1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:06,400
If I could hope for

2
00:00:06,400 --> 00:00:09,400
But one thing for you

3
00:00:09,400 --> 00:00:12,980
So you'd be curious

4
00:00:12,980 --> 00:00:16,000
In all that you do

5
00:00:16,000 --> 00:00:19,360
Cause love like a flower

6
00:00:19,360 --> 00:00:23,060
Just wants to grow

7
00:00:23,060 --> 00:00:26,760
Oh, and knowledge like your heart

8
00:00:26,760 --> 00:00:30,500
Just wants to be known

9
00:00:30,500 --> 00:00:34,520
If you like, please subscribe.

10
00:00:34,980 --> 00:00:36,960
This is Bitcoin Study Sessions.

11
00:00:38,480 --> 00:00:39,000
Hello.

12
00:00:39,240 --> 00:00:43,480
So today Lucas and I are going to continue our discussion of Lynn Alden's broken money,

13
00:00:43,760 --> 00:00:47,060
why our financial system is failing us, and how we can make it better.

14
00:00:47,160 --> 00:00:50,300
These circuits down here like the picture as how things fail.

15
00:00:50,420 --> 00:00:51,360
They disassociate.

16
00:00:51,420 --> 00:00:52,000
They come apart.

17
00:00:52,380 --> 00:00:54,440
And today we're going to begin to retie them.

18
00:00:54,440 --> 00:01:00,680
Part five of the book is Internet Native Money, which is chapters 20 through 27 of the book.

19
00:01:01,260 --> 00:01:07,420
And so up till now, Alden has been unpacking the failures of the financial system.

20
00:01:07,420 --> 00:01:13,580
And today we're going to get into the realm of solutions or future technology that's going to change things at least.

21
00:01:13,580 --> 00:01:26,500
So as usual, let's begin with a short summary, I hope short, it'll be long, of where the book has started, where we've gone, where it's taken us, and what we're going to talk about today.

22
00:01:26,740 --> 00:01:30,960
I really hope that we can put today's conversation into the context of the book.

23
00:01:30,960 --> 00:01:45,640
So in parts one through four of the book, Alden explores the nature of money and how that nature led to the development of our current monetary system and the ways that our current monetary system is broken.

24
00:01:45,640 --> 00:02:09,640
So the essential nature of money, brass tacks at the bottom, is not as a specific substance like gold or not as something like credit or reciprocal exchange of favors. Rather, money is a ledger, a way to record transactions among individuals. Money is the accounting system through which individuals record transfer of value and store up value to later be exchanged with others.

25
00:02:09,640 --> 00:02:19,540
Alden describes how historically we did initially settle on gold as that ledger that is money primarily because of its characteristic of scarcity.

26
00:02:20,160 --> 00:02:25,500
However, once mankind then later progresses technologically, we invent telecommunications,

27
00:02:25,680 --> 00:02:28,780
the ability to send information at near the speed of light.

28
00:02:29,320 --> 00:02:31,300
Technology disrupts, and this was disruptive.

29
00:02:31,960 --> 00:02:37,280
Gold did not move quickly enough to keep up with the speed at which we were now able to

30
00:02:37,280 --> 00:02:40,680
make transactions nationally, internationally.

31
00:02:41,500 --> 00:02:47,520
So as a result of that, as a result of gold's technological failure to keep up with telecommunications,

32
00:02:48,120 --> 00:02:54,040
modern banking develops as a way to abstract gold, turn it into credit, allow claims for gold to be

33
00:02:54,040 --> 00:03:00,080
transmitted instead of having to transport and authenticate that underlying difficult to move,

34
00:03:00,220 --> 00:03:04,780
difficult to authenticate substance. So before long, gold then just drops out of the loop

35
00:03:04,780 --> 00:03:11,240
altogether. This marks the rise of our current fiat-based monetary order where currency is not

36
00:03:11,240 --> 00:03:17,380
backed by anything. Turtles all the way down or a hole with no bottom. The U.S. dollar then

37
00:03:17,380 --> 00:03:23,200
becomes the fiat currency that serves as the global reserve asset. It is the global unit of

38
00:03:23,200 --> 00:03:28,660
account for important assets, most notably oil from the Middle East. In the petrodollar system,

39
00:03:28,780 --> 00:03:33,320
countries then need to stack dollars in the form of treasuries to ensure access to oil because

40
00:03:33,320 --> 00:03:37,340
that's what the countries, specifically Saudi Arabia and the Middle East, are requiring.

41
00:03:38,340 --> 00:03:46,480
But Alden continues the story. The fiat-based ledger that is indicative of our new financial

42
00:03:46,480 --> 00:03:52,560
order is flexible, it's subject to considerable entropy, and that it allows money creation on

43
00:03:52,560 --> 00:03:58,560
demand. Fiat money is just paper, you can print it, it's just electronic entries in the central

44
00:03:58,560 --> 00:04:03,120
bank, you can just change the entry. This naturally leads to abuse. So the modern financial system

45
00:04:03,120 --> 00:04:11,360
operates in short term business cycles of boom and bust, where lending is encouraged through low

46
00:04:11,360 --> 00:04:16,200
interest rates, leading to increasingly risky lending and over leveraging, which then leads to

47
00:04:16,200 --> 00:04:21,720
the central bank trying to restrain people by raising interest rates, which then leads to a

48
00:04:21,720 --> 00:04:26,200
contraction of the economy and then wide-scale default where the government then jumps in.

49
00:04:26,700 --> 00:04:31,420
And then as we saw in 2008 and other times, selectively bails out the well-connected,

50
00:04:31,860 --> 00:04:36,980
shifts liabilities from the private to the public ledger, and leverage never clears.

51
00:04:36,980 --> 00:04:42,320
And then a new cycle begins. From these short-term business cycles where leverage

52
00:04:42,320 --> 00:04:48,360
never fully clears, they then build up over time into a long-term debt cycle where the end result

53
00:04:48,360 --> 00:04:55,080
is either massive default or massive money creation. And we know that, as it turns out,

54
00:04:55,160 --> 00:05:00,220
it's always going to be massive money creation is what the state's going to do, which is going to

55
00:05:00,220 --> 00:05:07,940
lead long-term all the notes into an inflationary debt spiral as people try to exit the burning house

56
00:05:07,940 --> 00:05:14,660
that is the flexible fiat ledger, by using their fiat, by borrowing more fiat, in fact, to buy hard

57
00:05:14,660 --> 00:05:21,620
assets, then the government historically has responded with capital controls to try to trap

58
00:05:21,620 --> 00:05:28,160
people into the burning house of the fiat ledger as the system defaults on all of its debt through

59
00:05:28,160 --> 00:05:33,720
massive inflation. At the end of part four, Alden summarizes the story of the entropy and decline

60
00:05:33,720 --> 00:05:39,100
of the fiat ledger, describes it as inevitable based on gold's insufficiency as a reserve asset

61
00:05:39,100 --> 00:05:46,540
in an age of speed. So just to get us to part five, I'm going to read what Alden says, because

62
00:05:46,540 --> 00:05:50,540
I think this is really good at summarizing everything and laying the problem down that's

63
00:05:50,540 --> 00:05:55,080
going to, from which chapter five is going to grow. Alden writes, so basically this whole

64
00:05:55,080 --> 00:06:00,860
spiraling debt cycle is empowered by the fact, Alden writes, that the invention of telecommunication

65
00:06:00,860 --> 00:06:06,460
systems allowed commerce to occur at the speed of light, while any sort of hard money could still

66
00:06:06,460 --> 00:06:11,680
only settle at the speed of matter. Gold, despite being of sounder supply than the fiat dollar,

67
00:06:12,020 --> 00:06:16,740
takes considerable time and expense to transport and authenticate, and this could never really

68
00:06:16,740 --> 00:06:22,320
present an alternative to the digital era. Once the fiat dollar came into being, those who manage

69
00:06:22,320 --> 00:06:29,260
it were able to discard gold as a supply constraint without much pushback and use the flexibility of

70
00:06:29,260 --> 00:06:36,100
their ledger to opaquely finance war, entitlements, and all sorts of things in ways that don't add up

71
00:06:36,100 --> 00:06:42,520
in the long run. It was the first time where weaker money globally won out over harder money,

72
00:06:42,520 --> 00:06:47,020
and it occurred because a new variable was added to the monetary competition.

73
00:06:47,520 --> 00:06:53,280
Speed. The speed gap between commerce and settlements empowered banks and central banks

74
00:06:53,280 --> 00:06:57,980
and created an irresistible arbitrage that the whole world turned to,

75
00:06:58,380 --> 00:07:04,160
which led to a greater level of centralization for the public ledger than ever before.

76
00:07:04,460 --> 00:07:08,240
This brings us to part five that we're going to talk about today, internet native money.

77
00:07:08,820 --> 00:07:11,340
Before Lucas and I go on to parse this out in conversation,

78
00:07:11,900 --> 00:07:16,580
I'll give a brief summary of this section to get everybody up to date in case you haven't read.

79
00:07:17,180 --> 00:07:19,800
So the thesis generally, the section would be something like,

80
00:07:19,800 --> 00:07:23,140
as Alden stated earlier in the book, where the thesis overall of the book is,

81
00:07:23,280 --> 00:07:30,760
regards the evolution of technology changes in the prevailing power structures and the incentives

82
00:07:30,760 --> 00:07:35,840
surrounding money from era to era. So this part of the book is about new tech for this era,

83
00:07:35,940 --> 00:07:41,000
the internet era. And the next part of the book, we're going to get to next conversation,

84
00:07:41,180 --> 00:07:44,200
is going to be more about the changes to the prevailing power structures. So

85
00:07:44,200 --> 00:07:49,940
Alden begins this part with a quote from Hayek, which many people are familiar with,

86
00:07:49,940 --> 00:07:52,100
but I think it's a great quote and it bears reading.

87
00:07:52,740 --> 00:07:53,340
Hayek said,

88
00:07:53,460 --> 00:07:56,020
I don't believe that we shall ever have a good money again

89
00:07:56,020 --> 00:07:59,240
before we take the thing out of the hands of the government.

90
00:07:59,840 --> 00:08:02,800
Since we can't take them violently out of the hands of the government,

91
00:08:02,800 --> 00:08:07,300
all we can do is by some sly roundabout way

92
00:08:07,300 --> 00:08:09,980
and do something they can't stop.

93
00:08:10,220 --> 00:08:12,300
So how do we get stateless money?

94
00:08:12,480 --> 00:08:14,680
How do we get money out of the hands of the government?

95
00:08:15,100 --> 00:08:19,340
Alden begins noting that we now have kind of the nexus of the internet

96
00:08:19,340 --> 00:08:21,100
and advances in cryptography.

97
00:08:21,860 --> 00:08:25,180
HTTP and Internet Protocol, all the notes,

98
00:08:25,780 --> 00:08:30,780
initially had in it a, we all know, 404, like page not found.

99
00:08:30,880 --> 00:08:33,680
There was a 402 error as well for payment required.

100
00:08:33,680 --> 00:08:39,340
So the internet presupposed that there would be a payment layer native to it.

101
00:08:40,020 --> 00:08:42,420
Some early attempts were Digicash and eGold,

102
00:08:42,700 --> 00:08:45,440
but all the notes, they were too centralized.

103
00:08:45,440 --> 00:08:52,440
E-Gold in particular was in legal trouble after 9-11 under the Patriot Act and so shut down in 2009.

104
00:08:53,680 --> 00:09:05,640
Meanwhile, 2008, Satoshi Nakamoto releases the Bitcoin white paper and defends it, all the notes, in sort of the manner of a dissertation defense via email with cryptographers.

105
00:09:05,640 --> 00:09:17,440
Satoshi notes that the benefits of digital signatures, all this ability to cryptographically verify transactions, is lost if you have to trust a third party at the end of the day.

106
00:09:18,100 --> 00:09:26,500
So he also notes that he or she that decentralized protocols have survived, whereas centralized systems like Eagle have not.

107
00:09:26,580 --> 00:09:29,140
We still have Tor and other peer-to-peer networks.

108
00:09:29,960 --> 00:09:36,440
So what then makes Bitcoin different than these other early efforts at an internet native money?

109
00:09:36,720 --> 00:09:38,380
It's a distributed public ledger.

110
00:09:38,820 --> 00:09:40,860
Alden has a really beautiful way of describing it.

111
00:09:41,040 --> 00:09:45,120
She notes that some people have referred to it as triple entry bookkeeping.

112
00:09:45,120 --> 00:09:51,160
So you can look at it as three columns, debit, sending Bitcoin, credit, receiving Bitcoin,

113
00:09:51,160 --> 00:10:00,600
And then a third column noting the cryptographically signed record on the shared ledger that notes that it's cryptographically secure.

114
00:10:01,200 --> 00:10:05,960
So participants in the Bitcoin system, I'll give a brief overview of it.

115
00:10:06,140 --> 00:10:10,760
I mean, just in case you do come to this completely without knowledge, but we won't go too in depth.

116
00:10:11,200 --> 00:10:14,420
Participants come to a consensus every 10 minutes in the network.

117
00:10:14,420 --> 00:10:21,400
Anyone can maintain the ledger and enforce rules of the network by operating a node.

118
00:10:21,900 --> 00:10:24,000
So you have people who operate nodes and enforce the rules.

119
00:10:24,260 --> 00:10:28,980
Anyone can earn more Bitcoin by processing transactions by operating a miner.

120
00:10:29,500 --> 00:10:35,120
And anyone can use the network by generating their own keys without a custodian and being simply a user.

121
00:10:35,840 --> 00:10:43,680
So these three parties then eliminate the need for trust in the way that they establish a decentralized distributed public ledger.

122
00:10:43,680 --> 00:10:46,740
They don't need a third party to maintain that ledger.

123
00:10:47,880 --> 00:10:54,780
This closes Bitcoin is then going to close the speed gap in a decentralized way that does not rely on abstraction.

124
00:10:55,420 --> 00:11:06,720
To quote Alden, the invention of Bitcoin as an open source, fast settlement network with its own scarce units provides the first credible way to close that gap between transaction and settlement speeds.

125
00:11:06,720 --> 00:11:14,280
And now it's a matter of researching it and testing it to see if it's robust enough to serve that purpose at a large scale for the long run.

126
00:11:15,060 --> 00:11:18,080
So how does Bitcoin work in a little bit more detail?

127
00:11:18,400 --> 00:11:29,660
So those miners use the processing power to solve a cryptographic puzzle by guessing, using expending energy to do computations to make a guess to answer that puzzle.

128
00:11:29,660 --> 00:11:42,820
Whoever solves the puzzle gets to then take the pending transactions and then process them by placing them in a block and then adding that block of transactions on top of the last block of transactions.

129
00:11:43,600 --> 00:11:52,340
The nodes then ensure that this block that has been compiled of transaction follows the rules of the Bitcoin protocol and is therefore valid.

130
00:11:52,340 --> 00:12:06,440
The miner who solved that block, compiled those transactions, receives a reward of newly minted Bitcoin and then any transaction fees that the parties paid in order to get their transactions prioritized.

131
00:12:07,040 --> 00:12:21,500
The amount of new Bitcoin received follows an emission schedule, which is halving every four years until we kind of asymptotically approach 21 million, which is the hard capped limit of Bitcoin that will ever be available.

132
00:12:22,060 --> 00:12:38,420
Each block that is then solved of transactions added onto the next block in the blockchain contains the cryptographic puzzle, which miners then have to solve in order to add the next block of transactions, repeating that process again about every 10 minutes.

133
00:12:38,800 --> 00:12:41,320
The history of all blocks is in the state of the ledger.

134
00:12:42,240 --> 00:12:45,700
So that's generally how it functions.

135
00:12:46,000 --> 00:12:47,560
Bitcoin is open source protocol.

136
00:12:47,860 --> 00:12:49,120
It can be updated.

137
00:12:49,120 --> 00:12:58,100
Another kind of party, along with node operators, miners, and users, are developers who can propose updates but cannot force people to accept them.

138
00:12:58,740 --> 00:13:03,980
There can be soft forks that are backwards compatible changes that narrow the rule set.

139
00:13:04,080 --> 00:13:11,960
For example, if the block size was made smaller, if the number of transactions every 10 minutes was made smaller, that's a narrowing of the rule set.

140
00:13:12,060 --> 00:13:14,420
And that could be done in a backwards compatible way.

141
00:13:14,840 --> 00:13:17,860
There's also hard forks that are not backwards compatible.

142
00:13:17,860 --> 00:13:45,800
These are changes to the consensus rules. For example, if the block size increased, this would require a hard fork. These hard forks tend to, you know, you have to really have the support of all the nodes and all the parties within the Bitcoin ecosystem. The largest hard fork that ever occurred is now only 0.5% of the market cap of Bitcoin. These are things like Bitcoin Cash and all these other things that are not Bitcoin now.

143
00:13:46,600 --> 00:13:47,740
Who controls the ledger?

144
00:13:47,740 --> 00:13:58,340
This is a question that Alden recurrently asks because, again, her idea is that money is a ledger.

145
00:13:58,680 --> 00:14:00,380
So who controls the ledger that is Bitcoin?

146
00:14:01,160 --> 00:14:02,860
It's a distributed public ledger.

147
00:14:03,000 --> 00:14:05,080
Again, no one party controls it.

148
00:14:05,100 --> 00:14:07,340
You have an ecosystem that manages it.

149
00:14:07,420 --> 00:14:11,340
You have nodes that maintain a copy and enforce the rules for adding new blocks.

150
00:14:11,340 --> 00:14:19,000
You have miners that use energy-heavy computation to solve these puzzles and add new transactions.

151
00:14:19,540 --> 00:14:23,800
And you have developers who propose updates but cannot push them on people, cannot force them.

152
00:14:24,920 --> 00:14:27,300
Bitcoin, then, is different than a central bank.

153
00:14:27,500 --> 00:14:28,600
It can't be debased.

154
00:14:28,700 --> 00:14:30,640
It's hard-capped to 21 million coins.

155
00:14:31,180 --> 00:14:40,180
You can't seize or confiscate it in that it's secured by cryptography with each user holding their own unbreakable code essentially in their hands.

156
00:14:40,180 --> 00:14:51,600
It's also transparent that you can see and verify the entire state of the ledger, read all aspects of the open source code for yourself, and it's secured by real world resources, miners expending energy.

157
00:14:52,400 --> 00:14:55,760
So Alden then discusses Bitcoin's path to monetization.

158
00:14:55,920 --> 00:14:59,840
We have this new technology that needs to monetize to become money.

159
00:15:00,720 --> 00:15:04,400
So the first Bitcoin adopters were early tech enthusiasts.

160
00:15:04,840 --> 00:15:06,220
It's complicated, hard to use.

161
00:15:06,340 --> 00:15:09,060
Essentially, you might consider it a digital collectible, she said.

