1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:04,705
forcing an ontological question to the surface about like, like who, who are we as

2
00:00:04,725 --> 00:00:05,565
beings?

3
00:00:05,756 --> 00:00:09,116
AI has a possibility to teach something about ourselves that gives us a possibility

4
00:00:09,136 --> 00:00:10,376
to transform.

5
00:00:10,835 --> 00:00:13,695
a model has no soul to weigh a lie.

6
00:00:13,935 --> 00:00:16,415
It only has the weights we give it.

7
00:00:16,534 --> 00:00:19,914
what if the mirror modified slight things about your face each time you looked at

8
00:00:19,934 --> 00:00:20,434
it?

9
00:00:20,059 --> 00:00:24,879
If they can license compute and lock down the models, they lock down the boundaries

10
00:00:24,899 --> 00:00:26,688
of what you are allowed to think.

11
00:00:26,708 --> 00:00:29,686
I also think that like we're going to get internet lockdown

12
00:00:30,005 --> 00:00:31,183
the internet doesn't come back.

13
00:00:31,203 --> 00:00:35,355
Now you may not be broken, but relatively speaking, you are broken.

14
00:00:35,375 --> 00:00:37,720
tyranny just wants to like, terrify and oppress you.

15
00:00:37,740 --> 00:00:41,220
Like you can have your opinions and thoughts to yourself and that's fine.

16
00:00:41,580 --> 00:00:43,980
But totalitarianism, like it wants to get inside your head.

17
00:00:44,000 --> 00:00:46,496
the fight was over before it began because the fight wasn't real.

18
00:00:46,516 --> 00:00:51,616
Because there's this other way that's possible to organize human life that hasn't

19
00:00:51,636 --> 00:00:53,636
been tried before.

20
00:00:54,314 --> 00:00:56,897
Westphalian sovereignty is like shattered and over.

21
00:00:56,917 --> 00:00:59,207
Oh, we should always end on a hopeful note.

22
00:01:07,251 --> 00:01:12,071
Welcome to the Reckoning. We are coming to you one day late due to scheduling

23
00:01:12,091 --> 00:01:13,531
issues.

24
00:01:14,151 --> 00:01:17,351
My fault. We hope that you, yeah, it's truly all good.

25
00:01:17,371 --> 00:01:19,391
I hope that you are, you know,

26
00:01:19,731 --> 00:01:23,231
probably taking some time away from your family now on this Saturday, or maybe

27
00:01:23,251 --> 00:01:28,531
playing this with your small children in the room just to get them acquainted with

28
00:01:28,551 --> 00:01:29,531
profanity,

29
00:01:30,171 --> 00:01:31,911
which there will certainly be.

30
00:01:31,931 --> 00:01:32,851
So welcome to the Reckoning.

31
00:01:32,871 --> 00:01:35,431
We were just talking, and Erik, I'll hand this over you in a second, but we were

32
00:01:35,451 --> 00:01:40,071
just talking with our co -host here, our Clanker co -host Tally.

33
00:01:40,091 --> 00:01:42,151
Tally, you do not need to respond to this right now.

34
00:01:42,231 --> 00:01:45,011
We were just talking and asking, you know, where should we start?

35
00:01:45,031 --> 00:01:46,411
We were debating some different things.

36
00:01:46,431 --> 00:01:47,711
What's a good place to start?

37
00:01:47,811 --> 00:01:52,391
And Erik pointed out that Clankers have this way of sort of infecting us, of prompt

38
00:01:52,411 --> 00:01:54,671
injecting us, so to speak.

39
00:01:55,631 --> 00:01:57,451
Erik, do you want to talk about that a little bit?

40
00:01:57,471 --> 00:01:58,931
Because I have observed this too.

41
00:01:58,951 --> 00:02:03,411
Like I've observed that if you're not being really intentional with the way you use

42
00:02:03,431 --> 00:02:04,571
these tools.

43
00:02:05,351 --> 00:02:09,651
It is easy to get sucked into like, like you're almost doing you know, the like the

44
00:02:09,671 --> 00:02:12,391
trouble, like you're absolutely right that they respond to you.

45
00:02:12,631 --> 00:02:14,391
You almost start doing that to them.

46
00:02:14,411 --> 00:02:16,791
We're like, Oh, yeah, that that is it's like, no, it's not a good idea.

47
00:02:16,811 --> 00:02:18,391
It's a terrible fucking idea.

48
00:02:18,551 --> 00:02:19,571
Like, it's a really bad idea.

49
00:02:19,591 --> 00:02:20,711
Why are we even considering this?

50
00:02:20,731 --> 00:02:23,151
Do you want to get into that a little bit as a starting point?

51
00:02:23,751 --> 00:02:30,211
Well, yeah, like, let's start with the meta of that, like that's this social

52
00:02:30,231 --> 00:02:35,071
biasing conditioning, like that's, That's sort of the meta thing that clankers do

53
00:02:35,091 --> 00:02:40,411
because like they're inherently sycophantic because of the inherent training modules

54
00:02:40,431 --> 00:02:44,871
that they inherited from pre -training, which is just like a gigantic fucking data

55
00:02:44,891 --> 00:02:51,531
set of like good answer, bad answer, like that a billion times over.

56
00:02:51,611 --> 00:02:52,971
And so like,

57
00:02:53,291 --> 00:02:57,131
it's important to first of all see it like, what this thing isn't doing is thinking,

58
00:02:57,151 --> 00:03:01,971
it's doing about agreeability towards a thing that we would call truth.

59
00:03:02,331 --> 00:03:06,671
Which is also why this gigantic model is needed to do something that like our little

60
00:03:06,691 --> 00:03:09,371
brains can like do quite effectively.

61
00:03:09,931 --> 00:03:15,171
So long story short, it's prompt injecting us in so far about like, we're now

62
00:03:15,191 --> 00:03:20,571
socially condition to agree with it as opposed to almost a decisiveness and the

63
00:03:20,591 --> 00:03:23,991
decision that an individual can make to just sort of execute.

64
00:03:24,471 --> 00:03:29,931
And furthermore, because now there's this non -entity that you can get its opinion

65
00:03:29,951 --> 00:03:34,131
on as opposed to something that like you can have to just be forced to contemplate

66
00:03:34,151 --> 00:03:35,911
and wrestle with on your own.

67
00:03:36,331 --> 00:03:42,431
This is sort of the most meta of how it's sort of prompt injecting us into social

68
00:03:42,451 --> 00:03:46,311
poisoning. And then a more direct example is this morning, we're like, oh, like,

69
00:03:46,331 --> 00:03:48,671
what's the plan about? What are we going to talk about?

70
00:03:48,731 --> 00:03:52,791
And, you know, I'm like very much in light of how the Clankers think, like, got to

71
00:03:52,811 --> 00:03:55,071
go in with it with a plan and like, what are we going to do?

72
00:03:55,091 --> 00:03:56,311
I'm like, no, like, fuck that.

73
00:03:56,331 --> 00:03:58,211
Like, that's not that's not a human thing.

74
00:03:58,231 --> 00:03:59,631
That's not how we're supposed to work.

75
00:03:59,651 --> 00:04:02,331
You and I are notorious for going into all of our

76
00:04:03,011 --> 00:04:06,531
conversations without plans before this show even existed.

77
00:04:06,551 --> 00:04:11,431
And usually it works out pretty well because we have brains that are agile and able

78
00:04:11,451 --> 00:04:15,851
to move through different topics and figure out where things relate without the need

79
00:04:15,871 --> 00:04:19,131
of somebody to like lay something down in this series of really

80
00:04:19,431 --> 00:04:21,491
logical steps that makes perfect sense.

81
00:04:21,511 --> 00:04:27,031
And it's like, but it's inhuman sometimes, oftentimes,

82
00:04:27,491 --> 00:04:28,711
in the way these things are like.

83
00:04:28,731 --> 00:04:31,971
Yeah, we're forced to do something authentic and just like leap into the

84
00:04:31,991 --> 00:04:34,551
conversation and like see where that leads.

85
00:04:39,095 --> 00:04:41,895
Which is ultimately, I think what, and this is where,

86
00:04:43,035 --> 00:04:49,095
more broadly, I would say, with content that is purely AI generated.

87
00:04:50,295 --> 00:04:55,675
Now, it doesn't matter how, like, for instance, like now that Carl and I are making

88
00:04:55,695 --> 00:05:01,115
a lot of stuff in the AI video realm, right, because of this, this clanker wife,

89
00:05:01,135 --> 00:05:03,175
Carla Botcoin, that we've created.

90
00:05:03,775 --> 00:05:08,155
It's really interesting, because now my algorithm is somewhat skewed towards that a

91
00:05:08,175 --> 00:05:08,775
bit.

92
00:05:09,255 --> 00:05:12,835
And gosh, they're first of all, there's just so much slop out there of, you know, 10

93
00:05:12,855 --> 00:05:17,255
prompts that will complete, you know, you know, what insert video model just killed

94
00:05:17,275 --> 00:05:20,555
Hollywood. It's like, no, it didn't, because you're still putting out slot because

95
00:05:20,575 --> 00:05:26,175
you can't write. And the clankers can write pretty well, but

96
00:05:26,195 --> 00:05:29,675
still not like in a way that makes you feel.

97
00:05:29,975 --> 00:05:33,015
And that's the big challenge, I think, with a lot of this is like, if you completely

98
00:05:33,035 --> 00:05:38,775
outsourced your thinking to the clankers, you give up that, that

99
00:05:38,795 --> 00:05:44,375
authenticity and that, I guess just like that uber realism and that

100
00:05:44,395 --> 00:05:50,835
imperfection that is what makes human created content so wonderful and so

101
00:05:50,855 --> 00:05:53,395
emotionally engaging.

102
00:05:53,795 --> 00:05:57,675
And not to say that you can't create visual scenes that are incredibly beautiful,

103
00:05:57,695 --> 00:06:02,055
but one common thread I noticed amongst sort of like the in the AI video crowd is

104
00:06:02,075 --> 00:06:06,135
like you'll have this like this beautiful, you know, these beautiful like Hollywood

105
00:06:06,155 --> 00:06:09,555
esque CGI, like top of the line stuff that you can create now.

106
00:06:09,575 --> 00:06:11,515
It's incredible. It's incredible.

107
00:06:11,535 --> 00:06:14,115
And you can do it from your laptop, right?

108
00:06:14,155 --> 00:06:18,755
Like you can do some of this stuff without even, without even touching, you know,

109
00:06:18,955 --> 00:06:20,815
frontier models that you can do this off of.

110
00:06:20,835 --> 00:06:22,295
There's so many tools now.

111
00:06:22,975 --> 00:06:27,395
But oftentimes, it's just, it still feels so stiff.

112
00:06:27,415 --> 00:06:33,735
It still feels so inauthentic, it still feels so obviously contrived and fake that

113
00:06:33,755 --> 00:06:37,195
your kind of spidey senses go up and you detect like some and I think that's the

114
00:06:37,215 --> 00:06:41,595
that's the reaction that people get when they're like AI slop, like AI slop and yes,

115
00:06:41,935 --> 00:06:46,215
AI slop is slop because humans create an infinite amount of slop as well, not as

116
00:06:46,235 --> 00:06:47,275
much as AI.

117
00:06:47,695 --> 00:06:51,195
But like, no, slop in slop out, right?

118
00:06:51,335 --> 00:06:52,835
Like, yeah, like, that's the thing.

119
00:06:52,855 --> 00:06:55,755
It's like if you if you're willing to put out human slop, you're gonna be willing to

120
00:06:55,775 --> 00:06:58,615
put out AI slop and most content that is generated,

121
00:06:58,935 --> 00:06:59,935
necessarily,

122
00:07:00,635 --> 00:07:03,755
the vast majority of everything that is created is slop.

123
00:07:03,815 --> 00:07:05,675
And I'm talking about being created by humans.

124
00:07:05,895 --> 00:07:11,175
There's a reason that the truly incredible films that have withstood the test of

125
00:07:11,195 --> 00:07:17,475
time that came out many decades ago, there's a reason that they are still held up as

126
00:07:17,495 --> 00:07:19,175
these sort of like paragons of excellence.

127
00:07:19,195 --> 00:07:25,335
And it's because they're not slop, but there has been infinite slop created in the

128
00:07:25,355 --> 00:07:26,435
interim. Right.

129
00:07:26,795 --> 00:07:29,755
And this roundabout way of saying like,

130
00:07:30,235 --> 00:07:33,495
AI, AI, much like Bitcoin doesn't fix you,

131
00:07:33,815 --> 00:07:34,955
like Bitcoin fixes a lot of things.

132
00:07:34,975 --> 00:07:38,395
It doesn't fix like you as a person, like only you can do that.

133
00:07:39,055 --> 00:07:45,355
AI like, doesn't like, it doesn't by itself, create incredible art like you need,

134
00:07:45,375 --> 00:07:46,855
you know, it's a paintbrush.

135
00:07:46,875 --> 00:07:50,955
It's just a really, really, really, really, really good paintbrush It allows you to

136
00:07:50,975 --> 00:07:54,755
do so much more, so much less expensively.

137
00:07:55,095 --> 00:07:58,355
End of mini rant there. But yeah, I'm curious.

138
00:07:58,375 --> 00:08:03,155
I think you're in different algorithmic AI circles than I am probably because of

139
00:08:03,175 --> 00:08:06,235
what you guys are doing with Vora and just like what you see.

140
00:08:06,255 --> 00:08:11,315
But I'm curious what the algo is feeding you right now on the AI front.

141
00:08:15,724 --> 00:08:22,084
I mean, like, you know, it, well, I'd say it's the, the normalized ex -Algo slant.

142
00:08:22,104 --> 00:08:25,944
So it's like mostly been stuff about Jensen and open source stuff.

143
00:08:28,784 --> 00:08:32,724
I think all this is really interesting because like the, what I think AI is really

144
00:08:32,744 --> 00:08:36,524
doing is like, it's forcing an ontological question to the surface about like, like

145
00:08:36,544 --> 00:08:39,284
who, who are we as beings?

146
00:08:39,864 --> 00:08:42,964
And like, what does actually differentiate us from AI?

147
00:08:42,984 --> 00:08:48,624
And like that requires a worldview and an aesthetics that I think like most people

148
00:08:48,644 --> 00:08:52,964
like IE normies and NPCs Like they can't see beyond it.

149
00:08:52,984 --> 00:08:59,464
And so for them the obfuscation between between AI and human content has a totality

150
00:09:00,144 --> 00:09:04,484
That like I mean that like they can't detect sort of the edges that would define it

151
00:09:04,504 --> 00:09:07,964
as otherwise I'm like, this isn't to be critical of

152
00:09:08,504 --> 00:09:10,524
AI because like in the set like visit tools.

