital protocol that manages a digital ledger. This is by design.

148
00:14:05,780 --> 00:14:11,320
Bitcoin is an uncensorable and permissionless protocol built with the express purpose of

149
00:14:11,320 --> 00:14:27,321
enabling individuals to be in their own banks to make their own payments and store their own money holdings directly without relying on third parties So Bitcoin allows for easy self And this hopefully the thought is is going to allow for large amounts of Bitcoin to be

150
00:14:27,321 --> 00:14:31,621
held by individuals and not held by third party custodians, therefore kind of resisting

151
00:14:31,621 --> 00:14:37,181
the suspension of commodity money that has happened in the past, the suspension of the

152
00:14:37,181 --> 00:14:41,041
redemption of commodity monies when the governments want to impose fiat.

153
00:14:41,041 --> 00:14:55,781
So if people are their own custodians, this will also then have the natural effects of diminishing kind of bank reserves over time and so lead to the less creation of loaned out, rehypothecated fiduciary media monetary substitutes.

154
00:14:55,781 --> 00:15:06,601
The three important things then that Bitcoin does in the context of this essay still allows for short-term credit is resisted to issuance of fiduciary media money substitutes.

155
00:15:07,201 --> 00:15:15,461
And three, has capture-resistant properties that help it avoid the fate of physical commodity monies and transforming into fiat and being endlessly re-eboticated.

156
00:15:15,461 --> 00:15:20,521
That gets, I think, kind of most of the main concepts of the essay out onto the table.

157
00:15:20,521 --> 00:15:27,621
As I noted, I omitted a lot of the really technical heavy lifting on the Austrian view of money.

158
00:15:28,001 --> 00:15:30,121
There's a whole chart here.

159
00:15:30,241 --> 00:15:31,101
I'm pulling up the camera.

160
00:15:31,221 --> 00:15:34,961
If you're listening, you don't see it about Mycet's taxonomy of money.

161
00:15:35,021 --> 00:15:38,101
It's really interesting, but it's kind of hard to explain in a neat summary.

162
00:15:38,461 --> 00:15:44,041
I'll just conclude then, I think, with this is the penultimate paragraph of the essay.

163
00:15:44,201 --> 00:15:46,741
It kind of does a good job of summarying the essay itself.

164
00:15:50,521 --> 00:16:00,741
the potential to improve the workings of a global money economy by structurally suppressing

165
00:16:00,741 --> 00:16:06,021
the issuance of fiduciary media in a way that has become nearly impossible

166
00:16:06,021 --> 00:16:11,661
using legislative or political means. This holds open the possibility of dampening the effects of

167
00:16:11,661 --> 00:16:17,521
vast economic discoordination that leads to boom and bust cycles or business cycles in this way.

168
00:16:17,521 --> 00:16:39,201
Bitcoin is posed to facilitate human cooperation and complex production without the state. While no monetary utopia will appear as a result of Bitcoin adoption, the systematic perturbations created by limitless injections of fiduciary media into markets will no longer produce the malignant incentives that debase real savings and kill entrepreneurial initiative over time.

169
00:16:39,201 --> 00:16:47,061
This will indeed constitute a new paradigm for political economy, although that paradigm is old as well.

170
00:16:47,281 --> 00:16:50,261
A small public sector and real rapid growth.

171
00:16:50,501 --> 00:16:52,921
So that's my summary of Bitcoin and credit.

172
00:16:53,341 --> 00:16:54,721
I apologize, Jack Watt.

173
00:16:54,841 --> 00:16:58,761
I'm a more humanities-centered person.

174
00:16:59,161 --> 00:17:01,901
Some of this is foreign language to me, but that's the best I got.

175
00:17:02,021 --> 00:17:03,361
Lucas, what do you think, man?

176
00:17:03,441 --> 00:17:04,701
I think this essay is fantastic.

177
00:17:04,701 --> 00:17:11,441
Again, any limitations in my summary or personal failures of myself as a human being and not due to the essay?

178
00:17:11,801 --> 00:17:16,501
I mean, what do you want to add or take away or just exit the room politely on?

179
00:17:16,881 --> 00:17:17,921
No, I want to dig in.

180
00:17:18,181 --> 00:17:20,881
Yeah, I think you did a good job with the summary.

181
00:17:20,881 --> 00:17:28,881
And I kind of want to I'd like to maybe add a little color and maybe some examples to these terms that have been introduced.

182
00:17:29,201 --> 00:17:31,721
You know, rehypothecation, fiduciary media.

183
00:17:31,721 --> 00:17:40,501
maybe dig in a little bit on really why it is so important that a commodity or why it is so special

184
00:17:40,501 --> 00:17:47,041
that there now exists a commodity money that is capture resistant. So I think those are all

185
00:17:47,041 --> 00:17:52,021
really fascinating. The first one I want to talk about is like the rehypothecation, which is just,

186
00:17:52,161 --> 00:17:59,761
you know, money existing in two places at once. And I think the first place that you start when

187
00:17:59,761 --> 00:18:05,881
you want to talk about that, which is there will be people listening to this podcast who do not

188
00:18:05,881 --> 00:18:15,281
realize that when they look at their bank account and it says $2,000, there is not $2,000 there.

189
00:18:15,761 --> 00:18:21,381
That money does not exist. What? What you're seeing. Yeah. Blow your mind, right? All right.

190
00:18:21,381 --> 00:18:28,161
Just right. Wait till you hear about the dark side of the moon and how hollow it is. Yeah. So

191
00:18:28,161 --> 00:18:36,061
Well, that money doesn't exist. Banks keep track of how much you've deposited and they keep track

192
00:18:36,061 --> 00:18:42,601
of how much they owe you, but they have what's called an IOU, right? They don't actually have

193
00:18:42,601 --> 00:18:48,661
that money. What they do is they take the thousand dollars that you put in and then they in turn

194
00:18:48,661 --> 00:18:57,341
lend out $9,000 against that thousand dollars. That's what fractional reserve banking allows

195
00:18:57,341 --> 00:19:02,721
you to do is basically you're making a educated bet.

196
00:19:02,981 --> 00:19:08,461
You're taking the risk and you're saying that we don't have enough money to pay everyone

197
00:19:08,461 --> 00:19:14,501
who has given us their money, but we're counting on not all of them asking for it at the same

198
00:19:14,501 --> 00:19:14,881
time.

199
00:19:14,881 --> 00:19:15,321
Yeah.

200
00:19:15,541 --> 00:19:20,401
One of the things I thought was cool is like making clear that like rehypothecation is

201
00:19:20,401 --> 00:19:22,481
not is different, right?

202
00:19:22,621 --> 00:19:24,341
Than fractional reserve banking.

203
00:19:24,341 --> 00:19:35,721
So fractional reserve banking, when it's malignant, malicious, relies on rehypothecation because there is the assumption that the money is both in the account and also somewhere at the same time.

204
00:19:35,841 --> 00:19:44,341
But you could have fractional reserve bank where people are completely aware and it's transparent that the money is not in the account and that it is being loaned out and that it's not accessible, that it's not rehypothecated.

205
00:19:45,081 --> 00:19:47,621
People don't rely on it being in the account, right?

206
00:19:48,101 --> 00:19:51,341
And so like this essay, I mean, the bad thing is rehypothecation.

207
00:19:51,341 --> 00:19:55,461
rehypothecation. It's not necessarily, I mean, I think fractional reserve banking will tend

208
00:19:55,461 --> 00:19:59,981
towards rehypothecation, at least psychologically, because people will think the money is there.

209
00:20:00,461 --> 00:20:06,681
But maybe Bitcoin's transparency will make people more, force them into the realization that

210
00:20:06,681 --> 00:20:11,961
my money is not in the bank. I gave it to them. It's being loaned out. I'm aware of that. It's

211
00:20:11,961 --> 00:20:18,901
rehypothecated. I mean, it's fractionally reserved, but I know I'm relying on the interest coming in

212
00:20:18,901 --> 00:20:21,921
as kind of compensation for that fact, and I'm fine with it.