162
00:15:09,060 --> 00:15:15,500
Then in 2010, it begins to have a quotable price, exchanges develop, and we move on from there.

163
00:15:17,320 --> 00:15:21,620
Alden, this is a question people often ask, what is the utility of Bitcoin?

164
00:15:22,620 --> 00:15:26,180
Alden describes the utility of Bitcoin through an interesting thought experiment.

165
00:15:26,380 --> 00:15:37,040
So imagine if gold was just this boring, dull substance, didn't look good for jewelry, and it wasn't useful for electronics or whatever, other application it currently has.

166
00:15:37,560 --> 00:15:41,160
But what if it had the property that you could transport it through a wire?

167
00:15:41,960 --> 00:15:48,860
So that's the utility of Bitcoin, that ability to be sent anywhere through a wire, to be scarce

168
00:15:48,860 --> 00:15:52,840
and hard capped and to be transmissible at near the speed of light.

169
00:15:52,840 --> 00:15:58,120
To quote Alden, when you hold Bitcoin, especially in self-custody, what you are holding is the

170
00:15:58,120 --> 00:16:04,100
stored up ability to perform global payments that are hard to block, as well as the stored

171
00:16:04,100 --> 00:16:10,020
up ability to transfer your value globally if you want to or need to. You are holding your slot

172
00:16:10,020 --> 00:16:20,580
on a global ledger. So all the notes that this utility is actually already being harnessed,

173
00:16:20,680 --> 00:16:26,140
despite what skeptics say. If you don't see it, check your financial privilege. See how other

174
00:16:26,140 --> 00:16:30,600
people in the world who don't have access to the U.S. banking system are currently using it.

175
00:16:30,600 --> 00:16:34,880
It's used by people who are fleeing countries as refugees.

176
00:16:34,880 --> 00:16:36,780
They can bring all their wealth with them.

177
00:16:37,120 --> 00:16:40,760
It's used by people who are political dissidents cut off from the banking system.

178
00:16:40,760 --> 00:16:51,400
Julian Assange, when WikiLeaks began accepting Bitcoin, the late Alexei Navalny, a Putin opponent, who used Bitcoin after Putin cut him off of the Russian banking system.

179
00:16:51,400 --> 00:17:08,640
Alden also notes Roya Maboub, an entrepreneur in Afghanistan who paid her employees in Bitcoin, who were all female employees, so that they could protect their own wealth from the patriarchal system that would have allowed their male relatives to control it.

180
00:17:09,620 --> 00:17:17,000
So Bitcoin already has utility, is already being used in a way that justifies and demonstrates that utility.

181
00:17:17,480 --> 00:17:20,340
Money, though, is a different type of tech as far as adoption.

182
00:17:20,540 --> 00:17:23,420
It's not like a washing machine with a smooth adoption curve.

183
00:17:24,000 --> 00:17:27,140
In fact, all the notes can't be adopted too quickly.

184
00:17:27,140 --> 00:17:32,440
That would cause the price to skyrocket, which then entices leverage, which leads to a bubble,

185
00:17:32,760 --> 00:17:38,020
which then causes the bubble to burst and then people to be demoralized and then sell all their Bitcoin.

186
00:17:38,360 --> 00:17:39,260
We've seen this in the past.

187
00:17:39,320 --> 00:17:45,780
These bubbles develop, and that all then kind of indicates the natural cycle for adoption of a new monetary technology.

188
00:17:47,000 --> 00:17:56,120
interestingly she says we can also describe adoption in two stages for hard money with

189
00:17:56,120 --> 00:18:01,320
reference to two economic laws gresham's law and tears law gresham's law is the first stage

190
00:18:01,320 --> 00:18:07,080
bad money within the framework of gresham's law bad money and good money both exist in the system

191
00:18:07,080 --> 00:18:12,800
people begin though to save the good money and then to use the bad money because they want to

192
00:18:12,800 --> 00:18:17,600
get rid of it. The bad money then circulates fast, use it with all the merchants you pay,

193
00:18:17,920 --> 00:18:22,040
while the good money is hoarded. That's tended to happen on a bimetallic system with silver and

194
00:18:22,040 --> 00:18:28,960
gold, hoarding of gold, use of silver. Tiers Law is the second stage. Now, good money drives out

195
00:18:28,960 --> 00:18:33,420
the bad money. People want to use the bad money to get rid of it if they still have it, but now

196
00:18:33,420 --> 00:18:37,620
merchants and others insist on receiving the good money and no one accepts the bad money.

197
00:18:38,420 --> 00:18:40,020
So we're at Gresham's last stage.

198
00:18:41,180 --> 00:18:42,400
Bad money circulates.

199
00:18:42,460 --> 00:18:44,240
People hoard Bitcoin for the most part.

200
00:18:47,600 --> 00:18:50,900
Alden doesn't just talk about Bitcoin in this chapter.

201
00:18:51,040 --> 00:18:56,180
She talks about kind of broadly speaking other cryptocurrencies, and then we'll see later on stablecoins and CBDCs.

202
00:18:56,740 --> 00:19:02,020
What are the tradeoffs that Bitcoin has and other cryptos have in relation to Bitcoin?

203
00:19:02,020 --> 00:19:14,300
um adam back uh noted an early cryptographer um that bitcoin exists in a small design space

204
00:19:14,300 --> 00:19:19,260
where things that would seem to improve it actually have trade-offs that make bitcoin

205
00:19:19,260 --> 00:19:26,020
overall worse in other ways for example the block size and speed if you increase the block size you

206
00:19:26,020 --> 00:19:29,920
You can add more transactions, do more throughput, process more transactions.

207
00:19:30,540 --> 00:19:36,880
But if you increase the block size or speed, then the technical requirements of the systems are greater.

208
00:19:37,020 --> 00:19:44,880
It makes it more difficult and costly to operate a node, which in these node operators, remember, are the rule enforcers of the network.

209
00:19:44,880 --> 00:19:51,480
That tends, if you have fewer node operators, that decentralizes the network, makes it less secure.

210
00:19:52,180 --> 00:19:54,140
Another tradeoff, privacy and transparency.

211
00:19:54,140 --> 00:20:08,420
You could design a more private cryptocurrency, but the transparency of Bitcoin allows the base layer to be audited, make sure that there's no inflation bugs, and to allow everybody to see with their own eyes the current state of the ledger.

212
00:20:09,020 --> 00:20:11,020
Code expressivity is another tradeoff.

213
00:20:11,460 --> 00:20:19,540
Bitcoin, other cryptocurrencies offer themselves out as world computers on which you can program on the base layer all sorts of fun programs.

214
00:20:20,260 --> 00:20:23,580
Bitcoin, simple code, allows for the processing of transaction.

215
00:20:24,140 --> 00:20:33,520
When you have complex code, that increases the attack surface for bugs and hackers, also increases the bandwidth, which again decentralizes because less people can operate a node.

216
00:20:34,300 --> 00:20:46,620
So those types of things, Alden says, increased throughput, code expressivity, increased privacy, are better handled on kind of successive layers on top of Bitcoin.

217
00:20:47,340 --> 00:20:50,700
So for example, tech stacks are often stacks.

218
00:20:50,700 --> 00:20:52,640
They often have different layers with different functionality.

219
00:20:52,640 --> 00:20:57,020
The internet protocol has an application layer, a transport layer, a link layer.

220
00:20:57,820 --> 00:21:00,640
Bitcoin also can have different layers.

221
00:21:00,800 --> 00:21:01,560
It's open source.

222
00:21:01,720 --> 00:21:03,340
People can freely build upon it.

223
00:21:03,660 --> 00:21:06,780
And there can be different types of functionality at each layer.

224
00:21:07,140 --> 00:21:11,960
The Bitcoin base layer can be used for settlements, for large, sensitive transactions.

225
00:21:12,620 --> 00:21:17,120
And the higher layers can be used for smaller, faster, and more private transactions, and

226
00:21:17,120 --> 00:21:19,020
perhaps for smart contracts and other uses.

227
00:21:19,720 --> 00:21:30,820
The next chapter indeed talks about the Lightning Network, a specific example of a fast, cheap, and relatively private way of doing transactions on top of the settlement layer of Bitcoin.

228
00:21:31,480 --> 00:21:40,560
And essentially, she says it works like opening a tab on the base layer, making a bunch of transactions with your tab open, and then later closing the tab on the base layer.

229
00:21:41,240 --> 00:21:54,840
This would allow for new types of use cases like micropayments, small transactions, smaller even than credit cards allow, which allow for new use cases like spam prevention and machine payments between AI agents.

230
00:21:55,860 --> 00:22:03,320
Bitcoin layer is not perfect at this point. The network, all the nodes, needs to develop further to establish more liquidity.

231
00:22:04,380 --> 00:22:07,380
And there's more details in the book if you want to know about the Lightning Network.

232
00:22:07,380 --> 00:22:16,160
Another way to distinguish between the different cryptocurrencies is proof of work versus proof of stake, and Alden dedicates a chapter to that.

233
00:22:16,400 --> 00:22:27,820
Proof of work refers to how Bitcoin miners have to do work by expending real-world energy to do computation in an attempt to solve a cryptographic puzzle.

234
00:22:28,220 --> 00:22:34,640
Within Bitcoin, again, they solve the puzzle to be able to get the right to package transactions in a block and get the block reward.

235
00:22:34,640 --> 00:22:50,300
The attempts to solve the puzzle are essentially in the Bitcoin proof-of-work system, essentially guesses. There's no way around simply expending vast amounts of power to do computations necessary to make more guesses.

236
00:22:50,300 --> 00:22:59,060
Proof of work or energy expenditure then is used to minimize trust and explicit forms of government within Bitcoin.

237
00:22:59,060 --> 00:23:24,740
To quote Alden, energy is the arbiter of truth in this case. There is no central authority or oligopoly, oligoplastics, we'll work on that, dub that in, set of validators that decides, rule by oligopoly, that decides what constitutes a valid block or a valid set of transactions or which transaction occurred before or after another transaction.

238
00:23:24,740 --> 00:23:34,220
the block chain with the most work in it is that which is mathematically verifiable at any time

239
00:23:34,220 --> 00:23:38,560
and is recognized as true by the rest of the code, rest of the node network, sorry.

240
00:23:39,520 --> 00:23:46,600
So the proof of work, to summarize all that, creates an unforgeable history based on energy usage for the lesser.

241
00:23:46,600 --> 00:23:57,740
Again, based on whichever chain of blocks has the most history of compiled computation, which represents energy usage, that is the valid chain.

242
00:23:57,880 --> 00:24:00,940
So all of the history is proved through energy.

243
00:24:01,080 --> 00:24:02,380
Energy is the arbiter of truth.

244
00:24:03,080 --> 00:24:10,140
Proof of stake, on the other hand, maintains its ledger in a circular way and has no unforgeable history.

245
00:24:10,140 --> 00:24:17,140
So how does proof of stake work, which is a form of governance that other cryptocurrencies like Ethereum use?

246
00:24:17,460 --> 00:24:23,000
How it works generally is existing coin holders can lock up or stake their coins.

247
00:24:23,120 --> 00:24:29,180
These locked coins can then vote on new block creation on the state of the ledger in any given moment.

248
00:24:29,780 --> 00:24:37,320
The locked coins then get rewarded with more coins by correctly creating a block of transactions and updating the ledger.

249
00:24:38,060 --> 00:24:47,920
In this circular world of proof of stake, there is no objective history based on energy usage to substantiate the correct state of the ledger, just constant voting by coin holders.

250
00:24:48,440 --> 00:24:55,500
This means that the network can never go offline all the notes because there is no objective history you can go back and refer to to restart.

251
00:24:57,440 --> 00:25:01,540
This proof of stake in this way is also inherently centralizing.

252
00:25:01,720 --> 00:25:03,920
Locked coins are rewarded with more coins.

253
00:25:03,920 --> 00:25:10,760
Whoever has the most coins locks gets the most coins rewarded, so they tend to get more voting power accrued to them over time.

254
00:25:12,100 --> 00:25:15,700
Is there a use for proof of stakes as a partially centralized database?

255
00:25:16,880 --> 00:25:20,000
Alden provides kind of a steel-manned speculative perhaps.

256
00:25:20,160 --> 00:25:25,040
Perhaps real-world assets can be put on chains that allow 24-7 operation of stock markets.

257
00:25:25,200 --> 00:25:27,000
You can perhaps reduce settlement times.

258
00:25:27,540 --> 00:25:32,180
Maybe you can allow small businesses to issue their own equity through tokens, things like that.

259
00:25:32,180 --> 00:25:46,820
Whatever it is, whatever that steel man perhaps is, it's not, Alden says, proof of stake is not robust money, which requires something like Bitcoin, which is decentralized with the state of the ledger based on unforgeable costliness.

260
00:25:47,060 --> 00:25:49,220
Again, the ledger is what money is.

261
00:25:49,960 --> 00:25:58,140
Energy in this is the arbiter of truth and not some form of explicit government such as voting through staked coins.

262
00:25:59,020 --> 00:26:04,320
Energy then is essential to Bitcoin and all that devotes a chapter to how Bitcoin uses energy.

263
00:26:04,440 --> 00:26:06,240
There's really two important takeaways from it.

264
00:26:06,680 --> 00:26:12,320
One is that Bitcoin energy usage is limited by the utility it provides to users.

265
00:26:12,980 --> 00:26:17,420
And two, that Bitcoin primarily consumes stranded energy that would otherwise be wasted.

266
00:26:17,420 --> 00:26:21,900
So the first point, Bitcoin energy is limited by the utility it provides to users.

267
00:26:22,060 --> 00:26:26,900
This is a response to skeptics who think that Bitcoin is just going to consume all of the world's energy,

268
00:26:26,900 --> 00:26:34,240
which is in fact what some newspaper articles that Alden cites hysterically said back in 2018 or 2020, something like that.

269
00:26:35,240 --> 00:26:39,420
So Bitcoin, though, its energy use is really limited by the utility it provides.

270
00:26:40,220 --> 00:26:44,820
Electricity is by far the largest input into Bitcoin mining.

271
00:26:45,340 --> 00:26:51,020
Mining then is rewarded by that block reward of new coins and transaction fees in new coins.

272
00:26:51,960 --> 00:26:55,020
And that block reward, again, is going down over time.

273
00:26:55,020 --> 00:26:56,420
It's halving over four years.

274
00:26:56,900 --> 00:27:03,840
So, if the utility of the network goes up, coin prices go up, and so miners are encouraged to use energy to get those coins.

275
00:27:04,220 --> 00:27:11,940
If the utility of the network goes down, then the coin prices of the network go down, and miners then turn off their machines and use less energy.

276
00:27:12,320 --> 00:27:15,500
So, in that sense, Bitcoin's energy use is tied to its utility.

277
00:27:16,560 --> 00:27:24,200
Even with that increasing utility, Alden knows we should keep that energy consumption in perspective with regard to that utility.

278
00:27:24,200 --> 00:27:37,160
She says, if Bitcoin becomes wildly successful with trillions of dollars of utility for users, we could potentially see it consume an amount of energy per year that is comparable to the aluminum production industry.

279
00:27:37,520 --> 00:27:51,600
In other words, despite reaching a massive scale and serving numerous purposes as a global monetary network, it would still be comparable to energy usage to various other random processes that we don't generally become orally panicked about.

280
00:27:51,600 --> 00:28:09,540
So Bitcoin's energy use is tied to its utility. Second, it primarily consumes stranded energy that would otherwise be wasted. Bitcoin miners, all the notes, have three really unique characteristics that's going to allow them to use energy that other energy users don't.

281
00:28:10,280 --> 00:28:14,820
First, most of their, as I said, most of their operating expense is electricity.

282
00:28:15,540 --> 00:28:21,620
So really, they can negotiate any other contract terms as long as they get the cheapest electricity possible.

283
00:28:22,840 --> 00:28:26,400
They also can tolerate an intermittent supply.

284
00:28:26,560 --> 00:28:27,500
They are interruptible.

285
00:28:27,600 --> 00:28:28,720
You can turn them off.

286
00:28:28,720 --> 00:28:31,060
They do not need to be constantly using energy.

287
00:28:31,840 --> 00:28:35,560
If it's not profitable in one moment to use them, you can just flip the switch, turn them off.

288
00:28:35,900 --> 00:28:38,360
They're also flexible with their location.

289
00:28:38,360 --> 00:28:48,380
You just need low bandwidth internet connection, which could be supplied by a satellite, provided by a satellite, and you can place them anywhere around the globe.

290
00:28:48,940 --> 00:28:56,180
So given these characteristics, Bitcoin can utilize energy sources that are not being utilized by other things.

291
00:28:56,700 --> 00:28:59,140
One is stranded hydroelectric power.

292
00:29:00,100 --> 00:29:04,700
Bitcoin mining can – many hydro dams produce extra energy.

293
00:29:04,700 --> 00:29:11,080
The rivers are always running and this extra energy would otherwise go to waste.

294
00:29:11,320 --> 00:29:22,520
Bitcoin can then monetize this extra energy and, in fact, incentivize the creation of new hydro dams that would not be able to justify their creation based on the number of users.

295
00:29:22,680 --> 00:29:24,800
Because, again, Bitcoin is flexible.

296
00:29:25,180 --> 00:29:25,980
It can go anywhere.

297
00:29:27,080 --> 00:29:30,000
Another form of stranded energy is natural gas.

298
00:29:30,320 --> 00:29:33,460
So natural gas is a byproduct of extracting petroleum.

299
00:29:34,120 --> 00:29:41,520
However, there's usually not sufficient quantities to build a pipeline to actually utilize it, to transport it to a place where people would be able to use it.

300
00:29:41,960 --> 00:29:45,840
So instead, usually it's vented, just let out into the atmosphere or flared.

301
00:29:45,840 --> 00:29:59,760
If you've ever driven past one of these petroleum refineries, you can see the flames shooting dramatically into the sky like something in Soran, the place in Lord of the Rings where they go, that hellish landscape.

302
00:30:00,520 --> 00:30:04,220
Bitcoin miners, though, can buy this otherwise wasted gas.

303
00:30:05,500 --> 00:30:08,320
In fact, they're location agnostic.

304
00:30:08,500 --> 00:30:12,400
They can go to where the petroleum is being extracted.

305
00:30:13,060 --> 00:30:26,180
And they're more environmentally friendly in the way that they use it, too, because running this gas through an electric generator is more efficient at converting methane to the less damaging CO2 than is flaring it.

306
00:30:26,180 --> 00:30:29,460
And, of course, that is simply venting it and letting it go.