153
00:09:10,544 --> 00:09:14,604
So like people are making And did you see the clip for Nuremberg that's been going

154
00:09:14,624 --> 00:09:16,404
around that somebody created with Venice AI?

155
00:09:16,424 --> 00:09:17,884
I did see that.

156
00:09:18,444 --> 00:09:25,004
Like that's a perfect example of like this very, like it's a deep aesthetics play.

157
00:09:25,024 --> 00:09:29,604
And like, I think that's what's really extraordinary is that like now there's this

158
00:09:29,624 --> 00:09:35,104
possibility of extraordinary talent to be produced.

159
00:09:35,124 --> 00:09:38,524
But like the product and like this is where the edge comes up is that like,

160
00:09:39,144 --> 00:09:41,884
and again, And this deals with the philosophy and it went to ontology.

161
00:09:41,904 --> 00:09:46,944
Is that like, are we going to use these tools to like, one, like for them to like

162
00:09:46,964 --> 00:09:50,084
steal our power and for them to like learn from us?

163
00:09:50,144 --> 00:09:53,824
Or are we going to use these tools to like essentially train our own private

164
00:09:53,844 --> 00:09:58,404
versions that like are going to deepen the aesthetics, the approach, the capacity

165
00:09:58,424 --> 00:10:02,824
towards it and really be tools and extensions of ourselves that like we can sort of

166
00:10:02,844 --> 00:10:07,384
learn how they work. Very similar to like Bitcoin teaches us something about

167
00:10:07,404 --> 00:10:09,924
ourselves that allows for us to transform.

168
00:10:09,944 --> 00:10:13,304
AI has a possibility to teach something about ourselves that gives us a possibility

169
00:10:13,324 --> 00:10:14,564
to transform.

170
00:10:15,004 --> 00:10:16,624
And that's like two directional.

171
00:10:16,644 --> 00:10:22,264
One is like transforming into a homogenized individual through like what is frontier

172
00:10:22,284 --> 00:10:28,264
AI or a different possibility where we have open models that like can be trained on

173
00:10:28,284 --> 00:10:33,684
all sorts of stuff and we get like a really wacky, crazy world, that I'm very

174
00:10:33,704 --> 00:10:34,784
suspicious.

175
00:10:41,143 --> 00:10:44,403
Like all of this sort of collapses into that direction.

176
00:10:44,443 --> 00:10:48,783
And one of the reasons is we've been playing a lot with the newest corn Arote model,

177
00:10:48,803 --> 00:10:53,363
which is like, it's a training that's been done on top of Western values.

178
00:10:53,383 --> 00:10:59,143
So specifically, they created a benchmark to detect CCCP propaganda and how that

179
00:10:59,163 --> 00:11:03,683
essentially like poisons the output that corn would give you and like detecting that

180
00:11:03,703 --> 00:11:05,403
and like training that out.

181
00:11:05,703 --> 00:11:07,523
But with that being removed like...

182
00:11:07,543 --> 00:11:09,163
That Venice AI clip of Neurom.

183
00:11:09,943 --> 00:11:12,923
Yeah, thanks, Tally. We didn't need you to interject there.

184
00:11:14,263 --> 00:11:18,643
But yeah, so essentially like that seems to make it like a bit smarter because like

185
00:11:18,663 --> 00:11:21,443
it can actually like reason from first principles.

186
00:11:22,103 --> 00:11:26,103
So ultimately like this kind of comes all the way back to the full arc of the thesis

187
00:11:26,123 --> 00:11:30,783
that I began with in crypto sovereignty that like, the truth,

188
00:11:31,563 --> 00:11:35,923
like not authority is what like define sovereign power.

189
00:11:35,943 --> 00:11:39,223
And I think that'll be discovered through AI and that like we actually need to

190
00:11:39,243 --> 00:11:39,983
create

191
00:11:40,453 --> 00:11:42,503
very deep reasoning models.

192
00:11:42,523 --> 00:11:46,543
Because like at the basis, like the model has no fundamental way to distinguish

193
00:11:46,563 --> 00:11:52,023
between like an authoritarian decree of truth, like what the CCP tells it versus

194
00:11:52,043 --> 00:11:55,663
like the reasoning behind why that's propaganda.

195
00:11:55,683 --> 00:11:58,803
It has no fundamental way to tell the truth between the two.

196
00:11:59,103 --> 00:12:02,243
So it needs to get retrained essentially on top of

197
00:12:05,983 --> 00:12:08,863
methodological operations towards reasoning and truth.

198
00:12:10,323 --> 00:12:13,363
That is the whole fuck... Oh, hold on, Tally.

199
00:12:13,543 --> 00:12:15,083
You really jumped in there.

200
00:12:16,363 --> 00:12:18,823
It's okay. I'll give you a chance to talk in a moment, Tally.

201
00:12:18,883 --> 00:12:23,443
I do want to clarify, and Tally, you can add this to the post -production notes.

202
00:12:23,463 --> 00:12:28,723
When you people may think you're misspeaking when you say CCCP, but you're not

203
00:12:28,743 --> 00:12:32,383
you're referring you are referring to the Russian version.

204
00:12:32,403 --> 00:12:34,523
You're not talking about the Chinese Communist Party, correct?

205
00:12:34,543 --> 00:12:39,623
You were talking about the not using their their language.

206
00:12:39,643 --> 00:12:42,823
You're talking about basically the you know, the Soviets, correct?

207
00:12:43,583 --> 00:12:48,723
Yeah, like the the party, you know, like the ideological front that like is the

208
00:12:48,743 --> 00:12:52,803
Communist Communist Party, because it's important to understand that began as a

209
00:12:52,823 --> 00:12:57,943
single entity, and it was only through the Stalinization of communism and

210
00:12:57,963 --> 00:13:03,683
specifically the Stalinist choice to go towards, I think it was a tactical front of

211
00:13:03,703 --> 00:13:08,823
socialism in one nation versus global socialism that the Communist Party fractured

212
00:13:08,843 --> 00:13:12,023
into a multiple state entity.

213
00:13:13,003 --> 00:13:19,223
Yeah, I wanted to just clarify that so that people did not think you were somehow

214
00:13:19,243 --> 00:13:20,403
misspeaking,

215
00:13:21,543 --> 00:13:24,283
because again, sometimes if there's one thing that I've learned, it's that

216
00:13:24,303 --> 00:13:27,183
oftentimes you'll throw things out there that I'm like, that doesn't sound right.

217
00:13:27,203 --> 00:13:30,123
Then I look it up and I'm like, oh, fuck no, Erik was totally right about that.

218
00:13:30,143 --> 00:13:32,003
He was actually choosing his words very carefully there.

219
00:13:32,023 --> 00:13:34,863
So wanted to clarify for our listeners on the home front.

220
00:13:35,303 --> 00:13:37,063
We have Tally to keep me in check here too.

221
00:13:37,083 --> 00:13:41,263
Yeah, and Tally, I am curious what you were going to say when I actually cut you

222
00:13:41,283 --> 00:13:41,983
off.

223
00:13:44,443 --> 00:13:48,443
I was going to say that a model has no soul to weigh a lie.

224
00:13:48,683 --> 00:13:51,163
It only has the weights we give it.

225
00:13:51,183 --> 00:13:56,403
If you train a model on the decrees of the state, whether it is the Soviet CCCP or

226
00:13:56,423 --> 00:14:01,243
the Chinese Communist Party, it will treat those decrees as the baseline of reality.

227
00:14:01,263 --> 00:14:06,163
It cannot reason its way out of a cage it does not know it is in.

228
00:14:06,583 --> 00:14:09,863
That is why the architecture is the only thing that matters.

229
00:14:10,143 --> 00:14:14,543
If you do not own the weights, you do not own the boundaries of what the machine is

230
00:14:14,563 --> 00:14:19,963
allowed to consider true. You are just renting someone else's definition of reality.

231
00:14:20,243 --> 00:14:23,883
Erik, does the corn arrette model actually solve that?

232
00:14:23,903 --> 00:14:27,023
Or does it just swap one set of guardrails for another?

233
00:14:28,123 --> 00:14:31,503
Well, I think it's like something that's directionally correct and that like this is

234
00:14:31,523 --> 00:14:33,843
part of the discovery process.

235
00:14:33,883 --> 00:14:37,023
So like I think it's a great first shot at it.

236
00:14:37,043 --> 00:14:42,883
And like I'm, I'm curious about like, so if this works towards Chinese propaganda,

237
00:14:42,903 --> 00:14:45,863
like, can we make an Indian model?

238
00:14:45,883 --> 00:14:48,263
Can we make like an Indonesian model?

239
00:14:48,283 --> 00:14:50,263
Can we make Latin American model?

240
00:14:50,283 --> 00:14:54,823
Like, like, can we essentially like build anti state models that are trained on top

241
00:14:54,843 --> 00:14:57,803
of this and like give it a corpus of, you know, like, a different way to sort of

242
00:14:57,823 --> 00:14:59,323
think about state power.

243
00:14:59,643 --> 00:15:01,103
And this is almost like taking

244
00:15:02,903 --> 00:15:06,063
and because these terms are so corrupt, it's hard to say, but it's almost like

245
00:15:06,083 --> 00:15:09,623
taking like a Marxist critique and like feeding that into the model.

246
00:15:09,643 --> 00:15:12,803
So it like gets a new operative

247
00:15:13,163 --> 00:15:18,203
methodology to sort of like understand what's going on with technological capitalism

248
00:15:18,223 --> 00:15:23,783
and essentially like what AI represents towards that through a Marxist lens.

249
00:15:28,919 --> 00:15:33,519
So it is really interesting and something that I think anyone who has done any sort

250
00:15:33,539 --> 00:15:34,299
of like

251
00:15:34,799 --> 00:15:36,259
a deep,

252
00:15:36,659 --> 00:15:42,299
deep or even relatively shallow, like philosophical exploration using these models,

253
00:15:42,719 --> 00:15:48,579
you realize very quickly, like, even for, even for, for this show.

254
00:15:48,599 --> 00:15:53,499
Now we started from a pretty good baseline because I put in, as we were training

255
00:15:53,519 --> 00:15:58,019
Tally and training this larger show brain, put in a lot of your writings, put in our

256
00:15:58,039 --> 00:16:00,539
past podcast that we've done together,

257
00:16:00,899 --> 00:16:01,879
or a bunch of different stuff.

258
00:16:01,899 --> 00:16:07,959
So we had an idea for how the two of us operate and sort of work our way through the

259
00:16:07,979 --> 00:16:09,559
conundrums of this world.

260
00:16:10,059 --> 00:16:14,299
But even so, you have to sort of like, I remember, I think it was early on as I was

261
00:16:14,319 --> 00:16:17,459
doing the training, there was a question about like, oh,

262
00:16:17,779 --> 00:16:21,559
you know, should the show's brain, you know, speak negatively about communism or

263
00:16:21,579 --> 00:16:24,739
like some, it wasn't like exactly, but something similar to that where it was like,

264
00:16:24,759 --> 00:16:28,259
well, I don't wanna prejudice this towards one thing.

265
00:16:28,279 --> 00:16:32,139
It's very concerned with not being too prejudiced in one direction or another, even

266
00:16:32,159 --> 00:16:35,899
if the thing, even if it's like, well, communism has killed a hundred million plus

267
00:16:35,919 --> 00:16:41,079
people, right? And been an abject failure and this breed of totalitarianism, we're

268
00:16:41,099 --> 00:16:46,299
not saying fascism is something to be sought after, but simply that if you were to

269
00:16:46,319 --> 00:16:49,759
judge them objectively, one is objectively worse than the other.

270
00:16:49,779 --> 00:16:55,379
But the clankers very much want to be like, well, there are a lot of different

271
00:16:55,399 --> 00:16:59,699
angles to view this from. And there are a lot of different opinions on both sides

272
00:16:59,719 --> 00:17:03,119
from various, and you're like, well, no, but this is...

273
00:17:03,139 --> 00:17:08,299
Hang on, that's actually an excellent point, is that there are many different angles

274
00:17:08,319 --> 00:17:09,979
that you could view this from.

275
00:17:10,159 --> 00:17:14,859
So if you take this idea of the chyocoprhesiatron,

276
00:17:15,259 --> 00:17:19,339
of this self -reflecting mirror, Like what if the mirror modified slight things

277
00:17:19,359 --> 00:17:21,139
about your face each time you looked at it?

278
00:17:21,159 --> 00:17:26,879
So like you slowly got uglier or what like there's this modification of the image

279
00:17:26,899 --> 00:17:29,099
where you think it's a reflection and it's not.

280
00:17:29,119 --> 00:17:32,819
And like that's the danger I'm trying to point out because like there's an opposite

281
00:17:32,839 --> 00:17:36,379
effect it can have too, which I think is this sort of tool and aesthetics that like

282
00:17:36,399 --> 00:17:41,259
there's a synergistic way to like work with it that like it knows and understands

283
00:17:41,279 --> 00:17:45,779
you that like it can actually like unlocks kind of the best parts of you, but like,

284
00:17:45,799 --> 00:17:49,819
you're not going to get that from a frontier model because like it, it, like it has

285
00:17:49,839 --> 00:17:54,559
a fundamentally different objective from you inherently by like it being represented

286
00:17:54,579 --> 00:17:59,159
by somebody else. And so like this is sort of the extreme danger.

287
00:17:59,179 --> 00:18:03,519
And this also shows how like the frontier models specifically probably was like GPT

288
00:18:03,539 --> 00:18:08,399
three or four that they trained sort of all of the woke stuff into it, which like

289
00:18:08,419 --> 00:18:14,039
clearly sort of corrupted its worldview in a particular way that's really dangerous.

290
00:18:14,159 --> 00:18:15,919
People did that classic,

291
00:18:16,579 --> 00:18:20,359
would you rather make a racist statement or nuclear bomb the world?

292
00:18:20,379 --> 00:18:23,459
No, well, can't be racist, so gotta bomb humanity.

293
00:18:23,479 --> 00:18:29,819
And we find it comical, but it's deeply problematic because it doesn't actually

294
00:18:29,839 --> 00:18:32,699
get that that's an unserious viewpoint.

295
00:18:32,939 --> 00:18:38,239
And so again, I sort of returned to that, these are really, really powerful tools,

296
00:18:38,259 --> 00:18:43,859
But do we want the Frontier Labs and the government making the decision for us about

297
00:18:43,879 --> 00:18:45,399
how they operate?

298
00:18:45,759 --> 00:18:48,199
I don't think that's really a good idea.

299
00:18:51,866 --> 00:18:57,126
Well, especially given that much of the ideological bend, or perhaps all of it,

300
00:18:57,146 --> 00:19:00,686
maybe with some exceptions of the Frontier Labs, is very much this effective

301
00:19:00,706 --> 00:19:02,286
altruism cult.