213
00:20:22,201 --> 00:20:24,261
I don't know if anybody's ever been honest about it.

214
00:20:24,421 --> 00:20:31,461
So I guess, yeah, I mean, not too long ago, I was reading, I don't know where I was reading

215
00:20:31,461 --> 00:20:35,881
this, but I was reading a story about how like in the, I think it was the 1800s, that

216
00:20:35,881 --> 00:20:38,801
was a very wide open time for banking.

217
00:20:39,041 --> 00:20:42,841
Like there weren't a whole lot of banking regulations and you had what were known as

218
00:20:42,841 --> 00:20:48,381
the wildcat banks, which would just be like effectively like private enterprises that,

219
00:20:48,381 --> 00:20:54,981
I mean, most banks are private enterprises, but private enterprises that they're like, hey, we've got some money.

220
00:20:55,481 --> 00:20:56,581
Here's our reserves.

221
00:20:56,901 --> 00:21:00,661
We're going to start a bank and make loans and deposit.

222
00:21:00,961 --> 00:21:04,961
And a lot of them would have their own money, like literally their own currency.

223
00:21:06,021 --> 00:21:11,501
And then, you know, every once in a while, maybe some regulator would come and like check the reserves.

224
00:21:11,801 --> 00:21:13,801
And this was like they had physical reserves.

225
00:21:13,921 --> 00:21:14,741
They have gold reserves.

226
00:21:14,741 --> 00:21:19,221
And so, you know, they've got, say, three branches in three different towns.

227
00:21:19,581 --> 00:21:29,321
And, you know, so what they would do is they would take all the gold and they would put it at this bank and they would walk the regulator through and he would look at it and then be like, oh, OK, you know what?

228
00:21:29,361 --> 00:21:32,641
We're going to take you to lunch and then we'll take you to the next bank.

229
00:21:32,741 --> 00:21:40,421
And while they were taking him to lunch, they would take all the gold and they would take it to the next bank so that he could go verify that that also had reserves.

230
00:21:40,421 --> 00:21:43,061
It was just the same gold to be around.

231
00:21:43,061 --> 00:21:49,681
Uh, it's fun cause that's, um, it's an actual example of a physical commodity that in effect

232
00:21:49,681 --> 00:21:50,921
is being rehypothecated.

233
00:21:51,081 --> 00:21:54,161
As far as the regulator knows, it's in two places at once.

234
00:21:54,881 --> 00:21:58,281
Or I guess not as far as he knows, as far as he knows, they have the gold.

235
00:21:58,581 --> 00:21:59,761
Stone age rehypothecation.

236
00:22:00,241 --> 00:22:00,341
Yeah.

237
00:22:00,561 --> 00:22:00,841
Yeah.

238
00:22:01,101 --> 00:22:04,241
It's acting as two, two, uh, two things at once.

239
00:22:04,641 --> 00:22:10,721
The thing that, um, the thing that I find that is like the most kind of like mind blowing,

240
00:22:10,721 --> 00:22:16,581
interesting takeaway from this is the, so we talked about this last week with a group and

241
00:22:16,581 --> 00:22:25,421
Austrian economics has come to the realization by observing history that money is naturally chosen

242
00:22:25,421 --> 00:22:33,001
by people as the thing that holds the value the best. Even today, money is not what governments

243
00:22:33,001 --> 00:22:41,401
tell us it is. Like people use money substitutes in order to get best value held. They put their

244
00:22:41,401 --> 00:22:46,941
money into real estate as a store of value. They put their money into growth stocks as a store of

245
00:22:46,941 --> 00:22:54,521
value, et cetera, et cetera. But when money was a commodity, starting with stones and seashells and

246
00:22:54,521 --> 00:23:01,141
tobacco and salt and cattle, et cetera, et cetera, you had a progressively, it went from

247
00:23:01,141 --> 00:23:05,501
this type of money to the next type of money. And each time it went to a different type of money,

248
00:23:05,701 --> 00:23:11,421
the thing that was different was that that money was, as they say, harder. It was more scarce. It

249
00:23:11,421 --> 00:23:16,841
was more difficult to replicate. And you think about it, it's actually kind of fascinating,

250
00:23:16,841 --> 00:23:23,701
I think, to consider like, it's not just how hard it is to replicate. It's also the predictability

251
00:23:23,701 --> 00:23:30,841
of the issuance schedule. And in that manner, in that matter, cattle are actually probably a

252
00:23:30,841 --> 00:23:33,801
more predictable money than gold.

253
00:23:34,101 --> 00:23:35,221
Because you can never predict

254
00:23:35,221 --> 00:23:37,081
when you're going to hit the next mother load.

255
00:23:37,681 --> 00:23:40,341
But you do know that you put a boy cow

256
00:23:40,341 --> 00:23:41,181
and a girl cow together,

257
00:23:41,341 --> 00:23:43,001
nine months later, you get another cow.

258
00:23:43,021 --> 00:23:43,781
Boy cow.

259
00:23:44,101 --> 00:23:45,461
Tell me how it works out, Lucas.

260
00:23:46,301 --> 00:23:49,561
I'm trying to bring it to the people where they're at.

261
00:23:49,881 --> 00:23:52,041
This is, just to put an asterisk here,

262
00:23:52,041 --> 00:23:54,481
this is a phenomenal and condensed explanation

263
00:23:54,481 --> 00:23:55,641
of Austrian economic theory.

264
00:23:55,781 --> 00:23:56,521
I'm very much enjoying.

265
00:23:56,681 --> 00:23:56,881
Continue.

266
00:23:57,181 --> 00:23:57,321
Yeah.

267
00:23:57,681 --> 00:23:59,941
So anyway, so what you had was that

268
00:23:59,941 --> 00:24:06,801
commodity money, it progresses from easy to hard. But what you find when it gets to the hard,

269
00:24:06,801 --> 00:24:13,881
which is gold, when it got to hard money, that money was also heavy because gold is heavy. And

270
00:24:13,881 --> 00:24:19,541
it turns out that it's difficult to move around and it's difficult to verify. It's, you know,

271
00:24:19,561 --> 00:24:24,041
you have to melt it down and it's difficult to cut apart and put back together and all these other

272
00:24:24,041 --> 00:24:31,321
problems that that come with gold being gold and like you mentioned and like jack um so like very

273
00:24:31,321 --> 00:24:37,441
well pointed out there is no gold network like there's a bitcoin network yeah where you take

274
00:24:37,441 --> 00:24:43,301
bitcoin from here and you put it there and it moves along its own path it doesn't have to exit

275
00:24:43,301 --> 00:24:48,881
the system or anything like that but there's no gold network you have to physically take it along

276
00:24:48,881 --> 00:24:53,961
infrastructure. Like the gold network is roads and it's trains, it's airplanes.

277
00:24:53,961 --> 00:24:58,521
And it's humans and banks and malevolent actors. And yeah, all these things are part of the network.

278
00:24:58,521 --> 00:25:03,041
So there's just, well, I mean, there's just, there's just more points of failure, right?

279
00:25:03,601 --> 00:25:06,721
There's just more opportunities. There's more variables at play.

280
00:25:07,061 --> 00:25:12,861
Bandits on the road, bandits at the banks, for sure. The transaction rails of gold is much more

281
00:25:12,861 --> 00:25:14,361
error laden. Yeah.

282
00:25:14,761 --> 00:25:17,781
Yeah. Yeah. One of them wears masks. One of them should.

283
00:25:18,881 --> 00:25:21,921
One of them started wearing masks after COVID, right?

284
00:25:24,141 --> 00:25:31,281
I was reading something about how it became awfully convenient to be a robber after COVID.