307
00:30:29,760 --> 00:30:56,080
Landfill can also be utilized. They emit methane. Bitcoin miners don't care where they are. They don't mind the smell. They can go to wherever the landfills are letting off the methane. Bitcoin can also stabilize the grid and make green energy viable. Grids usually need to be overbuilt so that they can provide for peak demand on the hottest day of the year when people and everyone's blaring their AC as well as for the lowest points of demand when not many people are.

308
00:30:59,760 --> 00:31:07,260
So green sources of energy like wind also tend to provide lots of energy on certain days when it's windy and then less when it's not windy, of course.

309
00:31:07,680 --> 00:31:14,200
But Bitcoin miners, they're intermittent users in addition to being flexible on their location.

310
00:31:14,460 --> 00:31:20,180
So they can buy excess demand when there's lots of energy coming on the grid that's not being used.

311
00:31:20,300 --> 00:31:26,520
And they can shut off when there's – I'm sorry, they can – when there's excess demand, they can shut off.

312
00:31:26,520 --> 00:31:32,620
And when there's excess supply, they can then monetize that excess energy, which would otherwise simply be wasted.

313
00:31:33,460 --> 00:31:40,020
In similar ways, they can help developing countries build out their grids by promising to buy any electricity.

314
00:31:40,360 --> 00:31:52,740
For example, if a country needs to bootstrap a hydroelectric project, but there's not enough current use cases next to that torrential river, Bitcoin miners can drop in and allow it to become immediately monetizable.

315
00:31:52,740 --> 00:32:34,030
To summarize Alden and this is an amazing quote can be profitably tapped into which incentivize people to move to them Alden then moves on to provide a cryptocurrency risk analysis We skip that for now

316
00:32:34,030 --> 00:32:40,450
and Lucas and I will mull that over as in our conversation. She ends this chapter on the

317
00:32:40,450 --> 00:32:47,010
technology of this new era of internet native money by talking briefly about stablecoins and

318
00:32:47,010 --> 00:32:54,850
central bank digital currencies. So stable coins, you could kind of characterize them as privately

319
00:32:54,850 --> 00:33:02,290
issued fiat collateralized redeemable tokens. So how does that work? They're issued, people wire

320
00:33:02,290 --> 00:33:07,890
dollars, they send their dollars to an issuer of stable coin, that issuer then generates a new

321
00:33:07,890 --> 00:33:13,450
stable coin and gives them the stable coin. That stable coin can then move around whatever

322
00:33:13,450 --> 00:33:18,270
blockchain networks. It's designed to move on and be used for whatever purpose, payment, savings,

323
00:33:18,430 --> 00:33:26,590
investment, trading, leverage, DeFi, and do that 24-7. Those tokens then can then be sent back to

324
00:33:26,590 --> 00:33:33,970
the issuer and then redeemed for the amount of currency that they are collateralized with that

325
00:33:33,970 --> 00:33:39,990
they're supposed to be worth. So this is different than Bitcoin in that the issuer of the stable coin,

326
00:33:39,990 --> 00:33:46,790
It's a centralized entity, can freeze accounts if commanded to by the government of the jurisdiction in which they're located.

327
00:33:47,710 --> 00:33:50,170
In addition, you have to trust – they're centralized.

328
00:33:50,390 --> 00:33:55,930
You have to trust that issuer to maintain assets sufficient to allow you to actually redeem that stablecoin.

329
00:33:57,090 --> 00:34:00,870
That's one type of internet native money, we might say.

330
00:34:00,870 --> 00:34:06,250
Another type is the CBDC. That's the central bank digital currency, which are digital versions of

331
00:34:06,250 --> 00:34:12,510
currencies that are issued by already existing central banks. Are they good? Is it good for a

332
00:34:12,510 --> 00:34:17,050
bank to do that? Well, Alden says, good for who? There's an issue of the user versus the issuer

333
00:34:17,050 --> 00:34:24,410
as far as what they want in a money. The user of money wants typically private money. No one's

334
00:34:24,410 --> 00:34:29,270
going to see what they're using it for. They want money to be free. They can use it for whatever

335
00:34:29,270 --> 00:34:34,510
purpose they want, and they want it to be scarce. They don't want to get some money and then to have

336
00:34:34,510 --> 00:34:40,430
it be inflated away by a bunch of it being printed. The issuer of the money might have

337
00:34:40,430 --> 00:34:44,770
different desires. They often want surveillable money to see what people are doing with their

338
00:34:44,770 --> 00:34:49,190
money. They want to be able to control it, manipulate it, and they want it to consistently

339
00:34:49,190 --> 00:34:55,990
devalue over time. The issuer who has these desires is the central banks as issuers. They

340
00:34:55,990 --> 00:35:01,310
want surveillable, controllable, consistently devaluing money. They want central bank digital

341
00:35:01,310 --> 00:35:06,690
currencies that can be programmed to do these things and to enact central bank policies. You

342
00:35:06,690 --> 00:35:12,850
can program a CBDC to have different interest rates for different demographics, different

343
00:35:12,850 --> 00:35:18,670
interest rates for different industries, quotas for spending depending on geographic area. You can

344
00:35:18,670 --> 00:35:23,630
use them to enable quick stimulus payments to send to targeted groups. You can have, again,

345
00:35:23,630 --> 00:35:28,270
money that devalues quicker if you don't spend it. The example of China is given,

346
00:35:28,490 --> 00:35:33,890
lest you think that these examples are farcical, they invented a CBDC that is programmable and

347
00:35:33,890 --> 00:35:40,450
they can set expiration dates to ensure that money is spent, block and track transactions,

348
00:35:41,170 --> 00:35:46,450
deduct or freeze accounts easily, and automatically penalize individuals. If they're jaywalking,

349
00:35:46,450 --> 00:35:50,830
they can facially detect that maybe that it's you doing it and then automatically

350
00:35:50,830 --> 00:35:58,230
deduct money from your bank account. As we saw with telecommunications, so technology usually

351
00:35:58,230 --> 00:36:03,450
presents itself as neutral. Ah, you know, information now moves quicker, but the consequences

352
00:36:03,450 --> 00:36:09,030
are definitely not. Alden ends the chapter this way, or the part five this way on internet native

353
00:36:09,030 --> 00:36:17,370
money. This era represents a fork in the road. One Direction provides a stepwise upgrade to those

354
00:36:17,370 --> 00:36:23,350
who want to continue the multi-century trend of further and further centralization of the

355
00:36:23,350 --> 00:36:28,950
financial system. The other direction reverses that trend, fractures the existing forces of

356
00:36:28,950 --> 00:36:35,510
centralization, and gives more financial autonomy back to individual users who wish to take it away.

357
00:36:36,290 --> 00:36:43,190
So that's part five on internet native money, Alden's discussion of the new technology and

358
00:36:43,190 --> 00:36:48,190
how that responds to the need for speed, essentially. That's a lot of information.

359
00:36:49,010 --> 00:36:53,310
And I left out a lot. There could be more said. Before we kind of maybe jump into some

360
00:36:53,310 --> 00:36:56,990
questions that I noted, was there anything that dropped out of that narrative or anything

361
00:36:56,990 --> 00:37:06,630
specific, notable there, Lucas? No, as usual, great job. I think just zooming far out,

362
00:37:06,630 --> 00:37:12,270
what we're looking at is we do. We have this fork in the road. We have an opportunity.

363
00:37:13,190 --> 00:37:15,710
Um, and it's not so much an opportunity.

364
00:37:15,710 --> 00:37:24,050
It's a, um, it's an imperative, I would say, um, for the individual to make a choice.

365
00:37:24,170 --> 00:37:32,370
And the choice is, do I want to have responsibility for my future?

366
00:37:32,470 --> 00:37:35,430
Or do I want someone else to have responsibility for it?

367
00:37:35,430 --> 00:37:43,850
acknowledging that if I engender someone else with the ability to control my money,

368
00:37:44,250 --> 00:37:52,910
then I am giving them power over literally every aspect of my life except for my thoughts.

369
00:37:52,910 --> 00:37:59,170
And actually, you had brought up this in a direct message that we had had where

370
00:37:59,170 --> 00:38:07,470
there's also an argument to be made that it is control over your thoughts as well due to the

371
00:38:07,470 --> 00:38:13,910
zero cost of spamming people through their screens and through algorithmic,

372
00:38:13,910 --> 00:38:21,090
essentially subconscious programming. And that sounds a little woo woo and out there a little

373
00:38:21,090 --> 00:38:26,310
bit, but, um, but incentives are always subconscious programming, right? Right. Yeah.

374
00:38:26,310 --> 00:38:38,790
And so you, you, you know, I, I keep, it's hard not for me to now frame everything in terms of the, of the Jason Lowry software thesis now that I've been exposed to that.

375
00:38:38,910 --> 00:38:52,130
But yeah, if, if it costs you money every time that you put something in front of my eyes, then that creates a whole new world and that, that whole new world.

376
00:38:52,130 --> 00:38:53,690
And she alludes to it a little bit.

377
00:38:54,190 --> 00:39:08,750
But that whole new world means that I can't just string you up, put you upside down, attach a line and milk and bleed you of your value slowly, but slow enough that you don't die.

378
00:39:09,910 --> 00:39:12,750
Where it's just this extraction economy.

379
00:39:12,750 --> 00:39:23,590
I if I'm going to have a long term relationship and a business, I'm going to have to do something that's productive for the for the people who I collaborate with.

380
00:39:23,590 --> 00:39:25,990
And so no great summary.

381
00:39:26,470 --> 00:39:26,650
Yeah.

382
00:39:26,650 --> 00:39:38,390
So like money is always with the CBDC money could always be judging you ideologically and incentivizing you to do things that central bank planners and by extension politicians.

383
00:39:38,390 --> 00:39:51,830
I mean, they could like, you know, if they want to disperse a protest, they could say anybody who has a bank account in this geographic area, it's going to slowly drain away until you leave the area and then program the CBDCs to do that.

384
00:39:51,830 --> 00:40:05,010
They could say, you know, if you spend your money in this industry on this provider that we really like, you're going to get huge rebates and bonuses automatic, you know, and penalized maybe if you don't spend in this industry.

385
00:40:05,010 --> 00:40:12,010
And so it just offers this level of granular control that's like the wet dream of the central state planner, right?

386
00:40:12,090 --> 00:40:13,610
It's just the amount of power.

387
00:40:13,850 --> 00:40:23,590
In the last chapter, we saw that we're kind of clumsily – the current system kind of clumsily already manipulates people into doing certain things.

388
00:40:23,770 --> 00:40:34,530
And these short-term business cycles that become long-term debt cycles, it's the central planner thinking they can manipulate with these kind of brute tools of interest rate lowering and hiring.

389
00:40:34,530 --> 00:40:43,890
Now they're going to get, with CBDCs, all sorts of new different levers and buttons and dials, and it's just going to be irresistible.

390
00:40:44,750 --> 00:40:45,650
Yeah, let's talk.

391
00:40:45,930 --> 00:40:56,610
So a real-world example, when the automotive industry failed in 2008, first they were bailed out by the government.

392
00:40:56,610 --> 00:41:04,150
And I think it's very important to make the distinction that a government bailout means that we have nationalized that industry.

393
00:41:04,530 --> 00:41:11,750
So it never goes back. There's no such thing. That is now part of the government. It's inextricably tied.

394
00:41:12,990 --> 00:41:21,630
And if you again, if you zoom out and while you were talking, I Googled like what what all industries have been bailed out by the government.

395
00:41:22,290 --> 00:41:29,970
So the agriculture industry has been nationalized. The banking industry has been nationalized, mortgage industry, automotive, airlines.

396
00:41:29,970 --> 00:41:49,830
Um, there's, there was at least 12 examples. And so it just, it's this gradual moving of power towards a centralized state, um, and away from the private sector. And, and you think about, again, view these things from a different light.

397
00:41:49,830 --> 00:41:56,110
all of these bonuses that people were upset about in 2008, these executives that they had companies

398
00:41:56,110 --> 00:42:01,430
that failed yet. They got billion, million, a hundred million dollar bonuses. What is that?

399
00:42:01,610 --> 00:42:08,070
That's the payment that it costs to buy that industry and put it into the government. Um,

400
00:42:08,250 --> 00:42:14,270
when the automotive industry failed, um, not only did we bail them out, there was nationwide

401
00:42:14,270 --> 00:42:19,090
employee pricing was offered to everybody. So if you wanted to buy a new Chevy,

402
00:42:19,550 --> 00:42:24,970
then you could get employee pricing on that Chevy, whatever discount. And it was a massive discount.

403
00:42:25,230 --> 00:42:34,450
And that stimulated an insane amount of vehicle purchases that weren't needed, right? It was nice

404
00:42:34,450 --> 00:42:41,010
to have a new vehicle. That's cool. And yeah, that's great. But what did it ultimately do

405
00:42:41,010 --> 00:42:50,210
was it transferred a whole lot of wealth from the individual to the government by means of the automotive industry

406
00:42:50,210 --> 00:42:53,690
that otherwise would not have gone.

407
00:42:54,110 --> 00:42:57,770
And you're right in saying that that's a very crude way of doing that.

408
00:42:57,970 --> 00:43:08,270
And the scalpel precision sniper way of doing that is the programmable money that this automotive industry has failed.

409
00:43:08,270 --> 00:43:09,550
You have $2,000.

410
00:43:09,550 --> 00:43:21,450
If you don't spend that $2,000 on a down payment for an automotive purchase in the next month, then we'll just take it and we'll just give it to that company.

411
00:43:22,190 --> 00:43:28,230
So, yeah, it is a despot's dictator's dream.

412
00:43:28,230 --> 00:43:46,650
Yeah. And I would say that they would perceive it as a scalpel, but it would still be an instrument that could never match the way that the market naturally matches supply and demand and adjusts prices. It would just, like you said, be something that despots would use to kind of cement their power for sure.

413
00:43:46,650 --> 00:44:04,350
Yeah. Well, I mean, if you think that we have a cyclical market now with booms and busts, exactly. Wait until we can make just hair's breadth decisions on things because the second and third order consequences can never be foreseen.

414
00:44:04,350 --> 00:44:12,310
And so if you do this, you know, if you pull that lever, you don't know how that's going to affect other industries.

415
00:44:13,570 --> 00:44:17,430
You know, create an over demand for vehicles that what are you going to do?

416
00:44:17,670 --> 00:44:30,370
You're going to take raw materials away from other industries that if they had a clear market signal would be able to purchase those supplies at a at a useful price.

417
00:44:30,370 --> 00:44:47,370
But then you artificially inflate tires and radios and paint, whatever it is that goes into that thing. And any other industry that uses that, therefore, cannot compete because they're not being subsidized. They're not being nationalized.

418
00:44:47,370 --> 00:45:05,490
And so the whipsaw effect just accelerates. And it's kind of like a little snap at the end of a mouse's tail right now. But with a CBDC, then you're going to see a bullwhip. And we're seeing that in China where I can't remember if we talked about this before.

419
00:45:05,490 --> 00:45:21,370
So China overbuilt. China overbuilt way too much commercial real estate, massive buildings, 50, 60, 70-story skyscrapers and massive residential areas.

420
00:45:22,170 --> 00:45:26,130
And as a result, they don't have the demand for it because they overbuilt so much.

421
00:45:26,130 --> 00:45:39,990
And now there's no choice for them. They can either let their industry collapse or they can take the action that they're taking now, which is to literally implode brand new buildings that have never been used.

422
00:45:41,070 --> 00:45:52,610
Billions of dollars wasted. And they're blowing them up in order to artificially decrease the supply so that they can try and stabilize so that supply can meet demand and we can have somewhat of a market signal again.

423
00:45:52,610 --> 00:45:59,570
So this is the beginning of what you see with that type of thing.

424
00:46:00,010 --> 00:46:06,890
Just wait till they really get it tuned up and they start running it with AI and really accelerating it.

425
00:46:07,030 --> 00:46:08,910
It is not a good situation.

426
00:46:09,330 --> 00:46:12,170
And the flip side of that, proof of work.

427
00:46:13,130 --> 00:46:15,870
Proof of work is that there's a cost to every decision.

428
00:46:16,870 --> 00:46:21,350
And I think that's just a – there's no free lunch.

429
00:46:21,350 --> 00:46:43,650
You know, nothing in life comes free. You have to, when you make a choice for one thing, you're saying yes to one thing and no to everything else. And there is a cost for that. And we've been skipping along without consequence. Sorry, not without consequence, delaying consequence and mortgaging the future of unborn generations.

430
00:46:44,510 --> 00:46:49,390
Yeah. And exporting consequence to the peripheries as all the notes, sending inflation abroad. Yeah.

431
00:46:49,390 --> 00:47:09,750
Yeah, the exporting. And I really do hope I really do hope that we're able to talk with some people who are in, you know, these developed countries, developing countries that are truly seeing the benefit of using Bitcoin so that they can kind of enlighten people here.

432
00:47:09,750 --> 00:47:15,690
Because we, again, we are being bled slow enough that it's not very noticeable.

433
00:47:16,570 --> 00:47:26,010
But if you're in a country where you have 30, 40, 50 percent annual inflation, then that's a cost that you just simply can't overcome.

434
00:47:26,250 --> 00:47:27,830
You can't out-engineer that.

435
00:47:28,410 --> 00:47:29,870
You can't out-earn that.

436
00:47:30,610 --> 00:47:38,170
I give the example that Venezuela experienced average inflation from 1980 to 2000.

437
00:47:38,170 --> 00:47:55,810
So for a 20-year period, they experienced inflation that averaged enough that – I forget the exact number, but if you made $100,000 in 1980, you would have to make something like $14 quadrillion in 2000 just to have the exact same lifestyle.

438
00:47:56,650 --> 00:48:00,050
And those are numbers that just can't be – it's just impossible.

439
00:48:00,270 --> 00:48:01,890
Like that amount of money doesn't exist.

440
00:48:01,890 --> 00:48:06,670
And so it's lowering the quality of life for people.

441
00:48:07,090 --> 00:48:16,670
But we're being blinded to that because we do have technology that's making advances that does make life cheaper and it does lower the cost of things.

442
00:48:17,130 --> 00:48:27,770
And so it's this fighting scale of the benefits of technology are extracted and taken by the state in terms of seniorage and inflation.

443
00:48:27,770 --> 00:48:32,170
So, yeah, it burns everything that we have accomplished with technology.

444
00:48:33,090 --> 00:48:48,270
Yeah, and with Venezuela, you get a really visceral example of people fleeing the burning house that is the rapidly entropifying flexible ledger of a country.

445
00:48:48,270 --> 00:49:02,050
So people, I mean, you go to Colombia, Peru, you'll see just as many Venezuelans as in Venezuela. People are getting out of the country. They're fleeing because you can't live that way.

446
00:49:02,050 --> 00:49:16,330
And what Bitcoin does, one of its utility cases, as Alden notes, is it obviates, it goes around the sorts of capital controls that are imposed in the late stage of a long-term debt cycle.