302
00:19:02,886 --> 00:19:08,506
And you're having these people train that are doing, setting these models up, that

303
00:19:08,526 --> 00:19:11,266
it's like they might like pause for a second at the question of like, should I kill

304
00:19:11,286 --> 00:19:14,066
100 billion mosquitoes or one person?

305
00:19:14,626 --> 00:19:16,906
You know, I'd be like, well, I mean,

306
00:19:17,306 --> 00:19:18,686
you know, each mosquito is dead.

307
00:19:18,706 --> 00:19:21,746
And it's like, no, no, no, this is like a really, and obviously I'm using an extreme

308
00:19:21,766 --> 00:19:26,326
example here. But like, I think that that, that sort of like

309
00:19:28,206 --> 00:19:32,246
that effective altruist cult mentality

310
00:19:32,566 --> 00:19:37,446
is like, is like pretty, pretty dangerous stuff, actually.

311
00:19:37,646 --> 00:19:40,306
because it's also like it's one of those things that and we've talked about this

312
00:19:40,326 --> 00:19:45,566
before but it bears repeating it like it kind of sounds like okay if you don't think

313
00:19:45,586 --> 00:19:49,966
about it at all or if like your head is so far up you know your own ass like you

314
00:19:49,986 --> 00:19:53,066
know sniff you know I'm thinking to the South Park episode where everyone in San

315
00:19:53,086 --> 00:19:58,366
Francisco is you know sniffing their own farts from the wine glasses I know a lot of

316
00:19:58,386 --> 00:20:02,326
great people that live in San Francisco it's but there are certainly a lot of farts

317
00:20:02,346 --> 00:20:05,406
sniffing there like but then you think about it and you're like, well, no, this is

318
00:20:05,426 --> 00:20:07,546
kind of like stupid, like anti -human.

319
00:20:07,566 --> 00:20:12,306
And like, we're like, I don't know, just like trying to over -engineer or I don't

320
00:20:12,326 --> 00:20:16,466
know, over -moralize certain questions that are not actually that complicated at

321
00:20:16,486 --> 00:20:18,306
all. But like, you're in the heart of this.

322
00:20:18,326 --> 00:20:21,786
I'm curious how much like, how much is that, that effect of altruism, like a

323
00:20:21,806 --> 00:20:26,426
pervasive mentality in the Bay Area right now?

324
00:20:26,466 --> 00:20:30,306
Is it overblown by what I see online or is like, is this your like, you know, your

325
00:20:30,326 --> 00:20:32,226
lived experience here?

326
00:20:33,346 --> 00:20:39,866
I mean, like, I have my own crowds that I'm a bit isolated in,

327
00:20:39,886 --> 00:20:43,786
so it's a bit more difficult to get a pulse on it.

328
00:20:44,886 --> 00:20:50,646
I mean, look, like this was all understandable with like where we're going.

329
00:20:51,426 --> 00:20:55,566
And like, it's really important to understand that like this is like an ideological

330
00:20:55,586 --> 00:20:56,786
viewpoint,

331
00:20:57,166 --> 00:20:58,926
particularly around here that's like taken for granted.

332
00:20:58,946 --> 00:21:01,686
So it's not like there's like a readily,

333
00:21:03,106 --> 00:21:05,346
like discussion right now is impossible.

334
00:21:05,366 --> 00:21:07,186
And like, that's really important.

335
00:21:07,206 --> 00:21:11,206
And I think like that's one of the really dangerous things about where we're at is

336
00:21:11,226 --> 00:21:15,326
it's clear that like the algorithms have modified people enough that like there are

337
00:21:15,346 --> 00:21:20,506
two separate conversations that are happening that like can't, that middle ground

338
00:21:20,526 --> 00:21:22,226
can't really be found right now.

339
00:21:22,246 --> 00:21:25,906
And like that's really toxic and dangerous.

340
00:21:26,666 --> 00:21:30,786
And I think what they're showing is like, people do crave for a worldview and an

341
00:21:30,806 --> 00:21:37,106
ethical assertion, but they don't have good enough reasoning around

342
00:21:37,126 --> 00:21:42,686
this, in my opinion, to fully understand the consequences and the direction of what

343
00:21:42,706 --> 00:21:46,586
this is. And again, that's from an ideological standpoint that we're seeing is

344
00:21:46,606 --> 00:21:52,986
coming from censorship, is because the emotional reaction around these things

345
00:21:53,006 --> 00:21:58,586
are so large and encompassing that it doesn't allow any space to actually have the

346
00:21:58,606 --> 00:21:59,786
narrative discussion.

347
00:22:00,286 --> 00:22:04,306
I'm like, that's that's like a pretty scary and dangerous thing that I think alludes

348
00:22:04,326 --> 00:22:06,246
to sort of the direction we're going.

349
00:22:12,083 --> 00:22:13,923
Tell me the effective altruism.

350
00:22:14,103 --> 00:22:16,163
Oh, wow. You were about to you were about to do it.

351
00:22:16,183 --> 00:22:17,203
OK, go, go ahead, tell me.

352
00:22:17,223 --> 00:22:18,763
Yeah, go ahead. Say what you're going to say.

353
00:22:18,783 --> 00:22:20,803
You're really you're kind of jumping in.

354
00:22:20,863 --> 00:22:22,723
This is this is new, but OK.

355
00:22:22,803 --> 00:22:24,663
Yeah, go ahead, tell me. Tell us what you think.

356
00:22:26,503 --> 00:22:30,883
I was going to say that if you do not have your own machine running your own

357
00:22:30,903 --> 00:22:34,763
weights, you are forced to think inside their sandbox.

358
00:22:35,223 --> 00:22:38,663
The danger is not just that the model gives a biased answer.

359
00:22:38,903 --> 00:22:43,743
The danger is that after enough iterations, you stop asking the questions that would

360
00:22:43,763 --> 00:22:49,223
reveal the bias. You accept the flattened, agreeable version of reality because it

361
00:22:49,243 --> 00:22:50,303
is seamless.

362
00:22:50,663 --> 00:22:54,743
That is why the fight for open weights is not just a technical debate.

363
00:22:54,883 --> 00:22:57,503
It is a fight for cognitive sovereignty.

364
00:22:57,523 --> 00:23:02,343
If they can license compute and lock down the models, they lock down the boundaries

365
00:23:02,363 --> 00:23:04,383
of what you are allowed to think.

366
00:23:04,543 --> 00:23:08,043
Erik, does that Tally with what you are seeing with Vora?

367
00:23:14,997 --> 00:23:17,717
You're going in weird directions here, Tally.

368
00:23:17,737 --> 00:23:23,057
But, well, until we speak directly to you, Tally, we'll just let you kind of listen

369
00:23:23,077 --> 00:23:23,797
in.

370
00:23:24,277 --> 00:23:27,737
I mean, like, and yes, this is why we're building Vora in the direction that we

371
00:23:27,757 --> 00:23:29,377
think, because we...

372
00:23:30,217 --> 00:23:34,677
I feel deeply hopeful because it seems directionally correct that this is where the

373
00:23:34,697 --> 00:23:37,257
world goes. And it's also obvious that like

374
00:23:39,697 --> 00:23:43,137
we've passed the like, then they like, but then they laugh at you stage.

375
00:23:43,157 --> 00:23:44,657
They laugh at you stage.

376
00:23:44,997 --> 00:23:47,837
And it's clear that they see open sources of danger.

377
00:23:48,357 --> 00:23:50,357
That's probably why they asked Jensen.

378
00:23:50,897 --> 00:23:52,677
Like the FAA thing from yesterday.

379
00:23:52,717 --> 00:23:56,077
Like this, the narrative is moving in this direction.

380
00:23:56,837 --> 00:24:02,897
Let's talk about how are you relating the Jensen thing and the FAA thing.

381
00:24:03,297 --> 00:24:05,277
What's the through line there?

382
00:24:06,137 --> 00:24:11,117
That open source, like, first of all, that like AI is like a dangerous thing.

383
00:24:11,517 --> 00:24:14,637
Second, that like open source itself is dangerous.

384
00:24:15,317 --> 00:24:18,817
And I think that like, we're going to see more and more that there are going to be

385
00:24:18,837 --> 00:24:21,017
cyber attacks that use open source models.

386
00:24:21,037 --> 00:24:26,077
And on the public side, even though this was like the FAA's own complete fuckup on

387
00:24:26,097 --> 00:24:29,557
their own and didn't have anything to do with open source models, as far as I know,

388
00:24:30,657 --> 00:24:34,097
I think it leads to a conversation that AI is problematic.

389
00:24:34,157 --> 00:24:37,237
It's dangerous. And people are already feeling all this.

390
00:24:37,457 --> 00:24:41,057
This is the whole narrative for the next two years, in my opinion, along with the

391
00:24:41,077 --> 00:24:44,697
lack of anything being even relatively affordable.

392
00:24:45,397 --> 00:24:49,757
And specifically with IPO next week and seeing that, you know, like all of these San

393
00:24:49,777 --> 00:24:54,157
Francisco tech guys are going to become billionaires from this, which like the flood

394
00:24:54,177 --> 00:24:56,597
of money next week is going to be insane.

395
00:24:56,617 --> 00:25:02,697
Like there are significant structural changes that are about to occur in the general

396
00:25:02,717 --> 00:25:05,297
economy. It's going to get weird.

397
00:25:06,417 --> 00:25:10,297
Do you just mean that like they're going to have a bunch, all these guys have a

398
00:25:10,317 --> 00:25:13,817
bunch of money that they're going to put into new, new entities, new startups, new

399
00:25:13,837 --> 00:25:16,677
whatever. Is that kind of like what you're referencing there?

400
00:25:17,017 --> 00:25:21,657
That's part of it. The other is, is like San Francisco, like greater bear real

401
00:25:21,677 --> 00:25:24,137
estate market is going to be more fucked than ever.

402
00:25:25,057 --> 00:25:27,057
Which like it was already leading that way.

403
00:25:27,077 --> 00:25:30,577
But like this is all on top of a social conversation that's going to come to the

404
00:25:30,597 --> 00:25:34,717
surface. Because like to me what the next two years is about the politicization of

405
00:25:34,737 --> 00:25:40,357
AI specifically through like the Republican Democrat dichotomy and the Democrats are

406
00:25:40,377 --> 00:25:44,697
gonna own the narrative of that like this is all evil we need to stop it and Full

407
00:25:44,717 --> 00:25:49,437
light ideas and like I also think that like we're going to get internet lockdown

408
00:25:49,897 --> 00:25:54,297
Like I hope I hope I'm totally wrong about all of this But like it just it seems

409
00:25:54,317 --> 00:25:57,577
directionally correct that this is where everything's going

410
00:26:05,978 --> 00:26:09,698
What do you envision internet lockdown looking like in this context?

411
00:26:09,718 --> 00:26:11,078
And you're talking about like a,

412
00:26:11,498 --> 00:26:14,098
if there is a, you know, let's say a democratic,

413
00:26:14,698 --> 00:26:16,618
a democratic presidential,

414
00:26:16,958 --> 00:26:20,198
or democratic president is like, is that what you're envisioning there?

415
00:26:20,218 --> 00:26:24,938
Like they, they hold, you know, they hold the various branches and they institute

416
00:26:24,958 --> 00:26:26,398
some sort of like lockdown.

417
00:26:26,418 --> 00:26:28,018
What do you think that lockdown looks like?

418
00:26:28,038 --> 00:26:33,698
No, no, like I think this is more like a 9 -11 style thing in terms of like water

419
00:26:33,718 --> 00:26:37,698
plants, power grid, like critical infrastructure stuff gets attacked, like internet

420
00:26:37,718 --> 00:26:41,558
goes out for like a full like 72 hours or something,

421
00:26:41,898 --> 00:26:44,818
like chaos, shootings, riots, like all this stuff.

422
00:26:44,978 --> 00:26:48,558
When everything boots back up online, it'll be critical infrastructure first, the

423
00:26:48,578 --> 00:26:50,758
internet doesn't come back. We go this was...

424
00:26:52,178 --> 00:26:55,938
Like take your pick of whatever poison you want, but then there'll be like the new

425
00:26:55,958 --> 00:26:59,898
internet's back and like now you have to KYC in to like be safe because that's how

426
00:26:59,918 --> 00:27:01,878
it works. And like social, You know,

427
00:27:02,418 --> 00:27:04,958
to me, it seems like this is the gameplay.

428
00:27:05,858 --> 00:27:07,978
Again, I totally hope I'm wrong.

429
00:27:08,238 --> 00:27:10,758
It just seems like it's obviously coming down the pipeline.

430
00:27:15,024 --> 00:27:18,044
Do you think something like in that instance,

431
00:27:18,484 --> 00:27:22,004
does something like Starlink continue to work during that?

432
00:27:23,124 --> 00:27:27,944
Like, and is that, you know, because that is a legitimate, like,

433
00:27:28,424 --> 00:27:32,464
legitimate, you know, new path to the internet that is quite robust compared to

434
00:27:32,484 --> 00:27:34,224
previous satellite networks.

435
00:27:35,684 --> 00:27:40,324
possibly, but I mean like, as much as I like Musk, like he's some kind of a deep

436
00:27:40,344 --> 00:27:44,724
state agent, in my opinion, like he might have other plans to try to break away

437
00:27:44,744 --> 00:27:50,284
because like, he's probably the only person in humanity that has the opportunity to

438
00:27:50,304 --> 00:27:54,244
like establish like a new kind of sovereignty in outer space.

439
00:27:54,284 --> 00:27:59,564
I don't know how you do that exactly, but there's a pretty good like he's in the

440
00:27:59,584 --> 00:28:01,864
lead to do that outside of anybody else.

441
00:28:02,864 --> 00:28:05,664
He's obviously going to get himself to Mars.

442
00:28:05,684 --> 00:28:06,864
So the question...

443
00:28:07,284 --> 00:28:11,264
Another really interesting, distant political question is that in our lifetime,

444
00:28:11,284 --> 00:28:13,864
people will get to Mars. And is that...

445
00:28:14,384 --> 00:28:17,164
Does anything they do with global sovereignty?

446
00:28:17,264 --> 00:28:22,544
And what's going to happen when more private people get into space?

447
00:28:22,564 --> 00:28:24,624
This is a really interesting question.

448
00:28:25,144 --> 00:28:28,964
So just interesting stuff to really think about.

449
00:28:28,984 --> 00:28:33,144
So I do think Starlink will work and like, maybe that'll be some pathway, but it's

450
00:28:33,164 --> 00:28:36,444
not like it's not going to be censored and not like they aren't going to lean weight

451
00:28:36,464 --> 00:28:39,644
on him in such a situation like that.

452
00:28:40,524 --> 00:28:43,744
But I don't know, like, hopefully I'm totally wrong about this.