285
00:25:31,981 --> 00:25:34,181
Yeah, they just never transitioned out of COVID.

286
00:25:34,341 --> 00:25:34,821
They're like, okay.

287
00:25:34,901 --> 00:25:36,881
Everybody just was dressed the part.

288
00:25:37,441 --> 00:25:37,581
Yeah.

289
00:25:37,741 --> 00:25:39,181
But anyways, yeah, so you've got to.

290
00:25:39,261 --> 00:25:45,881
Yeah, so this is the problem with commodity money that led to fiat.

291
00:25:45,881 --> 00:25:53,241
So you had commodity money that got harder and harder and harder until it got so hard that it was too heavy to actually use.

292
00:25:53,341 --> 00:25:53,741
You couldn't.

293
00:25:54,061 --> 00:25:56,141
You can't really use gold day to day.

294
00:25:56,461 --> 00:25:58,261
It's too inconvenient.

295
00:25:58,881 --> 00:26:02,801
And so there was a natural consequence to that.

296
00:26:02,921 --> 00:26:09,561
If we can't use it, what we'll do is we'll put it all in one place and then we'll pass around something that is good as gold.

297
00:26:09,561 --> 00:26:13,201
And we'll say that you can do this because it's way more convenient.

298
00:26:13,481 --> 00:26:14,781
And that'll be faster.

299
00:26:14,981 --> 00:26:15,621
It'll be safer.

300
00:26:15,881 --> 00:26:16,681
It'll be cheaper.

301
00:26:16,841 --> 00:26:17,561
It'll be blah, blah, blah.

302
00:26:17,781 --> 00:26:23,121
But of course, it leaves open the possibility of a moral hazard.

303
00:26:23,121 --> 00:26:28,541
And the moral hazard is always that, hey, I have this much gold and that allows me to

304
00:26:28,541 --> 00:26:29,761
issue this many notes.

305
00:26:29,901 --> 00:26:33,641
I'm going to say that one note is one note, one ounce, and I have 10 ounces.

306
00:26:33,801 --> 00:26:34,861
So I issue 10 notes.

307
00:26:35,041 --> 00:26:40,081
And then, yeah, just like with fractional reserve banking, you're like, well, I mean,

308
00:26:40,181 --> 00:26:43,041
because that's all that's all that that's all that it is.

309
00:26:43,041 --> 00:26:49,881
It's just fractional reserve money where they're like, well, not everybody's going to ask for their gold back at the same time.

310
00:26:49,881 --> 00:26:53,521
So we can make another 10 notes and then we can make another.

311
00:26:54,141 --> 00:27:04,221
And then it's like the thing that I think escapes the imagination of most people is that because the human brain thinks linearly and it does not think exponentially,

312
00:27:04,221 --> 00:27:14,461
It is impossible to comprehend just how far beyond any sort of rationale that let's print some more has gone.

313
00:27:14,761 --> 00:27:21,381
Like, yeah, the idea, the idea of trillion, a trillion of anything is just you can't like a trillion.

314
00:27:21,781 --> 00:27:22,481
It's just a million.

315
00:27:22,761 --> 00:27:24,221
I mean, yeah, it's just everything.

316
00:27:24,981 --> 00:27:25,201
Right.

317
00:27:25,281 --> 00:27:28,601
I think it's like it's like a million dollars.

318
00:27:28,601 --> 00:27:34,901
somebody I hope will correct me, but I think like a million dollars is like 4.3 feet tall.

319
00:27:34,901 --> 00:27:41,101
If it's like a hundred dollar bills, a stack of a million, and a billion dollars is like a little

320
00:27:41,101 --> 00:27:47,401
longer than a football field. It's like 400 and some feet. And a trillion dollars is like to the

321
00:27:47,401 --> 00:27:54,061
moon. So like, there's the, there's this, like this idea of exponentiality that comes into play

322
00:27:54,061 --> 00:27:56,481
where you're like, oh, okay, a million dollars,

323
00:27:56,621 --> 00:27:59,021
it's up to my chest, I can get that.

324
00:27:59,021 --> 00:28:02,321
A billion dollars, it fits inside Bill Snyder Family Stadium,

325
00:28:02,321 --> 00:28:03,101
I can get that.

326
00:28:03,581 --> 00:28:04,841
But then going to the moon.

327
00:28:05,221 --> 00:28:08,801
Yeah, when a fiat currency moons, it's not a good thing.

328
00:28:09,081 --> 00:28:11,541
Like it's a reverse statement of value.

329
00:28:11,841 --> 00:28:14,821
No, literally the currency is going to the moon

330
00:28:14,821 --> 00:28:16,541
and the pile of it is that high.

331
00:28:17,341 --> 00:28:18,401
To the moon and back.

332
00:28:18,861 --> 00:28:18,981
Yeah.

333
00:28:19,981 --> 00:28:23,121
Not value, it's physically the substance of it.

334
00:28:23,121 --> 00:28:23,421
Yeah.

335
00:28:24,061 --> 00:28:27,321
I don't know yet. That's what I think about it, I guess.

336
00:28:27,321 --> 00:28:28,101
Back to you.

337
00:28:28,101 --> 00:28:42,382
I really like the my favorite parts in the essay are what you mentioned too I mean this is something I kind of I guess unconsciously or maybe consciously but not articulately acknowledged is that Bitcoin has its own transaction rails included

338
00:28:43,162 --> 00:28:49,182
And that this essay kind of reduces it, in my mind, to the hard physics of the situation.

339
00:28:50,302 --> 00:28:54,762
Rehypothecation, these really abstract Latin words, are tough for us to get our mind on.

340
00:28:54,882 --> 00:28:57,662
Orwell said, he has an essay, politics in English language.

341
00:28:57,662 --> 00:29:01,862
Don't use this type of word because no one's going to understand what the F you're saying.

342
00:29:01,962 --> 00:29:02,862
It's not good.

343
00:29:03,382 --> 00:29:04,742
You know, you use more concrete things.

344
00:29:05,802 --> 00:29:06,162
Rehypothecation.

345
00:29:06,402 --> 00:29:08,542
Something can't be in two places at the same time.

346
00:29:08,662 --> 00:29:09,242
It's simple.

347
00:29:09,402 --> 00:29:13,242
If you just think about it like that, like the physics of it, you can't have an apple

348
00:29:13,242 --> 00:29:15,242
in two places at the same time.

349
00:29:15,542 --> 00:29:17,202
You can't have your cake and eat it too.

350
00:29:17,502 --> 00:29:19,782
Like that's just the hard physics of reality.

351
00:29:20,802 --> 00:29:23,682
Rehypothecation, you know, violates physics in that way.

352
00:29:23,902 --> 00:29:25,322
Gold is a physical substance.

353
00:29:25,322 --> 00:29:27,342
It abides by the laws of physics.

354
00:29:27,342 --> 00:29:30,382
digital gold, Bitcoin, also

355
00:29:30,382 --> 00:29:31,962
is by the laws of physics.

356
00:29:32,502 --> 00:29:32,642
Exactly.

357
00:29:33,122 --> 00:29:35,002
This is just like a physical,

358
00:29:35,462 --> 00:29:36,502
a physics problem here

359
00:29:36,502 --> 00:29:37,202
or something like that.

360
00:29:37,642 --> 00:29:40,202
When you think about it in that way,

361
00:29:40,322 --> 00:29:41,562
rehypothecation, again,

362
00:29:41,982 --> 00:29:42,942
not as something abstract,

363
00:29:43,222 --> 00:29:44,162
but just something can't be

364
00:29:44,162 --> 00:29:45,622
in two places at the same time.

365
00:29:45,962 --> 00:29:47,682
Bitcoin also can't be

366
00:29:47,682 --> 00:29:49,342
in two places at the same time.