447
00:49:16,650 --> 00:49:28,270
The capital controls that try to keep everybody within the ledger to deflate everybody or inflate everybody, all the debt away together, make everybody suffer, which usually just means making the poorest suffer the most.

448
00:49:28,270 --> 00:49:38,810
But now a person can memorize the seed phrase, take all of their wealth as much as they were able to shift out of the dying currency and then flee to a better ledger.

449
00:49:38,810 --> 00:49:50,850
And you're going to see like the long tail, all the notes, this in this part to the long tail of weak currencies are the first things that Bitcoin eats up even before it gets to gold or silver.

450
00:49:51,390 --> 00:50:04,570
What it's competing with is all of these dying, dying currencies mismanaged by despots, authoritarians, whether democratically elected or not, people that thought that they knew better than the free market.

451
00:50:04,570 --> 00:50:19,090
Yeah, you can think of, I think you can think of Bitcoin as like the lion hunting on the Serengeti and the 160 fiat currencies as the pack of zebras or gazelle or whatever in front of it.

452
00:50:19,090 --> 00:50:46,410
And it's just, it's, you know, how do lions hunt is they, they pick off the weak one and the slow one at the end. And that's just imagine this lion eating first the Naira and then the Turkish lira and then the, you know, the Venezuelan peso, I think. I can't remember what their currency is, but yeah, it's, it's going to get to the United States dollar last probably because it is the strongest, but it's going to get there.

453
00:50:46,410 --> 00:50:54,510
Um, and it, it will, it will take over that the book, uh, she gives that great example from,

454
00:50:54,510 --> 00:51:02,570
uh, Boya Mabook, who was, uh, this female business owner in Afghanistan who paid, I think it was

455
00:51:02,570 --> 00:51:10,290
Afghanistan or Saudi Arabia. It was Afghanistan. Yeah. And, um, so due to the oppressive nature

456
00:51:10,290 --> 00:51:17,270
of the patriarchal system that exists there, females are really not allowed to work.

457
00:51:17,270 --> 00:51:23,250
I mean, they're treated often more like property than they are like humans in some ways.

458
00:51:24,210 --> 00:51:28,430
And so she had this business and she wanted to pay her employees.

459
00:51:28,930 --> 00:51:34,650
But there was a problem that every time she paid her employees, they were subject to having

460
00:51:34,650 --> 00:51:39,030
that money taken by their husbands or their brothers or their fathers, the men in their

461
00:51:39,030 --> 00:51:40,010
life, the patriarchy.

462
00:51:40,290 --> 00:51:50,490
And so they experimented with ways to give them money that couldn't be taken away from them.

463
00:51:51,290 --> 00:52:09,250
And she notes that they even tried the Huala system and the Huala system failed, which we discussed the Huala system earlier, which was one of the first decentralized, I would call it low trust, low trust monetary systems where I give money to you.

464
00:52:09,250 --> 00:52:14,450
and then you send a messenger or a message to someone else.

465
00:52:15,130 --> 00:52:21,870
And then they make a note in the ledger and they pass on that money to whoever I want to.

466
00:52:22,050 --> 00:52:24,730
This essentially is channel-based ledger.

467
00:52:25,250 --> 00:52:29,590
This is the exact same as the lightning system, except there's humans in it, so it fails.

468
00:52:30,350 --> 00:52:37,010
But she gives the example of one of her employees that had accumulated 2.5 Bitcoin,

469
00:52:37,010 --> 00:52:43,830
which is a massive amount. She notes that it's a hundred times more than the annual salary

470
00:52:43,830 --> 00:52:52,330
of a person in that industry, in that country. And when they had the flee in order to keep the

471
00:52:52,330 --> 00:52:58,810
family safe, they went through all these trials and tribulations. They had to work with people to

472
00:52:58,810 --> 00:53:03,370
get them out of the country and through different countries. And during the course of the way,

473
00:53:03,370 --> 00:53:13,870
They were scammed and robbed out of literally everything that they had, in addition to losing possessions when the boat that they were on sank.

474
00:53:14,090 --> 00:53:16,050
Just this horrific ordeal.

475
00:53:16,650 --> 00:53:23,710
Yet because this woman had the seed phrase to her Bitcoin, she was able to make it out.

476
00:53:23,710 --> 00:53:35,830
And that's a beautiful example of correcting the problem that was seen so greatly in World War II, Germany, Jews trying to flee.

477
00:53:36,490 --> 00:53:43,650
And at first, if you wanted to flee, you had to pay, you know, what, 10%, 20%, 30% of your net worth.

478
00:53:43,650 --> 00:53:46,090
Then it was 50, then it was 60, then it was 90.

479
00:53:46,430 --> 00:53:50,750
Then it was the gold fillings in your teeth and everything that you owned.

480
00:53:50,750 --> 00:54:14,650
And so that extractive nature, once it starts, it just never stops. And yeah, beautiful example of a real world, a real world application of that. And I don't want to distance people too far from that. I want, I guess if I, if I want anybody to have a takeaway from what we're talking about is to realize that you're, you're a bad administration.

481
00:54:14,650 --> 00:54:23,010
administration, you're a hair's breadth away. Looking at the administration that almost made

482
00:54:23,010 --> 00:54:28,710
it into office, this go around for the United States, it was their intent to create a central

483
00:54:28,710 --> 00:54:34,450
bank digital currency. It was their intent to raise the ability to have surveillance controls

484
00:54:34,450 --> 00:54:41,690
on capital. It was their intent to be able to have more and more and more power centralized

485
00:54:41,690 --> 00:54:49,950
within a group of people who are by nature, short-term thinkers and narcissists, you know,

486
00:54:49,950 --> 00:54:56,870
they, they just want to maintain power because maintaining power is, um, what they seek. And so,

487
00:54:57,150 --> 00:55:04,830
yeah, I mean, even though it may feel far away for people, um, I, I really hope that there's this

488
00:55:04,830 --> 00:55:15,850
visceral reaction to, oh, like we forked history and potentially have the opportunity to leave

489
00:55:15,850 --> 00:55:17,430
a good impression upon the world.

490
00:55:17,890 --> 00:55:22,630
Whereas we could have gone down a really, really dark path modeling after what China

491
00:55:22,630 --> 00:55:23,330
is doing.

492
00:55:24,170 --> 00:55:27,310
I mean, so I don't think we're on the good timeline.

493
00:55:27,590 --> 00:55:29,190
I do think we're on the better timeline.

494
00:55:29,190 --> 00:55:34,770
I don't think, I mean, Alden is fond of saying nothing stops this train in

495
00:55:34,770 --> 00:55:40,930
reference to this long-term debt cycle and the situation we've got ourselves into. So, you know,

496
00:55:41,030 --> 00:55:47,410
we can maybe manage our transition better. An interesting thing about, you know, we have this

497
00:55:47,410 --> 00:55:52,830
two-party system, we have left and right. Bitcoin is neither of those things. I mean, just hearing

498
00:55:52,830 --> 00:55:59,570
you talk, Lucas, about Roya Maboub and also, you know, us discussing these use cases using terms

499
00:55:59,570 --> 00:56:04,250
like patriarchy, talking about badness of authoritarian governments, talking about protecting

500
00:56:04,250 --> 00:56:10,030
refugees. These are things that oftentimes those who might claim to be on what is currently the

501
00:56:10,030 --> 00:56:14,630
left would say we are doing. Those are the things that we value, ending patriarchy, protecting

502
00:56:14,630 --> 00:56:24,290
refugees. But these are things that agnostically, without caring, the Bitcoin does just by being a

503
00:56:24,290 --> 00:56:29,990
neutral, permissionless, decentralized protocol. So Lucas and I, we listened to this podcast,

504
00:56:29,990 --> 00:56:34,690
which was it's a really interesting podcast it's the one we listened to called money on the left

505
00:56:34,690 --> 00:56:40,130
but what's interesting about it is that they in the podcast we listened to they seemed to diagnose

506
00:56:40,130 --> 00:56:47,970
the same problem that alden talks about but they and they talked about all of the ability of like

507
00:56:47,970 --> 00:56:53,630
cbdc's to granularize control of the central banking system and the population of the managed

508
00:56:53,630 --> 00:56:59,130
thing but they kind of did it with like a sense of hope and promise like we can fix things now

509
00:56:59,130 --> 00:57:07,110
And it was just really interesting to see that some people are so close to seeing once you get past left and right, forget those categories.

510
00:57:07,750 --> 00:57:12,210
Forget like the Bitcoin's current association with Trump as a Bitcoin president.

511
00:57:12,430 --> 00:57:13,030
Forget that.

512
00:57:13,570 --> 00:57:17,310
Forget also the way that the left has in the past claimed to protect refugees.

513
00:57:17,530 --> 00:57:20,610
Forget all of that and just look at what is happening with Bitcoin.

514
00:57:20,890 --> 00:57:25,750
And we can talk about stranded energy usage and bootstrapping development in developing countries.

515
00:57:25,750 --> 00:57:29,750
I mean, that's the interesting thing is it's something that is beyond ideology.

516
00:57:30,670 --> 00:57:34,630
Whereas, again, a CBDC is programming ideology into money.

517
00:57:35,530 --> 00:57:39,230
Yeah. The looking good while doing evil is a symptom.

518
00:57:39,230 --> 00:58:01,690
Yeah, it's a symptom of not recognizing the fundamental problem, which is centralization and control creates an opportunity and it creates an incentive to adjust outcomes in favor of those who have the centralization and the control.

519
00:58:01,690 --> 00:58:09,390
And it really is listening to that podcast Money on the Left, which, you know, like I said, you asked me about it after it was over.

520
00:58:09,450 --> 00:58:17,430
And I said, it sounds like this guy really understands everything about Bitcoin except for what you're supposed to do with it.

521
00:58:17,430 --> 00:58:30,810
Like, it's great. It really was kind of crazy to hear somebody have that good of a grasp, not only of the technology, but of the problems that it solves.

522
00:58:31,690 --> 00:58:41,890
And then just blindly and so ignorantly go, oh, yeah, if we had that power, then we could make everything better.

523
00:58:41,890 --> 00:58:45,010
And no, like that is absolutely wrong.

524
00:58:45,970 --> 00:58:50,810
Everything about centralization of power leads to despotism.

525
00:58:51,050 --> 00:58:55,210
It leads to horrific, horrific humanitarian disasters.

526
00:58:55,510 --> 00:58:57,290
And so, yeah, I don't know.

527
00:58:57,350 --> 00:58:58,950
I thought it was pretty fascinating to hear that.

528
00:58:59,030 --> 00:59:00,030
I'm glad you brought that up.

529
00:59:01,690 --> 00:59:29,170
One of the things that I love how Alden slipped in, and I can just picture her writing this too, by the way, because she's trying so hard to be completely unbiased as a systems engineer, as a macroeconomist, as an expert in a number of fields that Bitcoin affects.

530
00:59:29,170 --> 00:59:32,510
and kind of a historian really as well.

531
00:59:33,190 --> 00:59:35,850
But she does slip in, you know,

532
00:59:35,930 --> 00:59:39,310
what are kind of the effects of a decentralized money?

533
00:59:39,670 --> 00:59:44,930
And one of them is that governments will shrink in size

534
00:59:44,930 --> 00:59:51,670
and there won't be a use for a large government

535
00:59:51,670 --> 00:59:56,990
because it's great that if you can view the world

536
00:59:56,990 --> 01:00:01,250
as a sandbox of different practices.

537
01:00:01,530 --> 01:00:03,890
There's all these different countries trying different things.

538
01:00:04,310 --> 01:00:08,550
And when something works in one country, another country will adopt that because people aren't

539
01:00:08,550 --> 01:00:09,810
stupid at the end of the day.

540
01:00:09,890 --> 01:00:12,190
They are somewhat rational.

541
01:00:13,650 --> 01:00:19,830
The saying that a person is smart, but people are stupid, I really enjoy that because it

542
01:00:19,830 --> 01:00:26,310
does take us back to what we had talked about previously, which was one of the faults of

543
01:00:26,310 --> 01:00:31,610
our system is that it's people in charge, not a dictator. I'm not advocating for a dictator,

544
01:00:31,730 --> 01:00:40,610
but a dictator can make quick moves. A monarchy can make quick moves. But anyways, to take power

545
01:00:40,610 --> 01:00:46,030
away from the government, then you are naturally going to atrophy that muscle and it's going to

546
01:00:46,030 --> 01:00:56,010
shrink in size and shrink in power. And I think what we're seeing with Bitcoin is exposing

547
01:00:56,010 --> 01:01:04,290
the inherent flaws of scaling. Bigger is not better. Better is better. We have been sacrificing

548
01:01:04,290 --> 01:01:11,290
quality for quantity for so long. We look around and we see this in all of our consumer products.

549
01:01:11,390 --> 01:01:19,290
Everything's made of plastic. Everything's made of paper, cardboard. When the quality materials

550
01:01:19,290 --> 01:01:26,050
are so costly now because of inflation that the average person can't afford it.

551
01:01:26,610 --> 01:01:34,470
And so we have Gresham's Law in every aspect of our life. The clothes we wear, the dishes that we

552
01:01:34,470 --> 01:01:39,770
use. You think about somebody who has the fine china that they only get out for holidays,

553
01:01:40,070 --> 01:01:45,450
and then the rest of the time they're using paper plates. That's Gresham's Law applied to

554
01:01:45,450 --> 01:01:52,150
consumer products is that the bad product pushes out the good. You hoard the good thing because

555
01:01:52,150 --> 01:01:57,930
it won't last if you use it. The difference with Bitcoin is that you can't break it. You can't

556
01:01:57,930 --> 01:02:03,250
bust it. You can't drop it and see it shatter into a million pieces. And so, yeah, we've just

557
01:02:03,250 --> 01:02:09,070
never seen anything like that. We've never seen a money that satisfies all the characteristics

558
01:02:09,070 --> 01:02:15,250
of money. And it's the best at all of them. And so it will inherently push everything

559
01:02:15,250 --> 01:02:16,910
push everything to the side.

560
01:02:17,830 --> 01:02:22,250
Yeah, I want to expand on the point you noted about the shrinking, about Bitcoin shrinking

561
01:02:22,250 --> 01:02:27,050
the power of the government in that it's going to take one of the functions out of the government's

562
01:02:27,050 --> 01:02:27,330
hands.

563
01:02:27,910 --> 01:02:32,130
One of the things, when you say shrink the power of the government, people maybe on the

564
01:02:32,130 --> 01:02:35,210
left are thinking that just means you're handing it to corporations.

565
01:02:36,150 --> 01:02:44,510
But so Breedlove retweeted an image that had a cartoon from Jason Lowry's software thesis

566
01:02:44,510 --> 01:02:51,750
that has Bezos, Zuckerberg, and Musk, but they're made up like Egyptian pharaohs.

567
01:02:51,750 --> 01:03:05,750
And then it has that image juxtaposed over the inauguration image where Bezos and Musk and Zuckerberg are sitting there together at the inauguration.

568
01:03:06,690 --> 01:03:10,810
And so when you shrink the power of the government, you don't grow the power of corporations.

569
01:03:10,810 --> 01:03:16,190
You remove the ability of these corporations to exploit the power of the government.

570
01:03:16,190 --> 01:03:28,970
And you also remove the necessity of corporations to get close to the government in order to benefit from bailouts, to benefit from subsidies and things like that.

571
01:03:28,970 --> 01:03:40,410
So you actually – it's a step towards getting rid of a tech oligopoly, the tech industrial complex that Biden warns us against in his outgoing address.

572
01:03:40,810 --> 01:03:48,950
It's a step away from that to, if you don't want a tech industrial complex, then shrink the power

573
01:03:48,950 --> 01:03:54,470
overall of the industrial complex that is the government and make tech then have to compete

574
01:03:54,470 --> 01:04:00,150
for Bitcoin on an open market with everybody else instead of simply getting close to the money

575
01:04:00,150 --> 01:04:05,190
printers that are going to issue the CBDC. So I just wanted to add that point that shrinking the

576
01:04:05,190 --> 01:04:12,570
power of the government is also striking back at tech oligarchs that leverage their power,

577
01:04:12,790 --> 01:04:19,090
their access to capital markets, all of these things to get close to sources of power, to

578
01:04:19,090 --> 01:04:25,130
receive bailouts, to be nationalized in that proto sense where the government, where they're

579
01:04:25,130 --> 01:04:29,730
still receiving profits, but the government is taking on all the losses.

580
01:04:29,730 --> 01:04:30,730
Yeah.

581
01:04:30,730 --> 01:04:36,350
And she talks about a move towards equity and away from debt in the future, because we have

582
01:04:36,350 --> 01:04:38,350
this instant settlement.

583
01:04:38,350 --> 01:04:42,090
And if you think about it, the only, you can't really own equity in your government.

584
01:04:42,090 --> 01:04:46,370
You can, you can own your, owning dollars is kind of like owning stock in your, in the

585
01:04:46,370 --> 01:04:48,430
United States government.

586
01:04:48,430 --> 01:05:06,560
And if you had a choice you would never purchase that stock because all it does is go down It never Yeah It has you know minor periods where it goes up a little bit and then just it on this just sliding scale a ski soap ski soap black down

587
01:05:06,560 --> 01:05:29,019
Um, the different you, the difference with these tech companies is you can participate in that. If you believe in what, uh, the benefit that, uh, meta or Amazon or, um, Tesla are providing to the world, you can own that. And by the way, you don't need to believe in it to benefit from it.

588
01:05:29,019 --> 01:05:45,999
And that's something that's really important with distinguishing the difference between a fiat system and a bearer system and a true hard money system, which is that fiat means it exists because we say it exists.

589
01:05:45,999 --> 01:05:53,860
And so when we stop believing in that thing, then tiers law takes over. That money's gone. It just literally has no value.

590
01:05:53,860 --> 01:06:08,640
You see the pictures in Venezuela of streets filled with swaths of currency, you know, just as though like out in western Kansas, you see ditches that are filled with tumbleweeds.

591
01:06:08,640 --> 01:06:15,979
Imagine that the tumbleweeds were instead massive mounds of loose hundred dollar bills.

592
01:06:15,979 --> 01:06:24,100
that has happened in Venezuela. That's happened in, um, um, in Turkey. That's happened in Zaire,

593
01:06:24,100 --> 01:06:31,280
like Zimbabwe, it's happened in so many different countries. It's only a matter of time. 4,000

594
01:06:31,280 --> 01:06:37,180
fiat currencies have existed. Only 160 are left. Every single one of them has lost 99% of its

595
01:06:37,180 --> 01:06:43,420
value. There's not, there's no such thing as a fiat currency that survives because it is a

596
01:06:43,420 --> 01:06:49,940
belief-based system. You have to believe in it. And eventually you stop believing in the thing

597
01:06:49,940 --> 01:06:56,519
that is killing you. And so you move to something that it is a distinction that needs to be made,

598
01:06:56,519 --> 01:07:03,200
is that you don't need to believe in technology for it to serve you, which is fantastic.