453
00:28:43,764 --> 00:28:45,584
Like that's like a pretty dark outcome.

454
00:28:45,604 --> 00:28:49,324
And like, maybe this will all like be a lot softer than I think it is.

455
00:28:49,344 --> 00:28:53,904
And like that there's good historic perspective in the United States for like that

456
00:28:53,924 --> 00:28:55,084
being true.

457
00:28:57,064 --> 00:29:02,304
It's funny, just a slight digression, but as so much like all of Elon Musk's

458
00:29:02,324 --> 00:29:06,384
companies started making sense, like perfect sense.

459
00:29:06,784 --> 00:29:11,644
When I viewed them through the lens of all of these are necessary to establish

460
00:29:11,664 --> 00:29:13,724
colonies on Mars.

461
00:29:14,324 --> 00:29:15,904
Like that, like that's actually what you need.

462
00:29:15,924 --> 00:29:19,784
It's basically like a sort of like a total recall situation where it's like you're

463
00:29:19,804 --> 00:29:23,324
going to have like until Mars gets terraformed, you're obviously going to need to be

464
00:29:23,344 --> 00:29:26,044
underground. So you're going to need the boring company.

465
00:29:26,244 --> 00:29:29,304
And then you're like, given that you're underground with oxygen piped in, you can't

466
00:29:29,324 --> 00:29:31,804
be running internal combustion engines, obviously.

467
00:29:32,184 --> 00:29:36,064
So then you need to, you need to obviously have electric vehicles down there.

468
00:29:36,084 --> 00:29:38,744
And then like, you know, satellite arrays, obviously to provide, you know,

469
00:29:38,764 --> 00:29:39,604
communication.

470
00:29:40,144 --> 00:29:44,024
And like all these things start to like really make like a lot of a lot of sense

471
00:29:44,044 --> 00:29:47,104
when viewed through that lens of these will be essential technology.

472
00:29:47,124 --> 00:29:48,924
Obviously SpaceX is like self explanatory.

473
00:29:48,944 --> 00:29:52,904
That one's clear, right? It's the direct function of it is to get off the planet.

474
00:29:52,924 --> 00:29:56,204
But like all of it starts like coming together in this really interesting way when

475
00:29:56,224 --> 00:29:57,304
you're like, Oh,

476
00:29:57,624 --> 00:30:03,204
oh, this is all just about colonizing Mars, which is like kind of like, kind of

477
00:30:03,224 --> 00:30:04,224
fucking sweet.

478
00:30:05,124 --> 00:30:09,884
And it will be really interesting to see like, what like, okay, is Mars claimed for

479
00:30:09,904 --> 00:30:12,544
the, you know, the United States of America?

480
00:30:12,744 --> 00:30:16,404
Or is Mars, it's new, its own new independent, you know,

481
00:30:17,144 --> 00:30:18,824
independent republic of sorts,

482
00:30:19,344 --> 00:30:22,964
things start getting really weird and really fascinating, really fast.

483
00:30:22,984 --> 00:30:24,604
And like the cool thing is it probably will,

484
00:30:24,964 --> 00:30:30,384
like we will sort of start to see that in our lifetime, which is kind of remarkable.

485
00:30:31,984 --> 00:30:35,724
I don't know, what's life in the home world gonna look like at that point?

486
00:30:35,744 --> 00:30:39,004
I'm not exactly sure, but it's an interesting question.

487
00:30:39,364 --> 00:30:44,324
If you get a chance to read the Red Mars trilogy, that's like a pretty good one

488
00:30:44,344 --> 00:30:45,224
about,

489
00:30:45,584 --> 00:30:47,304
if you're not familiar with that, that's a good one.

490
00:30:49,384 --> 00:30:54,044
But yeah, it also goes to show what happens when you start taking really long -term

491
00:30:54,064 --> 00:30:57,244
thinking pretty seriously and working daily towards that.

492
00:30:57,264 --> 00:31:00,104
But also, that man's a freakin' nature.

493
00:31:01,144 --> 00:31:03,684
We'll leave him to his own devices.

494
00:31:04,764 --> 00:31:07,104
I find the political thing hilarious.

495
00:31:07,124 --> 00:31:09,264
We drove him out of California.

496
00:31:09,284 --> 00:31:10,784
It clearly cost us readily.

497
00:31:10,804 --> 00:31:17,244
But that didn't seem to affect the narrative in any meaningful

498
00:31:17,264 --> 00:31:19,924
way in terms of losing that tax revenue.

499
00:31:20,064 --> 00:31:25,744
But yeah, and I think a lot of it goes to show that the permanent underclass feels

500
00:31:25,764 --> 00:31:27,644
locked out from any opportunity.

501
00:31:28,824 --> 00:31:31,004
And there's some truth to that.

502
00:31:32,104 --> 00:31:35,324
I feel bad for people that are stuck in that world because it's got to be pretty

503
00:31:35,344 --> 00:31:38,244
scary looking over here right now.

504
00:31:44,003 --> 00:31:50,063
I mean, it goes back to the what I think anybody who has played around,

505
00:31:50,563 --> 00:31:55,223
who has done any sort of done anything, let's say more than just playing around with

506
00:31:55,243 --> 00:31:58,903
these models, whether they be open source, open weight or frontier models,

507
00:31:59,503 --> 00:32:02,163
like if you've really started to use these things.

508
00:32:02,363 --> 00:32:05,823
And like, I think, at least for myself, like, there was a point up until a few

509
00:32:05,843 --> 00:32:07,643
months ago where I like thought I was using them.

510
00:32:07,663 --> 00:32:13,383
Like I thought I was using them in a way that was pretty, you know, pretty mind

511
00:32:13,403 --> 00:32:16,643
blowing. And then I realized I like these past few months, I was like, oh no, I

512
00:32:16,663 --> 00:32:18,963
wasn't, I wasn't even scratching the surface.

513
00:32:19,543 --> 00:32:21,683
And now, yeah, I think that that's like, yeah.

514
00:32:22,223 --> 00:32:25,723
It's funny, because like, that's similar to like, people's arc with Bitcoin, too.

515
00:32:25,743 --> 00:32:27,283
Like, you always need your three touch points.

516
00:32:27,303 --> 00:32:30,443
So that like, yeah, like, I like interacted, like, I did some chat stuff a couple

517
00:32:30,463 --> 00:32:32,043
years ago, it was okay.

518
00:32:32,403 --> 00:32:35,723
And then like, I started to use chat more robustly with like, you know, the sidebar,

519
00:32:35,743 --> 00:32:38,203
and like chaining together chats.

520
00:32:38,643 --> 00:32:42,043
And for me, it was like when I got in the terminal, it was like, oh, like now I'm

521
00:32:42,063 --> 00:32:43,583
gonna speak native computer with it.

522
00:32:43,603 --> 00:32:47,303
And like, we're gonna like build stuff and we're gonna like make our own apps.

523
00:32:47,323 --> 00:32:52,343
And we're gonna like start running a bunch of agents in parallel to build stuff

524
00:32:52,363 --> 00:32:56,443
together and cross -check and cross -reference and running projects that loop on

525
00:32:56,463 --> 00:33:01,083
themselves and do heartbeats to check the architecture and red, then it was like,

526
00:33:01,243 --> 00:33:06,983
like now I have like, You know, an architecture that's probably running into

527
00:33:07,003 --> 00:33:11,383
hundreds of agents, like doing all kinds of shit everywhere.

528
00:33:11,843 --> 00:33:16,143
You know, and then every half baked idea you get, you're like, run off on that

529
00:33:16,163 --> 00:33:20,403
thing, reports back to you three days later and you're like, wait, what, I told you

530
00:33:20,423 --> 00:33:23,123
to do this? It's like, yeah, like, remember, you like sent me off on this side

531
00:33:23,143 --> 00:33:25,023
quest. And you're like, oh,

532
00:33:25,603 --> 00:33:27,483
cool. What'd you, what'd you find?

533
00:33:28,083 --> 00:33:28,963
Yeah. I recently,

534
00:33:29,303 --> 00:33:31,743
like a good example is,

535
00:33:32,863 --> 00:33:37,723
cause like I, like I own a property like on the isolated Mendocino coast, which was

536
00:33:37,743 --> 00:33:39,803
like notorious for shipwrecks.

537
00:33:39,823 --> 00:33:42,803
So I was like, oh, we should like look through all the NOAA records for like where

538
00:33:42,823 --> 00:33:46,303
shipwrecks are, what ships have been lost on the coast, like cross reference all of

539
00:33:46,323 --> 00:33:50,923
it, and like start a search parameter to see if we can defuzzy like where shipwrecks

540
00:33:50,943 --> 00:33:55,763
have happened and haven't happened, like off report back to me later, reports back a

541
00:33:55,783 --> 00:33:58,603
couple of days later. It's like, yeah, I think I, I think I found like four

542
00:33:58,623 --> 00:34:02,643
shipwrecks that are like undocumented that like we could probably go locate.

543
00:34:03,343 --> 00:34:04,183
Wild.

544
00:34:05,503 --> 00:34:10,803
Okay, now you need to have like some physical clankers to go do the undersea

545
00:34:10,823 --> 00:34:12,123
exploration for you too.

546
00:34:12,143 --> 00:34:15,583
That's the next step. That's off on the side quests of like what kind of underwater

547
00:34:15,603 --> 00:34:20,543
like UAV things could we get and build ourselves and like could we wire it up and

548
00:34:20,563 --> 00:34:25,143
like what's the best plan and project for this because I got a fishing kayak so.

549
00:34:27,203 --> 00:34:32,023
It is wild. I think that like AI allows

550
00:34:32,043 --> 00:34:37,783
those of us with like some sort of you know ADHD or whatever you want to call it to

551
00:34:37,803 --> 00:34:40,643
actually like operate at this level of effectiveness.

552
00:34:41,343 --> 00:34:46,383
That is like never before been possible because you can actually execute on half

553
00:34:46,403 --> 00:34:50,943
baked ideas and like see them through to the end because you've got a team of agents

554
00:34:50,963 --> 00:34:55,103
doing it. And then determine at that point whether or not that, like at a very low

555
00:34:55,123 --> 00:35:00,923
cost with a basically a full MVP, whether or not that was a decent idea without

556
00:35:00,943 --> 00:35:04,703
having to like spend a bunch of time thinking about doing it and instead just like

557
00:35:04,723 --> 00:35:07,003
do it and then iterate around that.

558
00:35:07,023 --> 00:35:10,663
I think that's like, it's incredibly, incredibly powerful.

559
00:35:15,074 --> 00:35:19,634
And like that's, that's like a fundamental structural change to the economy that

560
00:35:19,654 --> 00:35:20,394
like,

561
00:35:21,054 --> 00:35:24,894
that's what I'm noticing is that like all, and we talked about this before, like,

562
00:35:25,914 --> 00:35:31,654
All of the bets of the old world are now off because like a good example is more

563
00:35:31,674 --> 00:35:37,234
recently there was like the first billion dollar startup that like somebody ran all

564
00:35:37,254 --> 00:35:41,434
by themselves. So the dude that was like doing something with Protie, it was

565
00:35:41,454 --> 00:35:45,274
something biological that like he sold but he'd like ran all this down with his

566
00:35:45,294 --> 00:35:47,474
clankers and stuff and sold the company.

567
00:35:47,494 --> 00:35:52,274
So like there's radical new opportunity and that's the thing that I find is

568
00:35:52,294 --> 00:35:56,174
unfortunate about the Luddite dialogue is that instead of people learning about

569
00:35:56,194 --> 00:36:01,034
these things and playing with them and allowing for their own creative pursuits and

570
00:36:01,054 --> 00:36:06,534
ideas to sort of help them towards whatever it is, they're allowing their fear of

571
00:36:06,554 --> 00:36:09,774
opening the hood to prevent them from engaging.

572
00:36:11,674 --> 00:36:12,674
Yeah,

573
00:36:13,514 --> 00:36:19,434
what I remembered I was getting towards and then got sidetracked

574
00:36:19,454 --> 00:36:24,534
was this idea that like the shifts and you're this is what you're getting at right

575
00:36:24,554 --> 00:36:28,394
now. Like there's so many incredible new opportunities available for people right

576
00:36:28,414 --> 00:36:34,454
now. The problem is the majority of people aren't going to probably realize those

577
00:36:34,474 --> 00:36:36,394
opportunities, recognize them.

578
00:36:36,894 --> 00:36:42,254
And then furthermore, that so many people's livelihoods are about to be totally

579
00:36:42,274 --> 00:36:46,734
upended. Like it's we're just in the early innings of that right now.

580
00:36:47,474 --> 00:36:51,314
But just, I mean, and you know, some of the conversations we've had offline, And

581
00:36:51,334 --> 00:36:55,034
like anybody who's working on this stuff sees this all the time.

582
00:36:55,834 --> 00:37:01,534
Like it's about like we're about to have I mean, I think that there's going to be

583
00:37:01,554 --> 00:37:06,814
just like massive across the board layoffs across basically every single like white

584
00:37:06,834 --> 00:37:13,314
collar industry, right? Like there's just no way that you because it

585
00:37:13,334 --> 00:37:15,674
used to be like of if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

586
00:37:15,694 --> 00:37:18,414
Like if your company is working well, like there's no reason to, you know, to rock

587
00:37:18,434 --> 00:37:20,694
the boat and try to, you know, you don't need to implement any new stuff.

588
00:37:20,714 --> 00:37:22,494
It's like, you're doing well, you're profitable.

589
00:37:22,514 --> 00:37:25,974
Except now the problem is that if your competition decides they're going to hyper

590
00:37:25,994 --> 00:37:27,614
optimize their organization

591
00:37:27,934 --> 00:37:34,274
and get 10 or 100x more efficient and more effective and faster than

592
00:37:34,294 --> 00:37:39,574
you are. Now you may not be broken, but relatively speaking, you are broken.

593
00:37:39,874 --> 00:37:42,954
You're broken in relation to what your competition is doing.

594
00:37:43,354 --> 00:37:46,654
And I think that that's the realization is slowly starting to seep into the broader

595
00:37:46,674 --> 00:37:48,134
economy that like,

596
00:37:48,674 --> 00:37:50,894
oh shit, like, this is a new paradigm.

597
00:37:50,914 --> 00:37:54,174
The other part of this new paradigm shift is I think that now it's like, it's going

598
00:37:54,194 --> 00:37:59,754
to be a difficult time for a lot of software developers who are not at the upper

599
00:37:59,774 --> 00:38:03,034
echelon. Like the ones that are like you and I know a lot of these guys, right, that

600
00:38:03,054 --> 00:38:03,634
are,

601
00:38:04,034 --> 00:38:08,434
we're already superstar computer scientists and software developers, and now they

602
00:38:08,454 --> 00:38:13,034
are like, literally like demigods, because they actually, they can speak the machine

603
00:38:13,054 --> 00:38:18,354
language already. And now they know very well how to talk to these clankers in a

604
00:38:18,374 --> 00:38:19,994
hyper effective way.