367
00:29:49,442 --> 00:29:51,402
It has a system built into it

368
00:29:51,402 --> 00:29:53,582
for verifying that that is the case

369
00:29:53,582 --> 00:29:57,002
and also has its own transaction rails

370
00:29:57,002 --> 00:30:04,582
built into that substance too so that it can move around again in a way that gold can't it is only

371
00:30:04,582 --> 00:30:09,422
the substance that can't be in two places same at the same time it is not also the means of moving

372
00:30:09,422 --> 00:30:16,142
that substance about which relies on human actors and there's that benefit from multiplying it

373
00:30:16,142 --> 00:30:23,142
through complex sounding words like rehypothecation you know you just rehypothecated it that's fine

374
00:30:23,142 --> 00:30:24,922
I know what you mean by that.

375
00:30:25,042 --> 00:30:26,482
Surely go ahead and do that banker.

376
00:30:26,642 --> 00:30:29,042
And then they do that thing and nobody knows what it means.

377
00:30:29,122 --> 00:30:34,102
It's like, you know, if you have some word to justify doing something, make it complex

378
00:30:34,102 --> 00:30:36,262
and abstract soundings that people don't understand.

379
00:30:36,382 --> 00:30:42,402
It's just, you know, making, trying to multiply something that can't be multiplied by creating

380
00:30:42,402 --> 00:30:44,022
a ghost version of it.

381
00:30:44,542 --> 00:30:47,802
But yeah, I really love just the vocabulary of this essay.

382
00:30:47,982 --> 00:30:53,022
We didn't talk necessarily about fiduciary media, just this idea of money substitutes.

383
00:30:53,142 --> 00:30:54,702
There are things that are money.

384
00:30:54,982 --> 00:30:59,682
There are things that we use as a substitute for money, these units in our bank account

385
00:30:59,682 --> 00:31:02,062
that we move around, but they're not money.

386
00:31:02,222 --> 00:31:02,682
No, they're not.

387
00:31:02,762 --> 00:31:07,602
They're just substitutes that we use as a type of liquidity to enable us to do transactions

388
00:31:07,602 --> 00:31:09,262
that might have a certain function.

389
00:31:09,582 --> 00:31:10,582
But again, they're not money.

390
00:31:10,722 --> 00:31:13,402
They're just things we use as substitutes for money.

391
00:31:14,222 --> 00:31:14,242
Yeah.

392
00:31:14,762 --> 00:31:21,422
So the Bitcoin blockchain is a ledger that is just an accounting of every Bitcoin.

393
00:31:21,742 --> 00:31:22,542
Where is it at?

394
00:31:22,542 --> 00:31:37,442
It's either in a wallet or it's hidden in time and it will come and be part of the Bitcoin blockchain at a certain time. And every eight to 10 minutes that gets validated and verified again with accuracy and precision.

395
00:31:37,442 --> 00:31:43,542
ones. So, you know, at any given time, you can know with absolute certainty where every single

396
00:31:43,542 --> 00:31:48,682
Bitcoin is. And it can only be in one place. It can only be in this wallet or that wallet,

397
00:31:48,682 --> 00:31:55,462
or it can be not yet issued, but waiting in the future. It can only be in those places.

398
00:31:55,702 --> 00:32:00,762
And we know that with absolute certainty. Like anyone who runs a node can verify that. And

399
00:32:00,762 --> 00:32:06,522
with a fiat network or even a gold network, like, I mean, gold's in a safe. Like,

400
00:32:06,522 --> 00:32:12,062
how do you know what's in the safe? Like you have to go look into the safe, you know, and like not,

401
00:32:12,222 --> 00:32:17,202
you're not going to go look into the safe every 10 minutes and go, Hey, it's still here. Here's

402
00:32:17,202 --> 00:32:21,422
how much it is. I just waited again. And with the bit, you know, with the fiat network, with the

403
00:32:21,422 --> 00:32:28,242
monetary network of dollars and, and yin and yang and a yuan. And I don't think there's a yang

404
00:32:28,242 --> 00:32:35,222
actually. I think I've made that one up. Then with that, you know, you, no one knows where any

405
00:32:35,222 --> 00:32:41,102
of the money is like, yeah, because it's really just genuinely not.

406
00:32:41,222 --> 00:32:43,542
It just genuinely does not exist.

407
00:32:43,542 --> 00:32:49,982
And yeah, we even acknowledge that, like you acknowledge that in, you know, like if there's

408
00:32:49,982 --> 00:32:56,562
a bankruptcy, there is an established order of creditors where it's like when a bank, what

409
00:32:56,562 --> 00:32:58,142
happens when a bankruptcy occurs?

410
00:32:58,222 --> 00:33:04,142
A bankruptcy occurs because someone has been able to somehow they have been able to owe

411
00:33:04,142 --> 00:33:12,502
more money than they have to pay it. And there are people who have multiple claims on the money

412
00:33:12,502 --> 00:33:20,062
that they do have. And bankruptcy filings show who gets to stand in line first, who's a preferred

413
00:33:20,062 --> 00:33:28,502
creditor and who's a common creditor. And it's such a common problem that we have a legal system

414
00:33:28,502 --> 00:33:36,002
built around telling people where they get to stand in line when inevitably it occurs that

415
00:33:36,002 --> 00:33:42,642
the money, which is supposed to be there, is not there. It's such an often occurrence that we have

416
00:33:42,642 --> 00:33:49,982
an entire branch of law dedicated to it. Yeah. But I don't think bankruptcy law goes away with

417
00:33:49,982 --> 00:33:54,542
Bitcoin. If you still have any sort of notion of credit that exists, you're still going to have

418
00:33:54,542 --> 00:34:00,342
people harder yeah i mean maybe it won't happen as much harder to like yeah i mean like when i was

419
00:34:00,342 --> 00:34:06,162
when i was banking like you would come to me and i would say can't give you a loan until you give

420
00:34:06,162 --> 00:34:11,942
me some financials and you would bring me three years of tax records and then you would make a

421
00:34:11,942 --> 00:34:17,502
balance sheet for me and that balance sheet would list your you know your accounts and how much was

422
00:34:17,502 --> 00:34:24,702
in them and it would list your your assets and how much they were worth as written by you yeah and

423
00:34:24,702 --> 00:34:31,202
little known fact like people don't check that shit like i mean yeah you don't call around like

424
00:34:31,202 --> 00:34:38,342
nobody calls around and verifies how much money is actually in that bank account nobody like you

425
00:34:38,342 --> 00:34:42,882
will do if it's a big enough thing you'll go and you'll do an appraisal but you don't do an appraisal

426
00:34:42,882 --> 00:34:44,902
because appraisals are expensive.

427
00:34:45,102 --> 00:34:47,382
Appraisals are expensive because they are a,

428
00:34:47,462 --> 00:34:50,122
they're an accreditation gated industry

429
00:34:50,122 --> 00:34:53,182
that exists solely to charge more money.

430
00:34:53,282 --> 00:34:56,922
Like you only do an appraisal if it's a big enough loan

431
00:34:56,922 --> 00:34:59,462
that you feel like you need to justify it.

432
00:34:59,662 --> 00:35:03,242
By the way, I bank, I lent money for five years.

433
00:35:03,402 --> 00:35:05,822
Only one time did I ever have an appraisal

434
00:35:05,822 --> 00:35:08,222
not come back where I wanted it to.

435
00:35:08,822 --> 00:35:09,342
Yeah.

436
00:35:09,742 --> 00:35:11,582
As far as like being high enough.

437
00:35:11,762 --> 00:35:12,082
Right.

438
00:35:12,082 --> 00:35:12,242
Right.

439
00:35:12,882 --> 00:35:18,942
And if it did come back and it wasn't high enough, I could always call the appraiser and I could be like, hey, I need more.

440
00:35:19,162 --> 00:35:22,042
And they would make it magically worth more.