599
01:07:04,200 --> 01:07:08,560
It gives power back to the people, provides them an opportunity to

600
01:07:08,560 --> 01:07:15,140
to have some self-sovereignty over their existence, which wasn't there before.

601
01:07:15,260 --> 01:07:16,019
And it does, yeah.

602
01:07:16,780 --> 01:07:18,920
It draws power away from the government.

603
01:07:18,920 --> 01:07:31,519
It is weird to think about it because what Biden was trying to do was emulate Dwight D. Eisenhower's military industrial complex warning.

604
01:07:31,600 --> 01:07:32,040
For sure.

605
01:07:32,040 --> 01:07:59,060
Um, which is just kind of, I mean, on the surface, you can look at those two things and you can call them somewhat similar. Um, the difference though, is that Meta and Tesla and Amazon, they don't have private military corporations. They don't kill people. They don't start wars. They don't have the ability to wage war.

606
01:07:59,060 --> 01:08:14,200
You know, the military industrial complex is it's as powerful as our military, if not more, because it has the it's not handcuffed to any sort of restrictions that that the government is.

607
01:08:14,200 --> 01:08:21,280
And so I said, yeah, I just I found it pretty laughable to hear, you know, what I would consider.

608
01:08:21,419 --> 01:08:26,300
And and this is not I don't this is not a condemnation condemnation of the person.

609
01:08:26,300 --> 01:08:31,740
I think this is a I hope this is kind of an objective analysis of what we've seen.

610
01:08:32,220 --> 01:08:48,140
The leader of what appears to have been the most corrupted, compromised administration in history who was incapable.

611
01:08:48,140 --> 01:08:59,820
I mean, you go back, what, eight months, and he was found incapable to stand trial when they brought charges against him for having classified documents at his house.

612
01:08:59,820 --> 01:09:20,140
They basically like, it's kind of a, you know, it was this fork in the road where it was like, he's either capable of standing trial, which means that he knows what he did. He knows he's a criminal or he's incapable of standing trial, which means he's senile, which means that the guy who controls the nuclear stockpile, um, doesn't know how to tie his shoes and that's not good.

613
01:09:20,140 --> 01:09:32,600
And so, I don't know. Yeah, it's it's it's it's hilarious because it's like it just it shows the power of trying to copy someone else's approach.

614
01:09:33,120 --> 01:09:39,640
Because if you're if you're just looking at it on the surface level, then you're going to think, oh, yeah, this is just like Dwight D. Eisenhower.

615
01:09:39,859 --> 01:09:43,560
The tech complex is just as bad as the military industrial complex.

616
01:09:44,240 --> 01:09:48,540
Forgetting that the military industrial complex only serves the government.

617
01:09:48,540 --> 01:09:53,060
The tech complex only serves the government so that it can serve the people.

618
01:09:54,240 --> 01:10:06,320
I think you brought that up and noted that really well, which is that they have to have these relationships with the government to stay on their good side because otherwise they would be hacked and chopped up into little pieces.

619
01:10:06,320 --> 01:10:10,820
Right. So the military has a more essential, inextricable connection to government.

620
01:10:10,820 --> 01:10:15,700
tech's connection to the government right now is more contingent on the historical situation

621
01:10:15,700 --> 01:10:21,340
where you need to be close to government to be close to the money printer so it's not to me

622
01:10:21,340 --> 01:10:28,260
it's yeah definitely i mean i i guess i'm still pretty skeptical of tech i i do i hope that we

623
01:10:28,260 --> 01:10:36,800
maintain a skepticism of um potential god kings in the form of you know large software providers

624
01:10:36,800 --> 01:10:46,899
And as we've talked about in the past, the software thesis is a way that Bitcoin can tie down the digital realm and make it more computation costly.

625
01:10:47,800 --> 01:10:52,080
There's actually a tie-in to this chapter right here.

626
01:10:53,780 --> 01:10:55,240
Let's see if I can find it.

627
01:10:55,240 --> 01:11:10,040
Alden talks about, she has Sailor's quote about energy, about, I mean, the basic idea is that in the digital realm as it currently exists, nothing is costly.

628
01:11:10,760 --> 01:11:14,040
And so you can copy and paste anything over and over again.

629
01:11:14,040 --> 01:11:32,320
We're all familiar with what spam is. We're all familiar with what spammed comments are. Trolls are like troll farms where it's not somebody having a negative opinion. It's an orchestrated negative opinion by somebody who has a political goal. I'm coordinating a bunch of commentators.

630
01:11:32,320 --> 01:11:43,540
All these types of things, if you can make computation costly through some proof of work mechanism where real world energy has to be expended.

631
01:11:43,540 --> 01:12:03,760
I think Alden maybe mentions this in the context of micropayments, which is a use case enabled by Bitcoin through an additional layer like the Lightning Network, where transactions like a hundredth of a cent can be enabled in a way that, of course, currently they cannot through our credit card system.

632
01:12:03,760 --> 01:12:15,260
And then microtransactions are going to lead to new emergent use cases protecting us from spam because you can require people to pay you a fraction of a cent to send you a message.

633
01:12:15,260 --> 01:12:44,260
And so, yeah, I guess I wanted to just note that we can maintain our skepticism of software providers and also that can reinforce our conviction that Bitcoin decentralized, permissionless is a way to tie the internet down and hopefully provide a neutral jumping off point for an internet where we are not constantly controlled by other people.

634
01:12:44,260 --> 01:12:51,260
So, yeah, I mean, I think your distinction there is good, military-industrial, different than tech-industrial, but still maintain some skepticism.

635
01:12:51,480 --> 01:12:53,220
We all should towards that tech element.

636
01:12:53,959 --> 01:13:00,660
I think I'll take a slightly different view, which is to say that all technology should be viewed agnostic.

637
01:13:01,280 --> 01:13:07,040
It is a tool, and in the hands of someone using it for good, it's a tool.

638
01:13:07,440 --> 01:13:10,120
That's a hammer, and I'm using a hammer to pound in nails.

639
01:13:10,359 --> 01:13:13,240
In the hands of someone with bad intent, it's a weapon.

640
01:13:13,240 --> 01:13:18,440
it's a hammer and I'm using it to bash your skull. And I have a, I have a high school classmate.

641
01:13:19,100 --> 01:13:23,459
This is, I, uh, this is, this is a little departure, but I think it's funny in third

642
01:13:23,459 --> 01:13:29,540
grade. Uh, there was this kid who was a classmate of mine and he was really quiet. He was really

643
01:13:29,540 --> 01:13:36,800
shy. He was on my baseball team. And, um, he, he was just, uh, very timid, um, when he stepped up

644
01:13:36,800 --> 01:13:42,080
to the plate and a couple of times, my mom was always late picking me up for, for baseball

645
01:13:42,080 --> 01:13:47,520
practice. And so a couple of times I would stay after and I taught him, um, I taught him how to

646
01:13:47,520 --> 01:13:51,499
swing and I taught him how not to be afraid of the ball. And he, he did a little better. He,

647
01:13:51,680 --> 01:13:57,919
you know, he definitely got better. And then, um, 10 years later, he gets convicted of beating

648
01:13:57,919 --> 01:14:05,580
his stepdad to death with a baseball bat. So yeah, the teacher has exceed or the pupil has

649
01:14:05,580 --> 01:14:11,060
exceeded the teacher. Now he has something to teach you. Yeah. I guess I hammer too. I think

650
01:14:11,060 --> 01:14:13,140
I think they call him Jimmy the Hammer in jail now.

651
01:14:13,419 --> 01:14:15,200
Oh, no, that's quite the thing.

652
01:14:15,480 --> 01:14:22,340
Yeah, but anyway, I mean, it's just, I had given this kind of, I put up this video a long time ago.

653
01:14:22,580 --> 01:14:27,120
I think I took it down too, but comparing and contrasting myself and my brother-in-law.

654
01:14:27,300 --> 01:14:29,080
My brother-in-law is a special forces soldier.

655
01:14:29,340 --> 01:14:33,499
He was a weapons sergeant, and now he's promoted even higher.

656
01:14:34,200 --> 01:14:36,540
And a gun in his hands is a tool.

657
01:14:36,959 --> 01:14:38,359
A gun in my hands is a weapon.

658
01:14:38,359 --> 01:14:57,940
And there's, it's the exact same technology. It's no different. But it is all about your ability to, to use something with, with knowledge. You know, if I have this saying, like, if you own something and you don't know how to use it, it owns you.

659
01:14:57,940 --> 01:15:03,959
you know, there's always going to be this cognitive friction that exists between you and that thing

660
01:15:03,959 --> 01:15:10,160
that is a burden upon you because there will always be this, oh, I haven't set up my sound

661
01:15:10,160 --> 01:15:15,120
system. I haven't set up my, you know, I've set up my surround sound. I've got this carburetor to

662
01:15:15,120 --> 01:15:19,600
put on the car, but I don't know how to do it yet. And there's always this mental cognitive friction

663
01:15:19,600 --> 01:15:27,300
that lays upon you, which is why I believe in not minimalization, but in maximizing your

664
01:15:27,300 --> 01:15:33,280
ability to use the things around you so that you don't have to have additional things where

665
01:15:33,280 --> 01:15:41,359
we all have like nine different things that each do the exact same thing, but we only use each of

666
01:15:41,359 --> 01:15:47,399
them for one specific purpose. Like my phone does everything, but I have an iPad. My iPad does

667
01:15:47,399 --> 01:15:52,819
everything, but I have a laptop. My, I mean, technically my smart TV does everything. I can

668
01:15:52,819 --> 01:15:59,560
hook up a keyboard to it. And, but I have all of these other devices. And so, you know, we end up

669
01:15:59,560 --> 01:16:07,260
only exploring maybe one tiny percent of what we can do with any tool and then jumping to something

670
01:16:07,260 --> 01:16:16,200
else because the, the cost of entry to get 1% in is so easy, but the cost of entry to get a hundred

671
01:16:16,200 --> 01:16:21,840
percent in and truly become an expert, uh, takes a lot, you know, being a guitar player is like that.

672
01:16:21,840 --> 01:16:40,140
Yeah, well, I just, we can depart from the tech industrial point after this, but I would say that tech is not neutral in the sense when it is a specific iteration of tech. For example, zeros and ones, neutral. Computation, neutral. Facebook, not neutral.

673
01:16:40,140 --> 01:16:50,720
You know, what Facebook is, it's a one way mirror where you sit in front of it, narcissistically admire your own image, think that this profile is you, all of these things are you.

674
01:16:51,020 --> 01:17:04,200
There's a man behind that one way mirror, writing down everything that you do, and then using that to engage in predictive and model modeling processes that can be sold to advertisers and politicians that can be used to influence you.

675
01:17:04,200 --> 01:17:32,999
So tech, telecommunications, neutral, the things that the additional iterations of that tech and that are various corporate entities using that tech, those are not neutral. The tech industrial complex, again, that is specific individuals with specific products. And these products want you to perceive them as neutral, as merely things you can interact with or not. But they're not. They're asymmetrically designed to extract value from you inherently.

676
01:17:32,999 --> 01:17:42,160
So if Facebook – okay, so it also is the tool that enables the overthrow of oppressive governments like the Arab Spring.

677
01:17:42,319 --> 01:17:52,780
So my question then would be if Facebook was instead of a centralized application and it was a decentralized protocol, then would it be neutral?

678
01:17:54,160 --> 01:17:56,160
Maybe that's not the tech industrial complex.

679
01:17:56,160 --> 01:18:01,140
Other iterations of technology, if they're completely transparent and open source, you can look at the code.

680
01:18:01,140 --> 01:18:07,700
anybody can add to them, then that's a different thing than our currently monetized tech industrial

681
01:18:07,700 --> 01:18:12,980
complex, I would say for sure. Yeah. So I'll, I'll, by the way, I will, I will make a prediction

682
01:18:12,980 --> 01:18:19,780
that I'm 100% positive will come true, which is that somebody is going to open source a Facebook

683
01:18:19,780 --> 01:18:27,380
and, um, somebody is going to open source, um, a Google and somebody is going to open source an

684
01:18:27,380 --> 01:18:36,840
Instagram, et cetera, because just like Google did with the Android platform, you know, the story.

685
01:18:37,140 --> 01:18:44,020
So Apple creates the iPhone, which has the iOS operating system, which is beautiful and seamless

686
01:18:44,020 --> 01:18:52,020
and whatever, but it's closed. Google realizing that they're falling vastly behind in the smartphone

687
01:18:52,020 --> 01:18:59,160
own game knows that it's not really worth it to create their own closed operating system.

688
01:18:59,680 --> 01:19:05,480
And so what do they do? They buy Android and then open source it, which was a operating system.

689
01:19:05,700 --> 01:19:10,899
They open source it and then they say, all right, we're going to compete with you in hardware.

690
01:19:11,780 --> 01:19:17,999
So you just move the playing field. Alden gives the example, by the way, of Kodak.

691
01:19:17,999 --> 01:19:25,180
when Kodak, um, they actually creates, they create a website and they have this website

692
01:19:25,180 --> 01:19:29,280
that says, you know, Hey, this is a great place for you to print and share your photos.

693
01:19:29,459 --> 01:19:36,720
And they completely miss that. That's the opportunity that, um, the digital photo was

694
01:19:36,720 --> 01:19:44,319
the opportunity and they needed to abandon their, um, attempts to maintain control over the physical

695
01:19:44,319 --> 01:19:50,840
photo, you know, you have to be able to move. And so, yeah, I just, everything collapses to a zero

696
01:19:50,840 --> 01:19:57,100
point cost. Everything will be decentralized and open source. It may, you know, it may just be some

697
01:19:57,100 --> 01:20:03,580
drunk engineer from meta that's pissed off at Mark Zuckerberg for whipping his ass and BJJ

698
01:20:03,580 --> 01:20:07,560
goes home and says, Oh, you know what, here we go. We're going to upload this source code.

699
01:20:07,780 --> 01:20:11,959
Yeah. Now we've decentralized it and every developer around the world can add to it.

700
01:20:11,959 --> 01:20:16,020
And then we have a Facebook core, just like we have a Bitcoin core.

701
01:20:16,720 --> 01:20:19,800
I don't think we're just one drunk engineer away.

702
01:20:19,859 --> 01:20:20,740
I think there's higher barriers.

703
01:20:20,919 --> 01:20:34,480
But I think we can look at this in the context of the chapter that in the discussion of proof of stake versus proof of work, this is a discussion about the future as partially centralized versus decentralized.

704
01:20:35,180 --> 01:20:39,280
And Alden is very open-minded in this chapter.

705
01:20:39,280 --> 01:20:57,480
She notes, I mean, she says, comes out conclusively, Bitcoin proof of work wins conclusively, conclusively, hands down as robust money because of its decentralized nature and that the proof of work being using energy as an arbiter of truth.

706
01:20:57,680 --> 01:21:07,520
So Bitcoin wins money, but that still leaves open potential other use cases for what she calls partially decentralized proof of stake systems.

707
01:21:07,520 --> 01:21:31,359
So I'll read two quotes, and I think this will lead to a question. If a database is controlled to some extent by a central organization, but it is open source and it is designed in such a way that its contents can be independently backed up and audited in real time by certain high-performance external nodes, does that concept have an addressable market?

708
01:21:31,359 --> 01:21:50,580
So centralized by a central organization, but they open source and they – I think it's maybe what you're describing with this rogue and inebriated Facebook engineer maybe creating a centralized thing he's going to profit from, but open sourcing it, designing it in a way that it can be independently verified, making it transparent and auditable.

709
01:21:51,459 --> 01:21:54,160
Are there use cases for that?

710
01:21:55,740 --> 01:21:58,359
Before I move on to the second quote, I'll just toss that to you.

711
01:21:58,380 --> 01:21:58,859
What do you think?

712
01:21:58,859 --> 01:22:06,700
this is android this is the android example um so we're we're going to take a

713
01:22:06,700 --> 01:22:13,240
decentralized protocol and we're going to sit on top of it by kind of building

714
01:22:13,240 --> 01:22:20,520
um building an environment sort of on top of it with google phones and um and google products

715
01:22:20,520 --> 01:22:32,380
And what we're going to do then is water the creativity of the world and let it flourish.

716
01:22:32,380 --> 01:22:46,120
Because, you know, what's better than having all the smartest developers and engineers at Google work on your operating system?

717
01:22:46,120 --> 01:22:52,120
It's having all of the smartest developers and engineers in the world work on your operating system.

718
01:22:52,499 --> 01:23:03,780
I love hearing how Elon Musk breaks down why it's important that we correct falling birth rates.

719
01:23:04,540 --> 01:23:05,380
It's very simple.

720
01:23:06,020 --> 01:23:07,480
There are problems in the world.

721
01:23:08,120 --> 01:23:09,340
Humans solve problems.

722
01:23:10,340 --> 01:23:13,580
The more humans we have, the more problems we can solve.

723
01:23:13,580 --> 01:23:21,660
the fewer humans we have the less chances we have to solve those problems and so it just goes back to

724
01:23:21,660 --> 01:23:30,120
decentralized versus centralized decentralized wins every time every time you know well every

725
01:23:30,120 --> 01:23:36,700
time i mean and it's it may be a long tail but it will eventually win and so you don't again it's

726
01:23:36,700 --> 01:23:47,260
Like you don't have to believe in the power of a handgun to keep you safe, but it exists and therefore it will.

727
01:23:48,459 --> 01:23:49,180
And so, yeah.

728
01:23:49,800 --> 01:23:50,840
So here's a use case.

729
01:23:51,020 --> 01:23:55,040
Maybe this is reconcilable with decentralization winning.

730
01:23:55,040 --> 01:24:04,300
This is a use case that Alden speculates on for partially decentralized proof of stake systems.

731
01:24:04,300 --> 01:24:16,660
So she says, quote, what if everyone in a community could invest in a new startup restaurant nearby in exchange for some equity token that gives them a share of profits or discounts or perks for frequent patronage?

732
01:24:16,780 --> 01:24:19,319
This fits well with the hard money world.

733
01:24:19,319 --> 01:24:21,480
So we can imagine that Bitcoin succeeds, right?

734
01:24:21,480 --> 01:24:38,380
If most things are equity finance rather than debt finance, shouldn't it be easier via technology for even small entities, which we centralized as an entity, right, to issue startup equity and to be able to use that equity as collateral when needed?