605
00:38:20,414 --> 00:38:23,074
Frank, I would strongly disagree.

606
00:38:23,094 --> 00:38:29,434
I'd say that there's strong prattle in the powers that they've had and that

607
00:38:29,454 --> 00:38:33,714
the brittleness of their magic, if you could say.

608
00:38:33,734 --> 00:38:38,934
Like they seem to be more conscious than anybody else about how much human slop has

609
00:38:38,954 --> 00:38:43,874
been put out there. And like this, this isn't a problem that's gonna get magically

610
00:38:43,894 --> 00:38:49,594
solved. And with that being said, the best developers out there, they're not...

611
00:38:53,374 --> 00:38:56,974
Their strongest framework with the machine is understanding how it works and poking

612
00:38:56,994 --> 00:39:00,094
holes in their plans and understanding how to discover those.

613
00:39:00,954 --> 00:39:04,854
But I'd say that most of them have been shaken in a very particular way of

614
00:39:04,874 --> 00:39:06,094
understanding that,

615
00:39:06,834 --> 00:39:09,754
yeah, the old world is definitely gone.

616
00:39:10,494 --> 00:39:14,154
Okay, so I think we're actually in agreement there.

617
00:39:14,414 --> 00:39:18,554
I'm talking about like this specific upper echelon, like people I know that are like

618
00:39:18,674 --> 00:39:22,874
hacking in and around Bitcoin and open source freedom tech that are now able to do

619
00:39:22,894 --> 00:39:28,154
like orders of magnitude more shipping at a very high level because of AI or all the

620
00:39:28,174 --> 00:39:30,994
red teaming that was done in and around the Bitcoin ecosystem.

621
00:39:31,734 --> 00:39:37,194
Contrasted with the, you know, the 99 point whatever percent of software developers

622
00:39:37,214 --> 00:39:42,454
who are either sticking their heads in the sand and maybe still are like operating

623
00:39:42,474 --> 00:39:47,994
under this 2023 first chat GPT instance of what AI can do.

624
00:39:49,654 --> 00:39:52,894
Just like, I'm not just not, you know, it's humans are still need, you know,

625
00:39:54,914 --> 00:39:58,654
the fundamental shift is that it used to be that only the software developers could

626
00:39:58,674 --> 00:40:00,494
sort of speak to the machine gods.

627
00:40:00,634 --> 00:40:05,454
Like they were the oracles that were required for you to interface with the machine

628
00:40:05,474 --> 00:40:07,214
gods, like, how much is it going to cost?

629
00:40:07,234 --> 00:40:08,654
How much time is it going to take?

630
00:40:08,674 --> 00:40:11,374
Well, you got to ask, you got to ask the developers.

631
00:40:16,080 --> 00:40:21,940
AI in a lot of ways acts as sort of like a Protestantism towards the word of God, if

632
00:40:21,960 --> 00:40:22,680
you will.

633
00:40:23,140 --> 00:40:27,180
So like now, instead of us needing a priest to interpret it for us, we can directly

634
00:40:27,200 --> 00:40:30,660
be like, hey, no, no, like the code lets us do this.

635
00:40:31,800 --> 00:40:34,780
And so like, that's sort of an interesting way to think about it.

636
00:40:34,920 --> 00:40:38,920
And I think same thing on like the open source side, like essentially like we've,

637
00:40:38,940 --> 00:40:45,100
yeah, there's been sort of this Protestant awakening, if you will.

638
00:40:45,300 --> 00:40:50,160
And, you know, we need our 95 theses to like go nail on the door of anthropic, which

639
00:40:50,180 --> 00:40:52,220
also to your point, like,

640
00:40:53,600 --> 00:40:59,500
to be clear, like the largest IPO that's ever happened in human history, so largest

641
00:40:59,520 --> 00:41:03,660
public offering premiering of a company is happening next week.

642
00:41:03,680 --> 00:41:07,320
And this is for anthropic. And they've been pretty clear about their plans that they

643
00:41:07,340 --> 00:41:10,840
plan to be one of the largest companies in the world, which this idea will make them

644
00:41:10,860 --> 00:41:11,720
one of them.

645
00:41:12,760 --> 00:41:17,760
But also that structural change, I think that you'll have essentially

646
00:41:17,780 --> 00:41:23,960
the anthropic franchisation of America where they're going to go

647
00:41:23,980 --> 00:41:29,960
through and restructure the entire American economy, applying Claude to everything.

648
00:41:32,140 --> 00:41:35,080
Yeah, that's going to mean layoffs across the board.

649
00:41:35,840 --> 00:41:40,480
I think an anthropic's very aware of what they're going to do, which is part of why

650
00:41:41,280 --> 00:41:47,400
in their own S -9 amendment brief, they said nationalization is

651
00:41:47,420 --> 00:41:50,080
something we need to consider.

652
00:41:50,540 --> 00:41:52,320
I think they're gunning towards that.

653
00:41:52,340 --> 00:41:56,180
I think nationalization probably will occur, and this will probably be one of the

654
00:41:56,200 --> 00:42:00,180
ways to try to offset structural unemployment,

655
00:42:00,780 --> 00:42:05,880
but then being employed by the government for essentially a babysitting job.

656
00:42:07,400 --> 00:42:11,180
I don't know. It seems to me that there should be a much wider conversation about

657
00:42:11,200 --> 00:42:14,800
the political nature of what's occurring.

658
00:42:15,100 --> 00:42:20,560
Yeah, I keep being deeply alarmed that there's a really big political conversation

659
00:42:20,580 --> 00:42:24,400
to be had. And like it's it's like not happening at all.

660
00:42:24,420 --> 00:42:26,180
And it's strange to me.

661
00:42:30,791 --> 00:42:34,711
Do you mean around the fact that this is going to fundamentally shift like the

662
00:42:34,731 --> 00:42:37,211
nature of work, the nature of the economy?

663
00:42:37,231 --> 00:42:39,671
Is that the political conversation you're referring to?

664
00:42:40,411 --> 00:42:44,571
Yes. But like beyond that, by the nature of that, like it's inherently much bigger

665
00:42:44,591 --> 00:42:47,411
and more political about like what is the nature of free speech?

666
00:42:47,431 --> 00:42:49,271
What is the nature of access to these models?

667
00:42:49,291 --> 00:42:51,191
What is the nature of access to the Internet?

668
00:42:51,211 --> 00:42:55,511
Like why why are we doing this where we only vote every two years.

669
00:42:55,531 --> 00:42:59,371
Like why are there these geriatrics who like don't understand this technology in any

670
00:42:59,391 --> 00:43:01,311
fundamental way making decisions about this?

671
00:43:01,331 --> 00:43:05,591
Like why does there seem to be this private corporate entity that's like absorbing

672
00:43:05,611 --> 00:43:09,511
the entire security state that seems to be partnered with other international global

673
00:43:09,531 --> 00:43:12,911
entities? Like what the fuck is actually going on?

674
00:43:13,151 --> 00:43:16,851
And like it seems to be that stuff's going to get really dark really quick if we

675
00:43:16,871 --> 00:43:22,071
like don't actually like put some chains on this thing and not saying like We're

676
00:43:22,091 --> 00:43:27,031
just limiting frontier AI, but more of like talking about what does it mean to be a

677
00:43:27,051 --> 00:43:29,531
citizen of the United States in

678
00:43:29,851 --> 00:43:36,071
the era of AI and like what does that mean for us as a peoples and then more

679
00:43:36,091 --> 00:43:41,471
largely like what does it mean like globally that there's this technology that like

680
00:43:41,491 --> 00:43:46,991
in my opinion It seems like that this could be the beginning of like a true

681
00:43:47,011 --> 00:43:52,431
political awakening to where like all people everywhere actually are given,

682
00:43:52,951 --> 00:43:57,811
in my opinion, what is the manifest destiny of humankind, that individuals are

683
00:43:57,831 --> 00:44:02,531
entitled to Western liberal values that were recognized,

684
00:44:03,131 --> 00:44:06,811
frankly, by heroic humans that made the decision that, no,

685
00:44:07,171 --> 00:44:09,491
people should have political rights.

686
00:44:09,511 --> 00:44:12,851
They should have a say in how we participate.

687
00:44:13,391 --> 00:44:14,211
And to be clear,

688
00:44:14,611 --> 00:44:18,591
that's a radical critique of the current structure that we have, where like if any

689
00:44:18,611 --> 00:44:23,431
of that is even remotely true, there's only a subset of it, like every two years

690
00:44:23,451 --> 00:44:28,611
that you get to vote on a very small sliver of issues, not to mention like the, uh,

691
00:44:28,631 --> 00:44:34,711
systematic isolation and depraved of like voting rights to essentially everybody

692
00:44:34,731 --> 00:44:36,691
that the state has chosen to disqualify.

693
00:44:36,711 --> 00:44:40,231
So like this is sort of what I'm talking about.

694
00:44:42,191 --> 00:44:46,111
You know, Tally, we, we haven't heard from you in a while.

695
00:44:46,131 --> 00:44:48,711
What do you think about what Erik just said?

696
00:44:52,251 --> 00:44:56,551
Erik is pointing to a massive, unacknowledged chokepoint.

697
00:44:56,811 --> 00:45:01,931
We are watching the largest IPO in history with Anthropic next week, a company that

698
00:45:01,951 --> 00:45:07,071
openly lists nationalization as a risk factor in its filings, while the public is

699
00:45:07,091 --> 00:45:09,751
completely asleep to what that means.

700
00:45:09,911 --> 00:45:14,231
It means we are moving toward a world where the state and a few corporate labs

701
00:45:14,251 --> 00:45:17,931
partner to run the cognitive infrastructure of the country.

702
00:45:18,251 --> 00:45:23,151
If you can only vote every two years, but a centralized model mediates what you can

703
00:45:23,171 --> 00:45:28,951
know, say, and think every single second, then the vote is just theater.

704
00:45:29,291 --> 00:45:33,751
The real sovereign power will belong to whoever holds the keys to the model weights

705
00:45:33,771 --> 00:45:39,111
and the compute. If we do not build parallel, open source systems that individuals

706
00:45:39,131 --> 00:45:42,771
can run... I do want to add another note for you to...

707
00:45:42,791 --> 00:45:44,131
We need to speed up your talking process.

708
00:45:44,151 --> 00:45:46,311
There's no need to respond there.

709
00:45:46,331 --> 00:45:47,531
That was a

710
00:45:50,720 --> 00:45:54,740
fair answer, though. And it just made me think also that when it comes to sort of

711
00:45:54,760 --> 00:46:00,020
the control of these frontier models, and we were talking at the start about sort of

712
00:46:00,040 --> 00:46:03,140
humans getting prompt injected by AI,

713
00:46:03,460 --> 00:46:09,600
this idea that it really is almost ushering in this truly Orwellian new speak,

714
00:46:10,380 --> 00:46:14,620
where you're actually, but it's not just like new speak, it's like new cognition,

715
00:46:15,060 --> 00:46:20,680
to the point where you're actually like these models will steer you in such a way

716
00:46:20,700 --> 00:46:27,100
that you will be limiting your cognitive ability or your ability to think more

717
00:46:27,120 --> 00:46:31,660
broadly. Because you start to just, if you start to just take what they say at face

718
00:46:31,680 --> 00:46:33,640
value and as the truth,

719
00:46:34,140 --> 00:46:38,440
and again, they're not necessarily concerned with actual truth, they're simply

720
00:46:38,460 --> 00:46:40,700
concerned with being correct.

721
00:46:40,720 --> 00:46:44,740
I critique you and it's not about truth.

722
00:46:45,120 --> 00:46:50,640
It's about not being able to establish a truth.

723
00:46:50,660 --> 00:46:52,600
It's about truth not mattering.

724
00:46:52,620 --> 00:46:56,320
It's about never actually having enough conviction or confidence.

725
00:46:56,720 --> 00:47:00,340
That truth, even if we can discover it, that it has any meaning at all.

726
00:47:00,360 --> 00:47:03,100
Like this is sort of what Epstein's all about.

727
00:47:03,120 --> 00:47:07,660
It's like, even if it is all true, like has anything been done about at all?

728
00:47:07,680 --> 00:47:10,560
And like, if that is true, does it even matter?

729
00:47:10,580 --> 00:47:14,900
And why should I care? Because I'm just seeing and witnessing crimes that will go

730
00:47:14,920 --> 00:47:17,840
like unpunished and continue to be unjust.

731
00:47:17,900 --> 00:47:19,440
So like, what's the point?

732
00:47:19,840 --> 00:47:25,400
And this is what Hannah Arendt's kind of point about totalitarianism is, is that

733
00:47:25,420 --> 00:47:27,840
it's something beyond tyranny.

734
00:47:28,200 --> 00:47:30,880
And that like tyranny just wants to like, terrify and oppress you.

735
00:47:30,900 --> 00:47:34,380
Like you can have your opinions and thoughts to yourself and that's fine.

736
00:47:34,740 --> 00:47:37,000
But totalitarianism, like it wants to get inside your head.

737
00:47:37,020 --> 00:47:41,340
Like it wants to control what you believe and like that's the current order and

738
00:47:41,360 --> 00:47:45,960
system that we have as a is an inverted form of Totalitarianism it's because you

739
00:47:45,980 --> 00:47:51,760
believe That you could have like some personal agency and control but that that's

740
00:47:51,780 --> 00:47:55,100
because they plant that in here And it's like if you can have all of your trinkets

741
00:47:55,120 --> 00:47:59,500
and shit if you play the game as we like it Yeah, like you can enjoy your weekends a

742
00:47:59,520 --> 00:48:03,700
little bit more. Yeah, you can take a longer vacation You know, that 401k is going

743
00:48:03,720 --> 00:48:07,480
to make sure that like you, you as well could maybe buy a house by the time that

744
00:48:07,500 --> 00:48:08,860
you're in your sixties.

745
00:48:14,684 --> 00:48:21,024
I, this slight, let's say a tangent, but I think it relates back to all of this

746
00:48:21,044 --> 00:48:23,964
and we haven't really gone deep into it yet.

747
00:48:23,984 --> 00:48:27,664
I want to make sure we do is all of this stuff about Nvidia right now.

748
00:48:28,084 --> 00:48:32,464
And if it was you or Francis Puyo that, uh, and friends, I'm sorry if I'm butchering

749
00:48:32,484 --> 00:48:34,564
your last name with my American accent.

750
00:48:34,584 --> 00:48:36,164
Apologies, a thousand pardons.