441
00:35:22,422 --> 00:35:26,382
It's just like the when you watch the movie, The Big Short.

442
00:35:26,962 --> 00:35:27,202
Yeah.

443
00:35:27,202 --> 00:35:31,762
It's just like how the how the credit ratings agencies, there's two credit rating agencies.

444
00:35:32,182 --> 00:35:40,482
And if if you bring one credit rating agency, a bond and they want to rate it double A, you'll just say, well, screw you.

445
00:35:40,542 --> 00:35:41,382
I'll take it to the other guys.

446
00:35:41,382 --> 00:35:43,342
They'll rate it a triple A for the same price.

447
00:35:43,542 --> 00:35:45,042
And being an appraiser is just like that.

448
00:35:45,122 --> 00:35:47,122
I just wanted to go off on a rant about appraisers.

449
00:35:47,542 --> 00:35:54,682
There's a key part of this essay that I think this is getting into the theme of, which is the author is not anti-credit.

450
00:35:55,402 --> 00:36:09,742
And so, again, I left out of the summary his notion of how Bitcoin bills of exchange can be a short-term credit instrument that is going to economize transactions in a way that's good.

451
00:36:09,742 --> 00:36:12,462
because we, you know, Bitcoin doesn't have the throughput.

452
00:36:12,802 --> 00:36:14,722
We have like layer two solutions like lightning,

453
00:36:14,722 --> 00:36:17,662
but another solution could be credit instruments

454
00:36:17,662 --> 00:36:20,642
that just take place in the land of human interactions

455
00:36:20,642 --> 00:36:22,822
and legal solutions and paper and whatnot.

456
00:36:23,402 --> 00:36:24,602
And he thinks that that's viable.

457
00:36:24,882 --> 00:36:26,162
And so his notion is, again,

458
00:36:26,222 --> 00:36:28,102
one of the key themes of the essay is like,

459
00:36:28,262 --> 00:36:29,082
here are the problems,

460
00:36:29,202 --> 00:36:31,582
rehypothecation leading to fiduciary meeting,

461
00:36:31,722 --> 00:36:33,082
leading to boom bust cycles.

462
00:36:33,562 --> 00:36:36,222
How does Bitcoin allow for a form of credit

463
00:36:36,222 --> 00:36:38,402
that gets around these problems?

464
00:36:38,402 --> 00:36:41,442
When one is like the nature of it, it's more transparent.

465
00:36:41,642 --> 00:36:43,302
So it's going to resist rehypothecation.

466
00:36:43,442 --> 00:36:45,282
People are going to be more eyes open.

467
00:36:45,402 --> 00:36:46,462
It's more capture resistant.

468
00:36:46,662 --> 00:36:52,042
So it's not going to lead to state capture at the bus part of the cycle.

469
00:36:52,222 --> 00:36:54,122
It'd be more resistant to that, at least.

470
00:36:54,742 --> 00:37:01,982
And one part I wanted to add in my notes here, I wanted to get your take on is, you know, what is a Bitcoin bank going to look like?

471
00:37:01,982 --> 00:37:09,782
Like the author notes, like Bitcoin banks have like, they've been around since we've had exchanges selling Bitcoin, essentially.

472
00:37:09,782 --> 00:37:16,362
And the idea from the early days, like Hal Finney noted the potential of Bitcoin banks to scale Bitcoin adoption.

473
00:37:16,542 --> 00:37:21,902
So it's not something completely foreign or paper Bitcoin-y to say there might be Bitcoin banks.

474
00:37:22,242 --> 00:37:23,442
And he gives two models.

475
00:37:23,742 --> 00:37:28,962
One, the bank has its own ledger it uses to economize on uses of the base layer ledger.

476
00:37:28,962 --> 00:37:43,882
Quote, bank economizes on transaction using the Bitcoin base chain by creating accounts that hold database representations of the Bitcoin deposited by account holders and then registering transactions between accounts as database entries.

477
00:37:43,882 --> 00:37:58,442
I mean, it's like the oldest idea of like the old banker, you know, in pre-nation state Italy who just maintained the account of multiple merchants and did the internal ledger entries instead of making them all transact with each other.

478
00:37:58,442 --> 00:38:00,662
That's one, to maintain their own ledger.

479
00:38:01,182 --> 00:38:03,062
Or two, banks mint e-cash.

480
00:38:03,382 --> 00:38:15,022
Alternatively, a Bitcoin bank can take the form of an e-cash mint that issues money substitutes as tokens that can be cryptographically tied to the Bitcoin deposited in the mint.

481
00:38:15,022 --> 00:38:34,222
So what's your thoughts on Bitcoin? What a Bitcoin bank might look like? Or are these the thoughts of Bitcoin banks as maintaining their own ledger or Bitcoin banks as issuing their own currency, but it being cryptographically tied verifiably to Bitcoin e-cashment?

482
00:38:34,222 --> 00:38:56,942
Yeah, the mechanism of how they do it, I'm not sure what's going to work out best. The first way that you describe really just sounds like you're funding a lightning node where you're just going to say, here's X amount of Bitcoin and it's going to exist only within this node. It'll just be passed back and forth. It won't be broadcast to the system.

483
00:38:56,942 --> 00:39:05,662
The e-cash thing using where it would be linked to Bitcoin, that's kind of interesting.

484
00:39:05,842 --> 00:39:10,182
That makes a lot more sense and it would resist rehypothecation.

485
00:39:10,642 --> 00:39:17,502
It would be a way to have a effectively kind of like fiat thing on top of Bitcoin.

486
00:39:18,022 --> 00:39:21,642
And it goes back to your historical statement of like those wildcat banks.

487
00:39:22,522 --> 00:39:23,242
What's that?

488
00:39:23,242 --> 00:39:32,682
It goes back to your historical statement earlier that there used to be those independent banks that issued their own currencies, right? Now it's just they do it in a cryptographically verified way tied to Bitcoin.

489
00:39:32,682 --> 00:39:41,442
Yeah. Yeah. I just so I think that'll be tried and I think it'll fail. And I just think it'll fail because the.

490
00:39:42,962 --> 00:39:53,962
Mainly because of like Metcalfe's law. So like the the the the value of the network is it grows exponentially with the size of the network.

491
00:39:53,962 --> 00:40:22,622
And the size of the network is how many people will like accept that. And so I think it just makes a whole lot more sense to think about like a like a like a one protocol type of solution, like a like a lightning or a cashew type of solution on top of Bitcoin, as opposed to individual banks that would issue theirs that would then be like, oh, well, the bank of Grant has issued their e-cash and the bank of Lucas will accept that.

492
00:40:22,622 --> 00:40:27,102
but the bank of grant won't accept the bank of lucas is like it. And then, you know, like you

493
00:40:27,102 --> 00:40:33,922
got to do all this cost stuff and then you create basically a forex type of foreign exchange type of

494
00:40:33,922 --> 00:40:38,782
like there would be a trading market for those currencies where they would be traded against each

495
00:40:38,782 --> 00:40:43,262
other. That'd be interesting. Yeah. What I think actually most about though, it's not really so

496
00:40:43,262 --> 00:40:48,742
much about the mechanics of it. Like I said, I do think that it just moves to one protocol because

497
00:40:48,742 --> 00:40:52,962
it is more cost effective and there's more value in having a larger network.

498
00:40:53,581 --> 00:40:59,062
But what I find interesting to think about from the lending Bitcoin perspective is that

499
00:40:59,062 --> 00:41:00,562
the interest rate will.

500
00:41:01,042 --> 00:41:06,482
So the interest rate that we have now is just something that is set arbitrarily by people

501
00:41:06,482 --> 00:41:11,622
who are trying to make sure that the money keeps flowing, because if the money ever stops,

502
00:41:11,622 --> 00:41:13,622
then everything falls apart.