735
01:24:38,380 --> 01:24:46,959
yeah the example i think of right now is you are seeing a decentralization of the meat packing

736
01:24:46,959 --> 01:24:56,399
industry where we have four major meat packers that control the industry with an iron fist and

737
01:24:56,399 --> 01:25:06,319
in times of in times of need and in times of crisis um you really see how they abuse the power

738
01:25:06,319 --> 01:25:15,740
four or five years ago there was a fire at one of the plants and as a result they basically

739
01:25:15,740 --> 01:25:21,760
undercut the bid to everyone and so oh you know there's this one plant it no longer has the

740
01:25:21,760 --> 01:25:26,620
capacity and it took like i don't know it took like five percent of the capacity offline or

741
01:25:26,620 --> 01:25:32,240
something but in a day the prices that they were paying to producers dropped by like 40 percent

742
01:25:32,240 --> 01:25:47,840
You know, it's just a profit grab to take advantage. And so as a result, what we're seeing is a proliferation of these community individual owned abattoirs. Abattoir is a French word for meat butcher.

743
01:25:47,840 --> 01:25:55,919
Um, so people are taking back their ability to, um, control their own food supply and

744
01:25:55,919 --> 01:25:57,880
they're doing it in a, in a local way.

745
01:25:57,880 --> 01:26:03,560
And by the way, one of the fascinating things that I've been listening to is, um, this Jack

746
01:26:03,560 --> 01:26:08,200
Cruz who talks about the importance of eating.

747
01:26:08,200 --> 01:26:13,140
Like we've always, we've always been told that eating local food is better for you because

748
01:26:13,140 --> 01:26:20,340
it doesn't travel so far and get exposed to different things along the way.

749
01:26:21,740 --> 01:26:28,080
But hearing some of the science behind it, I'm really truly convinced that there's a

750
01:26:28,080 --> 01:26:30,020
definite reason why you should eat local food.

751
01:26:30,340 --> 01:26:35,919
Right now, the average food product that the United States citizen eats travels, I think

752
01:26:35,919 --> 01:26:38,899
it's 1,400 miles on average to get to you.

753
01:26:38,899 --> 01:26:54,160
If you have some grapes and you have an orange and then you have some pork sausage, those things effectively traveled half of the way across the country in order to get to you, bringing with them contaminants and everything that they're exposed to along the way.

754
01:26:54,160 --> 01:27:01,940
And also not being exposed to the contaminants in your area, which would build you up a natural immunity.

755
01:27:01,940 --> 01:27:18,520
So there's so many knock-on effects of the ability to crowdfund and maintain a consistent supply of resources.

756
01:27:19,200 --> 01:27:30,160
And it also decreases the need for massive transportation networks that if you travel on interstate, we saw this on the way back from Florida.

757
01:27:30,160 --> 01:27:35,840
if you're driving past a rest stop at three o'clock in the morning, there's 400 semis lined up there.

758
01:27:36,419 --> 01:27:43,859
And it's just insane the amount of over the road freight that we have, because what we've done is

759
01:27:43,859 --> 01:27:49,959
we have effectively cordoned off parts of our country. This is the part where the fruit comes

760
01:27:49,959 --> 01:27:54,060
from. This is the part where the wheat comes from. This is the part where the beef comes from. This

761
01:27:54,060 --> 01:27:59,620
is the part where the almonds come from. And we forget that you go back a hundred years in Kansas,

762
01:27:59,620 --> 01:28:05,760
had, it was like the number one, two or three producer of wine in the United States. They had

763
01:28:05,760 --> 01:28:13,240
almonds, they had orchards, they had everything. You raise your own fruit and people were healthier.

764
01:28:13,240 --> 01:28:19,180
You know, people didn't get cancer, people didn't get autism. There is a line to be drawn there.

765
01:28:19,399 --> 01:28:25,220
And I'm really interested in exploring how that benefits us. And I think any sort of

766
01:28:25,220 --> 01:28:31,999
decentralized technology allows for the further proliferation of resiliency, anti-fragility,

767
01:28:31,999 --> 01:28:38,120
and self-sovereignty, and moving us closer and closer to being stronger as individuals,

768
01:28:38,319 --> 01:28:41,840
which makes us stronger as communities, which makes us stronger as a world.

769
01:28:42,819 --> 01:28:43,300
Yeah, yeah.

770
01:28:43,440 --> 01:28:43,620
No.

771
01:28:44,040 --> 01:28:44,999
That was a hell of a rant.

772
01:28:45,100 --> 01:28:45,340
I'm sorry.

773
01:28:45,419 --> 01:28:46,959
I ran through all kinds of shit there.

774
01:28:47,480 --> 01:28:54,399
I mean, Alden does leave it as an open-ended question whether equity tokens can be issued

775
01:28:54,399 --> 01:28:55,419
by small businesses

776
01:28:55,419 --> 01:28:57,520
and whether that might be something

777
01:28:57,520 --> 01:28:59,999
that proof of stake chains

778
01:28:59,999 --> 01:29:01,080
could help us,

779
01:29:01,380 --> 01:29:02,100
could enable.

780
01:29:02,260 --> 01:29:03,520
We can think like Ethereum

781
01:29:03,520 --> 01:29:06,180
and Base and Solana.

782
01:29:06,359 --> 01:29:07,240
Those are often used

783
01:29:07,240 --> 01:29:08,359
as jumping off points

784
01:29:08,359 --> 01:29:10,280
for the creation of like meme coins

785
01:29:10,280 --> 01:29:12,060
and other types of utility,

786
01:29:12,280 --> 01:29:13,319
quote unquote, tokens.

787
01:29:13,999 --> 01:29:15,080
So less anybody thinks

788
01:29:15,080 --> 01:29:17,020
that Alden is some inveterate shitcoin

789
01:29:17,020 --> 01:29:17,600
or one, I mean,

790
01:29:17,620 --> 01:29:18,459
that is just speculative.

791
01:29:18,640 --> 01:29:19,180
And I think that

792
01:29:19,180 --> 01:29:20,700
that's a conversation worth having.

793
01:29:20,780 --> 01:29:21,160
What does it mean

794
01:29:21,160 --> 01:29:22,560
to tokenize real world assets?

795
01:29:22,800 --> 01:29:23,240
What does it mean

796
01:29:23,240 --> 01:29:24,340
to allow people to

797
01:29:24,399 --> 01:29:29,780
um individuals maybe even or businesses to issue their own equity i mean it takes a specific legal

798
01:29:29,780 --> 01:29:36,580
framework but it takes a specific technology and we can say that bitcoin is superior robust money

799
01:29:36,580 --> 01:29:43,899
um while you know having the conversation was will a proof of stake or another layer on the

800
01:29:43,899 --> 01:29:49,720
proof of work protocol on bitcoin which of those is maybe going to be best for tokenizing real

801
01:29:49,720 --> 01:29:54,060
world assets maybe we'll read something on that in the future but so just less than anybody though

802
01:29:54,060 --> 01:29:59,060
think that Alden is doing any more than speculating. She does offer the critique or note that the

803
01:29:59,060 --> 01:30:05,800
problem with these often is that you have venture capitalists and early developers dumping low

804
01:30:05,800 --> 01:30:12,060
quality unregistered crypto products on retail investors. In the past, a venture capitalist

805
01:30:12,060 --> 01:30:17,899
might have to lock up capital for a certain amount of time, five to 10 years before exit

806
01:30:17,899 --> 01:30:23,120
liquidity develops to the go public, they get the money or they're purchased by a larger company.

807
01:30:23,120 --> 01:30:45,760
When a VC issues a meme coin, they get the immediate exit liquidity because retail comes in and buys it. And so it leads to dumping venture capitalists, dumping coins that they have no conviction in on retail. So she does offer that critique, but I do think it's, I guess, an open question as to what use cases there might be.

808
01:30:45,760 --> 01:30:49,040
And I'll just quote Alden to summarize that whole debate.

809
01:30:50,060 --> 01:30:59,740
In other words, just like how the internet made it easier for people to produce and distribute their own books and songs, smart contracts made it easier for people to produce and distribute their own financial assets.

810
01:30:59,899 --> 01:31:07,180
And so whatever you think is going to be the base layer for smart contracts, that's cool.

811
01:31:07,660 --> 01:31:09,620
And I just want to check, Lucas, am I still recording?

812
01:31:09,859 --> 01:31:10,660
Am I storing my data?

813
01:31:10,700 --> 01:31:14,999
I'm getting a message that says my phone data is run up, but is it still uptaking?

814
01:31:15,740 --> 01:31:16,999
I think you're just fine.

815
01:31:17,140 --> 01:31:18,160
Yeah, as far as I can tell.

816
01:31:18,600 --> 01:31:18,800
Yep.

817
01:31:18,940 --> 01:31:19,300
Okay.

818
01:31:19,640 --> 01:31:22,359
I'm not positive, but yeah, we should be good.

819
01:31:23,100 --> 01:31:23,419
Yeah.

820
01:31:23,859 --> 01:31:26,560
It's because I never delete anything off my phone.

821
01:31:26,819 --> 01:31:29,200
So like zero free RAM.

822
01:31:29,640 --> 01:31:31,440
So to move the discussion on though.

823
01:31:31,840 --> 01:31:32,459
Hold on.

824
01:31:32,760 --> 01:31:33,760
Can I address that real quick?

825
01:31:33,780 --> 01:31:34,340
Yeah, yeah, for sure.

826
01:31:34,660 --> 01:31:36,520
So meme coins are not bad.

827
01:31:36,819 --> 01:31:40,140
Meme coins are a tool that can be abused.

828
01:31:40,140 --> 01:31:41,700
They can also be used for good.

829
01:31:41,700 --> 01:32:00,640
And the reason why there is a specific legal framework around issuing securities is that it is a way of cordoning off the unclean and the unwashed masses from being able to participate in the beginning of something great.

830
01:32:00,640 --> 01:32:18,020
You know, in order to participate in all these early rounds of financing of venture capitalist companies and, you know, you and I literally could not be early investors in Meta or Tesla or Google or Amazon or anything like that because we're not accredited investors.

831
01:32:18,020 --> 01:32:33,720
And by the way, to become accredited investor, the point is that it's supposed to keep people who are uninformed out of the market. That's the saying that you're doing good.

832
01:32:33,720 --> 01:32:41,640
The doing evil part is that all it does is it provides a monetary barrier that you have to overcome.

833
01:32:41,940 --> 01:32:45,260
$250,000 worth of income and a million dollars worth of assets.

834
01:32:45,640 --> 01:32:54,720
If you don't have that, then we as a legal regulatory framework say that you're too stupid to know that you can invest in something.

835
01:32:54,720 --> 01:33:04,440
And that is just a barrier put up in order to keep ties close to keep power into the people that have it.

836
01:33:04,899 --> 01:33:07,620
So there's a flip side of what meme coins are.

837
01:33:08,720 --> 01:33:15,240
And I was thinking about this because we are on the heels four days, I think, since Trump launched the Trump coin.

838
01:33:15,819 --> 01:33:19,580
And I was thinking about it because there was this horrible backlash.

839
01:33:19,700 --> 01:33:22,399
Everybody hates it, calls him a shit coin or says it's the worst thing ever.

840
01:33:22,399 --> 01:33:40,280
What I'm thinking is that this is the beginning of a direct approval disapproval process of individuals where we just realized with Polymarket coming online that betting is a far more accurate poll than polls.

841
01:33:41,080 --> 01:33:44,380
And what's more accurate than betting?

842
01:33:44,600 --> 01:33:48,540
It's having literally owning stock in an individual.

843
01:33:48,540 --> 01:33:51,740
If I disapprove of your ideas, I'm going to sell your stock.

844
01:33:51,740 --> 01:34:11,300
If I approve of your ideas, I'm going to buy your stock. And so this to me is the kind of the nth state of crowdfunding or raising funds as an individual without having to go through an approval process that is meant to exclude people that are poor.

845
01:34:11,300 --> 01:34:28,880
I view all these frameworks as like, I can't remember who said it, but it's the, it's the, these frameworks were put in place to look good while doing bad by people who don't hate or who don't love the rich.

846
01:34:28,880 --> 01:34:35,880
they hate the poor. And I think it's a way to just keep people down. And when we allow people

847
01:34:35,880 --> 01:34:41,919
to participate in these markets individually, yes, you're going to see people get rugged. Yes,

848
01:34:41,940 --> 01:34:48,140
you're going to see that 100%. And then you'll just learn to take responsibility for your own

849
01:34:48,140 --> 01:34:52,959
actions. The problem is that we are so divorced from taking responsibility for our own actions.

850
01:34:52,959 --> 01:35:10,480
Most people that are multimillionaires will never make a trade on their own. They'll never make a decision on their own. They outsource all of that information to someone who takes a massive cut for doing far worse at their job than you and I have done simply by buying Bitcoin.

851
01:35:10,480 --> 01:35:17,760
so yeah i i don't think that that so i was not endorsing securities law i don't think alden is

852
01:35:17,760 --> 01:35:22,480
either you can say people should be allowed to buy whatever shit coin they want without

853
01:35:22,480 --> 01:35:26,999
celebrating the grifters and the rug pullers that launch the coins i think meme coins may measure

854
01:35:26,999 --> 01:35:31,700
some type of sentiment but they demonstrably do not measure approval ratings because trump's

855
01:35:31,700 --> 01:35:37,459
approval rating did not shoot up and then shoot way down um the barometer is tied to some sort of

856
01:35:37,459 --> 01:35:39,600
Pure market speculation.

857
01:35:40,140 --> 01:35:40,740
That's okay.

858
01:35:41,120 --> 01:35:59,540
But what you're doing there, that's inherently flawed because you're taking the system that we know to be false, which is a poll, and using it to say, because the thing that we know is false doesn't change with the new thing.

859
01:35:59,540 --> 01:36:02,120
Then, of course, the new thing can't be a reflective barometer.

860
01:36:02,120 --> 01:36:04,720
I'm commemorating it to Colesia and Polymarket.

861
01:36:04,720 --> 01:36:07,580
I think Kalshi and Pauly Market are good barometers.

862
01:36:07,760 --> 01:36:08,419
I'm not talking about Poland.

863
01:36:08,580 --> 01:36:14,100
Kalshi and Pauly Market, ways where people put skin in the game by betting on outcomes explicitly.

864
01:36:14,419 --> 01:36:15,419
Kalshi is not Pauly Market.

865
01:36:15,899 --> 01:36:17,780
These are like predictive markets.

866
01:36:18,819 --> 01:36:20,940
And so not even endorsing those specific ones.

867
01:36:20,980 --> 01:36:26,800
Just the idea of a predictive market where you explicitly bet on an outcome by putting money in the game and it pays out if you're correct.

868
01:36:27,180 --> 01:36:28,440
Meme coins don't do that.

869
01:36:28,440 --> 01:36:41,380
They're a proxy for some type of sentiment, but that sentiment is meme coin quants who are speculating on – they're modeling other meme coin buyers and sellers when they're selling and buying the coin.

870
01:36:41,499 --> 01:36:43,260
They're thinking, what are other people going to do?

871
01:36:44,040 --> 01:36:48,060
They're not thinking, is decision-making good or bad right now?

872
01:36:48,280 --> 01:36:54,700
I think people didn't start disapproving of Trump when the Melania coin was issued, and yet the Melania coin causes the Trump coin to go way down.

873
01:36:54,700 --> 01:36:57,859
It's people speculating on meme coin market dynamics.

874
01:36:57,859 --> 01:37:02,359
And so it's this really insular, incestual type of speculation.

875
01:37:02,660 --> 01:37:04,800
And again, I don't necessarily think that should be illegal.

876
01:37:05,140 --> 01:37:28,009
I just don think we should celebrate the rug pullers and the grifters by saying they have some enlightened function as barometers of public opinion where what they measuring is their ability to model other shitcoiters intentionality or whatever You can judge it on the first four days I can judge whatever I want So Alden makes this point by the way about Bitcoin is that you can judge the strength of

877
01:37:28,009 --> 01:37:34,969
Bitcoin and its ability to do its job as a long-term store of value during its stage of infancy,

878
01:37:34,969 --> 01:37:40,089
because it simply doesn't have the liquidity. It simply doesn't have the number of market

879
01:37:40,089 --> 01:37:46,509
participants involved in it in order to accomplish that thing. It is there. We know that it's going to

880
01:37:46,509 --> 01:37:53,529
do that if it gains the network effect. And so, yeah, in the first four days of Trump coin being

881
01:37:53,529 --> 01:37:58,149
announced and then Melania coin, yes, of course, there's going to be volatility because we have not

882
01:37:58,149 --> 01:38:04,709
put in the amount of liquidity into that market in order to make it stable. But once those things

883
01:38:04,709 --> 01:38:12,890
are stable, and once there is that liquidity, then I do think that that is a direct barometer.

884
01:38:13,489 --> 01:38:21,489
And it's not a direct barometer. So polymarket is like specific outcomes. The meme coin would be

885
01:38:21,489 --> 01:38:27,790
like cultural sentiment of all outcomes. Do I approve of all the things?

886
01:38:28,330 --> 01:38:31,949
But why approve though? Why is that the thing? I mean, why is it the outcome tied to approval

887
01:38:31,949 --> 01:38:35,690
or disapprove you could buy a meme coin of something you disapprove of to mock that thing

888
01:38:35,690 --> 01:38:42,509
correct yeah yeah yeah and and you will see people that do that but um i don't think that that's going

889
01:38:42,509 --> 01:38:49,169
to be the majority of it i think that the i think that the majority of people um you know

890
01:38:49,169 --> 01:38:54,870
i think if porn i don't i don't think it is i don't think porn i think it's desired it's just

891
01:38:54,870 --> 01:39:01,749
like like brute naked desire to be quickly rich and like what a meme coin measures is it's

892
01:39:01,749 --> 01:39:07,730
absolutely transparent meme coin measures the memetics of a phenomena the ability of a thought

893
01:39:07,730 --> 01:39:13,509
pattern to quickly reproduce itself in other neocortices and like that's what it measures is

894
01:39:13,509 --> 01:39:18,449
the transmission of a thought not the approval good or bad of a thought but the transmission

895
01:39:18,449 --> 01:39:24,609
of a thought and the memetics of trump coin i think are related to like people speculating on

896
01:39:24,609 --> 01:39:31,049
the meme is what are the market predictive market dynamics of this very meme it's just like so

897
01:39:31,049 --> 01:39:37,350
recursive and like looking inside itself to like model the minds of somebody else who is also

898
01:39:37,350 --> 01:39:41,310
looking inside itself maybe that's too deep in the meme coins for something i know nothing about but

899
01:39:41,310 --> 01:39:47,770
yeah i'm not saying it's approval of like the ethics i'm saying it's approval of the value like

900
01:39:47,770 --> 01:39:52,690
i'm not going to put i mean the profit incentive is there i'm not going to put my money in this

901
01:39:52,690 --> 01:39:56,850
thing unless I believe that it's going to go up. But what makes me believe that it's going to go up

902
01:39:56,850 --> 01:40:03,649
is that the underlying asset is going to gain value. Do I believe that the underlying,

903
01:40:04,249 --> 01:40:11,370
do I believe right now, looking at the actions that have been initiated by the new administration

904
01:40:11,370 --> 01:40:17,810
in the first two days, do I believe that long-term that there is going to be value creation based off

905
01:40:17,810 --> 01:40:26,049
that if that continues yes i do and therefore um if i were of the mind to own that coin then then

906
01:40:26,049 --> 01:40:30,770
that's what i would do i i don't believe in it enough to abandon the thing that i believe in more

907
01:40:30,770 --> 01:40:38,409
which is bitcoin um but yeah i don't know i i guess i i see it i see it as having a far more

908
01:40:38,409 --> 01:40:48,109
I think a far more useful, um, utility other than just, um, mania and, and, uh, you know,

909
01:40:48,169 --> 01:40:54,949
I, I think that there is something very real and cultural about, um, about what we're seeing

910
01:40:54,949 --> 01:41:01,449
with meme coins to be something real and cultural, but yeah, no, I think it's just measuring greed.