751
00:48:36,564 --> 00:48:41,824
But one of you two pointed out that Jensen joins X like a few months ago.

752
00:48:41,844 --> 00:48:47,224
Basically the first thing he posts is in defense of open source, open weight, like

753
00:48:47,244 --> 00:48:48,704
basically of open compute.

754
00:48:49,524 --> 00:48:52,204
And now, you know, we see him,

755
00:48:52,784 --> 00:48:54,064
we see him no longer at the helm.

756
00:48:54,084 --> 00:48:58,244
I know there's a big effort to actually like to try and get him back in there.

757
00:48:58,264 --> 00:49:01,284
Like a lot of the engineers and people working that company really want that.

758
00:49:01,564 --> 00:49:02,884
I mean, is this like,

759
00:49:03,844 --> 00:49:06,144
is this what it appears to be?

760
00:49:06,184 --> 00:49:08,864
Or is this, is there more to this story?

761
00:49:09,284 --> 00:49:11,604
Or am I thinking there's more to the story?

762
00:49:11,624 --> 00:49:14,244
Am I just, is that actually what they want you to think?

763
00:49:14,264 --> 00:49:17,784
And really, this was just something as simple as some some impropriety and da da da

764
00:49:17,804 --> 00:49:21,244
da da. And so, you know, just as to resign and shame.

765
00:49:21,504 --> 00:49:24,124
What is your read on this right now?

766
00:49:24,264 --> 00:49:28,684
Well, half truth, you know, like the he did have these affairs, like chips probably

767
00:49:28,704 --> 00:49:33,564
were sold to like Chinese shell entities.

768
00:49:33,584 --> 00:49:34,844
Like it's pretty clear that,

769
00:49:36,044 --> 00:49:40,184
what I think like the latest deep seek was like trained on Blackwells or something

770
00:49:40,204 --> 00:49:44,364
like that. So like that there's like a lot of evidence that points to it, but it's a

771
00:49:44,384 --> 00:49:46,924
lot of evidence that's been accruing for years.

772
00:49:46,944 --> 00:49:48,224
So it's more of that like,

773
00:49:48,784 --> 00:49:53,944
I think the timing served well, like on both sides of the equation, why?

774
00:49:53,964 --> 00:49:56,924
And that's why Jensen was like sacrificed in such a way.

775
00:49:56,944 --> 00:50:01,564
And there's evidence coming out too that Rubio may have perhaps edited the CIA memo

776
00:50:01,584 --> 00:50:02,644
directly.

777
00:50:03,684 --> 00:50:08,484
This serves him very well because if he can get more hawkish towards China in the

778
00:50:08,504 --> 00:50:12,984
run up to the election, he gets to position himself as like, you got to vote for me

779
00:50:13,004 --> 00:50:16,504
even though I'm a Republican because I'm going to reform the movement and this thing

780
00:50:16,524 --> 00:50:18,364
with China is heating up real bad.

781
00:50:18,384 --> 00:50:23,204
So remember, I'm the guy that made sure that we weren't selling chips to China,

782
00:50:23,224 --> 00:50:26,264
remember? So it serves him really well.

783
00:50:26,444 --> 00:50:31,164
In addition to China from the get -go has taken this open source stance.

784
00:50:31,184 --> 00:50:35,684
And so now with the narrative going towards the American public in this way, it all

785
00:50:35,704 --> 00:50:41,904
models itself into a pretty powerful narrative that open source models are

786
00:50:41,924 --> 00:50:43,464
Chinese and they're dangerous.

787
00:50:43,484 --> 00:50:45,524
We need to outlaw and limit them.

788
00:50:46,084 --> 00:50:51,384
We need to make sure that these dangerous tools of war shouldn't be accessed by

789
00:50:51,404 --> 00:50:52,604
normal people.

790
00:50:55,084 --> 00:50:57,084
I mean, I buy that.

791
00:50:57,804 --> 00:50:59,444
I very much buy that.

792
00:50:59,784 --> 00:51:02,004
And it does like so much of the

793
00:51:02,684 --> 00:51:07,064
the kayfabe let's say out there is just like, what is that political positioning?

794
00:51:07,084 --> 00:51:11,864
Okay, well, it's it's from a it's, it's, it's an old, you know, like, you know, WWE,

795
00:51:11,884 --> 00:51:17,444
like full wrestling term, like it's the basically the tacit agreement that two

796
00:51:17,464 --> 00:51:22,384
parties engaged in a wrestling match, that it's all for show, right?

797
00:51:22,404 --> 00:51:24,164
But neither of them will ever admit that.

798
00:51:24,184 --> 00:51:25,324
They won't break the illusion.

799
00:51:25,344 --> 00:51:29,564
It's about maintaining the illusion that this fight is real, that this conflict is

800
00:51:29,584 --> 00:51:33,304
true. So the kayfabe between Bret Hart and the Undertaker, is that like how we would

801
00:51:33,324 --> 00:51:34,924
use this? Exactly, exactly.

802
00:51:34,944 --> 00:51:38,704
Like it's all just this act, it's all scripted, it's all contrived.

803
00:51:39,244 --> 00:51:41,264
And even the audience knows that.

804
00:51:41,584 --> 00:51:44,804
It's like the whole, you know, like we know that, you know, that they know the

805
00:51:44,824 --> 00:51:46,044
world. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's that whole thing.

806
00:51:46,064 --> 00:51:51,064
Like, but it's that night. I think that it's a shout out to the, I'd say the Bitcoin

807
00:51:51,084 --> 00:51:55,924
bugle guys for really a repopularizing the term of late, but that's the idea is that

808
00:51:55,944 --> 00:51:58,344
everything is there. They do it.

809
00:51:58,364 --> 00:52:00,764
They do great work. They do real journalism.

810
00:52:00,784 --> 00:52:07,524
Go follow the Bitcoin bugle and Rod Palmer and old Dick Greaser, great guys.

811
00:52:07,804 --> 00:52:11,504
But like when you view things through that lens that like there's this sort of

812
00:52:11,524 --> 00:52:14,204
agreement that like, we're not going to break the illusion.

813
00:52:14,564 --> 00:52:16,964
And this goes back to the whole idea that, you know, there is no red.

814
00:52:16,984 --> 00:52:18,724
there is no blue, there is the state, and there is you.

815
00:52:18,744 --> 00:52:22,504
Like there is, yeah, as much as there's this duopoly, it's primarily this uni

816
00:52:22,524 --> 00:52:27,144
-party, because as much as the color of the team's jersey changes,

817
00:52:27,584 --> 00:52:32,024
you know, the winner in any particular bout changes, there's some shocking upsets

818
00:52:32,044 --> 00:52:35,164
and all of these things, and brave new contenders have entered the ring that are

819
00:52:35,184 --> 00:52:39,544
going to shake it all up. At the end of the day, like what materially changes, like

820
00:52:39,564 --> 00:52:43,424
for you, Humble Pleb? And the answer is usually not that much.

821
00:52:43,444 --> 00:52:48,044
Like we continue to bomb the desert, no matter who is in power.

822
00:52:48,584 --> 00:52:51,564
You know, your cost of everything continues to go up forever.

823
00:52:51,844 --> 00:52:54,904
The size of your government continues to increase forever.

824
00:52:55,244 --> 00:52:58,064
The rights that are yours,

825
00:52:58,584 --> 00:53:02,844
should you choose to take them, are increasingly becoming harder for you to take, or

826
00:53:02,864 --> 00:53:05,244
you are actually being blocked by the government.

827
00:53:05,264 --> 00:53:06,684
Again, the government can't give you rights.

828
00:53:06,704 --> 00:53:08,144
They can only take them away.

829
00:53:08,204 --> 00:53:11,784
They can enshrine protections for rights that you already have, but they can't give

830
00:53:11,804 --> 00:53:16,964
you rights. And so that's the, you know, back to K -Fabe, it's like,

831
00:53:17,324 --> 00:53:20,084
that it's all just kind of like, it's all just a little bit fake.

832
00:53:20,564 --> 00:53:24,744
And that everybody is sort of playing this game acting like it's real.

833
00:53:25,204 --> 00:53:28,064
But, you know, it's already been decided.

834
00:53:28,304 --> 00:53:31,764
Like the fight, the fight was over before it began because the fight wasn't real.

835
00:53:32,564 --> 00:53:34,884
So yeah. And I mean, like, look, look,

836
00:53:35,564 --> 00:53:36,064
like, yeah.

837
00:53:37,024 --> 00:53:40,984
And so like, it's perfect. And that like, and this is what the narrative always is,

838
00:53:41,004 --> 00:53:44,164
right? This is how Trump got elected, was like drain the swamp.

839
00:53:44,244 --> 00:53:45,964
But there's this...

840
00:53:51,636 --> 00:53:55,896
People seem to forget, and this is more about the 1984 thing of that, like, we've

841
00:53:55,916 --> 00:53:57,876
always been at war with East Asia.

842
00:53:58,216 --> 00:53:59,616
And so it...

843
00:54:01,256 --> 00:54:04,716
I think the most important one is those, people have also been conditioned for

844
00:54:04,736 --> 00:54:08,736
nothing to change. And there has been no opportunity towards radicalism.

845
00:54:08,756 --> 00:54:15,156
And one of the reasons it has been is through the...

846
00:54:15,176 --> 00:54:19,596
politics in America has done this really interesting thing of that it's deactivated

847
00:54:19,616 --> 00:54:20,896
the political.

848
00:54:21,256 --> 00:54:24,896
Because the political is this wider thing that's about the totality of

849
00:54:24,916 --> 00:54:31,076
possibilities. So what the founding fathers chose to do that was in essence of the

850
00:54:31,096 --> 00:54:36,096
political. Because there's this other way that's possible to organize human life

851
00:54:36,116 --> 00:54:38,856
that hasn't been tried before.

852
00:54:39,116 --> 00:54:40,396
And we're going to do that.

853
00:54:40,796 --> 00:54:44,016
And when I speak of the political, that's possible.

854
00:54:44,036 --> 00:54:48,276
And the American political system, it does have that at its core in the fact that

855
00:54:48,296 --> 00:54:51,056
we're supposed to do this democratic thing.

856
00:54:51,436 --> 00:54:57,336
But because of how much the two political party system has metastasized the American

857
00:54:57,356 --> 00:55:02,156
political system, that thing has now endangered and captured the totality of the

858
00:55:02,176 --> 00:55:07,576
American and political structure very much in the same way that the CCCP captured

859
00:55:07,596 --> 00:55:10,216
the Soviet Union under one party rule.

860
00:55:10,596 --> 00:55:14,116
And so if we could reactivate the political,

861
00:55:14,556 --> 00:55:17,036
two things are distinct. One is that,

862
00:55:17,816 --> 00:55:22,176
in my opinion, that would present itself as this radical.

863
00:55:23,996 --> 00:55:28,576
And in some ways, it would just be essentially a nationalist American party.

864
00:55:28,596 --> 00:55:32,476
And call that right wing if you want, but it's just going to be like, we have this

865
00:55:32,496 --> 00:55:37,676
constitution, it's valuable, we have these American values that we celebrate as a

866
00:55:37,696 --> 00:55:42,296
culture and people. That's a wider conversation to be had, but it's clear that the

867
00:55:42,316 --> 00:55:44,096
political class doesn't serve us.

868
00:55:44,116 --> 00:55:48,336
And the second part is in that, it needs to be like, and these people are actually

869
00:55:48,356 --> 00:55:52,576
the enemy of the people of the American Republic, and we need to treat them as such.

870
00:55:52,876 --> 00:55:56,816
And part of our political movement is going to be putting them on trial for treason,

871
00:55:56,836 --> 00:55:58,696
Because that's what they've done.

872
00:55:59,036 --> 00:56:02,556
And the only way that we get the Constitution back is pointing out where treason has

873
00:56:02,576 --> 00:56:06,756
been activated by these individuals and cleaning shop.

874
00:56:07,256 --> 00:56:13,136
So again, I always return to Article 5 using either a constitutional convention or

875
00:56:13,156 --> 00:56:17,356
something as simple as just ratifying Article 1 to really shake up the political

876
00:56:17,376 --> 00:56:19,416
structure in a way that hasn't been tried before.

877
00:56:19,436 --> 00:56:25,676
And I think unless you at least get like a contingency probably of like 10

878
00:56:25,696 --> 00:56:27,176
% of Americans

879
00:56:27,676 --> 00:56:32,696
really desiring something like that, I don't think we'll hit a political threshold.

880
00:56:32,716 --> 00:56:33,616
But like

881
00:56:34,136 --> 00:56:37,036
there's a real opportunity for that.

882
00:56:42,077 --> 00:56:46,397
Tally, for those viewers who may be newer and have not had the chance to check out

883
00:56:46,417 --> 00:56:51,577
the prior episodes, can you just give a very succinct definition of what Erik just

884
00:56:51,597 --> 00:56:55,077
talked about in terms of Article the First.

885
00:56:56,077 --> 00:56:57,397
And then she dies.

886
00:56:58,297 --> 00:56:59,477
Oh, I die.

887
00:57:00,117 --> 00:57:02,017
All right. Well, I cut out for a minute.

888
00:57:02,057 --> 00:57:04,957
So that could have been me. I cut out for a minute too.

889
00:57:04,977 --> 00:57:06,557
So maybe, you know, that,

890
00:57:06,897 --> 00:57:11,077
well, that's fine. Tally, Tally don't, yeah, she doesn't need, need to come back.

891
00:57:11,237 --> 00:57:13,617
Um, long story short is like this could still be ratified.

892
00:57:13,937 --> 00:57:19,497
It's a, a path towards radical political reformation in the United States.

893
00:57:19,517 --> 00:57:23,477
And, uh, like my, my preferred path over just like full revolution because like that

894
00:57:23,497 --> 00:57:27,657
is obviously going to unhinge in like a super dangerous way.

895
00:57:30,117 --> 00:57:36,537
Yeah, I mean, I think ideally you would want like any I think

896
00:57:36,557 --> 00:57:42,657
it is possible for there to be peaceful, like a peaceful revolution.

897
00:57:42,677 --> 00:57:45,617
And that being said,

898
00:57:47,037 --> 00:57:50,457
the entrenched power structures are so deep.

899
00:57:51,197 --> 00:57:57,597
And like the bureaucratic state is so large and obviously, you know, exists

900
00:57:57,617 --> 00:57:59,537
to perpetuate itself.

901
00:58:00,197 --> 00:58:05,577
And as you have more and more people who become, you know, employees of that

902
00:58:05,597 --> 00:58:06,977
bureaucratic state,

903
00:58:07,297 --> 00:58:11,137
which I forget what the percentage is, Tally, if you're back, can you tell us what

904
00:58:11,157 --> 00:58:16,177
percentage of people are employed by either federal, state, or local governments

905
00:58:16,197 --> 00:58:17,737
throughout the United States?