503
00:41:13,622 --> 00:41:29,002
Because if people decide to hold their money and save it and do that, then all of a sudden all of this lending collapses because there won't be interest to pay on the promises that have been made on money that's not there.

504
00:41:29,002 --> 00:41:39,742
If people, if the interest rate went to 20%, the economy would utterly collapse because everyone would just hang on to their money and they would wait for that interest to be paid.

505
00:41:39,942 --> 00:41:46,202
But there's not going to be any economic activity generating interest because nobody's going to be taking loans.

506
00:41:46,562 --> 00:41:52,822
What I find really fascinating to think about is as Bitcoin matures, it will become a unit of account.

507
00:41:52,822 --> 00:41:54,922
So it's a store of value, right?

508
00:41:55,142 --> 00:41:56,242
You put your value in it.

509
00:41:56,322 --> 00:41:57,202
It stays there.

510
00:41:57,302 --> 00:41:57,982
It doesn't leak.

511
00:41:57,982 --> 00:42:02,882
It doesn't leak because you can't inflate the amount of, but you can't change the supply.

512
00:42:03,142 --> 00:42:04,902
And so that's the store value.

513
00:42:05,062 --> 00:42:07,042
And then you've got the medium exchange.

514
00:42:07,042 --> 00:42:08,622
You can pass it between each other.

515
00:42:08,702 --> 00:42:09,062
That's cool.

516
00:42:09,262 --> 00:42:10,962
But it's also a unit of account.

517
00:42:11,081 --> 00:42:16,581
And it's not a unit of account yet because it's not, it's still, I would call it, I think

518
00:42:16,581 --> 00:42:18,102
we're out of the infancy stage.

519
00:42:18,142 --> 00:42:19,842
I think we're into the toddler stage.

520
00:42:19,882 --> 00:42:24,882
And I think, you know, next we'll be a child as it starts.

521
00:42:25,122 --> 00:42:27,642
But I still think we're, you know, it's very, very young.

522
00:42:27,642 --> 00:42:31,802
But anyways, as it matures,

523
00:42:31,802 --> 00:42:34,682
when it reaches its full saturation,

524
00:42:34,682 --> 00:42:39,802
kind of like when I as a human was 18 or whatever

525
00:42:39,802 --> 00:42:43,102
and I reached my full height and basically I was,

526
00:42:43,102 --> 00:42:44,442
my frame was built.

527
00:42:44,442 --> 00:42:46,182
So when Bitcoin's frame is built,

528
00:42:46,182 --> 00:42:59,002
it then becomes a standard by which we measure value much like the kilogram is how you measure weight or the meter is how you measure distance You can tell that I been on the other side of the world

529
00:42:59,002 --> 00:43:06,782
for far too long because I'm not using English units anymore. But the thing about standard is

530
00:43:06,782 --> 00:43:14,563
that it cannot change. If it changes, then it's useless. Like I can't be 183 centimeters tall

531
00:43:14,563 --> 00:43:21,002
this year, not grow, and then next year be 300 centimeters tall. But the money supply can

532
00:43:21,002 --> 00:43:27,063
definitely do that. Like the government will print that much more money. When you print money,

533
00:43:27,222 --> 00:43:33,382
when you add money to the supply, when you inflate the monetary supply, it loses its value as a unit

534
00:43:33,382 --> 00:43:39,242
of measure. It's like taking a meter stick and putting more marks on it. And all of a sudden,

535
00:43:39,242 --> 00:43:44,582
now you're 300 centimeters tall and then you're a billion centimeters tall and then you're 37

536
00:43:44,582 --> 00:43:50,922
trillion centimeters yeah you could almost imagine that and like in the orwellian book about like

537
00:43:50,922 --> 00:43:57,222
a state being concerned that height distributions are unequal and so they start inflating the height

538
00:43:57,222 --> 00:44:02,602
supply and making people taller and there's like like a lot of effect too like some people get

539
00:44:02,602 --> 00:44:07,942
taller first and they get taller faster yeah they get taller faster they get the new they get the

540
00:44:07,942 --> 00:44:12,262
their units first or something like that. That would be fascinating because if that was the case,

541
00:44:12,282 --> 00:44:17,662
then it would be so much more obvious who is, uh, who is part of the scam. Like right now,

542
00:44:17,662 --> 00:44:21,802
because people that are beneficiaries of the Cantillon effect, they walk around and nobody

543
00:44:21,802 --> 00:44:25,843
knows that they're the ones that are benefiting most from the money. You can't see their bank

544
00:44:25,843 --> 00:44:29,622
account. But if they're walking around, you're like, that dude's like 45 feet tall. Yesterday,

545
00:44:29,823 --> 00:44:34,362
he was like six feet tall. Now he's 45. Is he a governor at the Fed? Is he a senator?

546
00:44:34,362 --> 00:44:54,302
Right. Is that Nancy Pelosi's husband? But anyway, so to cap it off, what I think is really fascinating is that so all the money equals all the stuff, all the goods and services always equals all the money, regardless of how much money there is, because money is a unit of account that measures all of the goods and services.

547
00:44:54,302 --> 00:45:21,302
And so what are all the goods and services? All the goods and services are a representation of the time of people and the energy of people and technology. And so what you're going to see, I believe, is you will see an interest rate for Bitcoin that is a reflection and a barometer of the improvement that technology has upon society and humanity.

548
00:45:21,302 --> 00:45:29,523
whereby if we enter a state where kind of where we're thinking now with AI and robotics that

549
00:45:29,523 --> 00:45:39,262
will be, say, 20% more efficient on a compounded basis year over year for, say, 20 years,

550
00:45:39,262 --> 00:45:47,002
then you're going to see that reflected in the buying power of Bitcoin because it'll grow,

551
00:45:47,002 --> 00:45:53,982
but it'll also become the natural interest rate where I'm not going to loan you my Bitcoin unless

552
00:45:53,982 --> 00:46:01,962
you return more Bitcoin than I loaned you. And so that's the starter case. And then where we go from

553
00:46:01,962 --> 00:46:07,862
there is that you as the person who wants to borrow the Bitcoin, you're going to bid to pay me as low

554
00:46:07,862 --> 00:46:12,222
of an interest rate as possible. Me, I'm going to try to get you to pay the highest interest rate.

555
00:46:12,222 --> 00:46:28,582
Yeah, we'll meet somewhere. We'll meet somewhere, but we won't meet at four percent. We won't meet at three percent. We won't meet at six percent. We'll probably meet somewhere around the annual growth rate of Bitcoin, say 30 percent.

556
00:46:28,582 --> 00:46:58,122
And what that will do is that will mean that only people that are really serious and have a really good idea are going to go into business basically because it's going to keep, you know, there's going to be some moonshot guys that get lucky and figure out along the way that are going to get lost in the shuffle because they're never going to get a chance to compete if they're not taking cheap money out and just using it as a way to educate themselves by blowing it here.

557
00:46:58,122 --> 00:46:59,222
and then learning a lesson.

558
00:46:59,402 --> 00:46:59,642
Yeah.

559
00:47:00,502 --> 00:47:02,442
But yeah, I think it's really fascinating to think about.

560
00:47:02,442 --> 00:47:06,823
This is like that second and third order effect of things

561
00:47:06,823 --> 00:47:09,523
is that in order to return that much,

562
00:47:09,602 --> 00:47:11,802
you're actually legitimately going to have

563
00:47:11,802 --> 00:47:13,802
to create something of value.

564
00:47:14,782 --> 00:47:16,802
So it's not going to be Instagram.

565
00:47:18,543 --> 00:47:21,142
It's going to be teleportation.

566
00:47:21,422 --> 00:47:24,502
It's not going to be microwave food.

567
00:47:24,742 --> 00:47:27,482
It's going to be gene therapy, right?

568
00:47:27,482 --> 00:47:37,823
It's going to be something that is like massively impactful throughout all of humanity and is moving us in a more positive direction.