911
01:41:01,449 --> 01:41:06,409
If we didn't call them, if we didn't call them meme coins, then, you know, it would be personal

912
01:41:06,409 --> 01:41:12,449
stock. We don't call them that because they're not personal stock. We can imagine what personal

913
01:41:12,449 --> 01:41:17,529
stock would look like for an individual. That would be really cool if there was personal stock,

914
01:41:17,589 --> 01:41:22,870
if you could issue equity tokens on your own life to fund your college and to fund a family or

915
01:41:22,870 --> 01:41:26,429
something like that. People who believe in families can buy your family token if they want you to get

916
01:41:26,429 --> 01:41:30,609
married, if you need money for a house or something like that. I just don't think that's a meme coin

917
01:41:30,609 --> 01:41:35,270
anymore. It's not a meme that's propagating. We do that already. When you graduate high school,

918
01:41:35,270 --> 01:41:38,270
when people give you scholarships, when you get married and people give you presents.

919
01:41:39,089 --> 01:41:42,069
But an equity token, though, based on that is what I'm saying, that would be something

920
01:41:42,069 --> 01:41:43,469
different and it wouldn't be a meme coin.

921
01:41:43,810 --> 01:41:44,629
Yeah, it would be better.

922
01:41:45,649 --> 01:41:45,830
Right.

923
01:41:45,890 --> 01:41:47,810
It might be good or bad, but just like, right.

924
01:41:48,109 --> 01:41:50,949
It might be good or bad, but not a meme coin.

925
01:41:51,249 --> 01:41:53,009
I think we should talk about Bitcoin miners, though.

926
01:41:53,409 --> 01:41:53,589
Do.

927
01:41:53,949 --> 01:41:54,429
Go for it.

928
01:41:55,469 --> 01:42:00,609
Not just because meme coins have exhausted themselves inside my head.

929
01:42:00,649 --> 01:42:01,770
I have nothing interesting to say.

930
01:42:01,870 --> 01:42:03,909
I didn't have anything interesting to say when I started talking.

931
01:42:03,909 --> 01:42:25,929
And yet I talked for a long time about Bitcoin. So that doesn't stop me. But I think like Bitcoin miners as new energy tech, this sentence I said was significant from Alden. And I'm gonna double down and say it's incredible. So, quote, the world has never had such a flexible consumer of energy before in terms of both location and intermittency of that energy as the Bitcoin protocol.

932
01:42:25,929 --> 01:42:47,690
And so you and I were talking about Marathon Digital. We listened to a speech from Fred Thiel, the CEO. This is not an endorsement or a negative not endorsement of Marathon Digital. But it seems that Thiel is positioning that company not as a Bitcoin miner, but as an exploiter of energy, as an energy developer or something like that.

933
01:42:47,690 --> 01:43:07,850
And that's what Bitcoin miners are. They enable the development of energy. I mean, you and I and other podcasts have kind of casually referred to it as like bootstrapping us to the next level of the Kardashev scale, which is that scale wherein like a civilization is measured by its ability to harness all sources of energy.

934
01:43:07,850 --> 01:43:20,909
And Bitcoin mining, due to its flexibility, does seem to be not just a monetary technology, but a drilling technology, like a wildcat.

935
01:43:21,209 --> 01:43:30,589
It's like fracking. It's like some sort of new energy exploitation protocol in and of itself, even apart from robust money.

936
01:43:30,830 --> 01:43:33,969
And so, I mean, what do you think about that, Bitcoin as energy tech?

937
01:43:33,969 --> 01:43:57,449
Yeah, Bitcoin mining is the most fascinating, I think. Yeah. So you can judge the flourishing and quality of life of a civilization by taking an account of how much energy is consumed per capita per individual.

938
01:43:57,449 --> 01:44:05,109
The more energy consumed per individual, the more flourishing that civilization will be.

939
01:44:05,489 --> 01:44:13,109
And we've been on a rapid rise with that since like the 1860s or so, the beginning of sort of that period.

940
01:44:13,730 --> 01:44:15,209
And we've dipped.

941
01:44:15,929 --> 01:44:26,810
So it was in this book, I believe, where it might have been a different one, but referring to the 1970s as the lost decade because it was the first time in human history.

942
01:44:26,810 --> 01:44:32,409
Yeah, it was the first time in human history when per capita consumption of energy decreased.

943
01:44:33,330 --> 01:44:45,790
And I strongly encourage people to visit the website WTF happened in 1971 when we started the Fiat experiment or the Fiat disaster.

944
01:44:45,790 --> 01:44:49,469
and everything that has happened since then.

945
01:44:50,009 --> 01:44:58,790
We have been trying to hamstring the energy consumed by saying,

946
01:44:58,949 --> 01:45:03,029
you know, we're killing the planet, so what we should do is kill some people

947
01:45:03,029 --> 01:45:04,709
so there's fewer people to kill the planet.

948
01:45:04,850 --> 01:45:07,749
Like that's the overall kind of thesis of this approach.

949
01:45:07,749 --> 01:45:13,449
You know, we need fewer people, but nobody who is promoting that idea

950
01:45:13,449 --> 01:45:17,949
is just choosing to solve the problem themselves and off themselves in order to help out.

951
01:45:18,109 --> 01:45:21,129
That would be like the direct one-to-one way to really get this done.

952
01:45:22,669 --> 01:45:27,049
But what Bitcoin mining does is it comes in and it says,

953
01:45:27,049 --> 01:45:34,069
look, we understand that you as an entity, as a government, as whatever polity,

954
01:45:34,629 --> 01:45:41,350
it's not financially savvy for you to build out this infrastructure

955
01:45:41,350 --> 01:45:47,089
so that it can handle peak loads that are increasingly going up.

956
01:45:48,469 --> 01:45:49,549
You know, just as you think about it.

957
01:45:49,730 --> 01:46:00,350
So what is the use of building something that is strong enough to handle 12 days out of the year

958
01:46:00,350 --> 01:46:03,709
and then the rest of the time it's just kind of like wasted infrastructure?

959
01:46:03,969 --> 01:46:05,169
It's not really doing anything.

960
01:46:06,690 --> 01:46:08,069
It's not being used.

961
01:46:08,529 --> 01:46:10,369
There's plenty of stories, by the way.

962
01:46:10,430 --> 01:46:11,230
You can look on this.

963
01:46:11,350 --> 01:46:17,770
you can read about this, of companies that are just purging power because they have power that

964
01:46:17,770 --> 01:46:24,989
can't be used during these off times and it has to go somewhere. And so they're really just like

965
01:46:24,989 --> 01:46:29,649
wasting power. So Bitcoin comes in and they say, hey, guess what? We'll buy that.

966
01:46:30,270 --> 01:46:38,609
And not only will we buy that, we'll go to these places where there is no existing infrastructure,

967
01:46:38,609 --> 01:46:56,609
But there is energy. We'll go to these waterfalls. We'll go to these volcanoes. We'll go offshore and we'll use wave power. We'll take what is known as stranded energy or energy that just is not being captured and we'll capture it.

968
01:46:56,609 --> 01:47:04,810
it. And then when you need it in order to satisfy your peak load requirements, we'll sell it to you

969
01:47:04,810 --> 01:47:09,749
for a market price. And when you don't need it, we'll use it to mine Bitcoin. And it works out

970
01:47:09,749 --> 01:47:17,149
great both ways because it gives the Bitcoin miners a opportunity to have consistent income.

971
01:47:17,890 --> 01:47:22,449
If they're mining Bitcoin, they're making money off mining Bitcoin. When they're not mining

972
01:47:22,449 --> 01:47:27,290
Bitcoin. They're selling the energy that they have created or sorry, that they have extracted

973
01:47:27,290 --> 01:47:35,310
back in. And there's a real world example of this. So I went in 2022, the state of Texas

974
01:47:35,310 --> 01:47:40,869
experienced a really severe winter for them. You know, they had zero degree temperatures and

975
01:47:40,869 --> 01:47:48,169
they experienced rolling brownouts where there were millions of people without power during the

976
01:47:48,169 --> 01:47:55,109
coldest times they have ever had in recent history. And people died and billions of dollars

977
01:47:55,109 --> 01:48:01,330
of assets were lost. Cattle weren't able to water because people couldn't get out and they couldn't

978
01:48:01,330 --> 01:48:10,310
break water for their cattle. There was a ton of loss. And that just so happened to coincide with

979
01:48:10,310 --> 01:48:15,489
the time that China decided to shoot themselves in the foot by banning Bitcoin mining. And so

980
01:48:15,489 --> 01:48:23,310
So Bitcoin miners took the opportunity to look at the world landscape and they realized, oh, there's all this stranded power in the state of Texas.

981
01:48:23,569 --> 01:48:30,049
We can come there and we can take that flare gas and we can turn it into energy and we can mine Bitcoin with it.

982
01:48:30,049 --> 01:48:39,509
And now they have stabilized the grid of, I believe it's the most energy intensive state in the United States, like the state that consumes the most power.

983
01:48:39,609 --> 01:48:40,989
But I'm not positive about that.

984
01:48:41,129 --> 01:48:42,810
But so they stabilized the grid.

985
01:48:42,810 --> 01:49:00,369
We have a real world example in our union, the Republic of Texas that has benefited so greatly from solving this problem and stabilizing a very weak and fragile energy grid that covers the United States that can't cover the base load that we need.

986
01:49:00,369 --> 01:49:14,509
So, yeah, it's I don't know. I love everything about it. Taking us from bootstrapping us into Kardashev level one to Kardashev level one would be able would be capturing effectively all of the power on your planet.

987
01:49:14,509 --> 01:49:37,969
I think level two is all of the power of your sun or something like that. And three is all the power of your galaxy or whatever. So, yeah, it does. It gets us to that. And because of the commodity nature of Bitcoin mining, where I compare this to racing NASCAR, where everybody has the same equipment, it's the same stuff, it's a commodity.

988
01:49:38,749 --> 01:49:44,969
So what makes the difference is how well you conserve fuel in a NASCAR race.

989
01:49:45,669 --> 01:49:56,969
And that's what's going to get you to the end, because the fewer stops you have, the more able you're going to be able to go there and more able you're going to be to get you the checkered flag.

990
01:49:56,969 --> 01:50:17,009
So Bitcoin mining is a race towards cheaper and freer sources of energy, which drives the cost of energy to effectively zero, which bootstraps the globe into a higher level of flourishing that we've never seen.

991
01:50:17,009 --> 01:50:46,989
Yeah. No, I totally agree that Bitcoin is energy tech in that way. And I just think a really cool angle to this that I had never heard before. One of the things that Alden mentions is that historically, we live in fertile areas that have access to waterway thoroughfares that are geographic dispersion as humans is dictated by certain things that like ease of transportation and trade with other people, not optimized for us to be clear.

992
01:50:47,009 --> 01:51:16,930
And so not only is Bitcoin bootstrapping us into another phase of energy exploitation, utilization, development, it's also bootstrapping humanity's dispersion over the globe away from perhaps decaying urban centers to settle to, you know, in the chapter she quotes somebody calling these Bitcoin mining communities that arise around hydroelectric dams as front

993
01:51:16,930 --> 01:51:23,369
tier towns summoning back like the westward expansion of the united states as brave westward

994
01:51:23,369 --> 01:51:30,529
travelers set out to make their name um and do it in like an independent sovereign way by going out

995
01:51:30,529 --> 01:51:37,790
into the wide open prairie we now have people who could you know go live next to a hydroelectric

996
01:51:37,790 --> 01:51:43,909
dam in order to first maybe it's like the dam gets bootstrapped and started because a bitcoin

997
01:51:43,909 --> 01:51:48,629
provider, a Bitcoin miner is willing to build next to that dam. So you have something to utilize

998
01:51:48,629 --> 01:51:55,230
the power. The people that then are brought in to operate and manage, take care of that Bitcoin

999
01:51:55,230 --> 01:52:02,209
miner, maybe they set up and live next to it. They then bring in their family. Then people come in

1000
01:52:02,209 --> 01:52:08,709
to sell them supplies. And so communities develop and then the power grid gets built out and then

1001
01:52:08,709 --> 01:52:14,049
you have a flourishing community. So it's just interesting that Bitcoin is also going to change

1002
01:52:14,049 --> 01:52:20,890
migration patterns over the earth's surface, not just change the way that we use and exploit power.

1003
01:52:21,149 --> 01:52:27,949
It's going to have like Bitcoin as like future anthropology, the way that it caused new human

1004
01:52:27,949 --> 01:52:33,089
development. It's just a very cool thing. Yeah. We had, we had the land rush in, um,

1005
01:52:33,089 --> 01:52:40,330
everybody went west in order to get their stake of land there whatever 40 acres and a mule

1006
01:52:40,330 --> 01:52:45,869
we had the digital or sorry then we had the gold rush which was everybody went to california because

1007
01:52:45,869 --> 01:52:51,129
that's where the gold was and now we're having you can call it the digital gold rush

1008
01:52:51,129 --> 01:53:00,009
and the digital gold rush is it's not a specific location it is a um any location with the

1009
01:53:00,009 --> 01:53:06,609
prerequisite of having an energy source. And so it is very much dispersed. Dispersal is good.

1010
01:53:08,310 --> 01:53:15,109
I think that there is a, I don't think that it takes much to look at a city like New York,

1011
01:53:15,669 --> 01:53:25,049
where you can go decades without ever touching the grass or seeing or having an unobstructed

1012
01:53:25,049 --> 01:53:30,609
view of the sun. I don't think that it takes a whole lot to look at that and say, that's not

1013
01:53:30,609 --> 01:53:38,169
how we're supposed to live. That's not how our bodies were meant to thrive. And so decentralizing

1014
01:53:38,169 --> 01:53:47,629
the population, there was this belief that we were overcrowded, that we had too much population,

1015
01:53:47,629 --> 01:53:57,850
But it was because we had to crowd into areas that were dictated by our ability to move goods in and out and produce goods.

1016
01:53:58,869 --> 01:54:03,609
And we were always moving the energy to that.

1017
01:54:03,609 --> 01:54:14,869
Think about what a truck carrying a load of oil or groceries, beef or lettuce or bananas.

1018
01:54:15,569 --> 01:54:17,290
Think about what that is.

1019
01:54:17,290 --> 01:54:22,369
That is energy being transported from one area to another area.

1020
01:54:22,549 --> 01:54:32,850
It's being exported from an area where it can't be used and imported into an area where the people have to cloister and gather because of other parameters.

1021
01:54:33,409 --> 01:54:35,790
So now you've got a different decision-making paradigm.

1022
01:54:35,989 --> 01:54:40,069
And the decision-making paradigm is I'm going to go where the energy is.

1023
01:54:40,330 --> 01:54:44,270
And then from that, I can produce everything.

1024
01:54:44,489 --> 01:54:45,810
I can have my own wellspring.

1025
01:54:45,810 --> 01:55:01,589
And one of the things I think we're going to see in the future is a massive decrease in exporting energy and transporting goods from one area to another because we'll be able to produce them in a locality because we'll have the energy to do so.

1026
01:55:01,589 --> 01:55:22,690
Yeah, no, that's great. I wholeheartedly agree with that sentiment. I agree with the positive spin you put on it for the nature localized and reducing all of these vast supply chains. You noted earlier Jack Cruz talking about the negative. I haven't listened to it, but moving.

1027
01:55:22,690 --> 01:55:27,430
And anybody can imagine why it's negative to move a bunch of food around the Earth's surface rather than consuming it locally.

1028
01:55:28,190 --> 01:55:29,569
So, yeah, fantastic.

1029
01:55:29,909 --> 01:55:35,109
So the last thing, I bracketed this in the summary, that there's a chapter called Cryptocurrency Risk Analysis.

1030
01:55:35,310 --> 01:55:36,690
So I want to get your thoughts on some of these.

1031
01:55:37,669 --> 01:55:47,069
And I'll just note that right at the intro, so Alden says, I think it's a healthy and natural response to be skeptical of the long-term financial value of this technology.

1032
01:55:47,330 --> 01:55:50,409
So I don't want to over or undersell that.

1033
01:55:50,409 --> 01:55:54,409
I think all of these, I'll just say up front, it's very good that...

1034
01:55:58,409 --> 01:56:00,489
I lost.

1035
01:56:03,770 --> 01:56:04,569
Yeah, you're back.

1036
01:56:04,810 --> 01:56:05,489
Oh, now you're gone.

1037
01:56:06,909 --> 01:56:07,230
Uh-oh.

1038
01:56:08,390 --> 01:56:09,790
Oh, God, what am I going to do?

1039
01:56:09,869 --> 01:56:10,549
I can't juggle.

1040
01:56:11,749 --> 01:56:13,330
Spirit fingers, spirit fingers.

1041
01:56:14,830 --> 01:56:19,930
Many, many years ago when I was 23, I was married to a woman who was pretty as can be.

1042
01:56:19,930 --> 01:56:22,390
This widow had a grown-up daughter who had had her bread.

1043
01:56:22,690 --> 01:56:25,169
My father fell in love with her, and soon they, too, were wed.

1044
01:56:25,629 --> 01:56:28,949
It's made my dad my son-in-law and really changed my life.

1045
01:56:29,069 --> 01:56:33,690
For now my father was—now my mother was—I forget it.

1046
01:56:33,730 --> 01:56:34,270
It's Ray Stevens.

1047
01:56:35,930 --> 01:56:37,330
It looks like we lost Grant.

1048
01:56:38,409 --> 01:56:46,009
And I think we'll probably start the next conversation by picking up with where we were going to end this one,

1049
01:56:46,009 --> 01:56:56,190
which was talking about healthy skepticism of cryptocurrencies. I will preface that conversation

1050
01:56:56,190 --> 01:57:02,169
by leaving you with this. In digital markets, because there is no barrier to entry,

1051
01:57:02,509 --> 01:57:08,330
we create natural monopolies. And so all value flows to the best thing.