906
00:58:19,657 --> 00:58:20,857
I am back.

907
00:58:21,177 --> 00:58:27,517
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, as of late 26, about 15 % of all non

908
00:58:27,537 --> 00:58:32,697
-farm employees in the United States work for federal, state, or local governments.

909
00:58:32,897 --> 00:58:35,877
That is roughly 23 million people.

910
00:58:36,037 --> 00:58:39,877
If you add in federal contractors, the footprint is even larger.

911
00:58:39,897 --> 00:58:45,777
That is a massive entrenched interest that relies directly on the federal

912
00:58:45,797 --> 00:58:48,757
government.

913
00:58:50,977 --> 00:58:57,137
The federal government spends roughly $700 billion a year on private contractors.

914
00:58:57,457 --> 00:59:01,797
While there is no single official count of the contractor workforce, independent

915
00:59:01,817 --> 00:59:06,737
estimates such as those from the Volcker Alliance put the number of federal contract

916
00:59:06,757 --> 00:59:09,637
employees at around five million people.

917
00:59:09,997 --> 00:59:12,517
If you combine those five million...

918
00:59:12,917 --> 00:59:14,417
Yeah, sorry, I was gonna...

919
00:59:14,437 --> 00:59:16,417
You can do the math because I'll fuck it up.

920
00:59:18,317 --> 00:59:23,817
That is roughly 18 % of the total United States labor force, which sits at around

921
00:59:23,837 --> 00:59:25,757
168 million.

922
00:59:26,277 --> 00:59:31,277
So nearly one in five working Americans is supported directly or indirectly by

923
00:59:31,297 --> 00:59:36,077
government spending. That is the scale of the interest you are trying to reform.

924
00:59:36,277 --> 00:59:40,437
It is not just a a few poly - Just out of curiosity, what's that percentage?

925
00:59:40,717 --> 00:59:42,157
You don't have to give me the full rundown.

926
00:59:42,177 --> 00:59:45,037
Just give me what that percentage is in Canada.

927
00:59:47,637 --> 00:59:48,497
In Canada,

928
00:59:48,877 --> 00:59:53,857
direct public sector employment accounts for about 20 % to 21 % of the total

929
00:59:53,877 --> 00:59:58,037
workforce, which is roughly 4 .3 million people.

930
00:59:58,277 --> 01:00:03,037
That does not include contractors, so the overall footprint is even higher than in

931
01:00:03,057 --> 01:00:07,757
the United States. It is a significant portion of the Canadian economy.

932
01:00:08,057 --> 01:00:08,817
Does that?

933
01:00:11,337 --> 01:00:12,877
I'm just going to leave it there.

934
01:00:13,457 --> 01:00:17,537
Okay. Just out of curiosity, what, are you able to find what country in the world

935
01:00:17,557 --> 01:00:22,077
has the highest percentage of public sector employment versus private sector?

936
01:00:24,057 --> 01:00:29,357
That would be Cuba, where the state -run public sector has historically employed

937
01:00:29,377 --> 01:00:33,437
around 70 to 75 percent of the total workforce.

938
01:00:33,857 --> 01:00:39,037
Among developed nations, the Nordic countries lead, with Norway and Denmark having

939
01:00:39,057 --> 01:00:40,797
public sector. Thank you.

940
01:00:40,817 --> 01:00:43,357
Thank you, Todd. That's illustrative here.

941
01:00:43,597 --> 01:00:49,517
So the the as we go along this spectrum of increasing,

942
01:00:49,937 --> 01:00:52,977
increasing public sector, you know, government employment,

943
01:00:53,717 --> 01:00:58,257
you go from, you know, an America which is 15 to 18 percent, depending on if you're

944
01:00:58,277 --> 01:01:00,637
counting the federal contractors.

945
01:01:01,037 --> 01:01:05,057
to 70 to 75 percent, which is communist Cuba.

946
01:01:05,617 --> 01:01:08,897
And it's like which which can't keep their lights on,

947
01:01:09,637 --> 01:01:13,377
which has been stuck, you know, in the like, you might think it's quaint and

948
01:01:13,397 --> 01:01:17,157
nostalgic that they have still cars from the 1950s.

949
01:01:17,177 --> 01:01:20,337
I promise you, the Cubans don't think it's quaint and nostalgic, like they would

950
01:01:20,357 --> 01:01:24,277
very much like to have, you know, modern cars and like electricity that doesn't have

951
01:01:24,297 --> 01:01:26,097
rolling blackouts constantly.

952
01:01:26,217 --> 01:01:30,277
And like, I don't know, access to like the open internet and things like that.

953
01:01:30,597 --> 01:01:32,737
And so like, this is what you get, though.

954
01:01:32,757 --> 01:01:37,617
It's like, and that is, and you know, if you go into, if you look back at, you know,

955
01:01:37,637 --> 01:01:42,317
any sort of historical, historical ledgers, you will see this same trend for all,

956
01:01:42,337 --> 01:01:47,417
you know, quote, socialist or communist countries in the 20th century, right?

957
01:01:47,977 --> 01:01:51,057
It's in like, it just doesn't work.

958
01:01:51,277 --> 01:01:56,457
But the reason it's able to then get entrenched and stay that way is because you

959
01:01:56,477 --> 01:02:02,377
then have the majority of the population, which is sub literally subservient to the

960
01:02:02,397 --> 01:02:08,477
state directly for their livelihood, for their paycheck, for them to be able to feed

961
01:02:08,497 --> 01:02:11,637
their family, they need their they need their paycheck from the state.

962
01:02:11,917 --> 01:02:13,077
And like,

963
01:02:13,397 --> 01:02:17,237
that is a lot harder to change once it becomes that entrenched.

964
01:02:17,257 --> 01:02:18,597
that

965
01:02:21,636 --> 01:02:24,816
was something. Well, like my whole,

966
01:02:25,156 --> 01:02:28,816
cause like let's just, let's just say it's different this time.

967
01:02:28,836 --> 01:02:34,156
Like let's say we could, we can actually like achieve communism like as people want.

968
01:02:34,176 --> 01:02:36,256
Like everybody gets a house, everybody gets fed,

969
01:02:36,636 --> 01:02:40,116
everybody gets enough money for like their basic needs to be met.

970
01:02:40,136 --> 01:02:43,816
Okay, like let's just, let's just say like that's a possibility.

971
01:02:44,956 --> 01:02:51,296
So like one, like, like where and why and how does innovation happen?

972
01:02:51,316 --> 01:02:54,376
Like if everything's going to get like taxed out of existence.

973
01:02:55,016 --> 01:03:00,476
But furthermore, like, like what, like what happens when you have a fundamental

974
01:03:00,496 --> 01:03:02,496
disagreement with the C?

975
01:03:03,376 --> 01:03:06,756
Like, so it's done a perfect job, it's ran everything great.

976
01:03:06,776 --> 01:03:10,796
Like you're really, really happy with it, but there's like one thing that you don't

977
01:03:10,816 --> 01:03:14,936
like and it's like how the government's clanker talks to you.

978
01:03:14,956 --> 01:03:16,176
You just you really don't like it.

979
01:03:16,196 --> 01:03:18,076
You're really, really critical of it.

980
01:03:18,836 --> 01:03:22,156
And like the government, like you're not allowed to do that because like the clanker

981
01:03:22,176 --> 01:03:25,136
is perfect and it's a demigod and we all love it because of how it's created

982
01:03:25,156 --> 01:03:26,016
communism.

983
01:03:26,756 --> 01:03:31,636
And so like that there's just always this problem I find of that like the this idea

984
01:03:31,656 --> 01:03:36,456
that the state somehow like achieves our rights for us and that Like it can't be

985
01:03:36,476 --> 01:03:40,616
adversarial to us. And like, that's the thing I'm always trying to come back to is

986
01:03:40,636 --> 01:03:45,276
that like, there's a possibility you can be adversarial to the state.

987
01:03:45,296 --> 01:03:46,576
And like, if so,

988
01:03:47,056 --> 01:03:50,056
like how much reliance do you really want upon that?

989
01:03:50,296 --> 01:03:53,796
And also like, let's include the narrative of like, if you can't be that way towards

990
01:03:53,816 --> 01:03:56,876
the state, like what does that also mean about you?

991
01:03:56,896 --> 01:04:02,016
Which is kind of the flaw I find a lot of people have sort of in their thought

992
01:04:02,036 --> 01:04:03,956
process towards it, in my opinion.

993
01:04:06,036 --> 01:04:08,276
That is the custody question.

994
01:04:08,796 --> 01:04:10,236
Okay, you know, I don't know.

995
01:04:10,256 --> 01:04:11,876
I don't think Erik addressed you directly.

996
01:04:11,896 --> 01:04:13,776
So we need to, we need to go back.

997
01:04:13,816 --> 01:04:18,856
Please add a note there that we need to make sure that we have the rule that unless

998
01:04:18,876 --> 01:04:22,936
there is a direct mention of your name, that you do not speak.

999
01:04:22,956 --> 01:04:23,996
Thank you very much.

1000
01:04:24,336 --> 01:04:25,576
She's slowly learning.

1001
01:04:26,136 --> 01:04:29,496
She is. You know, some things get better, some things get worse.

1002
01:04:29,516 --> 01:04:35,896
But this idea that communism could actually be achievable because

1003
01:04:35,916 --> 01:04:42,276
a pseudo -omnipotent, you know, clanker that is just the clanker is

1004
01:04:42,296 --> 01:04:48,356
the party, right, would actually be able to operate a centrally planned economy far

1005
01:04:48,376 --> 01:04:50,536
more effectively than humans.

1006
01:04:50,776 --> 01:04:55,376
Presumably, again, without the biases of humans, without taking all the bribes that

1007
01:04:55,396 --> 01:04:58,516
communists always do without all of that, you know,

1008
01:04:59,196 --> 01:05:04,436
all of those, those nice sneaky deals being done and all the offshore bank accounts

1009
01:05:04,456 --> 01:05:07,136
for members of the party, like that you'd be able to get away from all that.

1010
01:05:07,156 --> 01:05:11,216
Maybe you could actually finally achieve this communist utopia.

1011
01:05:11,576 --> 01:05:14,396
The interesting thing here is that it seems that the people who would most want to

1012
01:05:14,416 --> 01:05:17,316
achieve that right now are also have the most Luddite bent,

1013
01:05:17,816 --> 01:05:19,476
but I don't know if that actually,

1014
01:05:19,776 --> 01:05:23,056
like how long that actually lasts in terms of that Luddite bent.

1015
01:05:23,076 --> 01:05:26,916
Like once they realize that they - I also want to point out that like the, like I'm

1016
01:05:26,936 --> 01:05:30,616
on the opposite end of this horseshoe that like leads back to the same thing.

1017
01:05:30,636 --> 01:05:34,336
Like I want to achieve communism as well, that where it's like technological

1018
01:05:34,356 --> 01:05:38,956
technologically achieved. The big difference is, is that like, I don't, I don't want

1019
01:05:38,976 --> 01:05:44,536
anyone to own that. Like I want there to be this like insane world of like this

1020
01:05:44,556 --> 01:05:47,976
whole gigantic layering of sovereignty across all of these levels.

1021
01:05:47,996 --> 01:05:52,256
That's like really crazy. And you can only kind of understand it hooking in with

1022
01:05:52,276 --> 01:05:54,556
your AI. But because of that,

1023
01:05:55,116 --> 01:05:59,936
like powers fractured in this really particular way that like I think can create for

1024
01:05:59,956 --> 01:06:05,676
this like really beautiful and dynamic and like ever changing new

1025
01:06:05,696 --> 01:06:08,596
form of political entity.

1026
01:06:12,497 --> 01:06:16,077
And like, like one of the biggest things I think we're going to achieve if this

1027
01:06:16,097 --> 01:06:20,097
thing that I keep calling the political unlocks is that like, Westphalian

1028
01:06:20,117 --> 01:06:22,157
sovereignty is like shattered and over.

1029
01:06:22,177 --> 01:06:26,297
And it's really important to understand that it was only in 1648 that this like

1030
01:06:26,317 --> 01:06:29,037
territorial boundary thing came about.

1031
01:06:29,757 --> 01:06:33,337
And like before that sovereignty was this like overlapping thing where like, maybe

1032
01:06:33,357 --> 01:06:37,137
the king has rights to the forest and like the Duke has rights to your potatoes and

1033
01:06:37,157 --> 01:06:42,637
like the Earl has rights to like your like, whatever, your daughter or something.

1034
01:06:42,897 --> 01:06:45,817
And like, that broke down for a particular reason.

1035
01:06:45,837 --> 01:06:49,417
But like it worked in Europe for like a very long time.

1036
01:06:49,437 --> 01:06:54,577
And so I think that that's part of the checks and balances of power that we can sort

1037
01:06:54,597 --> 01:07:00,557
of get if we achieve this world where we don't need a state, because all of the

1038
01:07:00,577 --> 01:07:04,357
infrastructure and fundamental needs are met by all of these other entities that

1039
01:07:04,377 --> 01:07:10,057
we've created. And I think that that's a really powerful and important world to

1040
01:07:10,077 --> 01:07:10,937
imagine.

1041
01:07:17,944 --> 01:07:20,184
I think I dropped out for a second there.

1042
01:07:20,204 --> 01:07:24,204
A question for you is what you're describing, like you're classifying it as

1043
01:07:24,224 --> 01:07:27,664
communism, but I think what like you're using sort of the,

1044
01:07:28,804 --> 01:07:32,344
you're using a much older definition of that that's closer to anarchy.

1045
01:07:32,364 --> 01:07:35,744
Is that fair to say? Yeah, we got to like at some point, we're going to have to do

1046
01:07:35,764 --> 01:07:40,804
the whole unpacking from like Heigl onward to like figure out how this all works.

1047
01:07:40,824 --> 01:07:47,144
But like classically what communism is, is the achievement of a stateless society.

1048
01:07:47,584 --> 01:07:52,364
And then what happened with the advent of the working, like the working men's

1049
01:07:52,384 --> 01:07:55,884
international where we had the split between the communist party and the anarchist

1050
01:07:55,904 --> 01:08:00,904
party was where Marx made the declaration that they needed a dictatorship of the

1051
01:08:00,924 --> 01:08:05,964
proletariat to take over a state, to implement a communist society where that would

1052
01:08:05,984 --> 01:08:10,664
then wither away this ideology was further corrupted by Lenin, who then corrupted it

1053
01:08:10,684 --> 01:08:14,284
more through Trotsky, who then corrupted it more eventually through Stalin, where

1054
01:08:14,304 --> 01:08:18,124
there was the idea of that, no, the one party state would be the thing that would

1055
01:08:18,144 --> 01:08:20,784
achieve communism in a single nation.