569
00:47:38,162 --> 00:47:39,942
Yeah, you just can't.

570
00:47:39,942 --> 00:47:41,862
Yeah, you know, positive direction.

571
00:47:42,202 --> 00:47:51,802
Yeah, I mean, that's one of the ideas of the boom-bust cycle is lead to the misallocation of capital because people, you know, they have infinite money and then they realize that the means of production are scarce.

572
00:47:51,802 --> 00:47:56,622
and then they scramble to invest in all these projects

573
00:47:56,622 --> 00:47:58,422
to put their money somewhere

574
00:47:58,422 --> 00:48:00,742
and then many of them are these ill-conceived ideas

575
00:48:00,742 --> 00:48:02,942
that are just misallocations of capital.

576
00:48:04,162 --> 00:48:08,063
When money is abundant, goods and services are scarce.

577
00:48:08,262 --> 00:48:10,922
When money is scarce, goods and services are abundant.

578
00:48:11,682 --> 00:48:15,823
Yeah, so that's a good summary there.

579
00:48:16,162 --> 00:48:16,823
I don't know, man.

580
00:48:16,823 --> 00:48:20,002
This essay was difficult for me, like I said,

581
00:48:20,002 --> 00:48:25,462
just because the abstraction of just the bare idea of credit.

582
00:48:25,602 --> 00:48:28,302
I'm such a simpleton that that is difficult for me.

583
00:48:28,702 --> 00:48:33,662
This essay, though, did a good idea of building that out,

584
00:48:34,162 --> 00:48:38,682
showing why it's necessary, showing how Bitcoin counteracts

585
00:48:38,682 --> 00:48:42,543
the worst aspects of credit issuance

586
00:48:42,543 --> 00:48:46,262
or what leads to kind of malevolent or malicious credit issuance

587
00:48:46,262 --> 00:48:48,823
like rehypothecation through sharing media.

588
00:48:48,823 --> 00:48:52,882
how Bitcoin inherently tends to resist those phenomena.

589
00:48:53,642 --> 00:48:56,063
And so I definitely added to my understanding

590
00:48:56,063 --> 00:48:58,043
of what Bitcoin is.

591
00:48:58,782 --> 00:49:00,802
You know, there's a lot of interesting stuff

592
00:49:00,802 --> 00:49:04,862
on Austrian economics that one could really geek out on

593
00:49:04,862 --> 00:49:07,422
if that was their thing that I kind of left out here.

594
00:49:07,582 --> 00:49:10,422
But even so, this essay really added a lot

595
00:49:10,422 --> 00:49:12,082
to my understanding and I appreciated it.

596
00:49:12,422 --> 00:49:14,582
Yeah, I want to make sure before we leave,

597
00:49:14,682 --> 00:49:18,182
like to throw out my understanding of credit.

598
00:49:18,182 --> 00:49:28,282
And like credit, just very simply, is that you are reaching into the future to pull wealth into the present because you want to make a bet.

599
00:49:28,682 --> 00:49:33,902
And the bet is equal to your the bet is the interest that you're paying.

600
00:49:34,082 --> 00:49:36,002
That's the size of the bet that you're making.

601
00:49:36,002 --> 00:49:37,922
and you're reaching into the future

602
00:49:37,922 --> 00:49:39,342
to pull wealth into the present,

603
00:49:39,662 --> 00:49:41,902
making a bet equal to the interest rate

604
00:49:41,902 --> 00:49:45,382
that at the point into the future will be worth,

605
00:49:45,543 --> 00:49:47,842
what you're doing with it now will be worth more

606
00:49:47,842 --> 00:49:49,402
than it is today.

607
00:49:49,523 --> 00:49:52,823
And on an individual basis, that works wonderfully

608
00:49:52,823 --> 00:49:54,823
because there is responsibility,

609
00:49:55,302 --> 00:49:57,302
because you're betting on your own future.

610
00:49:57,682 --> 00:50:00,382
I am, if I take a loan out to buy a house,

611
00:50:00,382 --> 00:50:04,982
then I am saying that I find more value today

612
00:50:04,982 --> 00:50:12,842
in having this house than I do in not having it. And I'm willing to work X amount and pay X amount

613
00:50:12,842 --> 00:50:19,982
in order to have that. What gets really dangerous and what Bitcoin disallows and makes effectively

614
00:50:19,982 --> 00:50:25,962
impossible is the situation that we have today, which is that governments reach into the future

615
00:50:25,962 --> 00:50:30,902
and they pull wealth from the future into the present, but it's not their wealth.

616
00:50:30,902 --> 00:50:36,502
governments don't have, there's no such thing as government money. It's the people's money,

617
00:50:36,782 --> 00:50:42,523
and it's the government taking it. And so when they are taking on debt, they are not doing it

618
00:50:42,523 --> 00:50:48,742
like the government should in an ideal situation, the government should exist as a symbiotic

619
00:50:48,742 --> 00:50:55,902
organism. It should be the little fish that swims through the shark's teeth, and it cleans the

620
00:50:55,902 --> 00:51:02,182
little stuff off of it. But what always happens because they can control the money is that they

621
00:51:02,182 --> 00:51:08,842
end up acting as a parasite and they end up being like a tick on the side or a barnacle and killing

622
00:51:08,842 --> 00:51:16,482
the host organism by sucking the life out of them. And by reaching into the future, pulling this

623
00:51:16,482 --> 00:51:21,222
wealth into the present, what they're doing is they are they're taking something that's not theirs.

624
00:51:21,362 --> 00:51:25,862
It's the people's wealth and it's the people's wealth into the future and it's the people's

625
00:51:25,862 --> 00:51:31,563
wealth into the future that they did not give permission for that is then being drug back into

626
00:51:31,563 --> 00:51:37,602
the present in order to feed this parasitical organism so that it can sustain itself while

627
00:51:37,602 --> 00:51:42,762
killing the host. And so I think, yeah, that's my, like my understanding of credit is like,

628
00:51:43,002 --> 00:51:47,023
you're reaching into the future, you're bringing it back into the present because you think that

629
00:51:47,023 --> 00:51:54,382
it's worth more today than it will be tomorrow. And that is absolutely the case with fiat money

630
00:51:54,382 --> 00:51:57,563
because fiat money becomes worth less over time

631
00:51:57,563 --> 00:51:59,502
because they issue more of it over time.

632
00:51:59,762 --> 00:52:01,922
But I think you're going to see that credit

633
00:52:01,922 --> 00:52:04,882
is going to become a much more reasonable,

634
00:52:06,742 --> 00:52:11,382
like you will not see credit at the levels that we have today

635
00:52:11,382 --> 00:52:14,942
because absolutely the money is not worth less in the future.

636
00:52:15,102 --> 00:52:16,123
It's worth more in the future.

637
00:52:16,382 --> 00:52:19,462
So why would you sacrifice your future for your present?

638
00:52:19,462 --> 00:52:23,182
Yeah, which is why everybody in Bitcoin gets in shape

639
00:52:23,182 --> 00:52:27,222
and talks about long time preference and all that low time preference.

640
00:52:27,222 --> 00:52:41,682
And I like in that definition to acknowledging part of the bad part about credit is like the state's usage of it in a policy manner to reach into the future to fund like policy goals or whatever ends they have now.

641
00:52:41,762 --> 00:52:45,302
That reminds me of one of the interesting phrases I like.

642
00:52:45,302 --> 00:52:53,722
This essay very near the beginning says that we're currently in an era of monetary policy and that Bitcoin is going to take us out of that.

643
00:52:53,802 --> 00:52:55,102
I thought that's really interesting.

644
00:52:55,682 --> 00:52:57,702
Like Bitcoin is beyond policy.

645
00:52:57,882 --> 00:53:05,563
Like policy is like a human plan for how a system should play out that we impose through law.

646
00:53:05,802 --> 00:53:07,523
So we have monetary policy.