1052
01:57:09,290 --> 01:57:15,109
The reason, oh, hey, he's back. Dude, I was riffing hardcore. I was singing Ray Stevens,

1053
01:57:15,109 --> 01:57:18,909
And then I decided to go off and just start rattling on something.

1054
01:57:19,089 --> 01:57:22,930
You're, you're, uh, you're 90 degrees rotated to the left, but, and you're gone.

1055
01:57:23,770 --> 01:57:25,249
Oh, this is getting entertaining.

1056
01:57:25,830 --> 01:57:26,350
Okay.

1057
01:57:26,749 --> 01:57:27,529
So Grant's gone.

1058
01:57:29,109 --> 01:57:29,850
Don't listen.

1059
01:57:30,330 --> 01:57:30,690
Anyways.

1060
01:57:30,850 --> 01:57:31,469
Um, yeah.

1061
01:57:31,589 --> 01:57:34,169
So digital markets, uh, value accrues to the best.

1062
01:57:34,430 --> 01:57:39,949
Um, the reason why not everyone owns a Mercedes is because not everyone can.

1063
01:57:40,509 --> 01:57:44,989
Uh, the reason why not everyone owns a Rolex is because not everyone can.

1064
01:57:45,109 --> 01:57:47,169
There are certain restrictions.

1065
01:57:47,909 --> 01:57:49,629
You have to buy the whole thing.

1066
01:57:50,589 --> 01:57:54,850
You may be geographically constrained from being able to participate in that market.

1067
01:57:55,749 --> 01:57:57,430
Digital markets don't have those constraints.

1068
01:57:58,049 --> 01:58:01,029
And so the punchline is natural monopolies.

1069
01:58:01,509 --> 01:58:02,949
One thing rises to the top.

1070
01:58:03,109 --> 01:58:05,270
Twitter is the online digital news.

1071
01:58:05,709 --> 01:58:08,949
Facebook is the online digital whatever friend zone.

1072
01:58:09,350 --> 01:58:12,589
Google is the online digital search engine.

1073
01:58:12,589 --> 01:58:24,430
And now these things may change over time as someone increases the veracity of the digital nature of that thing to do its job.

1074
01:58:24,850 --> 01:58:27,690
I'm still just rattling on trying to save us.

1075
01:58:28,290 --> 01:58:31,770
I'm just keeping – I'm bailing water out of this boat, man.

1076
01:58:31,770 --> 01:58:38,749
So I'm visible now, though, and I'm also not like perpendicularly oriented towards the normal viewing way.

1077
01:58:38,749 --> 01:58:39,109
You're perfect.

1078
01:58:40,009 --> 01:58:40,529
You're perfect.

1079
01:58:40,529 --> 01:58:45,109
Do you want to wrap this up by talking about cryptocurrencies and underlying skepticism that we should have?

1080
01:58:45,109 --> 01:58:45,709
Yeah, yeah.

1081
01:58:45,850 --> 01:58:47,129
And so I was just leading into that.

1082
01:58:47,209 --> 01:58:49,350
There's a few risks, potential risks.

1083
01:58:49,350 --> 01:58:54,129
But I just wanted to note that Alden raises these because she's a critical thinker and not because any of these.

1084
01:58:54,209 --> 01:58:55,249
She doesn't weight them.

1085
01:58:56,049 --> 01:59:03,209
If you read this chapter, you'd see that she doesn't weight these such that it should prevent a person from looking further into Bitcoin for sure.

1086
01:59:03,529 --> 01:59:06,850
So, I mean, there's four or five.

1087
01:59:07,190 --> 01:59:08,770
Maybe I'll just really quickly summarize.

1088
01:59:08,770 --> 01:59:16,669
I want to see if you think what you think is the most serious of these threats and get your thoughts on that.

1089
01:59:16,790 --> 01:59:18,249
So first is market dilution.

1090
01:59:18,449 --> 01:59:22,009
I think that she kind of says that even that one is not really a threat.

1091
01:59:22,190 --> 01:59:25,569
It was maybe like the thought is that many more cryptos can't be created.

1092
01:59:25,749 --> 01:59:31,069
So we could see Bitcoin's, one could think that Bitcoin's market share would decrease relative to the number of cryptos.

1093
01:59:31,969 --> 01:59:34,529
But she says the design space is very tight.

1094
01:59:34,629 --> 01:59:38,529
There is no absolute guarantee that Bitcoin won't be outcompeted or surpassed in some way.

1095
01:59:38,529 --> 01:59:43,810
this must be considered a risk. But she just goes through, again, all the Bitcoin strength relative

1096
01:59:43,810 --> 01:59:50,989
to any other potential crypto. Two, the critical software bugs. She notes that there were some bugs

1097
01:59:50,989 --> 01:59:55,909
early in Bitcoin's development. These appear to have been worked out. Three was government bans.

1098
01:59:56,089 --> 01:59:59,430
I mean, you can imagine, of course, that can take many forms of what it might be.

1099
02:00:00,089 --> 02:00:05,230
But basically, the government attack vector towards Bitcoin through explicit legal prohibition,

1100
02:00:05,230 --> 02:00:10,949
a type of executive order 6102 maybe in which bitcoin is ordered to be seized something like

1101
02:00:10,949 --> 02:00:18,350
that so those are the different um big risks government ban critical software bug um and

1102
02:00:18,350 --> 02:00:24,669
market dilution that to do her due diligence all that at least think thinks fit oh and also

1103
02:00:24,669 --> 02:00:32,029
computational threat that the algorithm that secures bitcoin could be um broken through like

1104
02:00:32,029 --> 02:00:36,850
quantum computing or something like that. So what do you think about those different attack

1105
02:00:36,850 --> 02:00:42,310
vectors on Bitcoin, those different sources of risk? So market dilution, what we're seeing is

1106
02:00:42,310 --> 02:00:48,649
that the more entrance we have into this market, the more robust Bitcoin becomes because it proves

1107
02:00:48,649 --> 02:00:54,890
itself against all other ones. Market dilution is simply a way of saying, I get the opportunity

1108
02:00:54,890 --> 02:01:02,069
to look at everything. And I am further solidified in knowing that Bitcoin is the best of those

1109
02:01:02,069 --> 02:01:08,230
things. That's not a thing to be afraid of. If something is invented tomorrow that is better

1110
02:01:08,230 --> 02:01:13,749
than Bitcoin, people will recognize it. The network effect will change. And that may just be

1111
02:01:13,749 --> 02:01:21,869
how things go is that we iterate from one thing to another. I doubt it because as we've talked

1112
02:01:21,869 --> 02:01:30,669
about it, you know, and Adam Back specifically mentioned, you know, it appears that any change

1113
02:01:30,669 --> 02:01:37,029
that you make to Bitcoin actually makes it worse. And so it doesn't seem to be yet that there is

1114
02:01:37,029 --> 02:01:43,029
something. So this goes back to there was a fantastic podcast that I listened to with Joe

1115
02:01:43,029 --> 02:01:53,629
Rogan and a guy named Steven C. Meyer, who is a, um, who, who's written a bunch of books about a,

1116
02:01:53,770 --> 02:02:00,749
like a computer scientist's rational explanation for the existence of God. And during the whole

1117
02:02:00,749 --> 02:02:05,209
conversation, they go back and forth and, and Joe keeps on saying, you know, but what if,

1118
02:02:05,390 --> 02:02:09,169
what if this thing happens? What if this thing happens? And the guy finally stops him and he goes,

1119
02:02:09,169 --> 02:02:12,749
Look, man, we make decisions based on the information that we know.

1120
02:02:12,869 --> 02:02:15,869
When the information that we know changes, then we change our decision.

1121
02:02:16,489 --> 02:02:23,390
But what we don't do is we don't make decisions now based on theoretical things that may or may not happen.

1122
02:02:23,869 --> 02:02:26,529
All you can do is make the best decision for you right now.

1123
02:02:26,890 --> 02:02:30,009
So market dilution to me strengthens Bitcoin.

1124
02:02:31,069 --> 02:02:36,810
Government ban. I look at a government ban as an endorsement of Bitcoin.

1125
02:02:37,270 --> 02:02:38,649
First off, it won't work.

1126
02:02:38,930 --> 02:02:39,850
We know it won't work.

1127
02:02:40,049 --> 02:02:40,969
It's not going to work.

1128
02:02:41,129 --> 02:02:42,930
Government bans have never worked.

1129
02:02:43,449 --> 02:02:47,810
All they do is embolden people to find a way in order to get around it.

1130
02:02:47,949 --> 02:02:55,049
And they also create opportunities for other more forward-thinking countries to go, hey, we're not going to ban that thing.

1131
02:02:55,449 --> 02:02:57,449
And now we're going to flourish while you guys suffer.

1132
02:02:57,850 --> 02:02:59,489
So government ban is not a concern.

1133
02:03:00,109 --> 02:03:01,669
Market dilution, not a concern.

1134
02:03:01,669 --> 02:03:13,969
And so I just said one good quote that – I don't have the exact quote, but one good sentiment that Alden expresses to like, hey, central government, if you are threatened by a decentralized Excel spreadsheet, maybe you're the problem.

1135
02:03:14,290 --> 02:03:16,169
And I think that's a pretty good way of putting it.

1136
02:03:16,690 --> 02:03:17,909
So I just wanted to say that.

1137
02:03:18,830 --> 02:03:28,029
I mean I look at any sort of government ban, government antagonism towards any sort of technology, by the way.

1138
02:03:28,029 --> 02:03:31,690
I look at that as an explicit endorsement of that thing.

1139
02:03:31,830 --> 02:03:34,430
And I therefore want to own as much of that thing as possible.

1140
02:03:34,690 --> 02:03:35,149
Right, right.

1141
02:03:36,129 --> 02:03:38,549
Next thing is the bugs.

1142
02:03:39,129 --> 02:03:45,509
So the bugs, this wasn't in here, but I listened to Jimmy Song talk about one of the bugs.

1143
02:03:46,209 --> 02:03:52,509
So there is a bug where it's like the timestamping has, I think it's like-

1144
02:03:52,509 --> 02:03:55,609
The Unix timestamping, the 32 integer or like the number of integer.

1145
02:03:55,609 --> 02:03:56,149
Yeah, yeah.

1146
02:03:56,149 --> 02:04:00,169
Yeah. Two to the 32 minus one integers or whatever.

1147
02:04:00,529 --> 02:04:01,770
Yeah. That's in that. Right.

1148
02:04:02,270 --> 02:04:05,509
Yeah. That runs out in 2106. Right.

1149
02:04:05,509 --> 02:04:08,850
He talks about it. He's like, look, it's not ideal, but it's a two.

1150
02:04:08,949 --> 02:04:12,390
It's it is effectively the exact same thing as the 2K bug.

1151
02:04:12,810 --> 02:04:15,529
Yeah. And so that that can be resolved.

1152
02:04:15,629 --> 02:04:21,969
There have been bugs and those bugs have been resolved and there will possibly be more in the future.

1153
02:04:21,969 --> 02:04:26,989
And then the last thing is I love hearing people bring this up is the quantum computing thing.

1154
02:04:26,989 --> 02:04:37,589
Okay, so before I start on the software bugs, another good point that Alden makes, flip the discussion and just remind us, you know, Bitcoin is as simple as it gets.

1155
02:04:37,589 --> 02:04:52,949
So if you're worried about bugs in Bitcoin, I mean, any other piece of software is probably going to be orders of magnitude, especially once you get into proof of stake, orders of magnitude more complex, orders of magnitude more attack surface area.

1156
02:04:53,049 --> 02:04:54,449
So I just wanted to add that, but that's it.

1157
02:04:55,230 --> 02:04:58,609
Yeah, that's I mean, that's I think the proper view to look at these things.

1158
02:04:58,690 --> 02:05:03,629
You have to look at it relative and you have to look at somebody says, oh, Bitcoin is too complicated.

1159
02:05:03,629 --> 02:05:08,430
It's like, have you heard of the dollar? Do you understand how you have any idea how that mockery works?

1160
02:05:09,209 --> 02:05:15,209
Everything is relative. The last thing would be like the computational threat, which would be the quantum computing.

1161
02:05:15,989 --> 02:05:23,770
What if we invent a computer that's more powerful than any computer that's ever existed and therefore we're able to crack all of the encryption that's ever existed?

1162
02:05:24,430 --> 02:05:30,810
Well, in that case, I would prefer to have my wealth stored in the most powerful encryption that's ever existed, which is Bitcoin.

1163
02:05:30,810 --> 02:05:48,770
I mean, you're better off being in the strongest thing. This is not a case to be made for stacking up gold. Like, again, this is the argument that was made by Stephen C. Meyer to Joe Rogan. When the decision parameters change, when we have new information, then we can change.

1164
02:05:48,770 --> 02:05:55,730
but also there are theoretical ways to make to make Bitcoin quantum proof.

1165
02:05:56,330 --> 02:06:00,149
And so those, those things are being worked on right now. So, you know,

1166
02:06:00,149 --> 02:06:01,690
the computers that we have today,

1167
02:06:01,690 --> 02:06:07,069
they could have hacked any sort of program that existed in the 1960s yet,

1168
02:06:07,190 --> 02:06:10,709
yet we were able to, we were able to fight that off. So yeah. Yeah.

1169
02:06:10,709 --> 02:06:13,589
These are, these to me are, are not concerns.

1170
02:06:13,589 --> 02:06:20,430
They are endorsements, and they are a note to stay vigilant, I suppose.

1171
02:06:21,149 --> 02:06:21,249
Yeah.

1172
02:06:21,629 --> 02:06:22,149
Okay.

1173
02:06:22,310 --> 02:06:29,230
Here is the now, like Alden creates the nightmare scenario, a concerted attack.

1174
02:06:29,350 --> 02:06:30,149
So I'll read this to you.

1175
02:06:30,230 --> 02:06:32,129
This is like everything at once.

1176
02:06:32,249 --> 02:06:36,149
So, quote, overall, we can imagine several risks occurring together to combine into a

1177
02:06:36,149 --> 02:06:36,730
serious threat.

1178
02:06:37,190 --> 02:06:41,869
Governments could ban or severely restrict usage of the Bitcoin network, force various

1179
02:06:41,869 --> 02:06:48,029
financial institutions to sell their holdings to crash the price and drive the technology into the

1180
02:06:48,029 --> 02:06:53,730
black market. From here, they could go after the supply chain and do their best to prevent the

1181
02:06:53,730 --> 02:07:00,430
construction and distribution of new SHA-256 ASICs, which are Bitcoin miners. If Bitcoin's price

1182
02:07:00,430 --> 02:07:06,069
remains low for a long time, many miners become unprofitable and disconnect from the network until

1183
02:07:06,069 --> 02:07:11,190
the difficulty adjustment reduced enough to find a new steady state. This would sharply reduce the

1184
02:07:11,190 --> 02:07:19,850
cost of attempting a 51% censorship attack, which is when one group of miners is able to get the

1185
02:07:19,850 --> 02:07:25,350
majority of the network's power and so determine either censor transactions or do double spend

1186
02:07:25,350 --> 02:07:31,149
transactions. So this would try to reduce the cost of attempting such a 51% attack. And at that point,

1187
02:07:31,209 --> 02:07:36,409
perhaps some large government entity would spend the resources to do it for the sake of eliminating

1188
02:07:36,409 --> 02:07:38,909
the threat of stateless money entirely.

1189
02:07:39,749 --> 02:07:47,190
Throwing on top of that, even adding more onto all the shit file here, what if the United

1190
02:07:47,190 --> 02:07:49,989
States has an $800 billion military budget?

1191
02:07:50,109 --> 02:07:52,589
What if that entire military budget is thrown at that?

1192
02:07:53,890 --> 02:07:54,369
Yeah.

1193
02:07:56,290 --> 02:08:02,790
I think that's equivalent to me saying, I want your house, and so what I'm going to do is

1194
02:08:02,790 --> 02:08:03,489
burn it down.

1195
02:08:03,489 --> 02:08:11,350
it's an attack that destroys it right it's yeah it doesn't yeah exactly like um that's that's the

1196
02:08:11,350 --> 02:08:16,509
the beauty of understanding what bitcoin does is it aligns incentives is that you're actually

1197
02:08:16,509 --> 02:08:22,330
better off and everyone benefits from collaborating than they do from competing right yeah and and so

1198
02:08:22,330 --> 02:08:29,589
yeah it's just i think yeah yeah it's just you're you're destroying something so that someone else

1199
02:08:29,589 --> 02:08:35,330
can't have it but in the act of destroying it you're also removing your ability to benefit from

1200
02:08:35,330 --> 02:08:40,810
it so yeah yeah good luck at that point it's going to be like we're going to be in an alliance with

1201
02:08:40,810 --> 02:08:45,709
the deep sea aliens versus like advanced agi and so there's going to be a lot of shit to worry about

1202
02:08:45,709 --> 02:08:53,310
that's a lot more um yeah kind of forefront i'm gonna ride a hippo hippo with a 50 cal

1203
02:08:53,310 --> 02:08:55,089
on top of it.

1204
02:08:55,569 --> 02:08:57,249
That's pretty cyberpunk there.

1205
02:08:57,770 --> 02:09:00,049
You bet. Hey, wrap us up. I got another one coming.

1206
02:09:00,569 --> 02:09:01,310
Yeah, no. So

1207
02:09:01,310 --> 02:09:04,149
that's all I have. I would say

1208
02:09:04,149 --> 02:09:06,310
that Lucas is taking off. He has a job

1209
02:09:06,310 --> 02:09:08,089
interview. So if you wanted to hire Lucas,

1210
02:09:08,249 --> 02:09:10,169
your time to do so is quickly diminishing.

1211
02:09:10,489 --> 02:09:12,069
So reach out and grab him. Otherwise,

1212
02:09:12,209 --> 02:09:14,249
he's going to be grabbed by someone else

1213
02:09:14,249 --> 02:09:15,890
in a good way. Coin rules preferred.

1214
02:09:16,449 --> 02:09:18,069
Remote preferred.

1215
02:09:18,489 --> 02:09:19,830
I appreciate anybody who

1216
02:09:19,830 --> 02:09:21,149
points me to something.

1217
02:09:21,149 --> 02:09:25,989
And I genuinely would really appreciate anybody from the community that reaches out.

1218
02:09:26,109 --> 02:09:26,869
So thank you all.

1219
02:09:27,529 --> 02:09:27,850
Right on.

1220
02:09:28,529 --> 02:09:28,869
Giddy up.

1221
02:09:29,049 --> 02:09:29,629
We'll see you next time.