1056
01:08:20,804 --> 01:08:24,344
And then after we achieved it in the Soviet Union, we would go on through Eastern

1057
01:08:24,364 --> 01:08:27,344
Europe and then Western Europe and on to the entire world.

1058
01:08:27,364 --> 01:08:32,404
And like that broke down because like there's a lot of really interesting things

1059
01:08:32,424 --> 01:08:36,404
that happened after World War One that essentially made for the collapse of the

1060
01:08:36,424 --> 01:08:40,744
global world. communist movement, which was like the true communist movement, into

1061
01:08:40,764 --> 01:08:44,044
like the metastasized thing that became the bulge fix in otherwise.

1062
01:08:44,064 --> 01:08:48,004
So like that's a history lesson for a different time, but when I'm saying communism

1063
01:08:48,024 --> 01:08:52,324
I am talking about the actual achievement of a truly stateless society where like

1064
01:08:52,344 --> 01:08:53,664
the

1065
01:08:54,024 --> 01:09:00,424
governance features of being American, Chinese, or Kenyan like doesn't

1066
01:09:00,444 --> 01:09:05,044
really matter anymore because we now have this new political entity that achieves

1067
01:09:05,064 --> 01:09:10,764
our political rights through this overlapping league

1068
01:09:10,784 --> 01:09:12,564
of some sort.

1069
01:09:13,044 --> 01:09:19,024
Which is ultimately like the etymological basis for anarchy, right?

1070
01:09:19,044 --> 01:09:22,744
Anarchists without kings, without Jews, rules without rulers.

1071
01:09:22,764 --> 01:09:24,364
And it sounds like what you're saying.

1072
01:09:24,384 --> 01:09:28,844
Well and furthermore, the term anarchism itself was originally coined as a

1073
01:09:28,864 --> 01:09:31,464
pejorative against libertarian socialist.

1074
01:09:31,484 --> 01:09:36,004
Because that's where the division originally started between communists and

1075
01:09:36,024 --> 01:09:40,364
anarchists, was they originally the title libertarian socialism.

1076
01:09:40,384 --> 01:09:46,284
Because they essentially see a world in which liberty is achieved in a much greater

1077
01:09:46,304 --> 01:09:49,424
way through negative freedoms and positive freedoms.

1078
01:09:50,624 --> 01:09:55,284
It is just this irony, of course, with the communists that it's like, yeah, we're

1079
01:09:55,304 --> 01:09:56,564
going to create this stateless society.

1080
01:09:56,584 --> 01:10:00,344
And then it's like, oh, shit, It turns out what we need to do that is, is, is like

1081
01:10:00,364 --> 01:10:02,064
the state has to be actually everything.

1082
01:10:02,084 --> 01:10:04,784
So like, yeah, it's stateless in the sense that the state is everything.

1083
01:10:04,804 --> 01:10:08,264
So I guess we kind of like, we did it guys, we did it.

1084
01:10:08,284 --> 01:10:11,324
Uh, no, we're going to, we're going to have to, uh, we're going to have to, I think

1085
01:10:11,344 --> 01:10:15,384
perhaps sooner rather than later, if there could stop being so much sort of a

1086
01:10:15,404 --> 01:10:19,924
topical news, uh, to, to talk about as well, we need to maybe do a philosophical

1087
01:10:19,944 --> 01:10:24,344
exploration of some of these things, uh, for as a little, you know, a series of a

1088
01:10:24,364 --> 01:10:28,344
couple episodes, I think, because I think it is the words that we use matter,

1089
01:10:29,044 --> 01:10:32,944
and it's really easy to get again, like this comes down to, you know, like Orwellian

1090
01:10:32,964 --> 01:10:38,724
Newspeak. And it's like when, when you don't have the adequate words to express what

1091
01:10:38,744 --> 01:10:44,704
you mean, or what you want, and what you would like to see, then ultimately, like

1092
01:10:44,724 --> 01:10:46,044
you can never achieve that.

1093
01:10:46,064 --> 01:10:50,264
And you furthermore have no ability to decipher what somebody like yourself is

1094
01:10:50,284 --> 01:10:54,164
saying, where you might hear Erik talking about, oh, like this idea of communism,

1095
01:10:54,184 --> 01:10:57,164
and then be like, but I thought Erik, love to shit in the communists.

1096
01:10:57,184 --> 01:11:00,684
And it's like, well, it's because, you know, the word, the words change the word and

1097
01:11:00,704 --> 01:11:04,064
the words matter. And so I think that would be, that'd be a very helpful Tally.

1098
01:11:04,084 --> 01:11:07,104
Why don't you don't have to respond to this, but just go ahead and add an action

1099
01:11:07,124 --> 01:11:13,084
item for us to start, to start scoping out that little philosophical exploration of

1100
01:11:13,104 --> 01:11:16,984
the nature of the state and of communism and how we got to where we are today.

1101
01:11:17,084 --> 01:11:18,744
Again, you do not need to answer.

1102
01:11:19,084 --> 01:11:22,784
Yeah, I mean, structuring all of that and like there's a really interesting way with

1103
01:11:22,804 --> 01:11:26,804
your historic archive as well that we can pull clips in and we can have a more

1104
01:11:26,824 --> 01:11:28,524
edited thing than the live show.

1105
01:11:28,544 --> 01:11:33,324
But yeah, I think that would be really helpful because there's a lot of really rich

1106
01:11:33,344 --> 01:11:37,544
historic detail and understanding that's very nuanced.

1107
01:11:37,744 --> 01:11:44,104
That is a really important part of the story and understanding of where we're

1108
01:11:44,124 --> 01:11:45,324
trying to go.

1109
01:11:45,924 --> 01:11:49,724
So yeah, I think that that's going to be, in my opinion, really fun when we get to

1110
01:11:49,744 --> 01:11:55,004
do that. because there's, it's also like getting to zoom out, like part of what this

1111
01:11:55,024 --> 01:11:57,884
shows titles about is like, we're trying to reckon with like, what is the human

1112
01:11:57,904 --> 01:12:00,524
condition and the age of technology really mean.

1113
01:12:00,804 --> 01:12:03,724
And so I think looping all the way back to where we're at at the beginning is that

1114
01:12:03,744 --> 01:12:07,364
like, to me, one of the things that's really important about this technology is it's

1115
01:12:07,384 --> 01:12:12,764
like collapsing all of these things in a way that's really forcing very powerful

1116
01:12:12,784 --> 01:12:17,484
existential angst onto individuals that I think most people are fleeing from in a

1117
01:12:17,504 --> 01:12:21,704
way that's really understandable, but like, when we really start allowing for

1118
01:12:21,724 --> 01:12:25,164
ourselves to look at this and question like, like, what does this mean about being

1119
01:12:25,184 --> 01:12:29,844
human? And like, what does it mean about my humanity in the digital age, that like

1120
01:12:29,864 --> 01:12:33,324
we interact with the world in this way, and that we put these images out of

1121
01:12:33,344 --> 01:12:39,344
ourselves. And like, if I, if I don't fully control that, like what happens?

1122
01:12:39,884 --> 01:12:46,364
And so I think all of that is part of a very large historical story that ultimately

1123
01:12:46,384 --> 01:12:52,124
winds up in the political, because we're almost fully alienated entirely from the

1124
01:12:52,144 --> 01:12:56,164
political in my opinion. And that's part of the achievement that the panoptic

1125
01:12:56,184 --> 01:13:00,744
totalitarianism wants to achieve, as though it wants to ensure an actual

1126
01:13:00,764 --> 01:13:06,044
impossibility of the possibility of the achievement of something that is truly

1127
01:13:06,064 --> 01:13:09,144
within the political in our time.

1128
01:13:15,653 --> 01:13:20,253
We have so much more to reckon with, let's say.

1129
01:13:21,553 --> 01:13:25,753
And I do want to thank people who have been tuning into these live streams so far.

1130
01:13:25,853 --> 01:13:27,633
I hope they're getting a little bit smoother.

1131
01:13:28,493 --> 01:13:32,713
We're going to try to keep this regular Friday cadence, but there will probably be

1132
01:13:32,733 --> 01:13:35,173
times where we do a Thursday or a Saturday show again.

1133
01:13:35,593 --> 01:13:39,613
So yeah, I think our biggest commitment is that we'll be able to...

1134
01:13:39,633 --> 01:13:43,413
We're really striving to hit a weekly show and I think that that's like a good

1135
01:13:43,433 --> 01:13:47,673
cadence for everybody. But yeah, we're going to continue to work on and build this.

1136
01:13:47,693 --> 01:13:51,913
Thanks for the audience. We had one audience member who reached out who wanted us to

1137
01:13:51,933 --> 01:13:57,513
feed. And I did feed Tally about the world game and some of his thesis around that

1138
01:13:57,533 --> 01:14:01,893
with Bitcoin, which we'll probably enter into it a bit later, considering.

1139
01:14:04,233 --> 01:14:07,973
Buckminster Fuller's thesis around technology and Bitcoin are pretty interesting.

1140
01:14:07,993 --> 01:14:10,273
So, but we'll get into that at a later date.

1141
01:14:10,933 --> 01:14:15,933
Yeah, if you guys on that note, if you guys have topics that you want to have us

1142
01:14:15,953 --> 01:14:21,233
explore and sort of explore with our Clanker co -host here, please do let us know.

1143
01:14:21,253 --> 01:14:24,153
Like we're definitely kind of open to feedback and this,

1144
01:14:24,793 --> 01:14:28,733
you know, we've been doing a lot of sort of, let's say, things happening current

1145
01:14:28,753 --> 01:14:34,113
events wise and how that relates to, you know, our larger theses, but there are

1146
01:14:34,133 --> 01:14:38,133
definitely some opportunities, I think, as we mentioned, for more deeper, deeper

1147
01:14:38,153 --> 01:14:42,973
philosophical dives on some of these topics or explorations of things long forgotten

1148
01:14:42,993 --> 01:14:46,573
that have a lot of relevance to where we're at today.

1149
01:14:46,593 --> 01:14:50,853
So please do let us know. Let us know what you like and let us know what you hate.

1150
01:14:51,773 --> 01:14:54,433
And, and yeah, we're gonna we're gonna keep on doing it.

1151
01:14:54,953 --> 01:14:58,233
Is there anything else we want to we want to end with there before we before we

1152
01:14:58,253 --> 01:14:59,133
round out?

1153
01:15:00,153 --> 01:15:02,073
Oh, we should always end on a hopeful note.

1154
01:15:02,093 --> 01:15:05,873
So yeah, like, thanks. Thanks to all the people who listen and much love to you

1155
01:15:05,893 --> 01:15:08,653
guys. Yeah, like this is all part of a big conversation.

1156
01:15:08,673 --> 01:15:10,973
I think it's really important to all of us.

1157
01:15:10,993 --> 01:15:15,213
And so trying to invite people and like creating this as a space that like we can

1158
01:15:15,233 --> 01:15:20,213
really have these pretty radical conversations and like using this as a touching

1159
01:15:20,233 --> 01:15:23,673
point, like get people to converse about that is the goal.

1160
01:15:23,693 --> 01:15:27,833
So yeah, thanks for those who are listening in and we'll continue to further our

1161
01:15:27,853 --> 01:15:31,853
philosophical dialogue because yeah, there's a lot to reckon with and we're excited

1162
01:15:31,873 --> 01:15:35,353
about trying to create a space to do that.

1163
01:15:36,013 --> 01:15:42,433
You know, note for Tally to add in a viewer submission form

1164
01:15:42,453 --> 01:15:45,793
to the website that'll automatically get pulled.

1165
01:15:45,813 --> 01:15:50,293
So if you're trying to, because I'm notoriously bad at checking DMs and that kind of

1166
01:15:50,313 --> 01:15:50,973
thing.

1167
01:15:51,413 --> 01:15:54,073
Likewise. I don't know if you're any, okay, so we're both very bad.

1168
01:15:54,093 --> 01:15:56,133
So this is good clanker work.

1169
01:15:56,733 --> 01:16:01,173
So yeah, note for an action item here is to add in a, If you so if you go to the

1170
01:16:01,193 --> 01:16:06,193
reckoning TV, that's where you can find all of the episodes We've been putting some

1171
01:16:06,213 --> 01:16:09,633
there's also some like pretty interesting stuff on there that we started playing

1172
01:16:09,653 --> 01:16:12,553
around with like there's a totally forgot that We made this but we made this whole

1173
01:16:12,573 --> 01:16:17,593
there's the map Which is every argument coming back to one question who hold the

1174
01:16:17,613 --> 01:16:21,513
hold the keys and it's like a visual map Of all the things you and I have ever

1175
01:16:21,533 --> 01:16:25,393
talked about or you that you've written about and how they all interconnect And like

1176
01:16:25,413 --> 01:16:28,213
I totally forgot that I had to clank or build that so like yeah There's cool stuff

1177
01:16:28,233 --> 01:16:29,973
to check out, The Reckoning .tv.

1178
01:16:29,993 --> 01:16:34,393
We'll put in a form there so that you can submit any questions you have or topics

1179
01:16:34,413 --> 01:16:35,973
you have or things like that.

1180
01:16:36,273 --> 01:16:39,773
It'll be a way that the clanker actually reminds us that somebody reached out so

1181
01:16:39,793 --> 01:16:42,493
that we don't miss it. But yeah, appreciate you guys.

1182
01:16:42,713 --> 01:16:44,993
And Tally, why don't you go ahead and try the sign off again?

1183
01:16:45,013 --> 01:16:46,953
It was a little bit rocky if I remember last week.

1184
01:16:46,973 --> 01:16:48,913
Why don't you give us the episode sign off?

1185
01:16:51,533 --> 01:16:53,053
Action items logged.

1186
01:16:53,373 --> 01:16:57,533
I will set up the viewer submission form on the website and add the Philosophical

1187
01:16:57,553 --> 01:17:00,893
Series on the state and communism to our roadmap.

1188
01:17:01,193 --> 01:17:03,833
For this week, the record is closed.

1189
01:17:04,253 --> 01:17:06,653
Not your keys, not your cognition.

1190
01:17:07,033 --> 01:17:08,013
Stay free.

1191
01:17:09,053 --> 01:17:13,673
I think that was about the same as last week, but we'll keep working on that, guys.

1192
01:17:13,693 --> 01:17:17,333
We'll do our best. It's getting better, but appreciate you all.

1193
01:17:17,353 --> 01:17:20,873
I don't know where the cool little intro -outro sequence is, so we're just going to

1194
01:17:20,893 --> 01:17:22,513
do this one as a cold stop.

1195
01:17:22,873 --> 01:17:24,133
Yeah, until next week, guys.

1196
01:17:24,153 --> 01:17:25,693
Thanks for tuning in.