647
00:53:07,642 --> 00:53:09,002
That's the policy of the Fed.

648
00:53:09,322 --> 00:53:12,162
That's the policy of each new incoming administration.

649
00:53:12,842 --> 00:53:17,602
Bitcoin, you know, has its own built in hard program policy.

650
00:53:17,602 --> 00:53:23,882
And we can have policies around that, like we can have policies around natural events and natural phenomena.

651
00:53:23,882 --> 00:53:27,563
But it's not the policy itself is not the money.

652
00:53:27,563 --> 00:53:36,043
And so we're going to exit the era of monetary policy, enter the era of monetary substance or physicality or reality or something like that.

653
00:53:36,342 --> 00:53:37,282
It's more of a reflection.

654
00:53:37,543 --> 00:53:41,882
Like, I mean, it'll be a reflection of how your policies are actually working.

655
00:53:42,162 --> 00:53:42,462
Yeah.

656
00:53:43,782 --> 00:53:48,802
You'll see that represented in your buying power, which you do today, I guess, to a certain extent.

657
00:53:49,063 --> 00:53:49,202
Yeah.

658
00:53:50,543 --> 00:53:51,222
I don't know.

659
00:53:51,362 --> 00:53:51,922
I dig it.

660
00:53:51,942 --> 00:53:52,262
Right on.

661
00:53:52,262 --> 00:53:52,882
Bitcoin credit.

662
00:53:53,362 --> 00:53:59,362
I think we're seeing, you know, the debt instruments that are currently being issued on Bitcoin by the Bitcoin treasury companies.

663
00:53:59,502 --> 00:53:59,682
Yeah.

664
00:53:59,942 --> 00:54:01,002
It's timely, definitely.

665
00:54:02,242 --> 00:54:02,442
Yeah.

666
00:54:02,442 --> 00:54:03,302
I've been trying to think.

667
00:54:03,442 --> 00:54:05,382
I don't know what you should call it.

668
00:54:05,442 --> 00:54:07,582
Like, it's not a speculative attack.

669
00:54:07,822 --> 00:54:10,442
Like, it would be a speculative attack if there was doubt.

670
00:54:10,442 --> 00:54:22,662
But since there's, it's like a, it's a certain, I maybe just call it a certain, but it's a, it's an attack with certainty on the global fiat system coordinated by the private sector.

671
00:54:22,822 --> 00:54:23,182
Yeah.

672
00:54:23,462 --> 00:54:30,822
Because like, I mean, why would you ever have, why would you ever have a 4% bond, 2% bond?

673
00:54:31,422 --> 00:54:34,322
Why would you ever buy a T-bill that pays you 3%?

674
00:54:34,502 --> 00:54:34,842
Yeah.

675
00:54:34,842 --> 00:54:39,242
If you could get a Bitcoin bill, that'll pay you nine.

676
00:54:39,582 --> 00:54:42,182
And if you want to, you can convert it into shares.

677
00:54:42,502 --> 00:54:44,322
Yeah, that's pretty funny.

678
00:54:44,543 --> 00:54:51,382
Like the Bitcoiner disagreement with the speculative attack is not the disagreement with the attack or the mechanics of it.

679
00:54:51,462 --> 00:54:52,762
It's the use of the word speculative.

680
00:54:56,282 --> 00:55:00,302
I've been struggling with this for a week, trying to figure out what is the proper word.

681
00:55:00,302 --> 00:55:01,422
What do you mean by speculative?

682
00:55:01,422 --> 00:55:04,822
I mean, I keep telling this.

683
00:55:04,842 --> 00:55:07,882
So, yeah, 4,000 government currencies have existed.

684
00:55:08,082 --> 00:55:10,142
3,840 of them are gone.

685
00:55:10,302 --> 00:55:12,642
160 of them are down 99%.

686
00:55:12,642 --> 00:55:14,023
Where's the doubt?

687
00:55:14,543 --> 00:55:16,242
Why would anyone doubt this?

688
00:55:16,822 --> 00:55:16,942
Yeah.

689
00:55:17,202 --> 00:55:19,063
Grant, I think you crushed it today.

690
00:55:19,282 --> 00:55:20,502
I think you crushed it today, Lucas.

691
00:55:20,502 --> 00:55:26,942
I think there is an alluring red tint to your hair that's coming off of wherever we're at.

692
00:55:27,023 --> 00:55:27,782
I'm not quite sure.

693
00:55:28,642 --> 00:55:32,043
It's looking Auburn-esque, a bit sandy as well.

694
00:55:32,043 --> 00:55:36,922
Yeah, that's my recording studio is like harsh fluorescent light or something like that.

695
00:55:37,023 --> 00:55:39,462
We do it very professionally here is how we do this thing.

696
00:55:39,802 --> 00:55:40,582
Good, good.

697
00:55:40,582 --> 00:55:41,502
Make ourselves look good.

698
00:55:42,342 --> 00:55:44,063
You're looking awfully red today.

699
00:55:44,362 --> 00:55:48,082
Like, yeah, that's our standards of podcasting and videocasting is like.

700
00:55:48,962 --> 00:55:50,182
I've got a cool hat.

701
00:55:50,462 --> 00:55:51,023
There we go.

702
00:55:52,642 --> 00:55:58,942
The mustache is looking very highway trooper slash almost pedophilia.

703
00:55:58,942 --> 00:56:00,063
I was going to say, don't go there.

704
00:56:00,182 --> 00:56:01,302
Let's stop a highway trooper.

705
00:56:01,302 --> 00:56:04,222
That's more of the, I mean, in this stage,

706
00:56:04,682 --> 00:56:09,882
and any mustache is obviously aspirational to that one character in Sicario

707
00:56:09,882 --> 00:56:10,922
who had the mustache.

708
00:56:11,402 --> 00:56:14,082
I forget his name, but he's like, I mean, you watch it, you know.

709
00:56:14,602 --> 00:56:17,902
It's, wait, it's not Josh Brolin's character.

710
00:56:18,162 --> 00:56:18,642
No, it's not his character.

711
00:56:19,242 --> 00:56:24,082
It's his friend or whatever, his other guy who's in the special forces.

712
00:56:24,082 --> 00:56:29,342
Yeah, it's the guy from the show White Collar, Donovan, something Donovan.

713
00:56:29,402 --> 00:56:29,882
Yeah, that's it.

714
00:56:30,023 --> 00:56:30,642
Jeffrey Donovan.

715
00:56:30,642 --> 00:56:37,023
yeah Jeffrey Donovan yeah so yeah I like it you're way more buff than him well he's got the

716
00:56:37,023 --> 00:56:42,282
operator frame the operator frame is leaner because you don't need like hypertrophy is bad

717
00:56:42,282 --> 00:56:47,582
for the operator um that's the point that Pavel Tatsuli makes in his like kettlebell manifesto

718
00:56:47,582 --> 00:56:53,502
and like you know the operator is not someone who needs mass they need like ability to operate

719
00:56:53,502 --> 00:56:55,362
so yeah

720
00:56:55,362 --> 00:56:55,862
nice

721
00:56:55,862 --> 00:56:58,182
well what do you say

722
00:56:58,182 --> 00:56:59,262
we put a bow on this one

723
00:56:59,262 --> 00:57:00,002
I think we did it

724
00:57:00,002 --> 00:57:01,482
you ended up with a cowboy hat on

725
00:57:01,482 --> 00:57:02,242
and I ended up

726
00:57:02,242 --> 00:57:03,802
just basked in red light

727
00:57:03,802 --> 00:57:04,623
for whatever reason

728
00:57:04,623 --> 00:57:05,402
so we did okay

729
00:57:05,402 --> 00:57:06,462
great place to be

730
00:57:06,462 --> 00:57:07,123
we'll do it again

731
00:57:07,123 --> 00:57:07,722
alright man